Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:01
The question we're going to as today
0:03
is. What? Is the purpose of a
0:05
military. What? Is a military here
0:07
do here in the United States of America? I
0:09
guess in many ways you would say well they
0:11
need to be ready to defend us against. Enemies
0:14
both foreign and domestic. Are.
0:17
They should be fighting ready for
0:19
whatever you know is happening. Now.
0:22
There's a lot of reasons that people decide
0:24
to join the military and I would guess
0:26
at the heart of it's not always so
0:28
that they can rush into battle a war,
0:30
but a lot of times they lack options.
0:32
They lack options to potentially a go to
0:34
university and in order to do that to
0:36
come from where they're at they see this
0:38
is an opportunity. If they join the military
0:40
then they will have the option to perhaps
0:42
go to college and and move on to
0:44
other things are the rest of their lives.
0:47
But. What if you met someone that said
0:49
you know I'm join the military, I
0:51
want to get a breast augmentation surgery.
0:53
You be like ah. Don't. The
0:56
that's why would join the military plane not a good
0:58
idea or like a face lift. And we
1:00
could even say that you know I've had Reza like
1:02
I just want to get in better shape, I
1:04
want to work out and therefore I did. The
1:06
military would do well, would certainly do that. but don't
1:08
you think after a couple years now that you're
1:10
all rip to be like? But what are all
1:12
the other reasons were here? What?
1:14
If you're going to join the
1:17
military to get a sex change
1:19
operation. The. Department of Defense
1:21
is estimated to be one of the
1:23
country's biggest employers of trans people. Staff
1:26
Sergeant William Alan Role is one
1:28
of over fifteen thousand transgender people
1:30
believe could be serving in the
1:32
United States Military. Or doctors
1:34
will treat them men in, give
1:36
them that medically necessary treatment According
1:38
to the protocols they provide a
1:40
path for those in service for
1:42
medical treatment, gender transition and recognition
1:45
in one's self identified gender. And.
1:47
They seek to protect the privacy of
1:50
all service members and to treat them
1:52
with dignity and respect at all times
1:54
Outside the military we're doing every week
1:56
and return to trying to rid of
1:58
all the barriers. The gate keeping
2:00
that has occurred in Trans Health. And
2:03
I feel like and the military
2:05
it's We still have those and
2:07
barriers requiring a brigade commander to
2:09
have proved my medical treatment plants.
2:11
transitioning is a lobby be that
2:13
is as a leader and I've
2:15
gotten rid of the distraction of
2:17
worrying about and. Concealing were
2:20
really was gender reassignment surgery will hurt
2:22
our medical readiness. I'm and you can
2:24
even deploy if if you're back if
2:26
you're not vaccinated properly or you don't
2:28
have the proper dental records in place.
2:31
so how are we supposed to deploy
2:33
people in keep our war fighting stance?
2:35
Is somebody to said gender reassignment surgery
2:37
insert taxpayers be be paying for them.
2:41
You. Know really good questions and
2:43
at the heart of this story
2:46
is one of our tug considers
2:48
for the High Wire. Great writer
2:50
Tracy Beans she's also the editor
2:53
in chief of Uncovered D. C
2:55
C put out an article that
2:57
has gone absolutely viral. Military doctor
3:00
says transgender surgery uptick paid for
3:02
with Us tax dollars. Celeste.
3:04
That beat around the bush on this
3:07
conversation. As. My honor pledged to
3:09
be joined by the one the only
3:11
Tracy. Beans. Tracy. All right, I've
3:14
what wanna say is just tell
3:16
me that this isn't true and
3:18
just you know I won't be
3:20
clear. I'm not against if transgender
3:23
people or gay or bi or
3:25
whatever you know, sort of. however
3:27
you identify if you're ready to
3:29
serve of military needs and perform
3:31
all the functions that are necessary.
3:33
I. Have no judgment there. But.
3:35
Always say that while you're in the
3:38
military that you can be set up
3:40
and that we're going to pay for
3:42
you to get. As. A sex
3:44
change operation. I would tell me that isn't true.
3:47
I wish I could. Absolutely. At his
3:49
trail. Unfortunately, I'm about a year
3:52
ago. the deal deep. Put. Out
3:54
a new. Policy. That explains all
3:56
of this kind of working conditions. You
3:58
need to be a. You apply
4:00
and be granted one of these surgeries in
4:03
the Us military and you need to be
4:05
serving for at. Least one hundred and eighty
4:07
days before you can go through this process.
4:09
They've invested a lot of money into working
4:12
group and health groups surrounding this issue within
4:14
the government and basically what this policy says
4:16
as you go when. They. Give you
4:18
a waiver if you can't get the care you. You
4:20
want right then and there on a military
4:23
I add on a military base our military
4:25
of facility. You get a
4:27
diagnosis of gender dysphoria. And. Then
4:29
you go through a process within
4:31
the military of getting your medicine
4:33
been on hormones i'm living real
4:35
life experience as they call it
4:38
as the opposite gender and then
4:40
you are eligible for or or
4:42
gender reassignment surgery along with a
4:44
whole host of other procedures that
4:46
would always be considered elective for
4:48
force, even active. Duty service members
4:50
were not I transgender So you're looking
4:53
I would know to what about what
4:55
you mean by that. I was using
4:57
those people that want surgery that are
4:59
not transgender. like what kind of surgeries
5:02
would they not yet of they're not
5:04
transgender. Let's. Say a woman
5:06
who wants a facelift. Okay, Her.
5:08
An eyebrow left or a breast
5:11
augmentation or liposuction. Or at least
5:13
Er. Heller. I'll either hair or
5:15
mobile. Those procedures are covered underneath
5:17
his policy for transgender people who
5:19
are going through transition while in
5:22
the Us. Military. And I
5:24
was already be shall not. Those would
5:26
be denied. Any one that's just a
5:28
woman that wants to get those things
5:30
or man there was a good as.
5:32
But as long as you say I'm
5:35
transgender suddenly this whole grocery list of
5:37
the types of plastic surgeries and you
5:39
know enhancements you want to get or
5:41
now available to you. Correct.
5:44
That is correct Unit the worst problem is the
5:47
way you started. The show was perfect because it's
5:49
true. You know, if you were getting the
5:51
military? fine more. Power to you serve
5:53
your country with honor. However, A
5:55
lot of people are get your not
5:58
deployable after this down you cannot. deploy.
6:00
And as a matter of fact, you
6:02
can't even deploy technically under the rules
6:04
and regulations that are on the
6:06
books now with a diagnosis of
6:08
gender dysphoria. It's a mental health condition
6:11
that requires counseling. You cannot deploy and
6:13
be overseas in the middle of a
6:15
desert somewhere and need therapy once every
6:17
week or once every two weeks or
6:19
once every month. The limit for therapy
6:21
that the government provides is once per
6:23
quarter max. And as you're going through
6:25
this terrible, you know, period,
6:28
in my opinion, where you're medically
6:30
transitioning from one gender to the
6:32
next, the counseling requirements for that
6:34
are very, very intense. So you're
6:36
not deployable then you have this surgery,
6:39
you're not deployable after and most of
6:41
these folks, I venture to
6:43
guess, will end up with a
6:45
medical discharge and then the US taxpayer will
6:47
then also be paying for their health care
6:49
for the rest of their lives, which is
6:51
intensive. It's not just, Oh, I'm just going
6:53
to go in for this little surgery and
6:55
come out and be fine. The rest of
6:57
their lives are on hormones. The rest of
7:00
their lives, they need surgical checkups. They
7:02
need constant medical care. So it's a big
7:04
issue in our, in our military. Let me take it
7:06
back because I want to make sure that we're not
7:08
misrepresented this or, or just to
7:10
clarify, when you say they have a
7:13
mental disorder, obviously that's the big argument
7:15
going on right now around this conversation
7:17
is, is this sort of gender dysphoria,
7:19
a mental disorder or not? But does,
7:21
how does the military determine that you
7:23
should be eligible? Like, you know, is
7:26
it, I mean, when you say it's
7:28
a mental disorder, why are you saying
7:30
that? How do they determine that? Because
7:34
in our own words, that's what they call
7:36
it. The US military uses the DS five,
7:39
which is the American psychiatric kind of
7:41
rule book for mental illness. And that's
7:43
literally what it's called. So, you know,
7:45
right on point with that comment, what
7:48
the conversation we're having greater in civilian
7:50
world out here in culture is that
7:52
this is absolutely normal and there's no
7:54
problem with it, but the US military
7:57
itself uses, They open up
7:59
the manual. Save a D S
8:01
Five on Mental Disorders The go Okay
8:03
definition of gender dysphoria. Tell me about
8:05
yourself, yet you fit that bill. You're
8:07
right in here in the book on
8:09
mental disorders. Therefore, you qualify for now
8:11
we putting you on hormones. For what
8:13
you say, they have to do hormones
8:15
for six months to a year. Something.
8:18
Like twelve months a year. they gotta act
8:20
like the other gender now and the and
8:22
I get would do. They have like people
8:24
monitoring that's and then once they've gone through
8:26
all of that now they're eligible to get
8:28
a As surgery and have body parts removed,
8:31
are added on and and and the rest
8:33
of it. Correct.
8:35
And it's very important you heard in that
8:37
intro video the use of the term medically
8:40
necessary. That term is used and abused in
8:42
my opinion of the Us military out well
8:44
because I've had friends who have been in
8:46
the military and he did heart surgeries dell
8:49
and we're not. Granted those heart surgery is
8:51
being told they were not medically necessary. They
8:53
were basically telling my friend, go get another
8:56
ablaze and you can't have the special procedure
8:58
that will save your life. It's not medically
9:00
necessary, but when it comes to this, they
9:02
have an entire division. To expedite
9:05
these claims, these. Waivers and their
9:07
granted the weavers by using the
9:09
term medically necessary in the definition
9:11
is very vague, almost the same
9:13
place as they say that vaccines
9:15
are safe and. Effective They use the
9:17
term medically necessary when it suits them.
9:19
What's really are you know And and
9:22
by the way, this is a very
9:24
expensive as set of surgeries. Usually it's
9:26
more than one. Ah, Loss of
9:28
revisions I can be needed in of
9:31
course all the drugs trying to handle
9:33
it's trying to make sure that whatever
9:35
you know you've added are taken away
9:37
that your body. sort of. Except that
9:39
massive change. So all that's incredibly expensive,
9:41
which is a deterrent for a lot
9:44
of people getting these surgery. So it
9:46
seems to me. That if
9:48
your you know you're in this
9:50
community that was a sex change
9:52
operations and you don't have a
9:54
way to pay for it. Seems
9:56
like the military literally just opened
9:58
up. You. Know. The say if
10:01
you need you know assertions operations.
10:03
the best way to do that
10:05
is com join the military. Ah,
10:07
We're here for you. I mean is
10:09
that the goal or mean are we
10:11
just that desperate for military that hey
10:14
there's a whole transgender you know community
10:16
that will come rushing in of we
10:18
pay for the sex change operations. Sell.
10:21
Never be able to serve. Probably ninety five
10:23
percent of them will never be able to
10:25
serve in the Us military under the qualifications
10:27
that are there. Now you know I have
10:30
the eye A doctor friends that came
10:32
to me with S and said there's been
10:34
this ridiculous uptick in the surgery. that military
10:36
hospital I'm seeing it on the the all
10:39
of them have been female to male transitions
10:41
that this person has seen and the interesting
10:43
thing about that is one of the requirements
10:46
After you go through this process through the
10:48
military's you need to change your gender within
10:50
the military. System. So you came and female
10:52
and you transition surgically to mail you need
10:54
to then be a male. In.
10:56
Their system and meet the benchmark
10:58
for men in the military. Tell
11:01
me with have everything else put
11:03
aside how many women. Are. Going
11:05
to be able to meet the benchmarks for
11:07
men for readiness in the military. Is
11:10
close to zero, which is the same argument
11:12
that we're having with women sports right now,
11:14
right? I mean, Ryan or so men are
11:16
so much stronger than women. It's just the
11:18
way it is. it's it's It's from a
11:20
readiness perspective. only forget you know the culture
11:22
part of it. Is a huge aftermath
11:24
to are kind to our country. As
11:26
I've said this I think on the
11:28
show before when I was working on
11:30
the Doctors television show I actually one
11:32
of the jobs I had was I
11:34
will go on the field and suit
11:36
a lot of surgeries over the doctors
11:38
did and I shot of friends are
11:40
transition surgery from female to male one
11:43
or the most outrageous things I've ever
11:45
witnessed in my life. But one thing
11:47
I can tell you for sure is
11:49
that the healing. Process.
11:51
From that is a long
11:53
process. So when we imagine
11:55
being you know you know
11:57
military ready I can imagine.
12:00
What I witnessed in that surgery room
12:02
I can imagine that you would be
12:04
ready to you know, charge a bumper
12:06
sarge into battle, Run into battle. For.
12:09
Several years and I mean run
12:11
into battle, have no access to
12:13
a shower anywhere for days. I
12:15
mean that the sacrifice our soldiers
12:18
milk in the middle of a
12:20
desert, sweating and dirt and sand
12:22
and sleeping on the ground and
12:24
whatever it takes a mean so
12:26
many of us aren't ready boards
12:28
but guaranteed someone that just had
12:30
a massive surgery either adding or
12:32
removing you know, a critical part
12:34
of the body. Adjusts even
12:36
imagine that soon. And you're saying that's
12:38
the case, that no one's going to
12:41
send his be one the field because
12:43
they need two much medical attention on
12:45
a constant basis. Certainly, they must need
12:47
the ability to shower and and clean
12:50
themselves off. Yeah.
12:52
It's it's a big, it's a big problem
12:54
and it will always be a problem. And
12:56
you know we haven't seen numbers and things
12:58
like that yet. Because again, this policy when
13:00
in about a year ago some folks are
13:02
coming up on their year now and that's
13:04
why the uptick. In these and in the
13:06
surgery the other interesting. Thing about this
13:08
dell that really got me was they really
13:10
do a like counseling with folks about their
13:13
loss of fertility when it going on hormones
13:15
or not or if they're going to have
13:17
an operation. Finally this will impact their fertility.
13:19
So they get counseling to say you might
13:22
want to freeze your eggs or you might
13:24
wanna consider what's going to happen if you
13:26
want to have are conceived. As an
13:28
active duty service member. And I know
13:31
from research I've done outside of this
13:33
in the civilian population, there are children
13:35
being placed on the puberty blockers and
13:37
hormones all over the country. I doubt
13:40
they're being advised about the impact on
13:42
their fertility. When they're eighteen. Nineteen,
13:44
twenty years old. Starting. These medicines
13:46
that thirteen. So there is a lot of
13:48
contradictory language in the deal. Be manual vs.
13:50
white, the government will stand at a podium
13:53
and tell you and what popular culture will
13:55
try and tell you. In. In
13:57
you know, the general public sphere. Either.
14:00
I mean, I don't know how big numbers they
14:02
would be, but what you're saying then is this
14:04
just started a year ago, they're all coming
14:06
to the end of that period in which
14:08
they had to be on the gender-blocking drugs
14:11
and walking around as
14:13
the other gender. And
14:15
now this tidal wave of
14:17
its surgery time is coming.
14:22
Does your average military surgeon know how
14:24
to do a gender reassignment or are
14:26
they bringing in specialists? Do you have
14:28
any idea how they plan on handling it? Because I
14:30
would think you'd have to know
14:32
how to do those surgeries. It's
14:36
a multidisciplinary team that they've put together
14:38
in all these hospitals. And the person
14:40
I spoke to was at one hospital
14:42
for one branch of the
14:45
military. And there are several
14:47
a week going on. In the case of
14:49
a woman transitioning to a male, a lot
14:51
of the surgery, some of it's gynecological, a
14:54
hysterectomy, and things like that, and
14:56
others reconstructive. So they have plastic
14:58
surgeons, they have people to operate
15:01
on the voice box, they have all kinds
15:03
of different doctors specializing in that, some in
15:05
the military, some they have to contract out
15:07
for. But they're really focused on keeping this
15:09
inside, Del. It's over and over
15:12
and over again in the policy. You
15:14
must have it here unless it's absolutely impossible for
15:16
you to have it here at the
15:18
hospital near you or the military hospital near
15:20
you. And that makes me think that there's
15:22
some sort of a financial component to this that
15:24
we just haven't discovered yet. And
15:26
that's obviously kind of just me guessing at this
15:29
point. But I know too much about how
15:31
the government works to think that this is just
15:33
happening for the sake of being safe about
15:35
it. One thing
15:37
that just boggles the mind, I mean,
15:39
this is really one of the craziest
15:41
stories that I've heard is because, as
15:44
I said before, why join the military? And what
15:46
is the function of a military? I
15:50
just, I struggle to see any
15:53
Value in this for the military. I
15:55
Mean, whatever your personal experience and why
15:58
you're doing what you're doing, that's... Fine,
16:00
But when we are funding our military
16:02
to be able to jump into action
16:04
and defend this and by imagine a
16:06
whole you know line of people a
16:08
sorry I can't be the one jumping
16:11
in there. Even though you've paid your
16:13
pay me to be here in your
16:15
pay for my surgeries, I'm actually not
16:17
able to do that for you. I
16:19
just I just can't imagine what. What?
16:22
Taxpayer would think that this is a
16:24
good idea and frankly like what nation
16:26
would think that this is how. We.
16:29
Sabina. This is a primary goal
16:31
for our military. It's just. One
16:34
of a mean I'm I'm I'm going to
16:36
be scratching my head for days and weeks
16:38
to com. Or Tracy it needs.
16:40
I love the work you're doing. I love
16:42
that you do. And so much of the
16:44
forests. of course. It's obvious now why this
16:46
story has gone viral. You getting any pushback
16:48
images are an argument against your perspective. I'm
16:50
I guess I'd have to ask that like.
16:53
Who's. Who would say this is a
16:55
great idea And here's why. I
16:58
haven't had any pushback which is kind of
17:00
scary I'm I've gotten a lot of people
17:02
from very own various places in the military
17:04
have come to me and said hey you
17:06
might want to see also a look at
17:08
Ces over here because this is. Agency
17:11
Wide and it's Mike's deeper than just
17:13
what we're talking about. Racism into the
17:16
a long series that I'm writing. Because
17:18
it is is something else dell
17:20
and and it's not helpful for
17:22
our defense. On. Are all.
17:24
While. We'll. Keep up the great
17:27
work Tracy! Love the work you're doing for us
17:29
and we'll talk to assume. That. They're going
17:31
to downing us. Or. I have.
17:33
You want to check out all the great
17:35
writing that she's doing for us? Go to
17:37
the High wire.com All sorts of awesome stores.
17:39
Many of them go viral, she's got her
17:42
finger on the polls and go to uncoverdc.com
17:44
Of course we're still a lot of a
17:46
writing one Support. That too.
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More