Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:04
From the Australian, here's what's on the front. I'm
0:06
Claire Harvey. It's Tuesday, June 4. The
0:14
Northern Territory's anti-corruption boss is embroiled in
0:16
a personal drama, with
0:18
the Australian revealing today Michael Riches' lawyers offered
0:20
his wife $20,000 as a settlement after
0:24
she applied for a domestic violence order
0:26
against him. Mr
0:28
Riches had made no admissions and
0:30
denies any wrongdoing. You
0:34
can read that story right now
0:37
at theaustralian.com.au Later
0:41
in today's episode, a very unusual guest
0:44
at the wedding of Brittany Higgins and
0:46
David Shiraz. Plus, all
0:48
the latest in a case that just keeps
0:50
rolling. First
0:54
up today, the immigration disaster engulfing the federal
0:56
government is getting worse. The
1:00
latest embarrassing admission from the minister
1:02
and why the Prime Minister is standing
1:04
by his man. It
1:20
was a remarkable claim by
1:22
embattled immigration minister Andrew Giles
1:24
on Sky News last week.
1:28
There is a quarter of a billion dollars
1:30
that we've invested in supporting our law enforcement
1:32
agencies to enforce that. And that's enabled things
1:35
like using drones to keep track of these
1:37
people. We know where they are. He
1:40
was talking about more than 150 people with
1:42
criminal records who've been released by the High
1:44
Court of Australia. They
1:47
were all non-citizens of Australia
1:49
and some had been convicted
1:51
of serious violent offences, including
1:54
murder and child sex abuse.
1:56
The High Court said the government
1:59
couldn't keep these people alive. people in
2:01
indefinite detention. The government
2:03
had tried to deport them to their
2:05
home countries with no success. So
2:07
they were set free and
2:10
it set off a political
2:12
nightmare now entering its fifth
2:14
month. Two
2:16
of the convicts, convicted
2:18
murderers, had no electronic
2:20
monitoring. It just happens all with
2:22
electronic monitoring. Because the law doesn't allow
2:25
it. Turns
2:27
out the claim about the drones was wrong.
2:30
There are no drones. And
2:33
on Monday the minister who's already at
2:35
the centre of this and another catastrophe
2:37
had to admit it. I
2:40
relied on information provided by my department
2:42
at the time which
2:44
has since been clarified. Giles
2:50
attacked opposition leader Peter Dutton.
2:53
This is a bloke who trusts
2:55
our immigration system, who trusts
2:57
integrity, who trusts enforcement, who let
3:00
nearly 1300 people out, not by
3:02
a court, not by a
3:04
tribunal, without any constraints
3:06
on their behaviour. That's the measure
3:08
of the man. That
3:10
other catastrophe I mentioned, that's where
3:12
the minister issued a new policy
3:15
that has inadvertently resulted in more
3:17
violent criminals remaining in Australia after
3:19
the government tried to kick them out. Over
3:23
the last week I have cancelled 30 visas
3:25
in the national interest. By the
3:27
end of this week we will
3:30
have in place a new revised
3:32
ministerial direction. And the Prime Minister
3:34
is backing him in. We
3:37
continue to refuse and cancel
3:39
visas on character grounds. We continue to
3:41
deport people who have no right to
3:43
be here. Since coming to government
3:45
we've deported over 4200 individuals from
3:49
immigration detention. Bruce
3:53
Lambman is appealing his loss in the
3:56
giant defamation battle with Network 10 and
3:58
Lisa Wilkinson. He lost his life. He watched his
4:00
appeal on Friday, and he'll be
4:02
arguing that Justice Michael Lee got
4:04
it wrong when he found Lerman
4:07
did, on the balance of probabilities,
4:09
rape Brittany Higgins. Lerman
4:11
has run out of lawyers willing to represent
4:13
him on a no-win, no-fee basis,
4:16
so he'll be representing himself up
4:19
against the expert defamation barristers Ten
4:21
and Wilkinson will no doubt engage.
4:24
They'll likely request the court order Lerman
4:26
to pay a surety up front to
4:29
ensure they do get paid if they
4:31
win. If the appeal
4:33
goes ahead, Brittany Higgins will likely need to
4:35
spend more time in court, but on
4:37
Saturday, Higgins got to enjoy a
4:39
moment of pure joy. The
4:42
former Liberal staffer married her partner
4:44
of four years, David Shiraz. The
4:48
wedding was held at the Ritzy Valley estate
4:50
in Karumbin on the Gold Coast. The
4:52
bride wore a dress by Australian
4:54
designer Paolo Sebastian, and
4:56
a big beaming smile.
5:00
Higgins posted to Instagram after the
5:02
ceremony, Today I married my best
5:04
friend. Security at the
5:06
event was tight, with members of the
5:08
media kept well away, although some did
5:10
make the guest list. Among the
5:12
80 or so people invited was
5:15
TV producer Judy McCrossum, whose optioned
5:17
the movie rights to Brittany Higgins'
5:19
unpublished memoir about her Parliament House
5:22
ordeal and everything that followed. One
5:25
guest caught R.I. is David
5:28
Shiraz's psychic friend Carrie de
5:30
Bloch. The Australian's margin
5:32
call column is reporting Shiraz has
5:34
turned to de Bloch for guidance
5:36
many times over his years in
5:38
Canberra. Coming
5:43
up, what's waiting for Brittany Higgins and David
5:46
Shiraz on the other side of the honeymoon?
5:49
While I've got you, we'd love you
5:51
to get more of this journalism by
5:53
subscribing to The Australian. Our subscribers get breaking
5:55
news alerts direct to their phones, newsletters,
5:57
special events and the most live- in
6:00
detail news, analysis and commentary
6:02
around the clock. Check us
6:05
out at theaustralian.com.au and
6:07
we'll be back after this break. Just
6:30
last week as former Liberal staffer Brittany Higgins prepped for her
6:32
big day, her legal representatives
6:57
were back in front of a judge
6:59
at the David Malcolm Justice Centre in
7:02
Perth. Higgins is being sued
7:04
by her former boss, Senator Linda
7:06
Reynolds, for social media posts made
7:08
last year. Reynolds says
7:10
her reputation was damaged by the
7:13
posts made separately on Instagram
7:15
and X, formerly known as
7:17
Twitter. I would like to
7:19
commend Justice Lee on all of his findings and
7:22
I think it is time that all parties in
7:25
this accept all of his judgments
7:28
and that includes Science Minister,
7:30
Attorney General and Attorney General's
7:32
Department. It's time for them to admit
7:34
they got it wrong. David
7:37
Chiraz was also on the hook, but
7:39
he's stepped back from the matter, saying
7:41
a trial would bankrupt him. This
7:44
latest legal action has had several
7:46
false starts, with mandated mediations breaking
7:48
down more than once. Now
7:50
Senator Reynolds is attempting to uncover the
7:53
details of a protected trust in
7:55
Brittany Higgins' name. Her lawyers
7:57
believe it's been set up to
7:59
shield a two-part deal. $1.4 million
8:01
compensation payout from litigation. Reynolds
8:04
lawyer Martin Bennett said last month he's been
8:06
waiting to receive a copy of the trust
8:08
deed since March. He
8:11
believes it holds important details that
8:13
will clarify its purpose. Basically
8:16
what they're trying to decipher is if
8:19
Brittany Higgins could actually pay damages or
8:21
legal costs to Linda Reynolds if a
8:23
judge finds the former senator was defamed.
8:26
The matter will head to trial in late July.
8:32
Late last month the other defamation
8:35
matter where Bruce Lerman unsuccessfully sued
8:37
Network Tenant Lisa Wilkinson was back
8:39
before the federal court. Front
8:42
listeners know Lerman lost overall
8:44
because Justice Michael Lee found he did
8:46
on the balance of probabilities rape
8:48
Brittany Higgins in 2019. As
8:51
you know he's appealing that verdict. Having
8:54
escaped the lines did Mr Lerman made the
8:56
mistake of coming back free. But
9:00
Justice Lee had big problems with Network Tenant
9:02
Lisa Wilkinson's journalism and they lost
9:04
on their other defense which was
9:06
qualified privilege. That is their
9:08
journalism was reasonable. The judge said
9:11
it wasn't reasonable. Lerman
9:13
will have to pay most of Tenant
9:15
Wilkinson's costs but it's unlikely he has
9:17
the multi-millions required to settle their bills.
9:20
Now Wilkinson and Tenant trying to sort out
9:23
who pays which parts of her legal bills.
9:25
This after the trial ensured all
9:27
Tenant's dirty laundry was well and
9:30
truly aired. Howard effectively
9:32
sacked Wilkinson from her on-air role
9:34
after she made an unfortunate Logie
9:36
speech even though Tenant had legal
9:38
and approved the speech. Howard
9:40
tried to persuade her not to engage her
9:42
own lawyers and Howard after
9:44
Brittany Higgins indicated she didn't like Wilkinson's
9:47
chosen lawyers. Howard Tenant tried to get
9:49
its former star to choose different representatives.
10:00
work 10. She was asking
10:02
for 10 to cover her costs in
10:04
the defamation case against Bruce Lehrman.
10:07
10 is still quibbling about how much of Wilkinson's
10:09
bills it should pay, but it all came out
10:12
in the open at the most recent hearing. Wilkinson's
10:14
total bill so far is $1.8 million.
10:17
That includes $8,000
10:21
per day in court for top defamation silk
10:23
Sue Chrysanthe SC plus $800 per
10:25
hour for preparation
10:27
work, sending emails and travel time.
10:30
It also includes another $3,500 per day
10:33
for the junior barrister working with Chrysanthe
10:35
Barry Dean and then the
10:37
solicitors who charged Wilkinson up to $750 per
10:40
hour for their work on the case. That
10:42
firm Gillis Delaney
10:45
charged $390 for one phone call and $16 for
10:47
a subscription to the Australian. At
10:52
least they've got impeccable taste. My
11:32
name is Manny Carutas and I'm a
11:34
former New South Wales policeman turned investigative
11:36
reporter with a passion for missing persons
11:38
cases. I'm here to quickly
11:41
tell you about our true Crime Australia podcast,
11:43
The Missing. In this series I look at
11:45
old missing persons cases which have all gone
11:47
cold in an attempt to try and uncover
11:49
new information which could help
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More