Podchaser Logo
Home
SIO449: The Northern Lights Went South for the Summer

SIO449: The Northern Lights Went South for the Summer

Released Monday, 27th May 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
SIO449: The Northern Lights Went South for the Summer

SIO449: The Northern Lights Went South for the Summer

SIO449: The Northern Lights Went South for the Summer

SIO449: The Northern Lights Went South for the Summer

Monday, 27th May 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:01

What's up sandwich heads? Today on Steve-O's Sandwich Reviews,

0:03

we've got the tips and tricks to the best

0:05

sandwich order. And it all starts with this little

0:07

guy right here, Pepsi Zero Sugar.

0:09

Farshal to Pastrami, craving a Cubano. Yeah,

0:11

sounds delicious, but boom! Add the crisp,

0:13

refreshing taste of Pepsi Zero Sugar and

0:16

cue the fireworks. Lunch, dinner, or late

0:18

night, it'll be a sandwich worth celebrating,

0:20

trust me. Your boy's eating a lot

0:22

of sandwiches in his day, and the

0:24

one thing I can say with absolute fact, everybody

0:28

is better with Pepsi. Get year round

0:30

comfort knowing your home is backed by

0:32

industry leading Lennox equipment and expert technicians

0:35

at Appalachian Heating. Special savings opportunities and

0:37

federal tax credits are available. So call

0:39

3048-775-566 or

0:42

visit us online at appheat.com to learn

0:44

more. You're a podcast

0:46

listener, and this is a podcast

0:48

ad. Reach great listeners like yourself

0:51

with podcast advertising from lips and

0:53

ads. Choose from hundreds of top

0:55

podcasts offering host endorsements or run

0:57

a reproduced ad like this one

0:59

across thousands of shows to reach

1:02

your target audience with lips and

1:04

ads. Go to lipsandads.com now. That's

1:06

L-I-B-S-Y-N ads.com. ["The

1:24

Hello and welcome to Serious Inquiries only. This is

1:26

episode 449. I'm your host,

1:28

Thomas Smith. And today I've

1:30

got astrophysicist Dr. Brian Gillis to

1:32

explain what the hell happened to

1:34

the sky the other day. This

1:37

is important. Somehow the Northern Lights

1:39

were no longer Northern. They

1:42

were very much lights, but they were

1:44

not as much Northern as they normally

1:46

are. And Brian volunteered to explain that

1:48

to us. And it's very complicated. It

1:50

is so much more complicated than you

1:52

might think. A lot of really fascinating

1:55

and complex science here that Brian will

1:57

try to make sense for us. So.

2:00

That's what's on deck for today. We'll pause for

2:02

a brief break that you don't have to hear

2:04

if you're a patron at patreon.com so serious pot

2:06

and I also want to note that a seriously

2:08

awful movies or a Seriously good

2:11

thing is on deck. Dr.

2:13

Steve Proper is back and he decided to

2:16

Give us a break and let us watch something

2:18

good and we watched the pilot episode of scrubs

2:21

To talk about kind of the medical science

2:23

involved there And it

2:25

was a very pleasant change from having to watch

2:27

house So that'll be on patreon.com/serious

2:29

pod very soon Thanks so much to those

2:31

who support the show you're the best you

2:33

make it happen And I hope you enjoy

2:36

the no ads and the goodies. All right

2:38

after this break Let's find out

2:40

what in the world happened to the sky the

2:42

other day The The delicious

2:44

ice cold taste of Dr. Pepper has a

2:46

lasting effect on people. Lindsay from Sacramento said...

2:48

Pro tip, 40 degrees is the perfect

2:51

temperature for an ice cold Dr. Pepper. Why

2:53

is 40 degrees the perfect temperature for Dr.

2:55

Pepper? We brought in Sue from Duluth, Minnesota to

2:57

tell us. Oh yeah, I know a thing or two

2:59

about cold. Oh, that right there is the

3:01

perfect kind of ice cold for Dr. Pepper. I'd

3:04

share that with my friend Nancy. She likes Dr.

3:06

Pepper too, you know. My coldest... Alright, that'll

3:08

be all, Sue. Having a perfect temperature for

3:10

your Dr. Pepper? It's a Pepper thing. Inspired

3:13

by Real Fan Posts. You're a

3:15

podcast listener and this is a podcast

3:17

ad reach great listeners like yourself with

3:19

podcast Advertising from lips and ads choose

3:22

from hundreds of top podcasts offering host

3:24

endorsements or run a reproduced ad like

3:26

this one across Thousands of shows to

3:28

reach your target audience with lips and

3:30

ads go to lips and

3:32

ads calm now That's Li B.

3:34

S y n ads calm and

3:37

we're joined by Brian Everyone's favorite astrophysicist

3:39

to tell us what happened to this

3:41

guy that broke I think how's

3:44

it going Brian? Yeah, hello Thomas things

3:46

are going well with me and how

3:48

are things with you good? I I

3:50

heard from the outside world that something

3:52

happened in the sky I've only I've

3:54

been chained to a rock at a

3:56

podcast factory, but people tell me oh,

3:58

yeah, nothing happened. Yeah Yeah,

4:00

I heard you've been making a new podcast there.

4:03

Congratulations. This is what, number six,

4:05

something like that? Who knows? Yeah,

4:07

thank you. Yeah. Okay. Yeah.

4:11

So for those who haven't heard

4:13

or are listening to this far

4:15

in the future, just last week,

4:17

there was a phenomenal display of

4:19

the Northern Lights, which was visible

4:21

from much further south than is

4:23

normal. Many people in the

4:25

US even were able to see

4:28

them, which the outside of Alaska

4:30

almost never happens. So

4:32

I thought that was a good time. Thomas had an

4:34

open slot in the show so I could come in

4:36

and talk a bit about what

4:38

exactly the Northern and Southern Lights

4:40

are and why this ridiculously

4:43

magical looking thing actually happens.

4:46

Yeah, I'm rooting for apocalypse. I'm hoping it

4:48

means it's all over soon,

4:50

but maybe there's just a more basic explanation.

4:53

But yeah, it really was incredible. Lydia

4:55

messaged me and was like, hey, you

4:57

should go see the Northern Lights. I

4:59

was like, what in the world does

5:01

that mean? Is there, is this code

5:03

for something? What are you talking about?

5:06

I had no idea because that like

5:08

in a normal day, what does

5:10

that mean? That means like, hey, I

5:13

know it's like 9 PM and you're

5:15

editing or whatever. Maybe it was like 10,

5:18

but go to Alaska right now or something.

5:22

And then I just was too busy and then

5:24

I saw people start to post stuff. I was

5:26

like, oh shit, really? And it was visible all the

5:28

way where we were, I think, and

5:30

are not far away from it, which is, you

5:33

know, Sacramento is not,

5:36

it's not the North Pole here. It's

5:38

not, uh, it's not very North. Yeah,

5:40

that was extremely unusual. The good news

5:42

is that it probably won't be the

5:44

last time in the near future that

5:47

there are going to be some good

5:49

Northern Lights displays. They might not get

5:51

as far south as Sacramento again,

5:53

but from everything I've heard or

5:55

kind of entering, uh, are part

5:58

of a, like a, a. year

6:00

or so cycle of the sun's

6:02

activity where seeing the northern lights

6:05

becomes more and more common. So

6:07

if you're living a bit further

6:10

north than that in the regions

6:12

that can normally see it, so

6:14

the cutoff for that is roughly

6:17

the UK, northern Europe, northern Russia,

6:19

and mid to

6:21

northern Canada. Like if you're

6:23

above the southern strip of Canadian cities where

6:25

they're all clustered, if you're a bit above

6:28

that you can often see the northern lights.

6:30

So that's the reason that can normally see

6:33

them. And then of course the southern lights

6:35

too. Physically they're exactly the same phenomenon on

6:37

the other side of the planet. So yeah,

6:39

they'll be active too if you're in Australia

6:41

or New Zealand. You should have some good

6:43

chances to see them again if you miss

6:45

them this time. I just never

6:48

thought about obviously the fact that there

6:50

would also be southern lights. Is it

6:52

just because there's not as many people

6:54

that tend to witness that? Why the

6:56

northern lights get all the credit? Yeah,

6:58

it's just because there are so many

7:00

more people in the northern hemisphere. Okay.

7:02

Yeah, that either already lives close to

7:04

them or can travel there quickly. Like

7:06

the northern lights are called the aurora

7:08

borealis and the southern lights are called

7:10

aurora australis. They're called the aurora in

7:12

general. But the southern lights is

7:15

visible from just Australia and New

7:17

Zealand. Even then not too commonly.

7:20

They're most often seen by people who

7:22

are, I think they were first observed

7:24

by westerners on ships that were exploring

7:26

the southern hemisphere. Now that there are

7:29

more residents of Australia and New Zealand,

7:31

they get seen more commonly. But yeah,

7:33

they just don't get talked about

7:35

as much. People down the southern hemisphere

7:38

just get forgotten about. But

7:40

they've got lights too. Yeah, definitely. You know,

7:42

I also saw the northern lights just on

7:44

a flight because flying across

7:46

the country usually does that like upward

7:49

geodesic or whatever the heck is called. And yeah, you

7:51

can see a lot further north when you're up higher.

7:53

And it took me a second to realize what it

7:56

was. I was like, what in the hell is that?

7:58

And then I thought of it like maybe. that's

8:00

the northern lights. I never thought of like the

8:02

angle, you know, being able to see kind of

8:04

further than you might think. But it

8:06

is a really cool looking thing. Yeah.

8:08

So a bit about them in

8:11

general, we've already covered so where for

8:13

the northern lights, but if you want

8:15

to get a bit more technical, the

8:17

lights form in a ring around the

8:19

poles. They aren't actually at the poles,

8:21

but ring around

8:23

them. And then you can see them from

8:26

much farther outside of that ring. And then

8:28

if you get too far away, the curvature

8:30

of the earth gets in the way typically,

8:32

unless of course you're in a plane. And

8:34

in which case you can see much farther.

8:36

Or if you're a flat earther. Yeah,

8:38

then you can always see them. Yeah,

8:41

exactly. Because it respects your religion and

8:44

there's visible all the time. Yeah. So

8:46

the next is probably what? What do

8:48

they look like? And a lot

8:50

of people have probably seen the northern lights

8:52

without realizing it as

8:55

one of the forms they take

8:57

is just a glow in the

8:59

north. And I've actually seen that

9:01

rather commonly leaving up in Scotland

9:03

as well within the zone where

9:05

you can see the aurora

9:07

under normal conditions. And I

9:09

got an app on my phone, which gives

9:11

me alerts for that if you also live

9:13

in the UK, it's called Aurora watch UK

9:15

for Android. This bro, I think they also

9:17

have an iPhone version, it actually gave me an

9:20

alert tonight. So after we're done recording this, I

9:22

might have to go to check and see

9:24

if we can see them again. But

9:26

most often when I get an alert,

9:28

it's just, oh, there's a bit of

9:30

a glow to the north, which yeah,

9:32

that is them. But it's not the

9:34

fantastical displays you see people posting pictures

9:37

of. And what

9:39

it actually turns out is going on with a lot

9:41

of those pictures is what

9:43

people are posting online mostly

9:45

are long exposure photographs, which

9:48

can pick up much more subtle contrast

9:50

in the sky than you can see

9:52

by eye. So the

9:54

photos actually look a lot better

9:56

than the aurora look

9:58

in reality. Unless you're lucky

10:01

enough to live in a place that's

10:03

far away from any light pollution, which

10:06

almost definitely most people don't. Most people

10:08

live in cities where there are lights

10:10

even at night. But

10:13

those who can get away from it can

10:15

have the Northern Lights being the only significant

10:17

source of light aside from the stars in

10:19

the sky and get some fantastic

10:21

shows that can just be seen by eye. That

10:24

would be cool. You know, I would say it

10:26

was one of the most disappointing things that I

10:28

learned that a lot of the coolest photos just

10:30

of anything are the long exposure stuff like

10:32

the night sky. I'd be like,

10:34

boy, you sure can see a whole lot of that Milky

10:37

Way when you're, I guess,

10:39

I don't know, somewhere other than here. And it's like,

10:41

well, no, a camera just was left on for a

10:43

month. And then that's what it looks like.

10:45

Yeah. And a lot of

10:47

that we could have seen if it weren't

10:49

for all of the light. One of the

10:51

frustrating things is light pollution is one of

10:53

those things that isn't really good for anyone.

10:56

It's wasteful of energy if you have light

10:58

that's going off into the sky. And

11:00

there are very often some simple

11:02

modifications that can be made to

11:04

street lights. You only need

11:07

the light to go down. So if you just put

11:09

a reflective surface above it, you only need half the

11:11

intensity to get the same light going down. Yeah,

11:13

a lot of places are doing that.

11:17

But then you also get things like

11:19

office buildings, which leave their lights on,

11:21

or they just have to have their

11:23

logo displayed at full brightness overnight. All

11:26

of this stuff adds up. And the

11:28

light that we get from the Aurora

11:30

is usually drowned out. And so a

11:33

lot of these displays are going on. We

11:35

just can't see them. And

11:37

it's a shame, really. Yeah. But

11:39

what's happening? Is the planet burning or something? Is

11:41

it climate change? Why do we got, I mean,

11:44

it's pretty crazy. Is it for once

11:46

going to not be something horrible that's

11:48

responsible for this crazy phenomenon going on?

11:50

As far as humanity knows, we are

11:53

not to blame for the Northern Lights.

11:55

They've been going on since humanity was

11:57

around. The way they looked... This

12:00

must have been like one of the

12:02

things that convinced people of the supernatural.

12:04

If you see these weird light displays

12:06

in the sky and have no understanding

12:09

whatsoever of what signs you could possibly

12:11

cause it. That's one of the things

12:13

that yeah, I get why people would

12:15

believe in like fairies or something causing

12:17

it because even these days

12:19

we don't fully understand the science behind

12:21

it. We've got a lot of pieces

12:24

of the puzzle put together. There are

12:26

just a few steps in the middle

12:28

where we aren't sure what's happening. So

12:30

I'll give you what steps we

12:33

do now. So step

12:36

one, we've already covered the where.

12:38

The where is a pretty big

12:40

clue as to what's happening and

12:42

that they occur in rings around

12:44

the poles. And this is a

12:47

strong indication that one of the

12:49

factors influencing them is Earth's magnetic

12:51

field. We can get into magnets

12:54

in a bit, but let's say

12:56

the technical stuff for a bit

12:58

later on and just wait

13:00

on that. The other clue is

13:02

that they are very

13:05

strongly correlated to activity in the

13:07

sun. Now that we're able to

13:09

monitor the sun with telescopes, we

13:11

can check for solar storms, what

13:13

they call coronal mass ejections, which

13:15

is when there's like a big

13:17

bubble in the sun that bursts

13:19

and spits a bunch of particles

13:21

at us. Whenever something like that

13:23

happens, we get typically a much

13:26

stronger auroral display. And that

13:28

type of thing is why we're going

13:30

into a period of seeing a bunch

13:32

more auroral displays. Like the sun has

13:35

long-term weather changes. Like you know how

13:37

on Earth every few years we get

13:39

El Niño and La Niña, the long-term

13:41

weather changes. The sun has things like

13:44

that too. There's an 11-ish year cycle

13:46

and we're hitting the peak of it.

13:48

Well just starting to hit the peak

13:51

of it and we should be expecting

13:53

to see stronger and more

13:55

common aurora coming up over the

13:57

next few years or so. What

14:00

the heck makes up the sun's weather

14:02

though? I just assume the sun's just

14:04

all hot. It's just hot

14:07

a lot. Just lots of hotness. What

14:09

different things are happening? It is

14:11

hot, but remember a few

14:14

episodes back we talked about

14:16

turbulence. And it's the

14:18

kind of chaotic thing. Like oh,

14:20

just on your recent episode with

14:23

Dr. Sutter, you talked about the

14:25

turbulence of the free body problem.

14:27

I just have to get this off my

14:29

chest. The show is called Free Body Problem,

14:32

but it features a four body problem. The

14:34

planet is a body too. It's

14:36

so tiny though that they don't count it, I

14:38

think. I think that's what it is. Well,

14:41

no, you do have to count it. If

14:43

you just have a planet and two stars,

14:45

you still do have to account for the

14:47

planet. Particularly because the planet is where all

14:49

the people are, its path gets very important.

14:51

I don't know. How far away do you

14:53

have to be to be a habitable planet

14:55

from a system like that? I'm

14:58

trying to defend the good name of

15:00

free body problem because one thing

15:02

that Paul said was that the reason we don't sweat

15:04

this in our solar system is like it's just a

15:06

series of two body problems and the other planets are

15:08

so tiny it doesn't really matter. Yeah,

15:11

that is a factor. The other

15:13

planets aren't going to send the

15:15

sun careening off or the

15:18

earth. You can

15:20

have chaos with just two

15:22

stars and one planet even if

15:25

the planet is infinitesimally small. If

15:27

you trace the path of that planet, that

15:30

planet's path will still be chaotic even if

15:32

the path of the two stars aren't.

15:35

If you care about what happens to the people, it

15:38

is how many stars plus

15:40

one planet problem. Gotcha.

15:42

Anyways, the point is chaos

15:44

affects the weather and chaos

15:47

basically boiling it down, particularly

15:49

for those who didn't listen

15:51

to that episode, is

15:54

a physical system that is

15:56

not random despite intuitively thinking

15:58

chaos is random. this. When

16:00

we speak in physics jargon, it

16:03

isn't. Chaos means something that's perfectly

16:05

deterministic. It follows the laws of

16:08

physics. If you rewind everything and

16:10

run it again, it will happen

16:12

the exact same way. But

16:15

the difference with chaos is

16:17

that while the present perfectly

16:19

predicts the future, the approximate

16:22

present doesn't predict to be

16:24

approximate future. So if things

16:26

at the beginning were slightly

16:29

different, the future will be

16:31

vastly different. Pretty much unpredictable.

16:34

Weather is one of the

16:36

quintessential chaotic systems. And

16:39

so the sun effectively

16:41

has its own weather. It's a

16:44

lot of particles in a hot

16:46

plasma throughout it, and a lot

16:49

of it being a nuclear fission

16:51

engine. And the

16:53

specific distribution of particles

16:56

is very complicated, random

16:58

in a sense. And

17:00

what this means is that over

17:03

time, small changes in positions of

17:05

the sun will build up into

17:07

bigger effects. And these lead to

17:10

large weather effects. And some of

17:12

these will have predictable patterns, and

17:15

some won't. It'll just

17:17

be chaotic. And these chronomassage

17:19

ejections, you can predict the

17:21

overall frequency and how that

17:23

will change over time. But

17:25

you can't predict exactly when

17:28

one will occur until

17:30

it's basically already started. So

17:33

that's how we get weather in the

17:35

sun. And that's why the auroras are

17:37

sometimes stronger than others. So

17:39

the two pieces we have so

17:41

far to the auroras is you

17:43

get activity from the

17:45

sun, spews out particles,

17:48

these particles hit the earth,

17:50

do something with the magnetic

17:52

field, we'll get back to

17:54

that something. This leads to

17:56

something happening around the poles.

17:58

And the final piece

18:00

we know for sure is what

18:02

causes the colors to be emitted

18:04

from the aurora. This part comes

18:06

from basically what's in the air.

18:09

So in the high upper atmosphere

18:12

where the auroras come from, the

18:14

most common elements are oxygen and

18:16

nitrogen. And particularly in the highest

18:18

regions where we see the auroras,

18:21

oxygen is more common in its

18:23

atomic form. If you remember

18:25

back to high school chemistry, you probably

18:28

remember that oxygen as we most often

18:30

experience it when it's on its own

18:33

is in O2, or

18:35

a molecule of two oxygen.

18:38

Yeah, and nitrogen is most commonly

18:40

N2. In the high upper atmosphere,

18:42

a lot of factors going into

18:44

it, oxygen is most

18:46

commonly in atomic form. Nitrogen is still

18:49

in molecular form, it bonds to itself

18:51

so strongly that it's so hard to

18:53

get apart. You should compare yourself, nitrogen,

18:55

am I right? Yeah,

18:57

oh, it would if it could, trust me. So

19:01

the poles are where the single oxygens go

19:03

to play the theme. Yeah. Okay, most

19:06

oxygen, monogamous pair bonding forever.

19:08

Yeah, so what's going on

19:10

in the Northern Lights is

19:12

basically a rays.

19:15

So think of it this way, that

19:17

energy gets injected into them from the

19:19

particles coming in from the Sun, and

19:21

then the energy, you know, they get

19:24

knocked around a bit by these particles,

19:26

and then they let out a yellow

19:28

of excitement. And this yellow of excitement

19:30

is the light we see. Like a

19:33

mosh pit. Yeah, basically, you've got a

19:35

lot of atoms in a mosh pit,

19:37

and they let out wells of excitement.

19:39

And because of quantum mechanics, the yells

19:41

they let out can only be a

19:44

very specific wavelength. And

19:46

you can think of it like a

19:48

miniature solar system with a nucleus with

19:50

electrons orbiting it. Quantum

19:52

mechanically, it's more complicated.

19:54

But the electrons

19:56

can only orbit in quotes

19:59

at certain. levels. Again,

20:01

due to quantum mechanical between

20:23

these levels is always a

20:25

fixed value. So the photon

20:27

that it spits out is

20:29

always going to have exactly

20:31

the same amount of energy. The

20:33

result of this is that we

20:35

get what we call emission lines

20:37

coming out of the particles and

20:40

for the aurora we primarily

20:43

see two lines from oxygen,

20:45

one red line and one

20:47

green line coming out

20:50

and a bunch from nitrogen. Nitrogen

20:52

as a molecule has much more

20:55

complicated behavior in what light we

20:57

can see so there are a

20:59

lot more potential emission

21:01

lines but the oxygen

21:03

ones dominate and so this is why

21:06

the aurora looks like it

21:08

does and this also explains why

21:10

we see different colors at different

21:13

altitudes. If you look

21:15

at most pictures of aurora you'll most

21:17

commonly see green which matches one of

21:19

the two lines from oxygen. This line

21:22

is stronger and the human eye is

21:24

also more sensitive to green so most

21:27

of the time auroras are going to

21:29

look green but sometimes you'll see the

21:31

red line as well particularly at higher

21:34

altitudes. Like during Christmas and stuff.

21:36

Yeah, yeah. It wants to

21:38

be a little Christmassy. This line

21:40

always shows up but sometimes it

21:43

gets suppressed. Electrons, it doesn't have

21:45

a chance to let it yell. Basically

21:47

a nitrogen comes by, bumps into it

21:50

and steals some of the energy but the

21:52

green one is more able to

21:54

let it out and all of that

21:56

combines gives an interesting mix of red

21:58

and green and then and all of

22:00

the other colors that come in from

22:03

nitrogen, but only when you can really

22:05

see them well. So this part, we've

22:07

got a good handle on. Okay, so

22:09

Northern Lights, they're pretty much always somewhat

22:12

going, is that true? Or I guess

22:14

on both poles. There's always some amount

22:16

of the sun's energy is doing whatever

22:19

it does, you know, in the privacy

22:21

of the bedroom of these molecules. It

22:24

makes something let out some energy, something,

22:26

something light. I sort of understand at

22:28

least what's going on there. But

22:31

it's just a question of it being stronger

22:34

and going further down the planet

22:36

or whatever. Why does that, I

22:39

guess I'm having a hard time understanding like the difference

22:41

in how it comes up or down. So

22:43

the strength of it usually depends on how

22:46

much is coming in from the sun. So

22:48

going back to our mosh pit example, you

22:50

know, it's always like you've got people in

22:52

a mosh pit and there'll be a bit

22:55

of noise coming out. They just kind of

22:57

shuffle around, occasionally bump each other, let out

22:59

an oof, sorry. But

23:01

then when the band gets on stage

23:04

and starts to play and

23:06

inject a lot of energy into

23:08

them, the mosh pit gets loud.

23:10

So the solar activity, when it

23:12

starts ejecting and spraying us with

23:15

many more charged particles, inject a lot

23:17

more energy into the system. So more

23:19

atoms get excited and more excited atoms

23:22

give off more light and it gets

23:24

brighter. I don't know why I'm

23:26

having a little bit of a

23:28

mental block unlike, so why is it,

23:30

it's around the poles because the

23:32

magnetic field of earth is like

23:34

more around there or, and so how

23:37

does that relate to these oxygen,

23:39

they're like the mosh pit-y thing. Why,

23:42

yeah, what's the relation of that? That's

23:44

the tricky part. Okay, so let's just put

23:46

a pin in that for one second because

23:48

there was one other part that's relatively

23:51

easy to address is what

23:53

happened a week ago as

23:55

we talked about this. If anybody's

23:58

looking at this far in the future, that would be...

24:00

around 10th of May, 2024, was

24:04

it wasn't just that they got

24:06

brighter than usual, they also got

24:09

significantly further south than usual. And

24:11

I think the trick here is

24:13

that where they occur

24:15

are also subject to weather patterns

24:18

on Earth, that the upper atmosphere is

24:20

affected by weather as well.

24:22

And this shifted the zone where

24:25

all these charged particles were hanging

24:27

out further south so that they

24:29

could be more visible. That

24:31

part relatively straightforward, at least

24:34

as straightforward as weather can

24:36

be. But we still have

24:38

to get into the question of why

24:40

they're hanging out up north in

24:43

the first place. And to do that, we're

24:45

probably going to have to get into trying

24:48

to explain magnetism as best I can

24:51

over an audio medium. When a

24:53

mommy magnet and a daddy magnet

24:55

love each other very much. Yeah.

24:57

So let's start, Thomas, what do

24:59

you know about magnetism? How would

25:01

you describe that? Literal magic that

25:03

wizards invented. So basically that insane

25:05

clown posse song, miracle, fucking magnets, how do

25:07

they work? That's where you're at. Never heard

25:10

of it, but fully agree with that message.

25:12

Fully agree with that. Okay. Yeah. I

25:14

could have written that, apparently. Our

25:17

everyday experience of magnets is their

25:19

chunks of metal, which do a

25:21

few things, all of which seem

25:23

to be related. They have two

25:25

ends which behave differently. We call

25:27

them poles, like the magnet will

25:29

have the north pole and a

25:31

south pole. And if

25:33

the magnet is able to move

25:35

on its own, it will typically

25:38

rotate to aligned with earth's magnetic

25:40

field. So that's the north pole

25:42

of the magnet points south and

25:45

the south pole of the magnet points north.

25:48

And if you have two magnets, they'll do

25:50

the same thing where the north pole of

25:52

one will be attracted to the south pole

25:54

of the other and vice versa.

25:57

So magnets opposites attract.

26:00

Magnets will also tend to

26:02

stick to a lot of

26:04

metallic surfaces that aren't themselves

26:06

magnetic. This is something we

26:08

call induced magnetism. It basically

26:10

temporarily turns other metals into

26:12

a magnet and then sticks to them

26:14

because of that. So magnets are

26:17

an attractive or repulsive force depending

26:19

on how they're aligned. From good

26:21

looking they are, yeah. Yes, exactly.

26:23

And now one other interesting thing

26:25

about magnets is if you look

26:27

at a magnet, let's say you've

26:29

got a bar magnet, one side is

26:32

the North Pole, one is the South

26:34

Pole. What happens if you cut that

26:36

magnet down the middle? What

26:38

do you have then? Hot dog filer hamburgers. Hamburger

26:42

style. Down the... Oh,

26:44

oh wait, what? Like do you cut

26:46

it in half long ways or? Short

26:49

ways between the North and South poles of

26:51

the magnets. Gotcha, okay. Now, yeah, that's a

26:53

good question. Do you get two... interesting. Do

26:55

you get two magnets with the North and South Pole? Or

26:58

do you get a North magnet and a South

27:00

magnet? Ah, I don't

27:02

know. Yeah, this is something that's

27:04

hard to just imagine but very

27:07

easily to do experimentally. And this

27:09

experiment is done and you always

27:11

get two magnets each with

27:13

the North and South Pole. Really? Yeah,

27:15

you can repeat this, cut each of

27:17

the smaller ones in half. You'll then

27:19

get like four each with their own

27:21

North and South. You can

27:23

keep doing this all the way

27:25

to the atomic level and eventually

27:28

you'll get a single atom of

27:31

iron, typically iron. You can make

27:33

permanent magnets instead of other things

27:35

but iron is by far the

27:37

most common. And that atom acts

27:40

as its own small magnet with

27:42

a North and South pole which

27:44

you can't split apart any further.

27:46

I mean, if you split iron, you

27:48

get a nuclear explosion. Actually,

27:50

no. Iron, you can't even

27:52

split to get a nuclear explosion. It's already in

27:55

a memory. You have to inject a ton of

27:57

energy. So if you split it, that won't happen.

28:01

You have to pour a ton of energy into it, you'll get

28:03

a fizzle. Iron is

28:05

the one element that you can't get

28:07

energy out of by either splitting or

28:09

fusing. Oh yeah, wow. Is

28:11

that coincidental or is that like the

28:14

reason why it is the magnet? I

28:16

think this part actually is coincidental. Okay,

28:18

gotcha. The reason why actually comes down

28:20

to the way the electrons are around

28:23

iron. So if we go back to

28:25

what I was talking about before, that

28:27

electrons are like miniature

28:29

solar systems around

28:31

nucleus. This is

28:34

wrong and it is very

28:36

importantly wrong because if electrons

28:38

were always going in circles

28:41

around atoms, every

28:44

atom would be magnetic. But

28:46

in practice, really only

28:48

iron and a couple others

28:51

are. So what's going on quantum

28:53

mechanically is that each electron

28:56

is more in a cloud of

28:58

probability space of where it could

29:00

be. And most energy levels

29:02

look something like a cloud or a

29:05

blob or something like this. They

29:07

get built up in a very

29:09

weird way. But the interesting thing

29:11

is that eventually when you get

29:13

exactly to iron, the newest energy

29:15

level you add is the first

29:18

one that's actually a ring. That's

29:21

the first time you could say in

29:23

some sense the electron

29:25

is orbiting. Even then,

29:27

it's not quite right. But

29:30

iron puts the electron in

29:32

the state that that energy

29:35

level of the electron has

29:37

a constant magnetic moment, we

29:39

call it, and causes magnetism.

29:42

Interesting. Don't understand it, but I'll take a word for

29:44

it. Are you also tired

29:46

of one size fits all weight loss plans? Meet

29:49

Noom, the personalized solution that meets you

29:51

where you are. Noom is

29:54

able to understand your unique needs

29:56

from dietary restrictions to medical concerns.

29:58

Unlike restrictive programs. NUAM embraces

30:01

your lifestyle and choices. Discover

30:04

a sustainable approach to weight loss, tailored

30:06

just for you. Honestly,

30:08

NUAM felt like it was made for me.

30:10

It's not just about what I eat, it's

30:12

about understanding why. With NUAM,

30:14

I've learned so much about myself

30:16

and built healthier habits that stick.

30:18

It's all about progress, not perfection.

30:21

Say goodbye to restrictive diets and

30:23

experience the NUAM app for yourself

30:25

with personalized lessons and expert coaching.

30:28

NUAM's psychology and biology-based approach has helped

30:30

over 5.2 million people

30:32

achieve their goals. Stay focused

30:35

on what's important to you with

30:37

NUAM's psychology and biology-based approach. Sign

30:40

up for your trial today

30:42

at nuam.com. That's n-o-o-m.com. And

30:45

check out NUAM's first ever cookbook,

30:47

The NUAM Kitchen, for 100 healthy

30:49

and delicious recipes to promote better living.

30:51

Available to buy now wherever books are

30:54

sold. What's

30:56

up, sandwich heads? Today on Steve-O's Sandwich Reviews, we've

30:58

got the tips and tricks to the best sandwich

31:00

order. And it all starts with this little

31:02

guy right here, Pepsi Zero Sugar.

31:04

Partials of astronomy, craving a cubano.

31:07

Yeah, sounds delicious, but boom! Add

31:10

the crisp, refreshing taste of Pepsi Zero Sugar

31:12

and cue the fireworks. Lunch, dinner, or late

31:14

night, it'll be a sandwich worth celebrating. Trust

31:16

me, your boy's eaten a lot of sandwiches

31:18

in his day, and the one thing I

31:20

can say with absolute fact... Every

31:23

bite is better with Pepsi. You're

31:26

a podcast listener, and this is a

31:28

podcast ad. Reach great listeners like yourself

31:30

with podcast advertising from Lips & Ads.

31:33

Choose from hundreds of top podcasts offering

31:35

host endorsements, or run a reproduced ad

31:37

like this one across thousands of shows

31:39

to reach your target audience with Lips

31:41

& Ads. Go to

31:43

lipsandads.com now.

31:45

That's l-i-b-s-y-n-ads.com.

31:48

So, to get down

31:50

into understanding, let's talk

31:52

about electricity and electrostatics

31:55

first, because... ...magnetism is really fascinating, and

31:57

I have a good story to share

31:59

with you. about how I uncovered that

32:01

it's actually two different laws of physics in

32:03

a trench coat. So when

32:05

I was learning about electromagnetism in school,

32:07

I was surprised to find that they

32:10

didn't start by teaching us about magnets,

32:12

which I like, what we deal with

32:14

magnets all the time. But

32:17

no, they started teaching us

32:19

about what they call electrostatics,

32:21

which is the simpler half

32:23

of the equation. Electrostatics

32:26

is kind of like gravity

32:28

except the opposite. So

32:31

gravity is simply mass attracts

32:33

other mass, and

32:35

electrostatics just adds one layer of

32:37

complication. Okay, charges

32:40

repel charges that are the

32:42

same and attract charges that

32:44

are opposite. So it's a

32:47

simple opposites attract like repels.

32:50

Things like electrons are

32:52

negatively charged, protons are

32:54

positively charged, so they attract each

32:57

other. Two electrons, both negative, they

32:59

repel each other. It's simple like

33:01

that. And then as you go

33:03

through, they start to introduce

33:05

how it relates to magnetism. And

33:08

what happens is that any

33:11

changing electric field, so this

33:13

could be caused by accelerating

33:16

electric charge, which if

33:19

you want a stable state, you

33:21

can have when you have an

33:24

electric charge orbiting something, it's constantly

33:26

accelerating towards the center. Any accelerating

33:28

electric charge causes a magnetic field.

33:31

So if you have an

33:33

electron actually orbiting a central

33:36

position, you get a fixed

33:38

static magnetic field. And

33:41

the way this magnetic field is

33:43

shaped is kind of like imagine a

33:46

doughnut that the

33:48

electron is orbiting around the center of

33:51

the doughnut, and the magnetic field lines

33:53

go on the surface of it through

33:55

the hole down to the bottom across

33:57

up the edge back over the top.

34:00

and down. So a field line

34:02

is just describing where the

34:05

imaginary magnetic field points at any specific

34:07

time. So this would be like your

34:09

north to south direction. You could trace

34:11

this out for any region of space

34:14

and you'll get a doughnut

34:16

shaped with the electron

34:18

going through the bulk

34:21

of the doughnut around the hole and

34:23

the magnetic lines going down through the

34:25

hole up around the edges. So you

34:27

follow me on that? I'll

34:30

take your word for it. No, it's one of those things

34:32

where it's like fundamental so I don't, I can't, it's hard

34:34

to, can't be like, oh but why?

34:36

You know, because you've kind of hit either

34:39

a fundamental why or just too

34:41

hard to explain to me why.

34:43

Yeah. Well okay. That part I

34:45

can answer. We can go one

34:47

layer deeper on that but

34:50

before we do let's zoom back

34:53

out to the earth. So the

34:56

earth has its own magnetic

34:58

moment because the earth has a ton

35:00

of iron in it and

35:03

magnets tend to induce other

35:05

magnets. So over time

35:08

the iron in earth, a

35:10

lot of it aligns their

35:12

magnetism and for complicated

35:14

reasons it aligns it more

35:16

or less with the pull

35:18

of earth's rotation which actually

35:20

notably isn't always the

35:23

same direction. There's evidence that

35:25

historically the earth's magnetic pull

35:27

has flipped multiple times

35:29

over its history. I think the best

35:31

explanation is that sometimes the earth gets

35:33

hit by a comet

35:36

or asteroid or something and

35:39

it knocks everything out of whack and then

35:41

it settles back the other way by chance.

35:44

That's crazy. Yeah. Right now

35:46

the magnetic pull aligns mostly

35:48

with the axis of rotation. It isn't

35:51

exactly there. So if you were to

35:53

follow up like friends if you follow

35:55

a compass let it point you north

35:58

it will point not in the sky. Exactly to

36:00

the North axial pole but the

36:02

North magnetic pole which right now

36:04

is a bit over the northernmost

36:07

island of Canada, Ellesmere Island Which

36:09

is it's like the old-school equivalent

36:11

of like when Google Maps had

36:13

the wrong thing at your house

36:15

or whatever and like drove A

36:18

bunch of people ended up at your house

36:20

because Google Maps said it was like a Chipotle

36:22

or something It's like that but the old-timey

36:25

thing maybe it'd be a bunch of ships

36:27

or in that whatever Canadian island They're like

36:29

no, it's not It's

36:31

magnetic north. It's not the real it's

36:33

not in the North Pole. Come on

36:36

There actually is a bit of an

36:38

issue with that but for airplanes because

36:40

airport runaways are always numbered according to

36:43

their angle relative to magnetic north

36:45

and Magnetic north keeps

36:48

changing and since Canada is so

36:50

close to the magnetic pole they

36:52

eventually got frustrated with having to

36:54

keep changing the Numbers

36:56

of their runways when magnetic north changed they

36:58

eventually said, okay screw it the rest of

37:01

the world You can do magnetic north. We're

37:03

doing geographical north so we don't have to

37:05

keep up with all of this Anyway,

37:08

that leads us to kind of the

37:10

shape of the magnetic field now

37:12

Let's go back to our donut

37:15

example. You draw your lines around

37:17

the donut You start

37:19

anywhere in the surface of the donut

37:21

follow the magnetic field It goes makes

37:23

a loop around it. Now one thing

37:25

you might notice about these loops Let's

37:28

say you draw four loops one pointing

37:30

out a right and left one up

37:32

and down on your donut At

37:35

the outer edge of the donut these

37:37

field lines as we call them are pretty

37:39

far apart from each other But

37:41

in the center they're close together.

37:43

Oh, right. That makes sense Yeah,

37:46

and when we draw a field line

37:48

diagram how close the lines are together

37:50

is Proportional to how strong

37:52

the field is so the

37:54

magnetic field is very strong going right

37:57

through the center of the donut and

37:59

we coming up around the sacs.

38:01

That's why it's so delicious on that part.

38:04

Yeah. Well, that's why they sell the whole separate.

38:06

That's the most delicious part of the magnet. Yeah,

38:09

so magnetic. Yeah. So if we take

38:11

this as Earth, Earth is like

38:13

the donut hole. Or it

38:15

overlaps a bit with the hole

38:17

because it has a magnet inside.

38:20

And so the field lines are

38:23

going to be all around us. You

38:25

can imagine like the Earth embedded in

38:27

a giant donut. And around

38:30

the north and south poles of the

38:33

Earth, you're close to the center of

38:35

the donut hole. So you've got the

38:37

field lines close together. And then off

38:39

to the sides, you're closer to the edges of the

38:41

donut where the field lines

38:44

are far apart. Oh, man. But I'm struggling

38:46

because you're saying the Earth is the donut

38:48

hole? Because if that were true, I would

38:50

expect everything to be close. Those field lines

38:53

to be close together all around the equator.

38:55

Because isn't that where the donut... Yeah. So

38:57

the trick is we have multiple donuts. One

39:01

donut inside another. I'm

39:03

just simplifying it down to one

39:05

donut. Okay. I want to make

39:07

sure I keep my donuts straight. Because that was something

39:09

that like when you brought that up, the field lines

39:11

is like, hey, for once I can totally visualize what

39:13

you're saying. And then it didn't work. So I just

39:15

want to make sure why. Yeah,

39:18

exactly. So the thing is we have

39:20

multiple donuts layered on top of each

39:22

other. Oh, it's not just one donut.

39:24

It's like a three-dimensional donut. Donut. So

39:27

like you might have heard of a tur

39:29

dakken, the chicken inside a

39:31

dakken inside a turkey. Here

39:33

we have a dough dough dough

39:35

nut nut dot. We have a doughnut inside

39:37

a doughnut inside a doughnut, which is much

39:40

better and also much

39:42

more cruel. Okay. So

39:44

we have doughnuts inside doughnuts and

39:46

around the pole, the whole part

39:48

of these three doughnuts are much

39:51

closer together. Okay. And

39:53

they come out of the Earth around the pole. Gotcha.

39:56

So closer together field lines, much stronger

39:58

field. And then around the

40:00

equator. the outer edges of

40:02

the donuts are farther apart and

40:04

so farther apart field lines is

40:06

weaker field. So overall

40:08

the magnetic field is much

40:11

stronger around the north and

40:13

south poles than is at

40:15

the equator. Gotcha. We won't

40:17

get into the jelly filling, but that's

40:19

another episode later on. Yeah, so then

40:22

the other piece of

40:24

the puzzle is answering why does

40:26

the magnetic field cause charged

40:29

particles to be around there.

40:32

And this is just another

40:35

way that electricity and magnetism

40:37

go together. It's basically the

40:40

same way that electricity

40:42

can cause magnetism, magnetism

40:44

can cause motion in

40:47

electrically charged particles. And

40:49

the way it works is just

40:52

imagine one of these field lines, which

40:54

is just you draw the line north

40:56

to south and until it forms a

40:58

complete loop. If an

41:00

electrically charged particle gets close

41:02

to one of those lines, it'll

41:04

tend to start spiraling around it.

41:07

So to go with the

41:10

metaphor, just imagine somebody who

41:12

loves trees a lot walking through a forest.

41:14

Whenever they get close to a tree, they

41:16

reach out their arm, touch it and start

41:18

spinning around it. I like that.

41:20

That's nice. So up in the

41:23

north and south poles, we've got

41:25

a variable forest of magnetic tree

41:27

lines. And all of these

41:29

charged particles are tree lovers and they get

41:32

caught in the forest and start hanging around

41:34

up there. There are

41:36

many fewer trees out near the equator

41:39

for the particles to get stuck in.

41:41

And even when they do, you know,

41:44

they might start spinning around the

41:46

magnetic field line, but they'll also

41:48

have some velocity either north or

41:50

south just by chance. And then

41:52

they'll spin around it while slowly

41:54

going north until eventually they get

41:56

to where the field line is

41:58

going down. Oh. No,

42:01

no. Yeah, they

42:03

get to the Iggdrasil up at the North Pole. Yeah.

42:06

The field line starts curving back down

42:08

into Earth and then other things like

42:10

atmospheric pressure capture them there. Like

42:13

they'd be fighting against the higher pressure to get

42:15

down. And so the

42:17

magnetic field lines basically capture these

42:19

particles, guide them up the poles

42:22

where the big mosh party is

42:24

happening and they can all celebrate

42:26

their tree loving together in the

42:28

big forest. Right. Because it's one of

42:31

those things where I think I get

42:33

caught in like magneto mode or not. Like

42:35

I'm like, yeah, it's just the magnetic, whatever,

42:37

but got to remember there's also other forces

42:39

like happening all the time as well. So

42:41

it's like that interplay of

42:43

the magnetic force and then also atmospheric

42:46

stuff going on. Yeah. The

42:49

magnets want to guide them one way and

42:51

then the atmosphere pushes the other and eventually

42:53

they get balanced out and they just kind

42:55

of pile up near the poles. And then

42:57

eventually other things come around like the solar

42:59

wind will steadily blow them off. And

43:02

then when there are big coronal mass

43:04

ejections from the sun, they excite all

43:07

of them. They have a big party

43:09

spew out Northern and Southern lights

43:11

that we can all see and have a

43:13

lot of fun. Then a few of them

43:16

get blown off. Many of

43:18

them get blown off in the party. But

43:20

what we see is just the lights coming from them.

43:24

So do we complete the loop there? The

43:26

donut loop? Yeah. So that's the

43:28

reason why the particles are hanging out there. And

43:30

then I guess I, so here's what I'm still a

43:32

little stuck on. Now the

43:35

crazy lights being seen by

43:37

people as far South as

43:39

somehow me, that's not

43:41

a question of more particles getting

43:43

trapped, right? Because that would be

43:45

all earthy stuff. It's

43:47

a question of... Well, the particles do

43:50

often come from the sun. The

43:53

oxygen and nitrogen, yeah, those

43:55

elements come from previous stars,

43:58

But there's also a lot of

44:00

that that... the got into the

44:02

fun at some point and got

44:04

blown towards us. The whole thing

44:06

is complicated but most of that

44:08

does tend to just come from

44:10

earth, earth's atmosphere or kind of

44:12

interplanetary medium of that is the

44:14

death. but given the vacuum thought

44:17

is that the sun is somehow

44:19

sending more. I thought the sun

44:21

was just doing activity lights part

44:23

was it does and more. These

44:25

grow messages and spend a lot

44:27

of particle towards us at the

44:29

big. Miss him as he almost

44:31

as if by law is third

44:33

smaller end of things but there

44:35

is a significant amount that are

44:37

these more masses elements which the

44:39

sun doesn't is yet produce. It

44:41

isn't at that stage or that's life

44:44

but same from previous stars that

44:46

went through their life cycle than produce

44:48

them and then they've just been

44:50

hanging out throughout the source the

44:52

some some of them ended up falling

44:55

into the fun and then getting

44:57

blasted out at us others for

44:59

distant planets and. Get into

45:01

the atmosphere and gets knocked off

45:03

and then slowly come back down

45:05

so it's a bunch of thanks.

45:07

Okay so when it comes when

45:09

the lights go further south it's

45:11

not because of like a stronger

45:14

thing is activating stuff. Further down

45:16

is that there's more. of

45:18

the stuff the more the trapped particle

45:20

a as to as so fuzzy on

45:22

that it's a bit of both the

45:24

of as fun as the more things

45:26

this is part of what isn't fully

45:28

known about it is how much as

45:31

in is being activated more and how

45:33

much as more particles being added to

45:35

the mix but a lot of it

45:37

being seen further south pacific gets brighter

45:39

and brighter it is the further south

45:41

you can see it because he know

45:43

it's a disused the atmosphere the farther

45:45

and then also just optically the by

45:47

something. In the fainter it is.

45:50

But they're also weather patterns on

45:52

earth. a bad effect. Is

45:54

that exists with a particular taste

45:56

where the weather Was married for

45:58

two with us. Kind of

46:00

blew the whole really not much

46:03

farther south than in normally goes.

46:05

At the same time that we

46:07

had a huge storm from the

46:09

sign activating everything's so basically everything

46:11

a line to make them much

46:14

more visible further south than almost

46:16

ever. had lots of the lots

46:18

and lots of variables and they

46:20

all time came up Millhouse for

46:22

the at the Northern lights. Exactly.

46:25

Matsumoto doesn't mean we're dying or the

46:27

climb and or something then know that

46:29

stuff. No, no, this is something that

46:31

happens completely independently from us. If we

46:34

really want to, we could try to

46:36

pump up extra oxygen and nitrogen into

46:38

the air. Ah, I'm probably not the

46:40

best use of our resources such as

46:43

well. It is very shape. Wrangles.

46:45

Astrophysicists. We can have a nice thing

46:47

using this doesn't I think we had

46:49

to have is this is just a

46:51

nice thing of it. It's eclipses. It's

46:54

just something nice south of them will

46:56

gathering and cause that eclipse assists know.

46:58

And Eclipse? Fum. I will. That's nice. So it's

47:00

and you're dealing with you. Expect maybe a bit

47:02

more this? who knows if it'll be. On

47:05

way my an act of the woods the

47:07

like lots of crazy raised up there. yeah

47:09

we may not get out of like the

47:11

again we might get even like the earth's

47:13

been look around particles are getting lucky Him

47:15

I right. Yeah,

47:17

if you're somewhere far north enough that their

47:19

regular you could probably get a nap for

47:22

it will the one I used as a

47:24

row of what's the Pay and you know

47:26

probably use that almost anywhere is optimized for

47:28

the Uk. it's healthier how far into the

47:30

you feel like if we can see them

47:32

in Scotland or England and but it'll. Tell.

47:34

you when the sun is more active

47:37

at least so as the earth over

47:39

and say norway is fry so useful

47:41

for you or mill tell you when

47:43

it's than likely though if you're in

47:45

love those regions get a now if

47:47

you're further south you'll probably get more

47:49

false alert than are worthwhile on a

47:51

nap like that you may wanna look

47:54

for news reports i i think a

47:56

lot of people to alberta to it

47:58

from my guy nasa's twitter account or

48:00

something like that. So, yeah, there are

48:02

other sources, but yeah, it's something to

48:04

watch out for. The The

48:06

delicious ice cold taste of Dr. Pepper has

48:08

a lasting effect on people. Lindsay from Sacramento

48:10

said... Pro tip, 40 degrees is the

48:12

perfect temperature for an ice cold Dr. Pepper. Why

48:15

is 40 degrees the perfect temperature for Dr.

48:17

Pepper? We brought in Sue from Duluth, Minnesota to

48:19

tell us. Oh yeah, I know a thing or two

48:21

about cold. Oh, that right there is the

48:23

perfect kind of ice cold for Dr. Pepper. I'd

48:26

I'd share that with my friend Nancy. She likes

48:28

Dr. Pepper too, you know. My coldest... Alright, that'll

48:30

be all, Sue. Having a perfect temperature for

48:33

your Dr. Pepper? It's a Pepper thing. Inspired

48:35

by Real Fan Posts. or

48:48

visit us online at appheat.com to learn

48:50

more. Hi, I'm Lauren and I

48:52

work for Meyer. People always ask,

48:55

why do I shop there? It's because

48:57

I can get great quality and value

48:59

in one stop. Like this

49:01

week's hottest deals on locally grown asparagus

49:03

and select cuts of fork. Plus

49:06

I can earn 50 points per gallon

49:08

of gas pumped at any Meyer Express

49:10

through June 1st with Empercs. Meyer

49:12

has all I need and just one

49:14

stop and the same low Meyer prices

49:16

in store and online. Exclusions apply,

49:19

see all deals in the Meyer app. We

49:21

put a pin in, can we go

49:23

down any further than magnetism? And

49:26

I wanted to answer that one for you. I

49:28

wanted to leave it to the end as it's

49:30

where things get pretty technical but it's an interesting

49:32

story I wanted to share. So

49:35

let's go back to when I

49:37

was in high school learning about

49:39

electricity and magnetism. They give us

49:41

all of these equations like how

49:44

moving electric particles cause a magnetic

49:46

field and then a magnetic field

49:48

will apply a force to moving

49:50

electric particles other than the ones

49:53

that caused them. And one

49:55

of the things I highlighted was that

49:57

if you have two wires with electricity

49:59

flow. through them and they're

50:02

parallel to each other, the magnetic

50:04

fields caused by these two wires

50:06

will cause them to attract each

50:08

other. That's just the way the

50:10

math works out. So

50:12

then I started imagining, okay, so

50:14

these wires, they have electrons moving

50:17

through them and then enough

50:19

protons there to balance out the charges

50:21

so that each of them is overall

50:23

neutrally charged. We don't have any electrostatic

50:26

force to worry about, but what if

50:28

we did? And I was thinking,

50:30

okay, so if we had just

50:32

two streams of electrons, they

50:35

would still attract each other

50:37

through magnetism but also repel

50:39

each other from the electrostatic

50:41

force. Now the

50:43

strength of the magnetism is proportional to

50:46

how fast the electrons are traveling. So

50:48

could they travel fast enough that

50:51

it exactly balances out?

50:53

And then I started

50:56

thinking, okay, what about from a relativity

50:58

perspective? So let's say you have them

51:00

fast enough that it balances out and

51:02

then let's say you go and take

51:04

a ride on one of those electrons.

51:07

Now as we discussed way back in one

51:09

of the first episodes I did with

51:11

you on special relativity, you can basically

51:13

shift your frame of reference in the

51:16

universe to any other constant velocity and

51:18

all the laws of physics are exactly

51:20

the same. So if you shift to

51:22

ride one of those electrons, the electrons

51:24

in the other stream will all be

51:27

stationary. For your perspective, you

51:29

just have two lines of

51:31

electrons standing there. So there

51:34

wouldn't be any magnetism in this perspective,

51:37

but there would be the

51:39

electrostatic force. So from that

51:41

perspective, the electrons should be repelling

51:43

each other. But from the

51:45

first perspective, the two forces cancel out and

51:49

the lines don't move. So what's

51:51

going on here? Why do we

51:53

seem to get this contradiction in

51:55

the laws of physics? So

51:58

what I did was I went and talked Okay,

52:00

well what philosophy do you

52:02

need for these two to

52:05

cancel out. I. Plugged it

52:07

into the equations. And. The value

52:09

I got out was. Exactly.

52:11

The fetal I like the A. New

52:14

predicted it. Yeah, this is

52:16

a day To The top

52:18

to all of this is

52:20

that I realize that you

52:22

have to account for both

52:24

magnetism and Relativity. And the

52:26

thing is that. You

52:29

can actually do this from either

52:31

perspective. Just say. Okay, from of

52:33

the perfect of somebody riding the

52:36

electrons, the have to be retelling

52:38

each other at this rate. And

52:40

then there are some velocity Relativity

52:42

causes time dilation. If we account

52:45

for time dilation and then go

52:47

back to our perspective, we see

52:49

them retelling each other a bit

52:52

less. And. No one other

52:54

way to characterize the Republic's other

52:56

a bit less is saying. Okay,

52:59

there's this normal electrostatic forces and

53:01

there's also this other forced pulling

53:03

them together. And. Many

53:06

do the calculations that time

53:08

dilation effect slowing the repulsiveness

53:10

is always. Exactly.

53:13

Equal to what's the magnetic

53:15

force staff. For.

53:17

What it turns out is that. Electrostatic

53:20

magnetism and Special

53:23

Relativity are. Intertwined

53:25

that in a way. it isn't three

53:27

separate laws of physics the but. To

53:30

Laws of Physics. if you

53:32

have just electrostatics and special relativity

53:34

magnetism just appears there if you

53:36

want everything to be consistent so

53:38

are you view phase the grand

53:40

unified theory solved it it's not

53:42

that messes one step but it's

53:44

not one of the things i've

53:46

brought up a couple of times

53:48

as that a lot of these

53:51

theories you can dig down deeper

53:53

and so let's try to throw

53:55

their that portal episode that some

53:57

of the greatest physicists are those

53:59

that discovered negative one laws of

54:01

physics. And this is a case where you've

54:03

unified a few and said that now these

54:06

three things are actually just two things. Although

54:08

I did happen on to this on my

54:10

own, of course, I was far from the

54:12

first to realize this has been long

54:15

known. And I think actually this

54:17

was known in a sense of

54:19

known even before Einstein's theory of

54:21

special relativity. If you go back

54:23

to Lorentz calculating it out, he

54:25

stumbled upon that you need

54:28

this time dilation to have that constant

54:30

speed of life. You just input it

54:32

into a fully unified theory. Hmm. Well,

54:34

that's crazy. Yeah, the whole thing is

54:37

crazy. And I just find it all

54:39

fascinating how this all fits together. And

54:41

you get these phenomenally complicated interplay of

54:44

different laws of physics. You see how

54:46

much work for physicists like Brian do

54:48

that you can enjoy your Northern Lights,

54:50

everyone. Yeah, if we didn't understand it,

54:53

you wouldn't be able to see it.

54:55

Exactly. It wouldn't be there. Yeah. Yeah,

54:57

I agree with that actually. So no,

55:01

that's super cool. I can't pretend I

55:04

followed all of that. But I think

55:06

the important stuff, the donut related analogies

55:08

will stick. And once

55:10

again, thanks, Brian. Is there anything

55:12

you want to plug shout out?

55:14

I don't have much going on

55:16

my my own. So I'm just

55:18

gonna plug my campaign to update

55:20

the opening arguments icon to use

55:22

the Garamond font. Oh, okay. The

55:24

change.org petition. Yeah,

55:27

we'll see. But I can't make any promises, you

55:29

know. All right. But

55:33

go to change.org/Garamond. Oh,

55:36

a Garamond. Thanks so much. Astro

55:38

physicist, Dr. Brian Gillis. Cool

55:40

explanation. And let's all go enjoy some

55:42

guilt free Northern Lights near you. All

55:45

right. Thank you. Transcribed

55:54

by. So

56:04

the King's new lemonade lineup is

56:07

here. Name and a lemonade The

56:09

Smoothie King Way try strawberry. Guava

56:11

Lemonade ask refresher over ice

56:13

a power up in it

56:16

can energize, or a blueberry

56:18

lemonade smoothie lead it up

56:20

being. Made with

56:22

real fruit. Real juice for a

56:24

real sipping good summer. Yeah yeah,

56:27

Data is no Smoothie Kings New

56:29

lemonade lineup of for a limited

56:31

time. Who. Stars Day. The

56:34

delicious ice cold taste of Dr. Pepper has

56:36

a lasting effect on people. Lindsay from Sacramento

56:38

said... Pro tip, 40 degrees is the

56:40

perfect temperature for an ice cold Dr. Pepper. Why

56:42

is 40 degrees the perfect temperature for Dr.

56:45

Pepper? We brought in Sue from Duluth, Minnesota to

56:47

tell us. Oh yeah, I know a thing or two

56:49

about cold. Oh, that right there is the

56:51

perfect kind of ice cold for Dr. Pepper. I'd

56:54

share that with my friend Nancy. She likes Dr.

56:56

Pepper too, you know. My coldest... Alright, that'll

56:58

be all, Sue. Having a perfect temperature for

57:00

your Dr. Pepper? It's a Pepper thing. Inspired

57:02

by Real Fan Posts. We

57:08

didn't have. Much.

57:12

More laws of. Physics

57:31

litter.com.

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features