Andrew Webbur's journey of Fate begins when he is confronted by his long time nemesis, Jason Vanzant. Jason accuses Andrew of stealing his girlfriend and confronts him with violent repercussions.

Mr. Spieker, the principal of Calumet Bay High, also seems to be on the warpath with Andrew in his sights. Neither Mr. Spieker nor Jason Vanzant compare to the butterflies in Andrew's stomach, as he wrestles with his feelings for Bethany Mogg.

As if Andrew didn't have enough problems, he begins receiving mysterious; "I know who you are" messages. The mysterious stalker seems to know about Andrew's secret abilities. To save the future, Andrew and his friends must discover, "Who is Stalking Andrew?"