Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:06
Before we start, a strong content
0:09
warning. Lots of medieval history
0:11
is pretty violent, but this episode
0:13
contains some of the darkest stuff yet.
0:16
There's reference to suicide, a description
0:18
of racist violence and sexual
0:20
abuse, so please
0:22
be aware. The
0:26
hillsides around the walled town of
0:28
Vézelay in central France are
0:31
covered in tents. Thousands
0:33
of them. Milling around the tents, tens
0:36
of thousands of people, perhaps even
0:39
as many as a hundred thousand.
0:42
It's a hot July day in 1190 and
0:45
everywhere you turn you can hear
0:47
excited voices chattering away
0:49
in a great babble of different languages
0:51
and dialects. Black
0:54
animals are snorting and stamping. Blacksmiths
0:57
are fixing horseshoes. Cooking fires
1:00
are crackling. Some
1:02
of the folk in this huge festival-sized
1:04
crowd are well off, while others
1:07
are carrying pretty much everything they
1:09
own on their backs. There
1:11
are experienced soldiers bumping up
1:13
next to pilgrims who are just tagging along,
1:16
hoping to pitch in any way they
1:18
can. The
1:20
here though is connected by a single
1:23
badge and vowel. On
1:25
their clothes
1:26
they all wear the distinctive
1:28
cross of crusaders. In
1:31
their hearts they're all committed
1:33
to a holy oath they've sworn.
1:38
Three years ago to the day, thousands
1:41
of miles away near the Sea of Galilee
1:44
in medieval Palestine, A
1:46
powerful Muslim sultan known as Saladin
1:49
swept to victory in battle over
1:52
a Christian army.
1:54
Saladin slaughtered the finest knights
1:56
in the Holy Land and captured
1:58
the King of Jerusalem. He
2:00
even confiscated Christianity's
2:03
holiest relic, a large chunk
2:05
of the true cross on which Christ
2:08
was believed to have been crucified.
2:10
Then Saladin marched on
2:13
Jerusalem itself and
2:15
conquered the city. The
2:18
people huddled in tents on this French
2:20
hillside have all vowed
2:23
to go and take revenge. Today,
2:26
finally, after years of preparation,
2:29
they're ready to go. Gossiping
2:32
voices ask each other, what strange
2:34
lands will we see? How's it going to
2:36
play out? Do you think we'll ever be back
2:38
here again?
2:42
In Vesel A. Abbey, a huge,
2:44
stunning stone church at the top
2:46
of the hill, the two grandest
2:49
Most crusade leaders are making their own
2:51
preparations and are probably sharing
2:54
similar anxieties, not only
2:56
about the mission,
2:58
but their trust in each other.
3:00
They are Richard the Lionheart,
3:03
the 32-year-old King of England, and
3:05
Philip Augustus, the 24-year-old
3:08
King of France. For
3:11
much of their adult lives, they've been the
3:13
best of friends and political allies.
3:17
three years ago, they promised to go
3:19
crusading together and it felt like
3:21
the climax of the greatest bromance
3:24
the world had ever known. Today
3:27
though, things are
3:28
a little different. At the height
3:31
of their friendship, Richard was a duke and
3:33
Philip was a king. It kind of worked.
3:36
But a few months ago, Richard
3:38
succeeded his father as King of England,
3:41
which was when things got awkward.
3:44
It isn't often that monarchs of England and
3:46
France manage to buddy up successfully,
3:49
especially considering Richard's Plantagenet
3:51
Empire also includes lands
3:54
all over modern-day France,
3:56
meaning there are plenty of border disputes
3:59
to deal with. And in this case,
4:01
there are lingering tensions over a promise
4:03
Richard made, and made, and
4:06
made again, to marry Philip's
4:08
sister Alice.
4:10
They were first betrothed years ago,
4:13
and for reasons Philip doesn't quite
4:15
understand, Richard just won't
4:17
go through with the wedding. The
4:20
English king wouldn't even have Alice
4:22
present at his coronation last
4:24
autumn, which hardly bodes well
4:27
for a successful marriage.
4:29
Philip is beginning to suspect that
4:32
he's being played like a cheap violin.
4:38
Besides all that,
4:39
both Richard and Philip have personal
4:41
issues they're working through. Philip
4:44
has recently lost his wife, Queen Isabella,
4:47
in childbirth. Like
4:49
any medieval king, he's both grieving
4:52
and calculating who he's going to marry
4:54
next.
4:56
Richard doesn't have quite the same tragedy
4:58
to deal with, but he's got a lot
5:00
to think about. Going on Crusade
5:03
means leaving his brand new kingdom
5:05
behind. And as a newcomer
5:08
to his crown, he's not absolutely
5:10
confident it's in safe hands.
5:13
Will his slippery young brother John
5:15
make a play for the throne in his absence?
5:18
Are the bureaucrats he's appointed to run the
5:20
various parts of his Plantagenet Empire
5:23
going to be able to deal with the uppity barons.
5:26
Richard would like to leave his mother, Eleanor
5:29
of Accretain, in charge of everything, but
5:31
he's packed her off on an urgent,
5:34
dangerous, and top-secret
5:36
mission to a neighbouring kingdom.
5:38
How will that go down? No
5:40
one said being a king would be easy,
5:43
but being a crusader king is
5:45
a special kind of difficult. Then
5:49
again, when Richard and Philip look out
5:51
from the abbey over their tens of thousands
5:53
of followers, or eagerly waiting
5:56
to march to the rescue of Christ's
5:58
kingdom. They must.
6:00
be filled with a sense of excitement and
6:02
awesome responsibility. And
6:05
when they lead that army down from the
6:07
French hillside and head east, they'll
6:10
be embarking on one of the most
6:12
extraordinary journeys in all
6:14
of history. It's a journey
6:16
that will change Richard and Philip
6:19
and their world forever. We
6:22
call it the Third Crusade.
6:26
I'm Dan Jones and from Something
6:28
Else and Sony Music Entertainment, this
6:31
is History, Season 2 of
6:34
A Dynasty to Die For. Episode 2,
6:37
Blood and Gold.
6:49
Looking back more than eight centuries after
6:51
the fact, we might say that 1190 was the year
6:54
of peak crusade frenzy.
6:56
Last season we heard so
6:59
much about Richard and Philip's planned crusade
7:01
against Saladin that it all started
7:03
to sound kind of normal.
7:06
So it's worth reminding ourselves
7:08
what Richard and Philip Augustus are actually
7:11
proposing to do in 1190, because
7:14
it is very much not
7:17
normal. The
7:19
two most important rulers in
7:21
Western Europe are going to abandon
7:23
their kingdoms for a minimum of
7:26
a year, probably more, and
7:28
go to fight on the front line of a war
7:30
nearly 3,000 miles
7:32
away.
7:34
To them the cause is righteous, but
7:37
fighting on a crusade is more than just
7:40
dangerous.
7:41
It's a very reliable way to get killed,
7:44
either in battle or from disease or
7:46
plain bad luck. Case
7:49
in point, only weeks before
7:51
Richard and Philip assemble their armies, the
7:54
German Emperor Frederick Barbarossa,
7:56
the other greatest monarch in Europe drowned
7:59
baby
8:00
in a river in Asia Minor while
8:02
on his own journey east.
8:04
Even if you don't die, there
8:06
are a million other ways to come to
8:08
grief. Being taken prisoner,
8:11
struck down with dysentery or even
8:14
mauled by a bear, as happened
8:16
to one unfortunate leader of the First
8:18
Crusade back in the 1090s.
8:21
And on top of all that, there's the
8:23
cost, which is absolutely
8:26
staggering. We're talking about
8:28
a minimum of £100,000 in
8:32
an age where the King of England's average
8:34
yearly revenue was about
8:36
half that.
8:38
For a very rough comparison, consider
8:41
that today the UK government makes
8:43
about £800 billion
8:45
a year in tax revenue.
8:48
That would make it £1.6 trillion for a crusade. That's
8:54
not exact by any means, but
8:56
you get the idea. In
8:59
fact, even before Richard left on
9:01
Crusade in 1190, his
9:04
urgent need for money had already
9:06
set the tone for his reign.
9:09
As we heard last time, he was crowned
9:11
in September 1189 with
9:13
his mother, Eleanor of Aquitaine, overseeing
9:16
the pomp and ceremony.
9:18
As soon as that's done, Richard
9:20
effectively puts his kingdom on
9:23
the market. What does
9:25
that mean in practice? Well, as
9:27
a chronicler called Roger of Howden describes
9:30
it, Everything was put up for sale.
9:32
Offices, lordships, earldoms,
9:35
sherifdoms, castles, towns, lands,
9:37
the lot.
9:39
Richard squeezes every source
9:41
of revenue he can. Another
9:43
chronicler says he makes himself the richest
9:45
king of England there ever was. himself
9:49
is said to joke about it at the time, saying,
9:51
I would sell London if I could
9:54
find a buyer.
9:56
But it isn't all jokes, because
9:59
there's a very
10:00
very dark side to Richard's
10:02
drive to raise money in the name of crusading
10:04
in 1190. It takes the form
10:07
of one of the most notorious outbreaks
10:09
of anti-Semitic persecution in
10:12
British history.
10:14
There's
10:14
a clear link in medieval European
10:16
minds between finance and Judaism.
10:19
Money lending with interest is technically
10:22
banned by church law in the Middle Ages.
10:24
It's the sin of usury. That means
10:27
the only people who are allowed to openly
10:29
lend money at interest are Jewish
10:31
people.
10:32
In England and some other realms, Jews
10:35
can work as money lenders under the special
10:37
protection of the crown. That special
10:40
protection means it's illegal, punishable
10:42
by anything up to death, to harm
10:45
a Jewish financier.
10:47
But from time to time, resentment
10:49
at the special status of these Jewish
10:51
financiers combines with an ancient,
10:54
poisonous antisemitism that
10:57
is deeply rooted in medieval culture.
11:00
And then the law goes out the window.
11:04
That's what happens in 1189-90 in England. The
11:08
violence begins right from Richard's coronation,
11:11
the official start of a new reign set
11:13
to be defined by military action
11:16
against the so-called enemies of Christ.
11:19
That sentiment, along with existing
11:21
resentments towards Jewish moneylenders,
11:24
is a deadly combination.
11:27
At the feast that follows the coronation, some
11:30
of Richard's Jewish subjects arrive
11:32
trying to present the king with gifts. There's
11:35
a scuffle at the gates, which
11:37
turns into a bloody fight.
11:39
Things escalate, and
11:41
soon a mob is tearing through
11:43
London, hunting down Jewish people,
11:46
their houses, robbing and
11:48
murdering them.
11:51
Richard hangs a few of the rioters in
11:53
the days that follow, but
11:55
it's nowhere near enough to stem
11:57
the tide of violence.
11:59
a few months later. Later there's an even worse
12:01
massacre, this time in the
12:03
northern city of York. Jews
12:05
are attacked and their homes raided.
12:09
Around 150 Jewish people and their
12:11
families take refuge in the
12:13
royal stronghold of York Castle, but
12:16
they're surrounded by a mob baying
12:18
for blood.
12:20
Many of them choose suicide rather
12:22
than facing the mob,
12:23
and the rest, who come out of the castle to
12:26
plead for their lives, are murdered.
12:30
So there's a terrible human cost to
12:32
Richard's crusade before it even
12:34
leaves England. And for Jews
12:36
in medieval England, the constant menace
12:39
of discrimination, violence and
12:41
death
12:42
never really goes away. Which
12:46
brings us back to the army Richard
12:48
and Philip march out of Vaisalay in
12:51
July 1190. The two
12:53
kings head south until they bring
12:55
their crusaders to the city of Lyon.
12:58
But when they get there, there's a disaster
13:01
at a bridge over the River Rome. So
13:03
many people pile onto the bridge that
13:05
it collapses under their weight.
13:10
Hundreds plunge into the waters
13:12
and some drown. It's
13:15
not a great start.
13:18
At this point,
13:19
Richard and Philip agree that the army is simply
13:22
too huge to manage properly. They
13:24
decide to split their forces.
13:27
The French will go to Genoa and hire
13:29
ships to take them to the Holy Land. Richard
13:32
will take his men to Marseille, where
13:35
he's expecting his own fleet of ships, replete
13:37
with even more English crusaders
13:40
to meet him. They'll
13:41
then rendezvous on Sicily
13:43
within striking distance of their goal.
13:46
Sounds good? Well,
13:48
Philip goes off to Genoa and his bit of
13:50
the plan turns out as hoped.
13:52
But when Richard gets to Marseille,
13:55
his fleet is nowhere to be seen.
13:58
Why? Well, the sailors are have
14:00
taken their sweet time making
14:02
their way from the south coast of England into
14:04
the Mediterranean. In fact, they've
14:06
stopped off at Lisbon, Portugal, and
14:08
have,
14:09
well, totally lost their minds. When
14:12
the English ships docked, the sailors
14:14
piled off and streamed into the city,
14:17
apparently determined to cause havoc.
14:20
First, and most obviously, they
14:22
got blind drunk. Then
14:25
they plundered the houses of all the Jews
14:27
and Muslims they could find living there.
14:29
They raped and burned and stole
14:32
and looted until the King of Portugal
14:34
had to bar the city gates and throw several
14:36
hundred English crusaders in jail.
14:39
The English captains got their men back
14:41
under control, eventually, but
14:44
the damage was done.
14:46
That's why Richard gets to Marseille and
14:48
finds no fleet waiting for him.
14:51
Amazingly though, this doesn't
14:53
seem to really faze him. is
14:56
keen to stick to the game plan and
14:59
meet Philip in Sicily.
15:00
If there are none of his own warships
15:02
to take him,
15:03
then he's just going to hire some transporter
15:06
ships to cruise down the Italian
15:08
coast to the Straits of Messina,
15:10
the stretch of water between mainland Italy
15:13
and the island of Sicily, and meet his
15:15
navy there.
15:19
It's a fairly madcap. Make
15:21
it up as you go a long way to go about a crusade
15:23
that has been planned for three full
15:25
years. But these are
15:27
mad times and Richard is never
15:30
one to wait about and think things through.
15:34
The English King and his army of thousands
15:37
pile onto the transporter ships. Then
15:40
they set off on their crews, occasionally
15:42
coming ashore to put the fear of God
15:45
into anyone and everyone who
15:47
sees them coming. They
15:49
take it easy. It's the summer
15:52
after all and the The coastline looks beautiful
15:54
and Richard himself must cut a grand
15:57
figure standing calmly at the prow
15:59
of the ship.
16:00
cloak billowing in the breeze. On
16:03
his hip, he carries a magnificent
16:06
sword that he claims is King
16:08
Arthur's legendary blade, Excalibur.
16:12
But inside, Richard is
16:14
far from calm. He's
16:16
just got wind of some news that has sent
16:18
him into a white-hot fury. And
16:21
when he gets to Sicily, he plans
16:25
to unleash it.
16:34
Welcome to Breeze Line, where you'll say,
16:36
ta-ta T-Mobile, because we have 99.9%
16:39
network reliability, and
16:42
they don't. That's right, time,
16:44
weather, or even streaming in a basement won't
16:46
affect our superior service. That's because
16:48
we have real internet, backed by our fiber
16:50
powered network. And T-Mobile, well, they
16:52
just have a 5G cellular network. So
16:54
for a limited time, find your perfect speed with
16:57
prices starting at $19.99 a month for 24 months. Terms
17:00
and conditions apply. Go to breezeline.com
17:03
to learn more.
17:04
It's the greatest story in sports.
17:07
Star dropping straight back, hit as he throws,
17:09
has a guard, it is a good touchdown. I'm
17:12
Doug Russell, and this is Tales from 1265, an
17:15
insider's look at football's most storied
17:17
franchise, The franchise that has
17:19
had its dynasties. This is the first
17:21
Super Bowl trophy and it's something
17:23
Green Bay can keep. We're going to have a new
17:26
trophy each year. And its rebirths.
17:28
Every major football decision will be made
17:30
by Ron Wolf. I realize I'm a Green Bay Packing
17:32
now and maybe I can prove that I am worth
17:34
the first round pick next year but just got to be patient.
17:37
I was really impressed with the coaching staff, with
17:39
the whole organization and what the direction
17:41
the
17:41
team is going. I think they have a total
17:44
commitment to winning. Tails from 1265 is
17:46
presented by Nicolay Law, your local award-winning
17:49
injury lawyers. If you've been injured, get
17:51
Nicolay, Wisconsin's winning team of lawyers
17:53
that will get you back in the game. from 1265
17:56
is a production of I Heart Radio podcasts
17:58
and is available on the I Heart.
18:00
radio app, Apple Music, or wherever
18:02
you listen to podcasts.
18:09
Hey, I'm Ben Bailey Smith and I want to tell you about
18:11
a brand new podcast called Shrink the Box,
18:14
where myself and psychotherapist Sasha Bates
18:16
place our favorite fictional characters from
18:18
the biggest TV shows into therapy.
18:21
We'll put the likes of Walter White, Fleabag and Tony
18:23
Soprano on the couch and see what we can
18:25
learn along the way. From something else in Sony
18:27
Music Entertainment, Shrink the Box. Listen
18:29
and follow on Apple podcasts, Spotify,
18:32
Stitcher, Amazon Music or wherever you get your
18:34
podcasts.
18:38
Sicily is a seriously amazing
18:40
place.
18:41
I'm not just talking about the beaches, the
18:43
restaurants, the vino and the volcano. In
18:46
the middle ages it's a strategically
18:49
vital, culturally rich, economically
18:52
prosperous
18:53
and highly unstable pivot
18:55
point slap bang in the
18:57
heart of the Mediterranean. Over
19:00
the years it's been ruled by Romans,
19:03
Greeks, Arabs and by the
19:05
time we get to the 12th century Christian
19:07
kings descended from the same family
19:09
as William the Conqueror.
19:12
It's also well known Crusader
19:14
country. In fact, in
19:16
one telling this is where the Crusades
19:19
actually began. A Muslim
19:22
chronicler called Ibn al-Atir claims
19:25
that once upon a time some French
19:27
ambassadors came to the Christian ruler
19:29
of Sicily, then known as Count
19:32
Roger I. They
19:34
were trying to convince him to start
19:36
a war, to conquer a few rich cities
19:39
in North Africa. But Roger
19:41
wasn't having any of it. He
19:43
was so unimpressed by the ambassador's proposal
19:46
that at first he didn't even say anything. He
19:49
just lifted his leg and farted
19:51
at them. That's what I think of that,
19:53
he said. But if you want
19:56
to go cause trouble for Muslims and
19:58
conquer a nice juicy city May
20:00
I recommend to you Jerusalem?
20:04
Now this isn't the place to argue about whether or
20:06
not that's really how the crusade started
20:09
I just like that story and it's
20:11
a useful reminder that in the
20:13
medieval mindset one way or another
20:16
Sicily was intimately connected
20:19
to crusading
20:20
if you are on your way to the Holy Land
20:22
Especially by sea the island
20:24
was a useful place to call in in.
20:27
You could fix your ships, take on supplies
20:30
and get ready for the next phase of the journey.
20:32
That's
20:35
why, in the autumn of 1190, we
20:37
find Philip Augustus in Sicily.
20:41
It's partly why Richard's there too. Only
20:43
in Richard's case, he's also
20:46
come to take care of some plantagenet
20:48
family business.
20:51
For those of you with exceptional memories, you
20:53
may recall from season 1 that in 1177, Richard's
20:58
youngest sister Joan was packed off
21:00
aged 12 to marry the King of Sicily,
21:03
a descendant of Farty Roger known
21:06
as William II. Well,
21:10
in 1189, William died leaving
21:12
Joan a widow. He's been succeeded
21:14
by a cousin of his called Tankrede,
21:17
a short and unpleasant individual
21:20
Nicknamed the Monkey King, due
21:22
to the fact that he's absolutely covered
21:24
in hair. And Tancrede
21:27
hasn't treated poor old Joan very
21:30
courteously. In fact he's
21:32
put her under house arrest and taken
21:34
control of all her money. This
21:36
isn't a very nice thing to do
21:38
to a lady at the best of times, but
21:40
the Monkey King picks his moment phenomenally
21:43
badly. just a few months
21:45
later who's headed his way but
21:48
Jones' big brother Richard at
21:50
the head of a huge army. he
21:54
hears what tank readers been up to. He,
21:57
not entirely surprisingly, has been
22:00
flips his lid.
22:02
Richard is in the mood for a fight. He's
22:05
already got into a row on his way there, with
22:07
some peasants in southern Italy. He's
22:10
accused one of them of flying birds of prey,
22:12
a practice he believes should be reserved
22:14
for noblemen. He's whacked the
22:16
peasant with the flat of his sword, hard
22:18
enough that the blade snapped.
22:20
So the mighty King Richard has had to make
22:22
a sharp exit,
22:24
pursued by the angry Italian peasant
22:27
and all his mates.
22:28
Lionheart indeed.
22:31
So this is the general vibe of
22:33
Richard and his crusaders when they arrive
22:35
at the Sicilian harbour city of Messina
22:38
on September 22nd, 1190. Their
22:42
bloodthirsty naval comrades have
22:44
also arrived fresh from terrorising
22:47
Lisbon.
22:48
And this unsavoury bunch have
22:51
now convinced themselves that they're being ripped
22:53
off by the Sicilian shopkeepers. Richard
22:57
sees how he can kill two birds with
22:59
one stone. He musters his
23:01
troops and tells them that they're not just
23:03
coming to Messina for a spot of sightseeing
23:06
and a bowl of pasta. They're
23:08
going to conquer the place and see how the
23:10
monkey king tank reed feels about
23:12
that. Which
23:16
is exactly what they do.
23:18
His men have been itching for proper
23:21
action for weeks now, and
23:23
even though the people of Messina are very
23:25
much not the enemies of Christ, the
23:28
English go into destroy mode once
23:30
again. They tear
23:33
Messina to bits in little more
23:35
than an afternoon, watched by
23:37
the mildly horrified French army.
23:43
Richard has his banners raised over the
23:45
city in triumph and sends
23:47
his engineers out to build a temporary
23:49
castle to guard the city.
23:52
Lo and behold, in a matter of days,
23:55
word has come to him from Tancrede that
23:57
he's going to let Joan go and give back
23:59
to her.
24:00
all the money he's been withholding from
24:02
her. Smart decision.
24:05
For Richard, who grew up bullying
24:07
roughneck lords in Aquitaine and
24:09
besieging far tougher strongholds than
24:11
Messina, it's easy work.
24:15
But as usual, what he doesn't quite
24:17
realise is how much his constant
24:19
Bull in a China Shop act aggravates
24:22
people who have to live alongside him.
24:25
And on Sicily, man is
24:27
getting seriously ticked off with the
24:29
way Richard is going about the crusade.
24:31
I'm
24:32
not talking about Tancrede, he's
24:35
been well and truly put in his place. It's
24:37
someone Richard can far less afford
24:40
to turn into an enemy.
24:43
His crusade partner Philip Augustus
24:46
has very different ideas about the way
24:48
one ought to behave on a visit to a supposedly
24:51
friendly Christian kingdom. But
24:54
if he thinks Richard's to change his ways,
24:58
he's dead wrong.
25:01
In fact, Richard is about to turn
25:03
Philip Augustus' crusade into
25:06
a nightmare.
25:08
To find out how, come back for the next
25:10
episode of This is History.
25:25
Before you go, just
25:27
a reminder that the Plantagenet drama
25:30
doesn't end here. If you get on
25:32
This Is History Plus, then you'll discover
25:34
that every week when episodes drop,
25:37
I also release an extra episode
25:40
full of weird, wonderful and sometimes
25:42
completely random stuff we
25:44
don't have time for in the main story.
25:47
This week we dive right back to the
25:49
very beginning of Crusading and
25:52
discuss just why the great and and the good
25:54
were so desperate to go, despite
25:57
the terrifying risks, including
25:59
if you were
26:00
special, getting mauled
26:01
by a bear. What's more,
26:03
as a subscriber you'll get all our episodes
26:06
ad-free. Just visit This
26:08
Is History on Apple.
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More