Podchaser Logo
Home
Ep.59 - The Disturbing Case of The Rack Man

Ep.59 - The Disturbing Case of The Rack Man

Released Monday, 22nd January 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Ep.59 - The Disturbing Case of The Rack Man

Ep.59 - The Disturbing Case of The Rack Man

Ep.59 - The Disturbing Case of The Rack Man

Ep.59 - The Disturbing Case of The Rack Man

Monday, 22nd January 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

I got to start secretly recording Keith when he doesn't

0:02

think the microphone is on. That's a terrible idea. Yeah,

0:04

that was good. So I enjoyed you listening to all

0:06

the actresses you would have sex with. That's

0:09

not what happened. All

0:12

right. Hey you and welcome. My name

0:14

is Mike and I'm once again joined

0:16

by Keith for another episode. Other

0:20

than that, oh man, you guys don't want to know what we

0:22

were talking about before I pressed record. It was very innocent. Was

0:24

it? Yeah.

0:26

So as you can tell, as you can

0:28

tell by his dirty, despicable thoughts being

0:30

recorded forever. There out for all. Joining

0:33

in by Keith. Hello. Hello. Hello, Keith. How

0:36

are you today? What's going on? Great. Yeah,

0:38

excited to be here. Excited to be back

0:40

at it again. New year, new podcast. You

0:42

are brimming with excitement. I can see it

0:44

in your eyes. You came here, sparkles, sparkles

0:46

in your eyes. You skipped in the door.

0:48

You brought that podcast glow. Yeah, exactly. Ready

0:51

for the pod glow. So

0:53

what's going on? You know what Keith? What's

0:56

going on in your life? And let's, let's talk

0:58

here. So, you know, uh, you record a podcast, you

1:00

have a regular job that you got, you're doing the

1:02

family life. You got it. You got a wife and

1:04

a kid, you know, doing your thing, working

1:06

your job. And then you come over to old

1:08

Mike in the evening and we have our, we have

1:11

our little podcast. We have our little podcast session. Um,

1:13

we shoot the shift. We do have a couple of

1:16

beers every now and again, but still do the dry,

1:18

dry January. I'm

1:20

drinking a, um, a delicious can of

1:22

diet. Coca-Cola. I'm trying to watch my

1:24

figure. Uh, hey, listen,

1:27

I'm Turdie tree now, you know, you gotta watch those

1:29

cows. You know

1:31

what I'm saying? You gotta gotta keep it tight. Keep

1:35

it tight for the fans. Yeah, exactly. That's

1:37

it. Yeah. Yeah. You're not drinking either

1:39

in solidarity. You are. Yeah. I know

1:41

Keith texted me. He was like pints

1:43

smiley face. I said, alas. Nope.

1:45

No, no, not tonight. Kind of Carlsberg. No Carlsberg

1:48

for Keith. I know. Yeah. You're drinking a, probably

1:50

the best beer in the world. No,

1:52

it's awful. I hate Carlsberg. Yeah, I do. I really

1:54

don't like it. I read it. I, I think it's

1:56

just, it tastes like shit. I liked the price. For

1:59

some reason. cheapest. What

2:01

do you mean for some reason it's cheap? You're only drinking

2:03

it because it's the cheapest. I always go with cubes on

2:05

the cheap. No, you're cheap fast. I

2:09

like to spend my money elsewhere. You're actually not really a

2:11

man who buys things very often. You're not a very

2:14

materialistic person I would say. No, I'm

2:16

really not. I don't wear it by my

2:18

money. The bank. I put it in the bank. That's

2:20

probably the most exciting thing I do. There you go. I

2:23

love saving. Yeah? There you go. Great little saver. Just looking

2:25

at how much money we have to take. We're on

2:27

the way for a rainy day. Exactly. So what's been going

2:29

on? What's going on with you?

2:31

Any stories? Any mad stories for the fans?

2:33

They all want to... Oh, by the way,

2:36

I don't know if I should say this on the podcast because

2:38

it's kind of a spoiler. But on the

2:40

subreddit, the dot chapter subreddit or

2:42

slash chapter, someone posted... Somebody found

2:45

your Instagram. Did they? Yeah. How?

2:48

I have no idea. From frickin'

2:50

weirdos out there. Some sleuth. Yeah,

2:53

they posted it. Yeah, honestly,

2:55

fair play to you. But yeah, they did. They

2:57

were like, is this Keith? And it was your

2:59

Instagram. Oh, so it is. Okay, yeah. I don't

3:02

follow you. You found me. So they

3:04

did. I don't follow you on Instagram specifically because I'm

3:06

like, yeah, okay. If I follow you, you can go

3:08

to who I'm following. Right, yeah. And they'll be able

3:10

to follow. I don't know how they found you. Yeah.

3:14

But then they found pictures of

3:16

you and it was a picture

3:18

of you, a picture of which is how I describe

3:20

you. A picture of a cat. Oh, yeah. Black cat.

3:22

And then... We've decided... I

3:24

don't say that. We've decided with Salem. Yeah.

3:26

And I really want the Philip, but... I

3:29

like Black Philip. I think that's great. Me too. But my

3:31

daughter's stuck on Salem. That's fair. So it's like, okay. Yeah.

3:34

We compromised and we went... She can win this

3:36

round. I actually want to bring

3:38

it up because it's kind of funny. So

3:40

this is for the Redditors out there. Okay, where

3:43

is it? Have I

3:45

found the majestic Keith? Is what somebody

3:47

posted here. All right, here you go.

3:50

See? That's you.

3:52

Hey. Well done. Congrats

3:55

to E-A-M. E-I-M. They did. That was...

4:00

You are correct. Obviously with the comments that we see with the comments

4:02

I need actually start being a bit more active on

4:04

what Instagram because I got us Yeah, I should

4:07

probably get it and then I haven't really done

4:09

much honest. Yeah. No, you're in post in Instagram

4:11

anyway So for those who are right there who

4:13

want to follow them? I mean don't fucking I

4:21

don't even know. I don't know why you didn't put your Instagram on

4:23

private. Anyway, it's like almost like you wanted to be found Did

4:26

you even check your Instagram does anybody start following

4:29

you? I actually didn't even think I said I

4:31

said I said probably should upon private and didn't

4:33

think about it Probably should okay. So here's what

4:35

it says So it says how I found a majestic

4:37

Keith and a picture of your Instagram and then picture

4:39

of who you follow And one of them is me

4:41

and then says greetings all after weeks

4:44

and weeks of every session debate. I

4:47

Believe my partner. Okay, so it wasn't this person

4:49

their partner May have located

4:51

the face of the wild mysterious and

4:53

majestic Guys

4:56

if only you knew I

4:58

hear your back from big dog. Where's my logic? No one's

5:00

ever used those words to describe you Here's

5:04

the first on the podcast It's mentioned that Keith

5:06

has recently made an Instagram and his face is

5:08

in their profile pic and he has no posts

5:10

at the time The second point is this bearded

5:13

beauty Is

5:16

following that chapter and then surely then says

5:18

surely this must be the one the one

5:20

is capitalized There you

5:22

go I

5:25

do but I do have a picture of the cat

5:27

up there as well. So and then the top rated

5:29

comment is by Marty 61

5:31

says perhaps nice investigating or as Mike would say

5:34

look at you. Hey, look at you. Yeah

5:37

One person did say actually in your in

5:39

your in your I don't know if you'd

5:41

say this defense I don't think this defense. I

5:44

think fucking put you up everywhere It

5:46

says I think if you wanted his face shown

5:48

he would have given Mike permission to show it

5:50

Please don't take offense, but this seems like overstepping

5:53

to me. That's a by one person. What do

5:55

you think of that? I don't care Keith doesn't

5:57

give a shit post his face everywhere. And yes,

5:59

somebody actually said There's a black cat in his

6:01

yard on the podcast you mentioned

6:03

it father Greery Rasputin. That's your own

6:05

first in college. Yeah And

6:10

of course even Guinness in your thing and you always talk

6:12

about Guinness that was the Christmas Guinness when we were drinking

6:18

Literally there's three pictures on one is the Guinness one is the black

6:21

cat and one is you We

6:23

long hair into twos as I know I kind of put it

6:25

those three photos like that's it. I thought I got man Oh,

6:28

well, there you go. There you go

6:30

folks Here

6:38

is the teeth has been added

6:40

he's out of the

6:42

out of the non-identified closet All

6:46

right, okay before you get into this I wonder

6:48

you know another complaint down here, but I'm

6:51

just fucking talking I think I actually

6:53

feel like the fact that I'm not drinking is making

6:55

me more to the chest more

6:57

Shitty-chaddy more fucking scatterbrained You

7:00

know a common complaint I see about

7:02

podcasts is that people the podcaster hosts

7:04

don't get into it A lot of

7:07

people want okay. This podcast is about

7:09

XYZ. Mm-hmm begin Yes, start talking

7:11

and you know, we take a very different attitude

7:13

and that's after podcast to shoot shit We do

7:15

like to shoot shit, you know, we like to

7:17

we're not just you know, your your your narrators,

7:20

you know We were your buddies, you know, but

7:22

we're shooting to shit with creative vibe of we're

7:25

in the pub chatting away And

7:27

you're there listening. Also, I feel

7:29

it gets me into it easier as well Yeah, instead

7:31

of just kind of because sometimes I arrive here. I

7:33

was like, hey, let's let's get into it. Let me

7:35

sit down It's very hard kind of just start Ron.

7:37

Oh, I need I need to I need to warn

7:39

you know, I need to warm up the cannon That's

7:41

it. That's you know. All right. There you go.

7:43

That killed about nine minutes All

7:46

right. Hey you and welcome. My name is Mike

7:48

and in this old one we're going back

7:50

there under my For

7:53

a pair of mysteries today's story is

7:55

actually been two kind of sort of

7:57

mysteries. I guess you could say would

8:00

say salt. Yeah, sort of half salt I'd say.

8:03

Well, very well put. Well,

8:05

look at it working into us. Very good. And

8:07

these stories have confounded investigators throughout the

8:10

last century and maybe, just maybe, they'll

8:12

confound you too. So let's get into

8:14

it. We have two stories today. Both

8:16

are linked by Australia. So you know

8:18

what I mean? Put into your mind

8:21

koalas, kangaroos, didgeridoos, other funny words. I

8:23

like what's up. There you go. Would

8:25

you like to go to Australia? Yeah,

8:27

I'd love to go to Australia. I've

8:30

always wanted to go. The

8:32

videos of the giant spiders are enough

8:34

to put me off and make

8:36

me fucking not want to go. But I would love to

8:38

go. It looks like a beautiful country. I like

8:41

it. The people seem pretty, pretty badass. They're

8:43

all hot as well. Do you know how

8:45

strange they're like sexy people?

8:47

Yeah, well, yeah, they're all descendants

8:49

of criminals. So literally it's only

8:52

the strong survive. So I think

8:54

that's probably why they're just like, they're like genetically bred

8:56

to be like just like tall, strong. Also

8:58

when you're just looking around where we live,

9:00

a bunch of sport heads. Yeah,

9:02

I know. I know. We're just like, yeah, I know. Anything.

9:08

I know. It's a low bar. Yeah, I always

9:10

say all the good looking art people were taken

9:12

away by the Vikings. That's why the Norwegians are

9:14

also good. Hot looking. They stole all our hot

9:16

people a thousand years ago. Left all the ogos.

9:19

No, you can say. You're not welcome on the

9:21

boat. No, there's some room over there. No, no,

9:23

no. You

9:26

can say here, we're not going to destroy your

9:29

den. You're fine. So

9:32

our story begins on August 11th

9:34

1994 when a man named Mark

9:37

Macfay-de-sun and his small crew

9:39

were at a spot fishing on the

9:41

Hawkesbury River just north of Sydney. Hawkesbury

9:46

River, by the way, real big. Stranded by jungle

9:48

on all sides. And it looks pretty cool. There's

9:51

some pictures and videos of Hawkesbury River. It looks

9:53

like a jungle river, kind of

9:55

like straight out of a video game. If you want to put

9:57

it that way. And I just said he

9:59

was excited. to pull in a hull much

10:01

heavier than usual. Mark

10:03

had no idea he was about to

10:05

open the lid on a mystery that

10:08

would bamboozle Australia for decades.

10:11

Expecting to either see a net bulging with

10:13

fish, trash or maybe even a giant squid

10:15

or a shark. Mark got none of

10:17

the above. Maybe it was the

10:19

hawksbury river monster. One of Australia's strangest

10:21

cryptids. Well this is how

10:23

it goes. Good intern folks. Tell

10:26

me more. It supposedly has two sets

10:28

of flippers, a lengthy snake-like

10:30

neck and four arses. No

10:34

that last part's a joke. It basically looks like the

10:36

Loch Ness Monster. Oh cool. Yeah

10:38

supposedly but there's Aboriginal rock art

10:40

between like 3 and 4 thousand

10:42

years old in the area that

10:44

describes creatures. Yeah who knows. Honestly

10:47

though if a new cryptid is actually going to be

10:49

found my money is for it to be found in

10:51

Australia. Well yeah they have some mad creatures out there.

10:53

All the weirdest creatures. They're going to find

10:55

something fucking bizarre out there. Something shouldn't be

10:57

alive. But somehow it is. That's very true.

10:59

Keith, he once again with your random fact

11:01

you knocked it out of the park. So

11:05

no Mark Peterson did not pull up the

11:07

hawksbury river monster. I

11:10

bet he wish he did. I bet he wish he

11:13

did too. I'm sure he fucking wishes he did. Because

11:15

but what he did pulled it out. It took him

11:17

a few moments to figure out what

11:19

exactly he was looking at. It was

11:21

a mix of hard right angles and

11:23

squishy pale clumps. Then it

11:26

hit him. What Mark was

11:28

looking at, what they had just pulled out

11:30

of the river was a large metal

11:33

crucifix. Not a cross, a crucifix. It's

11:35

actually a fun fact. I did not

11:37

know this. But it's not a

11:39

crucifix unless it comes with a person attached. So

11:42

it's a cross with that person. It's a crucifix with the

11:44

person. Most commonly Jesus. But in this case

11:46

it wasn't Jesus. It was someone else. Right okay.

11:49

So the crude rusted structure

11:51

was the unmistakable shape of

11:53

a human body. Mostly

11:56

wrapped in black plastic. It

11:58

was pale, bloated, fried. from substantial

12:00

time underwater and badly decomposed, but

12:03

it was certainly a real human

12:05

body. What Mark could make

12:07

out was the sight of a long,

12:09

thick bone sticking out of the mess

12:12

of plastic and seascum. This

12:14

crucifix structure had been welded into

12:16

a torture device. Dude, that's stuff

12:18

of nightmares isn't it? Grim.

12:21

Peterson, once he calmed down, called

12:23

the police, and crime scene investigators

12:25

and forensics came to study this

12:27

gruesome find. Once they'd

12:29

managed to confirm the remains were

12:31

100% human, the body and

12:33

the crucifix were passed on to pathologist

12:36

Dr. Christopher Lawrence. Lawrence

12:38

removed the black plastic wrapping, stripping

12:41

away large chunks of hair and

12:43

fatty tissue as he went. The

12:46

corpse had been secured to the

12:48

structure with orange rope and twisted

12:50

metal wire. The only items

12:52

in this John Doe's pockets were an

12:54

open packet of cigarettes and a lighter,

12:56

neither of which were any use in

12:58

identifying who he was. Lawrence's

13:01

investigation revealed several key details

13:03

about the victim. It

13:05

was a man, I think they

13:07

call him Blokes in Australia. Blokes

13:09

and Sheila. Blokes and Sheila, there

13:11

you go. Caucasian, likely of Mediterranean

13:14

or European descent, and had

13:16

been aged somewhere between 21 and 46 years

13:19

old. That white on age range,

13:21

that's how badly decomposed the remains

13:23

were. He also determined that the man

13:26

stood at just 5'2 or 5'4 in stature. He

13:29

was a short king and his official

13:32

cause of death was blunt force

13:34

trauma. Though critically, Lawrence couldn't

13:36

confirm whether the man had been killed

13:38

before or after, being tied to the

13:40

crucifix. The level of

13:42

decomposition meant that efforts to obtain

13:44

fingerprints were fruitless and yielded nothing

13:46

but indistinct smudges. Even

13:49

trying to get a solid DNA sample

13:51

for testing against databases was a no-go.

13:53

Any hope of a speedy resolution to the

13:56

mystery was kicked into the bin when searches

13:58

of the missing person were found. the person's

14:00

database turned up no results. It's important

14:02

to note our DNA, by the way, back at this stage,

14:04

it was in its infancy and was

14:07

only just becoming more widely used

14:09

and had recently been recognised as

14:11

legally admissible. I went down to

14:13

a bit of a rabbit hole. You did! You

14:15

did! Looking into the decomposition

14:17

of bodies, of corked water and...

14:21

Ooh! So first of all,

14:23

it's gross. Yeah, I think I've seen

14:25

some pictures online of what water

14:28

does to the human body and that you

14:31

don't want to know. It's pretty nasty. They don't

14:33

even look like bodies anymore. But

14:35

I found that forensic pathologists, they actually

14:38

made major improvements recently in the ability

14:40

to get fingerprints from even advanced, decayed

14:42

corpses. The process is called tanitopraxi, which

14:44

comes from tanitos, which is the god of death

14:46

in Greek mythology, which is kind of cool. But

14:50

it's still a fairly young discipline in

14:52

funeral homes to embalm bodies. From

14:54

a forensic point of view, their focus is

14:57

mainly on the reconstruction of the original appearance

14:59

of the bodies, which

15:01

have advanced decay. And the meta is

15:03

done by removing fluids from tissues, restoring

15:05

their original tension and volume. But

15:08

when applied to the hands, it can produce high-quality

15:10

fingerprints. But I still feel, in this case, like,

15:12

this is like years later, they kind of felt it.

15:14

I still kind of feel in this case, it was so

15:16

far gone, I don't think they're going to get anything off it.

15:18

This body was like severely decomposed. We'll get to it, but

15:21

yeah, you thought it had been in the water for a while.

15:23

So investigators' next go-to was what

15:25

little remained of the victim's clothing.

15:28

An everything Australian brand polo shirt

15:30

and medium, and a no sweat

15:33

branded sweatpants. Unfortunately, they

15:35

just happened to be some of the most

15:37

popular and generic brands sold in Australia and

15:39

didn't narrow down the search at all. Though

15:42

investigators did get some helpful information back

15:44

from a study of a metal structure.

15:47

Or to be more exact, some

15:50

tiny particles attached to the cross.

15:53

Senator Donald Anderson of the School of

15:55

Biological Sciences found that the structure and

15:57

the body had not been under the

16:00

the water for more than a year. A

16:24

cast and forensic reconstruction of the

16:26

victim's face was created, and for

16:29

a while, the man's image was

16:31

everywhere. The unidentified man

16:33

soon gained the name The Rackman, and

16:35

that's how he'd be known for over

16:37

25 years. As

16:40

is usually the case, the publicity brought in

16:42

an offer of a cash reward, and

16:45

as that usually goes, authorities got no

16:47

shortage of tips from randos, sidekicks and

16:49

just well-meaning members of the public. Despite

16:52

the reward eventually hitting 100,000 Australian

16:55

dollars, no one could offer

16:57

anything that led to a positive identification.

16:59

Did you see the reconstruction of the

17:01

face? I will now. Kind

17:04

of horrifying. But it also kind of- Oh wait, no, I

17:06

think I have. Yeah. Oh yeah, it's

17:08

very creepy. It kind of strangely looks like the drummer

17:10

from The Hill a bit as well. Keep

17:12

Moon. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I

17:15

think the eyebrows and hair, but yeah. Very

17:17

weird. Creepy. I mean, I think

17:19

it's just the fact that it's like a

17:21

wax face. That'll do

17:23

it. But weird. Let's

17:26

go and take a look. It's weird. The

17:28

weird thing, however, is that this was

17:31

clearly a very intentional and well-planned out

17:33

murder. Whoever had done this likely had

17:35

not acted alone. In fact, investigators were

17:37

pretty certain, right from the very beginning,

17:39

that they were looking for multiple suspects.

17:42

After all, the victim might have been slight

17:44

of bills, but it still would

17:46

have likely taken more than one person

17:49

to create the rack or the crucifix,

17:51

let alone kill the man and fix

17:53

him to the steel structure. The

17:55

weight and the size of the crucifix meant that

17:58

to have a transporter and dumped into the

18:00

river complete with a man attached, no

18:02

one person could have or would have

18:04

managed to be able to do it

18:06

themselves. Police were definitely looking

18:08

for multiple people. One really

18:11

worrying detail that might seem minor but

18:13

is considered a key detail is the

18:15

level of welding involved. You see, there

18:17

is a big difference between a hobbyist

18:20

and a pro when it comes to

18:22

welding, it's a skill that's easy to

18:24

learn, takes a long time to master.

18:27

Whoever welded the crucifix had done a pro

18:29

job on it, which kind of makes this

18:31

seem a little bit more creepy. I think

18:34

that there was someone who was a master

18:36

making this thing. I mean, if it was

18:38

like done like shittily, kind of throwing together,

18:40

trying to get a lashing it up like

18:43

last minute. Now it's like, oh no, this

18:45

is like planned out. And they purposely done.

18:47

Yeah. And they really took their time to

18:49

make this. Like that body wasn't going anywhere. The

18:51

crucifix, it was kind of measured to

18:53

size for it about like it was perfectly. Really?

18:56

Per a short guy. Yeah. And

18:58

it also included some rebar in the

19:00

middle that was kind of welded in the structure

19:03

like an L shape. Okay. So

19:05

that was to prevent the body from falling

19:07

off. So you had the flat

19:09

structure of the crucifix in the middle of this L

19:11

shape. So the body was kind of stuck.

19:13

And then it was also like it was tied down with

19:16

wire and the rope around the boat. Yeah. That

19:18

body wasn't going anywhere. Wow. And

19:20

due to it being the early 90s, of course, two of

19:22

the first early targets were A, gangs

19:25

and B. Doo doo doo

19:27

doo. See this baby. Yeah. Yeah.

19:30

The moral panic around Utes listening to the

19:32

devil's music and being inspired to get all

19:34

stabby was very rife at this time. And

19:37

gang violence had been on the rise around

19:39

the world. Once again,

19:41

the investigators and the investigation

19:43

went nowhere and detectives were left a

19:45

little more frustrated than when they had

19:48

started. The very nature of

19:50

the case with several people involved pointed

19:52

to a conspiracy. It's a goddamn fucking

19:54

conspiracy of some kind. Usually

19:57

in these cases, it's just a matter of

19:59

time until someone's. This lifts up and says

20:02

something they shouldn't, but this time no one

20:04

was talking a very bizarre and

20:06

creepy mystery. This is goddamn

20:08

Satanist welders, huh? It's

20:10

a very niche sub-genre of Satanist, but

20:13

very dangerous. Yeah, I mean, it sounds

20:15

like something Satanists would do. Yeah, yeah. Make

20:18

cool shit. I feel so. It's one that

20:20

never actually turns out to be the Satanist in the

20:22

largest cases, but there actually

20:24

was one, there was a known

20:26

case in Ireland where we had

20:28

our very own Satanic murder. With

20:31

the crucifixion and shit? Yeah, yeah.

20:33

Wow. Tell me more. What is

20:35

that? What's that? So there

20:37

was, so a seven year old boy, he

20:39

was found dead. He was lashed in crucifix

20:42

fashion to the rafters of an attic in

20:44

Dublin in 1973 out in Palmerstown, which

20:47

is near the Phoenix Park. Which is

20:49

like west of Dublin. Yes, yes. Most

20:52

people who were listening to this are probably not familiar with that familiar with

20:54

Dublin. You don't know Palmerstown?

20:56

Yeah. But beneath the hanging

20:59

body there was like an altar on which there

21:01

was a chalice and communion hosts which were laid

21:03

out. And a 16 year old

21:05

boy who was obsessed with the occult, he pleaded

21:07

guilty to the murder and he was sentenced to life in

21:09

Britain. Very interesting story. He was

21:11

just obsessed with Satan and shit, so he

21:13

killed another boy, brought him to

21:16

his attic and crucified him. Yeah, so he

21:18

was obsessed with like hiding with the occult.

21:20

He started off with like neighbours, dogs and

21:22

cats would go missing. Oh, the usual serial

21:24

killer shit? Yeah, yeah. He was just like

21:26

washing these animals and then he just leveled

21:28

up and then he brought out his, it

21:30

was one of his neighbours. His mother was

21:32

out working, so he said that he babysit.

21:35

He brought him out and killed him and then hung him

21:37

in the crucifix for him up in the rafters in his

21:39

attic. Wow. And what his parents came home and

21:41

were like, what's the name of that? Well

21:43

yeah, there was an investigation went out. Oh,

21:45

for a missing kid. For a missing kid in the garden he found it. The

21:49

police. Yeah. Holy shit. That's

21:51

why. Yeah, that's the F's to the V.

21:54

Mmm. Mad, okay. Yeah,

21:56

well, I don't think it was him who did this one,

21:58

but you never know. You never know. An

22:01

early front-runner for the identity of the

22:03

man behind the mystery was Joe Viviano.

22:07

Viviano was the right height and age

22:09

and had even been said to resemble

22:11

the facial reconstruction by several people who

22:13

knew him. Better yet, was that

22:15

Viviano had also previously been convicted of drugs-related

22:17

offenses, so he could maybe link this to

22:19

a gang. Maybe he pissed off the wrong

22:21

gang and they literally crucified him. Viviano

22:24

had been missing since being last seen

22:26

in the Drumoyne suburb of Sydney. It

22:29

was all looking good, and the police

22:31

were hopeful to clear things up by

22:34

comparing results from a forensic odontologist. By

22:37

the way, I had never heard of the term a

22:39

forensic odontologist. And a forensic odontologist,

22:41

I'm bringing out the pointer here, got a

22:43

key style. Did you know? There goes that

22:45

finger. A forensic

22:47

odontologist is the person brought in

22:50

to identify folk via dental records.

22:52

I actually would have thought it was a dentist who would do it, but no.

22:55

It's a forensic odontologist. Although maybe they're a

22:57

dentist and an odontologist in their spare time.

22:59

Maybe. Yeah, a bit of pocket change in

23:01

the weekend. Exactly, yeah, a bit of cashing

23:03

hands. Yeah. You

23:05

know? But however, the records couldn't be found

23:08

of Viviano's original black teeth. So

23:10

finally, they tested what little DNA they

23:13

had from the unidentified victim against Viviano's

23:15

and came back with a... It

23:19

was not him. And the investigation was

23:21

right back at square one. Another

23:24

strong theory in the gangland vein, the

23:26

identity of the giando, was believed it

23:28

could be in fact Christopher Dale Flannery.

23:31

Flannery had become somewhat infamously

23:34

known as Mr. Rentakill, a

23:37

nickname he certainly didn't earn by

23:39

exterminating rats. Or did

23:41

he? See, Flannery had

23:43

earned himself a reputation as an enforcer

23:45

and hitman for hire and had been

23:48

alleged to be behind several high profile

23:50

murders in Australia. Those

23:52

murders included a barrister, a lawyer,

23:54

and an undercover drug squad detective.

23:56

So pretty hardcore targets, as you

23:58

can imagine. And as

24:00

you also can probably imagine, Flannery was on a

24:03

lot of people's shit list, and it wouldn't have

24:05

been the greatest shock to have him turn up

24:07

dead. After escaping conviction on

24:09

several occasions, it seems that in May

24:12

1985, Flannery

24:14

got on the side of one

24:16

too many bad guys, and narrowly

24:18

survived an assassination attempt that also

24:20

targeted his family. That's not

24:23

something you do to a dangerous guy like

24:25

Flannery, without the intention to make sure you

24:27

get him. Flannery disappeared after

24:29

he reached out to a former

24:31

employer, and fellow top-line bad man

24:33

George Freeman. Flannery was apparently

24:35

on his way to see Freeman in

24:38

a taxi when he vanished. Whether

24:40

something happened before, after, or during

24:43

that fateful taxi trip was

24:45

never known and may never

24:47

be known, and some proposed

24:49

that the discovery of the

24:51

Rackman had finally revealed Mr.

24:53

Rentakill's final resting place. It

24:56

was a genuine and solid theory that a lot of

24:58

people sincerely expected to plan out. This guy had gone

25:00

on a lot of people's shit lists, he'd been on

25:03

a lot of gangs, a lot of stuff like that,

25:05

and something this traumatic wouldn't be that out of place.

25:08

After all, Flannery had enough enemies with considerable

25:10

means and motive to be able to have

25:12

something like this done. It would also

25:14

explain the sheer vindictive nature of the killing.

25:17

It was all looking good until Flannery's

25:19

dental records came in, or

25:22

the forensic odontologist, who said, don't

25:24

mind if I do, another job

25:26

for me folks. And, well, nope,

25:28

did not match. Dental records did not

25:30

match. The theory was done. Does the

25:33

investigation have to start all over again?

25:36

I'm not sure if it was related to gangland killing.

25:39

There definitely was a level of professionalism

25:41

with this crime, but I can't

25:43

feel with ganglands to send a message.

25:46

They're like, don't do it again. I don't know

25:48

why they would go through all this effort to

25:50

stay just in the labra scene and then also

25:52

hide the body so no one would ever find

25:54

it. You're jumping ahead. We

25:57

will come back to this. Okay. We'll come back to

25:59

this. Another promising lead seemed

26:01

to be that of 22 year old

26:03

Stephen Collin Bryant. Bryant had

26:05

visited a neighbor two days before Christmas

26:08

1993 and apparently agreed to

26:10

join his friends, James and Christine, for

26:12

Christmas dinner. Only Stephen would

26:14

never arrive. Actually, in fact, Stephen was

26:16

never seen again. Though he lived alone

26:19

and it wasn't unusual for him to

26:21

go several days without contacting anyone, the

26:23

fact that he missed the appointed Christmas

26:25

lunch had alarm bells ringing over the

26:27

jingle bells right away. But it wasn't

26:29

until Valentine's Day in 1994, over a

26:32

month later, that Stephen was actually reported

26:34

missing. The subsequent investigation found

26:36

Stephen's house in good order and it didn't

26:38

seem as though Stephen had been intending to

26:40

go away for a long time, with

26:43

clothes still in his wardrobe, food still

26:45

in his cupboard. The phone

26:47

bill and utilities were also active

26:49

up until, well, Stephen went missing.

26:52

Though he hadn't accessed his bank account since even

26:55

earlier in December 1993 on the 16th. So

26:58

how long he'd actually been missing, nobody

27:01

really knows. Police have

27:03

said that they are no closer to

27:05

the truth behind Stephen's vanishing. Nothing has

27:07

been seen or heard from and there

27:09

were hopes that the rock man would

27:11

solve the mystery. Honestly, until very recently,

27:13

Stephen was considered a strong possibility. But

27:17

the last possibility that stood

27:20

long time neck and neck

27:22

with Stephen Bryant, that the

27:24

remains belonged to Max Tanshevsky.

27:27

37 years old at the time of his

27:29

disappearance, Tanshevsky hadn't been seen since January 1993,

27:33

when he'd been seen with his then

27:35

girlfriend in Newtown, Sydney. Max,

27:38

as it turned out, was something of a

27:40

degenerate gambler and would often walk around with

27:42

large amounts of cash on him. The

27:44

last time he was seen alive, he

27:47

was carrying $1,800, having

27:49

recently withdrawn the money from his bank

27:51

accounts. Max, he had a habit of

27:53

heading off to the Gold Coast for

27:55

frequent gambling spurges and would have inevitably

27:57

rolled back sometimes with winnings, more

27:59

often than not. And that's

28:02

exactly how his partner expected this latest trip to

28:04

end, but more and more days passed and there

28:06

was no sign of Max. Like

28:09

Steven, Max was never seen again

28:11

and no one knew what happened to him. He

28:13

was known to have several deaths to various

28:16

unsavoury people, just as you'd expect a man

28:18

with a severe gambling addiction to have, so

28:20

what likely happened to you, as I said,

28:22

he didn't win or he

28:25

did win. So for the last

28:27

decade, Bryant and Tanshevsky were the candidates most likely to

28:29

have suffered the

28:37

gruesome death. After

28:39

24 years of investigation, alongside

28:41

huge advancements in DNA, the

28:44

mystery, or at least

28:46

part of the mystery, was finally

28:48

solved when samples taken at the

28:50

time of the discovery of the

28:52

remains were finally tested with modern

28:54

techniques and it turns out, one

28:56

of the police's guesses was right

28:58

the entire time. In August 2018, Deputy

29:02

State Coroner for New South Wales,

29:04

Paul McMahon, officially ruled that the

29:06

remains belonged to none other than

29:09

Max Tanshevsky. That's where

29:11

the story ends, for now at

29:13

least. There is little else publicly

29:15

known about Tanshevsky. The most

29:18

common theory is the obvious one, that he

29:20

got himself into debt with the wrong people

29:22

and they decided to make an example out

29:24

of him to dissuade anyone else from doing

29:27

the very same, but as

29:29

you just mentioned, my dear friend, the obvious

29:31

problem with that theory is that, well, there's

29:33

a couple. One is that

29:35

numerous people would have known about

29:38

this, about what had happened to Max

29:40

and nobody ever said anything.

29:43

Also, as you said, if it was gang

29:45

related, he owed the money and a gang

29:47

wanted to make an example out of him,

29:49

a horrific death and then kept a secret.

29:51

Yes, yes, crease makes, yes,

29:53

and the river where nobody would find it, you put

29:56

that up in the fucking center of Tans. Like

29:58

Mexican cartel chopping heads off and

30:00

hanging them on light posts. Yeah, they video put it

30:02

online. Yeah, exactly. Yeah, yeah, yeah. This is like, we'll

30:05

kill you in a gruesome, horrible way to make an

30:07

example out of you until no one will be dead.

30:09

Yeah. It doesn't make any sense. Yeah, yeah, yeah. This

30:12

sounds more like the work of like, I don't know,

30:14

just some sick son of a bitch who did this

30:16

for his own personal pleasure. Because I mean, it doesn't

30:18

seem like it was for the masses. That's what I

30:21

thought as well. But then also, there is a point

30:23

of there's so much to it to produce one person.

30:26

So like, you're like a syndicate of serial killers, you know?

30:28

I mean, I think it is possible. OK,

30:30

it could technically be one person with

30:32

great efforts. Yes, yeah. You know, if

30:34

they were planning this for a long

30:36

time, someone who really wanted, like this

30:38

was something super personal, really wanted to

30:41

hurt Max Tanchovsky. Max, I don't know,

30:43

did something to him, did something to somebody he loved,

30:45

who knows? Again, not a lot

30:47

is really known about Max. So maybe he

30:49

was a real piece of shit who yada,

30:51

yada, yada. This is like that law abiding

30:53

citizen movie with your man, Traded. Traded Bullard.

30:55

Yeah. And like, you know, maybe it's like

30:57

one of those things he planned it out

30:59

for months, building the thing. Could have just

31:01

been in the wrong place around then. Or

31:04

maybe somebody was just testing it out, you

31:06

know? Was using it as an old

31:08

guinea pig. He knows. With very

31:10

little currently being known about his

31:12

life before his remains are found

31:14

in the Hawkesbury River, suspects are

31:16

non-existent. Maybe one day there will

31:19

be a breakthrough, and we'll have a why

31:21

to add to the who. Yeah,

31:24

when it was announced that the mystery had

31:27

been solved after 24 years, they

31:29

didn't receive the fanfare that they talked it with from the

31:31

public. They were like having balloons and

31:33

fireworks. Hey, everybody, look at this. You guys did

31:35

it. But it was like, but who

31:38

did it? It was like, oh, I don't know. Exactly. I

31:40

don't know. I just had like one of the theories if it

31:42

is part of a gang, maybe some will flip. We'll find

31:45

out at some point. But yeah, I

31:47

don't know if there's any reason to celebrate just yet.

31:49

Yeah. It's a wild one. It is a wild one,

31:51

yeah. It's terrifying. And now let's move

31:54

on to story number two we have

31:56

today. This is like this little mini

31:58

episode we're doing here. two

32:00

little ones there instead of our usual one big one

32:02

next episode will be one big one But now we're

32:04

talking about two little ones and part

32:06

two of this episode is the pajama

32:08

girl Mystery this

32:11

one. It's again a mystery

32:13

kind of sorta. Yeah mystery

32:17

Let's get into it. So for our

32:19

second Aussie mystery We're staying in New

32:22

South Wales and once more we begin

32:24

with a discovery that likely changed the

32:26

lives of everyone involved Though this one

32:28

is a good bit old See

32:31

on September 1st 1934

32:34

a young farmer named Tom Griffith was

32:36

walking along how long road which a

32:38

quiet country road Think middle of nowhere.

32:40

It's barely murdered in a dirt road

32:42

fields on either side It's three and

32:45

a half hours north of Melbourne and

32:47

he was accompanied by his family's newly

32:49

acquired bull well as

32:51

he was walking along this road on a

32:54

quiet sunny morning the sight of a hessian

32:56

bag a burlap sack Sticking out

32:58

of a culvert by the side of the road caught

33:00

his eye I'm sure those of

33:02

you who watched or listened to another that chapter

33:04

know by now that nothing good ever Comes

33:07

from looking in a bag you'll find abandoned even

33:09

in previous episodes of the podcast. We've talked about

33:11

bags No, there's no good folks.

33:13

Don't touch bags But

33:16

every simple fanboy wasn't so jaded and

33:18

he was like what's that in? He

33:21

went over had a go inside whatever

33:23

he expected to find maybe candy hmm

33:25

Well that thought was punted out of

33:28

his mind when he came face to

33:30

face with a young woman staring right

33:32

back at him all

33:34

around the horrific finding the air was

33:37

thick with the smell of kerosene and

33:39

singed hair a Witness local

33:41

to the area reported that they had seen

33:43

a fire in the area on the 29th

33:46

of August two days before It's

33:48

a rural area and with the body being found on September

33:50

1st at around 9 a.m It's

33:52

likely the fire to witness saw was indeed

33:55

the bag and body still alight luckily

33:57

for investigators a strong pouring

34:00

of rain that evening saved

34:02

the body from being completely

34:04

obliterated. The body was

34:07

taken to the medical examiner and,

34:09

well, examined. It was

34:11

quickly apparent that the woman had

34:13

suffered horrifically prior to ending up

34:15

where she was found. After

34:17

removing a towel that had been wrapped

34:20

around the woman's head, the

34:22

examiner found that her

34:24

skull had been almost caved in. The

34:27

only small mercy being that she was dead

34:29

before she had been set on fire. The

34:32

medical examiner also found a small caliber

34:34

bullet, likely at 22, lodged

34:36

in the woman's throat. Regardless,

34:38

he determined that it probably wasn't a

34:40

fatal shot and it wasn't

34:43

his opinion that the sustained and

34:45

vicious beating was what actually killed

34:47

her. Police put it

34:49

out that they had an unidentified woman, slim,

34:51

aged between 20 and 30 with brown hair.

34:56

The most uniquely identifying thing about the

34:59

woman was her clothes. She

35:01

appeared to be wearing yellow

35:03

silk, Chinese-style pajamas with red

35:05

detailing. Though owing to the

35:08

fire that had ravaged her body, not

35:10

much remained. One thing

35:12

that was obvious was that the

35:15

woman had been killed somewhere else

35:17

before her body

35:36

was dumped and set on fire. So

35:38

not only did investigators not have

35:41

a motive suspect victim ID, they

35:44

didn't even have the scene of the murder. What

35:46

the police decided to do was rather

35:48

interesting. Fair

35:51

play to you. They

35:53

came up with a very interesting idea to try

35:55

and get attention to identify this woman and hopefully

35:57

solve her brutal murder. decided

36:00

to make the corpse into an attraction. Genuinely.

36:04

This was well before the advent of

36:06

DNA and modern forensics, so the police

36:08

knew that the best shot they had

36:10

at identifying the woman was simply

36:13

to have someone come forward who recognised her and

36:15

could tell them. So, rather

36:19

than just taking a picture and putting it in a newspaper,

36:22

they refused to allow the body to

36:25

be buried and instead they

36:27

preserved the body by freezing

36:29

it solid and having

36:31

it put on display at

36:33

Sydney University's medical school. Again,

36:36

why not just take pictures of her face,

36:38

put it in all the newspapers, rather than

36:40

g'day, have a look at that, right?

36:43

It's a body, it's a frozen body,

36:45

you don't believe it's mine? And I know it, like they kind

36:47

of struggle to keep her feet and bones as well. Yeah. Like,

36:50

as I said, just take a photograph. Yeah,

36:52

I mean, do they get a lot of

36:54

tourists and, you know, fucking rubberneckers at the

36:56

Sydney University's medical school? Like, is it just

36:58

anybody can just walk in? Sure

37:00

they did after this. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

37:03

Although it seemed like a totally crackpot

37:05

and unnecessarily macabre thing to do, it

37:07

actually kind of worked. Some

37:10

time after the body had become a

37:12

bit of a tourist destination, out of

37:14

the blue, police got a call telling

37:16

them what they believed the name of

37:18

the corpse to be. Florence

37:20

Linda Augustine, known as

37:23

Linda. That name would

37:25

come up again and again throughout the investigation.

37:28

When it was first raised, the name

37:30

meant little, but soon more

37:33

and more people recognized the body

37:35

as being Linda Augustine. Authorities

37:37

pulled her dental records and

37:40

to their shock, they

37:42

didn't match. They were similar,

37:44

but Linda had too fewer fillings than

37:46

this Jane Doe and so Linda Augustine

37:48

was soon ruled out even though people

37:50

kept coming forward saying that's Linda. The

37:53

weeks and the months that followed, images of

37:56

the body did appear in newspapers which was

37:58

now always preceded by pajama girls. That's

38:00

what she was known as now, the pajama girl. You got

38:02

the rack man and the pajama girl. Many

38:04

of the articles involved fantastical speculation,

38:06

seemingly based solely on the fact

38:08

that the woman had been wearing

38:10

exotic Chinese-style pajamas. This led to

38:12

a whole, oh, mystery, asked me

38:14

some kind of, you know, spy

38:16

novel. Mm. The horrific

38:19

tragedy even became somewhat of a cautionary tale

38:21

with the usual, you know, conservative speculation that

38:23

she'd suffered the fate of a loose woman

38:25

and that, you know, this is what, what

38:27

else did she expect what happened? All that,

38:29

that kind of shit. Well, you're saying she's

38:31

a loose woman because she's wearing pajamas? Yeah,

38:34

exactly. Is that because of these exotic

38:36

pajamas? Probably, I guess. I don't know.

38:38

I don't know. As soon as any

38:41

woman dies, it's spicked and blaming, usual

38:43

shit. On the other side

38:45

though, an equal amount of press was based on

38:47

the woman's exotic beauty. The photos given

38:49

to the newspapers were doctored to

38:51

make the girl appear more alive. They wanted,

38:54

she was a real head turner, I guess.

38:57

So there you go. I still find them mad

38:59

that they were freezing the body and just blame

39:01

us. Yeah. And this is, it's not the only

39:03

time in history that they used to do that.

39:06

So in 19th century Paris,

39:08

the morgue had become one of the

39:10

city's most popular tourist attractions. In fact,

39:12

by the end of the 19th century,

39:14

the morgue attracted so many visitors that

39:16

nearly every Paris guidebook meant it. Originally,

39:19

the morgue, like it served as, it

39:22

served the purpose of allowing friends and

39:24

family to identify unidentified bodies, but very

39:26

few visitors actually arrived with the intention

39:28

of searching for a missing person. The

39:31

morgue grew some more mysterious, the cause

39:33

of death, the greater number

39:35

of tourists came to view this person's body.

39:38

One history professor wrote, the morgue served

39:41

as a visual auxiliary to the newspaper,

39:43

staging the recently dead who had been

39:45

sensationally detailed by the printed world. Whenever

39:48

the newspaper is reported on an unknown decapitated

39:50

person or a bloody trunk on display, tens

39:52

of thousands of people would flock to the

39:54

morgue to see it. It really was nothing

39:57

to do back then. That you re- yeah.

39:59

Yeah. I've seen drawings of

40:01

what the morgue looked like and it was

40:04

kind of like a museum of corpses. So

40:06

they had the exhibition room which held up

40:08

to about 50 visitors at a time. Two

40:11

rows of corpses they lay on rock slabs

40:13

behind. How many bodies did they have? Like

40:16

10? I'm

40:18

not sure many bodies they held at the time. But

40:20

yeah, they'd hold a good few bodies. There were two

40:22

rows of them. Right, okay. And

40:24

then the clothing worn by the deceased was

40:27

hung alongside them. And then there was cold

40:29

water from the ceiling dripping

40:31

down on the bodies and trying to

40:33

slow down decomposition. That is so fucking

40:35

dark. It's really dark, yeah. It means

40:37

fascinating. People really saw

40:40

this as a type of entertainment. In

40:42

1886 a four-year-old girl was found dead with

40:44

a single mysterious bruise on her hand. And

40:46

after seeing it in the newspaper, readers rushed

40:48

to see the body of the girl who

40:50

was posed in a tiny dress behind the

40:52

glass and the morgue. And over the course

40:54

of a few days, over 150,000 people

40:58

had visited the morgue just to catch

41:00

a glimpse. You have a dead girl.

41:02

That is so... It's messed up. And

41:05

if visitors, if they were lucky, they could

41:07

also potentially witness a criminal investigation for

41:10

a time. So law enforcement,

41:12

they frequently brought individuals suspected of

41:14

murder to the morgue hoping that

41:16

confronting the victim's bodies was illicit

41:19

confession by shocking the suspects with

41:21

the reality of their actions. They

41:25

were like, what are you doing? They

41:27

were like, what are you doing? They

41:29

did it. They did it. They

41:31

were like, what are you doing? But

41:33

it was like some sort of macabre

41:36

theater, which apparently has still been used

41:38

today with the pajama girl putting her on display,

41:40

freezing her. Yeah. Mad. That's

41:43

interesting. Man, that's so dark. That just makes

41:45

me think of like, it's so gothic. It's

41:48

gothic as fuck. Yeah, it's such like dark

41:50

tourism. Yeah, real dark tourism. Yeah, I imagine

41:53

people with the 1800s with their old fancy

41:55

clothes on and just like very dark cave

41:57

area looking at dead bodies. weekend

42:00

like so as I said there was something to do and

42:02

yeah like there was some visitors that would go when like

42:04

it might be a slow week in the morning they'd get

42:06

pissed off if there was nobody there yeah

42:09

so it kind of makes the Paris catacombs all

42:11

the skulls and shit they have then they're like

42:13

along the walls and they're obsessed with death and

42:15

I was like yeah this is real morbid yeah

42:18

so slowly but surely the Agassini

42:20

line of inquiry faded away and

42:22

was ruled out the investigation

42:24

faded into the background as life went

42:27

on and the tragedy the

42:29

tragedy of the pajama girl became a

42:31

spooky story told among locals in

42:33

spite of their best efforts even preserving

42:35

the body in formaldehyde and a zinc

42:37

bathtub for a more permanent display no

42:40

more names were popping up one

42:43

Hail Mary was to track every

42:45

single woman aged under 40 years

42:47

old that had failed to vote

42:49

in the elections following the discovery

42:51

of the body but even this

42:53

dragon at style search turned up

42:55

no new information though

42:58

the mystery grew interest faded

43:00

and over 10 years passed

43:02

by without any developments then

43:06

all of a sudden suddenly as

43:11

they say this is

43:13

so fucking stupid everything was magically solved

43:15

and the case was tied up in

43:18

a nice little bow magically heavy heavy

43:21

on the magic folks so

43:24

this is what happened and very believable in

43:27

March 1944 police

43:29

commissioner William McKay was out

43:31

for dinner right big

43:33

dog police commissioner out for dinner

43:36

at a very hoity-toity Italian restaurant

43:38

in town at dinner weird

43:42

feeling in the back of his neck he noticed

43:44

one of the waiters in this restaurant was acting

43:47

frankly a little odd like

43:49

what's going on with that guy here right McKay

43:51

then asked him this question where were you

43:53

September 1st yeah exactly yeah W and I

43:56

and the waiter said all right you got

43:59

me I'm the guy

44:01

who killed the pajama girl. It

44:04

was his wife, Linda Agassini,

44:06

the whole time. As

44:10

a result of this very sudden

44:12

confession, Linda's dental records were checked

44:14

again, and this time, if

44:17

you can believe it, the long dead

44:19

corpse had lost a couple of fillings,

44:21

and the records, they now

44:24

matched. Wow. That's

44:26

convenient. That is, that's just

44:28

the most convenient darn thing of all time,

44:30

isn't it? The corpse

44:32

just happened to lose fillings, and this man just

44:34

happened to admit to it, in the middle of

44:37

a crowded restaurant. Give that commissioner a medal. Case

44:39

closed. The

44:41

waiter was Anthony Agassini, and was apparently

44:43

admitting that he'd accidentally killed his wife

44:46

Linda after the two had gotten into

44:48

an argument. Somehow, he'd accidentally

44:50

shot Linda in the troton and killed

44:52

her. You've noticed, believe that

44:54

didn't kill her. He panicked, discarded her body

44:56

in the culvert, where he was hoping the

44:58

fire would render it unrecognizable, but

45:00

the rain ended as fine. He didn't think it

45:02

was gonna rain, but it did, and hence why

45:04

she was found. Tony Agassini

45:07

was an Italian Australian who

45:09

had married English-born Florence Linda

45:11

Platt in a Sydney registry

45:13

office in 1930. Linda

45:15

moved to New Zealand at just 19 years old, before

45:18

later moving over to Australia,

45:20

where she later met Tony.

45:22

Oddly enough, when McKay fingered him for

45:25

the crime, He didn't want the first crime.

45:27

Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, bend over pal.

45:30

Tony had only just returned to

45:32

Sydney after spending four years in

45:35

internment camps. McKay had

45:37

almost certainly been aware of Tony, as

45:39

he frequented Tony's place of work, the restaurant,

45:42

on many occasions, before Tony was

45:44

sent away to have his politics corrected.

45:48

Now, to say the wrap-up

45:50

was convenient for McKay, bit

45:52

of an understatement, McKay was facing

45:54

rumors of corruption. He

45:57

was facing, I love this, he was facing rumors of corruption, so

45:59

he... Invented solving the

46:01

case. Uh, was it, was

46:03

it? It was it. I guess what, you'll never

46:06

believe her feelings just happened to fall out. This

46:08

is mad. And then he also confessed to me

46:10

in a restaurant. Great. Wild shit, I know. So

46:13

yeah, he was facing rumours of corruption and was

46:15

looking very likely to be booted from his position.

46:17

And he really needed a win right

46:19

there and then when he single-handed- at least

46:22

just so happened. Fucking, Azor

46:24

Tikhal, solved the biggest and most public

46:26

murder mystery of the day. McKay,

46:29

he wasn't used to being praised in the

46:31

media. And it was far more common to

46:33

read that the police had messed up. But

46:36

suddenly, that was all gone. And

46:38

he put a big fat green tick next

46:40

to a whole bunch of red ink. And

46:42

like that, the slate was

46:45

clean. Big dog McKay was

46:47

back in town. Sounds a bit

46:49

too good to be true. It definitely sounds very,

46:51

very much too good to be true. It

46:53

was pretty widely known that Linda Agostini

46:56

had a not insignificant drinking problem. I

46:58

was always up for a party time.

47:01

Obviously, being married to Tony wasn't exactly

47:03

conducive to the wild and free lifestyle

47:05

Linda longed for. So the

47:08

two would regularly clash, sometimes

47:10

violently. Tony gave this

47:12

as the main reason for the argument

47:14

that spilled over into Linda being shot

47:17

dead. Apparently Linda woke him up

47:19

with a revolver in the face and the gun

47:21

had got off as they struggled for it. Naturally,

47:24

there was several huge discrepancies between

47:26

the scene, the body, the known

47:29

facts, and what Tony Agostini said

47:31

in his confession. In

47:33

his statements, admitting to the killing, Tony said

47:35

that he'd poured petrol over his wife's body,

47:37

but it was actually kerosene that was used

47:39

to start the fire. He said it was

47:41

a revolver that had shot her when it

47:43

was a .22, which is a much smaller

47:45

cover. He also said that the gunshot was

47:47

what killed her, and he didn't mention the

47:49

extreme beating that she had actually received that

47:51

had likely killed her. That could just

47:53

be to cover up being a wife beater. He was happy

47:56

to be known as a murderer, but didn't want to be

47:58

known as a wife beater. Oh, it's you, but she's not

48:00

what- I wouldn't be there. Yeah, or I'm not a monster.

48:02

Yeah, he's not a bastard Um, I

48:04

could also be the fact that he just didn't know the details in

48:07

the case because he did not Actually

48:09

do it. So whether

48:11

it was Linda Agassini We

48:14

don't know people identified as Linda,

48:16

but the dental records didn't match until

48:19

they did match Miraculously,

48:22

but Linda's a miss like his wife's a

48:24

miss. Right? I don't know. I didn't even have

48:26

a wife You tell

48:28

me even with the monumental

48:30

amount of reasonable doubt Tony was

48:33

eventually Extradited to Melbourne to

48:35

stand trial. He was actually acquitted

48:37

of murder but found guilty of involuntary

48:40

Manslaughter for which he just got

48:42

six years in prison adding

48:44

more fuel to the fire Tony wouldn't even

48:46

serve that being released and deported back to

48:48

Italy in 1948 after just three years in

48:51

prison Tony

48:53

died in Italy in 1969 and

48:56

that is where we finish it officially the

48:58

case is rubber stamped as closed

49:00

but the reality might

49:03

be very different because at the

49:05

end of the day the dental records never matched

49:07

until They did match and

49:09

the case was closed a little too

49:11

easily would so many discrepancies between what

49:14

Tony said and what actually happened We

49:16

may never know for certain who the woman in the

49:18

pajamas was and what really

49:20

happened to Linda Agassini There

49:23

you go Mmm, I guess

49:25

whoever was the girl in pajamas. It's

49:27

still such a good like f you from

49:29

beyond the grave Yeah, so the killer was

49:32

trying to dispose your body and have it

49:34

hidden and now your face is literally frozen

49:36

in time Yeah, he's plastered out haunting you.

49:38

Yeah, right, right. Yes. It's it's really really

49:40

weird I mean, I mean even just reading

49:42

up here a little bit more the pajama

49:44

girl had brown eyes Agassini a blue different

49:47

bust size Different

49:50

shapes nose. There's a lot of

49:55

Was a completely different person and by

49:57

the way, you know the pajama girl

50:00

It was known to be a head turner right that's

50:02

what they were saying. She looks beautiful Look

50:05

at that picture Linda Agostini right now Not

50:08

gonna be mean, but she's no head turner.

50:10

Let me tell you that she I mean there

50:12

you go Yeah

50:16

No, yeah, not for me. No not

50:19

me, but you know someone yeah, she's she's

50:21

a person I hope she's not

50:23

mean yeah, not me But

50:26

uh yeah, so who actually

50:28

knows what happened to Linda who

50:30

knows who the pajama girl Really

50:33

is there's there's been some other suspects,

50:35

but I'm none have ever really been

50:38

Strong like Linda was always the strongest until it was

50:40

pretty clear. It wasn't her So

50:43

who knows who knows what really happened?

50:45

I mean the case is officially closed

50:47

But uh smells like horseshit to me

50:49

absolutely 100% good mystery. It's

50:51

a good mystery. It is an interesting one

50:53

Yeah, there's two good mysteries two fascinating ones

50:56

Yeah, there you go This whole episode of

50:58

the Vacher next episode of course will be

51:00

a back to a regular one story one

51:03

We just do some a little bit different

51:05

absolutely for this all episode um and yeah

51:07

alright Keith final thoughts I guess we as

51:09

we end this old one final

51:11

thoughts hmm Time

51:13

key time key time key there. I don't

51:16

know just a yeah, it's mad Just I'm

51:18

still kind of digesting what we went through

51:20

there and such to figure out Like

51:22

it's just the egg is being one. Yes.

51:24

Yeah, it's mad. It's a real head scratcher Yeah,

51:26

I feel like it's a real rabbit hole. Yeah

51:29

sure I've been gonna like I said like gonna

51:31

let the similar digest that might come back to

51:33

myself a little bit later Just kind of look

51:35

at it again fresh eyes, but yes, it's mad

51:37

very Yeah, yeah, I love a good mystery. You

51:39

do love a good mystery. You know Keith. You're

51:41

the biggest mystery evil Well

51:43

you mystery that's been solved by the folks in Reddit so there you

51:45

go there we go All right, okay,

51:47

yeah, exactly. I can fucking solve anything All

51:51

right folks. Thank you so much for listening it means a

51:53

lot to me means a lot to Keith I know it is new

51:55

designs Yeah,

51:58

listen new episode of the That

52:01

Chapter podcast is out every single Monday

52:03

so set your alarm clock bitch and

52:05

check it out. But

52:10

until the next one please take care of each other and yourselves

52:12

because I'll love you alright

52:14

thanks guys let

52:31

me try it again the process is called

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features