Popular Reviews of The Scaredy Cats Horror Show

I would give this podcast three stars, because I liked the people involved and the premise. However, I feel much of the potential for such an interesting concept was wasted along the way. The first episode, with the exquisite film The Exorcist, turned out to be frustrating, because there were no rules established beforehand for how Vogt should watch these movies. I was also disappointed by the Ari Aster episode, where a lot of nuance of the movies remained not discussed, ultimately. Those two movies were rich enough to deserve an episode each. The whole show rushed over the whole genre experience, I felt. But having said all that, it is still entertaining for a casual listener. Just don't go into it looking for a thorough appreciation of the horror genre. This is more about the fun conversations, and Vogt's extreme aversion to feeling scared.

Alex and PJ are amazing and the way they decided to make a fun low key show during quarantine is amazing and I loved the guests they had on the series.

I expected something different from the description. It was a decent discussion.

I love this podcast! PJ and Alex are so fun to listen to and they make me laugh. I am afraid of scary movies, so I love listening to this podcast. The movies they've covered so far are ones that scared me so much as a kid, and it's nice to go through them and hear what others have to say about them. It makes them a little less scary :)