The family saga continues (even though we did not plan on it)! This week, Maddie and Izzy talk about the Jamison family murders and the murder of Jon Benet Ramsey.

29 - A Family Story

Mar 11th, 2021 1h 2m

This week, Maddie and Izzy switch it up. Izzy talks about the mysterious disappearance of Lars Mittank, while Maddie discusses the possibility of reincarnation with the story of the Pollock Sisters. But, at the end of the day, it's a show abo

28 - Fire, Water, and Feet

Mar 4th, 2021 1h 1m

Maddie and Izzy did it again. Once again, they managed to choose theories that perfectly compliment each other! Starting to get a little creepy... Anyways, enjoy as Maddie discusses the fiery mystery of Mary Reeser, while Izzy dives into the

27 - Opposite Opposite Day

Feb 25th, 2021 1h 3m

It's Opposite Day for Maddie and Izzy! Or, is it the opposite of Opposite Day? Well, we'll find out. Izzy talks about theories on Edgar Allen Poe's death, and Maddie covers the death of Natalie Wood.

26 - Free the Baker

Feb 11th, 2021 1h 10m

In this episode, Maddie investigates the mysterious death of Gloria Ramirez, while Izzy covers theories about the Pont-Saint-Espirt mass poisoning. Also, FREE THE BAKER!

25 - Ghost Dates

Feb 4th, 2021 1h 6m

In this episode, Izzy uncovers the mystery of Forest Fenn's treasure, while Maddie dives into the mysterious death of Michelle von Emster. Oh, and we read a very creepy poem.

24 - Lewis Carroll's Burn Book

Jan 28th, 2021 1h 10m

This week, Maddie dives into the mysterious death of Elisa Lam, while Izzy jumps into the rabbit hole questioning whether Lewis Carroll is Jack the Ripper.

22- Lost and Found

Jan 14th, 2021 1h 4m

Let's be honest, Maddie may have screwed up the episode titles and put 23 ahead of 22. That, of course, makes this... the lost episode. In this found lost episode, Izzy tackles the Bruce Lee curse while Maddie covers the mystery of the Tromp

23 - Muffin Boy

Jan 7th, 2021 1h

New year, same podcast! This week, Maddie and Izzy talk about the mystery of Roland T. Owen and question whether Finland even exists. In other words, we are starting the new year off right!

21 - Hate that Cat

Dec 31st, 2020 1h 1m

To welcome 2021, Maddie and Izzy ask a lot of questions when discussing the Simulation theory and the disappearance of Asha Degree. Celebrate the new year with some philosophy and mystery!

20 - Unicorn Burrito

Dec 24th, 2020 1h 6m

Merry Christmas Eve! Our gift to you this holiday season is this episode! Maddie covers the unsolved DB Cooper case, while Izzy gets lost in the stars talking about the Time Cube theory.

19 - White as a Goat

Dec 17th, 2020 57m 41s

Happy holidays everyone! This episode, Izzy covers wacky theories on lizard people, while Maddie discusses the mysterious death of Thomas Ince. Also, Maddie is a reptile?

18 - Sole Souls

Dec 10th, 2020 1h 9m

This week, Maddie and Izzy cover some weird and wild stories. Maddie discusses the crazy Ho No Hana Sanpogyo cult, while Izzy talks about the mysterious Utah monolith.

17 - The Water Episode

Dec 3rd, 2020 1h

This episode, Maddie and Izzy have another psychic moment, leading up the the much anticipated: Water Episode. While Izzy covers theories about the Titanic, Maddie discusses the mystical properties of Lourdes Water. Take a sip and listen!

16 - More Sugar Please

Nov 26th, 2020 1h 12m

Happy Thanksgiving everyone! This episode, Maddie and Izzy cover the theories surrounding Princess Diana's death and the chaos of the New Coke Launch. Add some extra sugar to your Thanksgiving turkey and listen up!

15 - Maps and History Stuff

Nov 19th, 2020 1h 1m

This week, Maddie and Izzy cover the mysterious secret room in Mount Rushmore and the iconic Paul is Dead theory. As always, get ready for some tangents and some serious theories!

14 - Inspired by Rocks

Nov 12th, 2020 1h 15m

This week, Maddie decides to explore the stories on New England's Bennington Triangle and Bridgewater Triangle. Meanwhile, Izzy shines light on the Flannan Isles Lighthouse disappearance. Moral of the story: we shine.

13 - John Baloney

Nov 5th, 2020 1h 6m

With spooky season over, Maddie and Izzy both happen to cover random and very not spooky theories. While Izzy talks about a potential Starbooks marketing conspiracy, Maddie catches all the Pokémon theories out there. Don't be a John Baloney a

12 - Swords? In Stones?

Oct 29th, 2020 1h 12m

As spooky season draws to an end, Maddie and Izzy cover two final spooky theories: Ouija Boards and the Stanley Hotel. Join us in closing out spooky season with some frights and some laughs!

11 - Lump of Bread

Oct 22nd, 2020 1h 2m

This week, Maddie and Izzy continue to honor spooky season by discussing the Salem Witch Trials and Robert the Doll. Get ready for some laughs, scares, and plenty of theories!

10 - Worst Ladder Ever

Oct 15th, 2020 1h 9m

To celebrate 10 episodes, Maddie returns to another aviation conspiracy by covering Lindbergh Baby Kidnapping. Meanwhile, Izzy delves deeper into spooky season by looking into the legend of Black-eyed Children.

9 - Pigeon Funeral

Oct 8th, 2020 1h 7m

Spooky season has finally arrived and Maddie and Izzy have some theories to match it! Izzy discusses theories on time-traveling humans, while Maddie talks about cursed horror movies. Prepare for supernatural scares and lots of laughs!

8 - Are There Mimes?

Oct 1st, 2020 1h 8m

This week, Maddie and Izzy talk about the mysterious Man in the Iron Mask and return to one of Izzy's childhood obsessions: lip balm. Get ready to earn some trivia points!

7 - Circus Clouds

Sep 24th, 2020 1h 13m

In this episode, Maddie and Izzy explore theories on Chemtrails and the Heaven's Gate cult. Take a bite into some apple puns as Maddie and Izzy apple-solutely roll off topic (we apple-ogize for the rotten jokes).

6 - Sassy Captain

Sep 17th, 2020 1h 8m

This week, Maddie and Izzy cover the mystery of the Mary Celeste and the insane weirdness of the Denver Airport. Buckle up maties for another wild set of conspiracy theories!