Podchaser Logo
Home
Shocking, Heartbreaking, Transformative 2 - The Grimy Stuff

Shocking, Heartbreaking, Transformative 2 - The Grimy Stuff

Released Tuesday, 23rd January 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Shocking, Heartbreaking, Transformative 2 - The Grimy Stuff

Shocking, Heartbreaking, Transformative 2 - The Grimy Stuff

Shocking, Heartbreaking, Transformative 2 - The Grimy Stuff

Shocking, Heartbreaking, Transformative 2 - The Grimy Stuff

Tuesday, 23rd January 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

You're. Listening to Radio to Be

0:02

A presents from Pr Axes Radio

0:05

Topeka. Before

0:08

we get started, there's another pack ft

0:10

want to check out for clerics Seen

0:12

on Radio has a new series that

0:15

tells the story of the only successful

0:17

coup to tie in Us history in

0:19

Wilmington, North Carolina. November eighteen, Ninety Eight.

0:22

It's a story with disturbing residents today

0:24

in our time have orchestrated attacks against

0:26

democracy and the threat of political violence.

0:28

Look for that goes of a cool

0:31

season. Six have seen on Radio this

0:33

and now. Wherever you listen to podcasts.

0:37

Before. We start. A quick note

0:39

to say that this show is serialized, so

0:41

if you haven't listened to episode one yet,

0:43

Please. Do So Now. After.

0:47

Interviewing thirty strangers from the internet,

0:49

I had to make some tough

0:51

choices. Select. For subjects

0:54

to feature in this documentary

0:56

series, here's who I chose:

0:58

Ernesto, a Dominican American fashion

1:01

model and aspiring designer in

1:03

his twenties navigating new sobriety.

1:07

Me: confidence reinforcing our

1:09

fuel Obama so. Judy

1:11

a white woman in her seventies who

1:14

became homeless after her beloved husband's death

1:16

just a few months before Cove it

1:18

hit the more than happy to sign

1:21

this it just said com Every time

1:23

I sign a document I like a

1:25

copy Jess Hawaiian punk musician in their

1:27

twenties who found out there adopted and

1:30

have a biological brother who has long

1:32

wanted just back in his life there's

1:34

I saw a documentary on the thing

1:37

I I I would use and shit

1:39

I didn't know. This is like p.

1:42

And last but not least, Michael,

1:44

a middle aged black rider and

1:46

rapper who recently got out of

1:48

prison and is now trying to

1:50

become a professional public speaker. My

1:53

words: you're Commercials will be

1:55

like a masterpiece. I

2:00

call them all up to let them know they thing

2:02

cast. No

2:04

no yes we met at the

2:07

documentary edition or just saw them

2:09

have a you I. Wanted to

2:11

give you call because I'd love

2:13

for you to participate in the

2:15

documentary series if you're still interested.

2:17

I am. So eyes of

2:19

lives lost to wasn't for says

2:21

yes nerves be offered him he

2:24

does. Wonderful new gray My mother

2:26

users ah you made mine. I'm

2:30

just same and this is shocking.

2:34

Transform. It is. Here.

2:45

Is my first subject or ness still.

2:48

In his audition. My

2:50

name's in the school. I

2:53

was born and raised in the

2:55

Bronx some twenty years old. Or

2:59

construction to them a part time

3:01

model. Of course

3:03

Ernesto as a model he's got

3:05

to sign Cheekbones, thick eyebrows and

3:08

these dark still lies that long

3:10

losses. And he carries himself

3:12

with an aloofness you might expect. From

3:15

a notably beautiful twenty year old

3:17

home for. The wanna tell me about

3:19

how you found my and why you decided. To

3:21

respond as a resurgence had consensual

3:24

Craig's list sang. A

3:26

Song man. Zola

3:29

to read through. Her.

3:34

Seems a do it again my

3:36

foot in the door. Using spring

3:38

and summer vocals these has a

3:40

good recommended as the law. Even

3:42

when a model you know know

3:44

say a word it's on me.

3:47

Assure that isn't very expression and

3:49

season body language and. Said

3:52

a lot of psychology in. Syria.

3:55

And Iraq. And Syria says think.

3:59

He knows. Meaning my culpability

4:01

in gaining muscle suppose he

4:04

says, well, As.

4:07

You know, in this series I'm

4:09

trying to do documentary differently. I.

4:11

Wanna take on a collaborative approach

4:13

to storytelling in which my subjects

4:15

such. The Course. And then

4:17

I try to realize their vision. So

4:20

I've asked Ernesto to tell me what

4:22

he would like are documentary about him

4:24

to be about. And it

4:26

turns out that he has come up

4:28

with options to possible stories. Mongoose

4:31

was of course since we

4:34

can be put through. The

4:37

sir sounds like a profile of

4:39

ernesto experience in the fashion industry.

4:41

been as i spoke as know to talk.

4:45

To the Freudian own called

4:47

objects good have to. Have

4:50

been referred to as an option

4:53

but to me as part of

4:55

the game being a model and

4:57

puts his things as an extravagant

4:59

industry home. but it's not easy.

5:01

Him and. The second is about his

5:04

long struggle with drug addiction. Moses

5:06

And who says. He

5:09

was a reflection of the problems,

5:11

a symptom the house herself medically

5:13

you know how to answer some

5:16

of the boomers cancel was roses

5:18

opening of. Tells

5:20

me about the it's in Rehab programs

5:23

he's been enrolled in since he was

5:25

sixty. Four years since he started, the

5:27

program is finally about to complete it.

5:31

Is not a conventional we have is

5:33

as and therapeutic community. So

5:36

Ernesto is offering to narrative

5:38

there's either er nest, oh,

5:41

the young model navigating a

5:43

cutthroat fashion industry, or Ernesto

5:45

newly sober, restarting his life

5:48

after. Addictions Treatment. Normally

5:56

I have a detailed plan for any

5:59

story and. The Power that's part

6:01

of the savvy documentary and business

6:03

plan. Pitch something with a clear

6:05

focus, a narrative that you can

6:07

outlined before you even start collecting

6:10

tape. That way you

6:12

can make sure you don't waste your

6:14

time or your networks money. In

6:17

practice that means that my interviews

6:19

are usually pretty direct his documentary

6:21

and tend to steer conversations and

6:23

interviews. ask for more details where

6:25

they want them died, the subject

6:27

to where we think there will

6:30

be scenes in action and we

6:32

definitely made sure that any subject

6:34

we've picked can deliver the goods.

6:36

This feels like playing those awful

6:38

this out loud but I think

6:40

my reactions of as he was

6:43

sort of like this person seems

6:45

really nice but he has. Claimed

6:47

as a me this as

6:50

a very sudden they're it

6:52

sounding story me though. That's.

6:55

Radio Topi as executive producer Audrey Markiewicz.

6:57

After I played her and the rest

7:00

of the Radio Topi a team some

7:02

of the tape for my auditions. This

7:04

was before we settled on the for

7:06

subjects. It. May sound

7:09

harsh if you don't work in media. But.

7:11

Arteries just doing what every one in

7:13

our industry does. Deciding. On

7:16

which stories are worth telling. Or.

7:18

Not. Based. On what we

7:20

think the audience wants. And. Is

7:22

clingy as it may sound to

7:24

call someone's life story generic. Let's.

7:27

Be honest. You're. Listening to this

7:29

right now because you're hoping to hear

7:31

something that will entertain you and maybe

7:33

teach you something new. You.

7:35

Want something that feels face. And

7:38

I want to give you that. Plus. Radio

7:40

Topeka is a selective to teach

7:42

network, so they're literally banking on

7:44

me producing something that will turn

7:47

heads. And as

7:49

I interesting processes eating in a we're

7:51

going to make a documentary about you

7:54

and your life over the next over

7:56

minimum. But I don't know

7:58

exactly what about it yet. You

8:00

know, Okay,

8:02

so back to er nest as

8:04

two pitches: Modeling and addiction. Part.

8:08

Of my project is to challenge

8:10

myself not to have a destination

8:12

in mind. To. Let my subjects

8:14

lead the way. Despite.

8:16

That the dangers of whipping

8:18

up something generic. So.

8:20

When Ernesto invites me to follow him behind

8:23

the scenes at a high profile fashion show

8:25

he's walking, a couple weeks later, he jumped

8:27

at the other two. Are

8:31

you. Have

8:34

a seat over here. We

8:37

need a few blocks from the venue. Is

8:39

the rainy grey day and every

8:42

other person walking by seems like

8:44

they're either carrying a multi camera

8:46

or is over six feet tall.

8:48

We take shelter under an awning

8:50

in scope as the crowd. I'm

8:53

wondering how are you feeling that you normally do

8:55

before? So. Pretty

8:57

nervous when I know the

8:59

nervousness is nestled in isn't

9:02

part of life in Greece

9:04

has to be. was a

9:06

citizens a. Hamburger.

9:11

Know the socio nice This is a

9:13

familiar face before it happens in the

9:16

same as those of us. Are

9:19

Nest tells me he's really excited

9:21

about to sell to securely because

9:23

the designer is Dominican. American like

9:25

him is a meaningful shows

9:27

has just about the person

9:30

is of lifting entire community.

9:32

When Earnest so finishes his cigarette, we mosey

9:34

over to the then you. So

9:37

what's the money like for a good like this? And

9:40

a serious. Are you. What

9:43

is really for me and said the

9:45

you don't know what the right. For

9:48

you wouldn't be doing it is. There

9:51

was a money doing freely. It's

9:54

possible that he says or if

9:56

anything random then I wouldn't go

9:58

to the one. Also. Then

10:00

amanda half cellphone experience

10:02

to know riot. Yoga

10:05

know rate. Have.

10:10

Any other some moving other

10:13

big name him most model

10:15

the result really the Disney

10:17

exceeding the smokers and. I

10:20

mean that's insulting to the it's like you're

10:22

working. For.

10:27

We're I have some unmarked back

10:29

doors, and Ernesto confidently risks me

10:32

past security into a bustling. Hardware

10:37

maker of I'm aware that. There

10:41

are no and to cherish parked

10:43

in here. And loitering around

10:45

the room are a bunch of other

10:47

models, all waiting for a space to

10:49

open up. It. Looks like the

10:51

majority of the. Models. Here are also

10:53

like. Enough.

10:57

On the world over medicated. I will. Allow

11:01

you. To

11:05

see. The

11:07

diversity is boy and remind me

11:10

of the European Kapil Sibal the

11:12

closer than those really gross. Yeah

11:14

totally honest. Agree with a soccer

11:16

for friend and they stand around

11:19

talking shop for thirty or seven

11:21

minutes. Then the guys my my

11:23

can bag of here and Ernesto

11:25

introduces new his documentary on the

11:27

guys. Really impressed says he loves.

11:29

Documentary: What regular cigarettes?

11:32

I make a documentary about the

11:35

people. Are

11:39

worthy. Not see

11:41

that as audio is a

11:43

Saudi I am a foreigner.

11:45

Seen what you hear about

11:47

it at itself together mass

11:50

and creepy or them is

11:52

the movies I get. Slowly

11:55

been talking. It's gotten a lot. More

11:57

crowded. Than her. Maybe

12:01

there's a chance to get a meal for my hands. Sit.

12:04

In their okay. Great!

12:07

We are in business. Or

12:09

nest so is in the makeup chair and

12:11

it's about time. I imagine

12:13

you've had enough of the chatting and

12:15

waiting around for the option to start.

12:18

The Laurie, I'm on it. Is

12:21

Ernest I need you to describe what we're looking.

12:23

So where are we? Any decent

12:25

documentary and is able to do.

12:27

Their work thanks to a trustee

12:29

bag of tricks. Like getting

12:31

people to describe things. In. Detail for the

12:33

high seas at a fashion show. This is

12:35

a key so hundred and like well as

12:38

the eyes of you do the so you

12:40

can be seen in Europe alive. To

12:43

secret sauce that and sub free much

12:45

any documentary. Is sound design with the

12:47

little bit of scoring. Mckillop

12:50

for sound designer. I'm selma take

12:53

it away. Nice. While

12:56

the models and line the the getting

12:58

the nails on a hair done everything

13:00

none of the same time the on

13:02

the phone said to sell fees and

13:04

as the biographers skyn photos of production

13:07

feals running around in the looks together.

13:10

Club foot on every book Luna denim

13:12

skirt that of the utility that in

13:14

lot of parties summer's. Almost

13:17

or knows where? into the A

13:19

Report on with his arms around

13:21

like a zigzag. Chaotic. This is

13:23

crazy. Perhaps

13:30

the most essential tool as editing?

13:32

Just like Michelle can build us

13:35

a vibe from scratch. Everything you

13:37

hearing your average documentary has been

13:40

carefully curated and constructed from many

13:42

more hours of recording with thousands

13:44

of invisible internal cuts. So

13:49

let's go back to Er Nest as

13:51

description of what he's wearing for the

13:53

runway. the denim skirt with the utility

13:55

jacket. Here's the original unedited. Recording but I'd

13:58

put on a boat. I'm

14:00

going to Dunham does. Not

14:06

follow the nativity desert latter part is

14:09

the most sensitive and math exam and

14:11

don't have that I'm scared for the

14:13

big utility dad do a lot of

14:15

parties, the self. As you can hear

14:18

or Nesters original take drugs that see

14:20

don't get the full force at how

14:22

ethic he looks to create that impact.

14:24

I slip away all. The words they don't

14:27

need. More than

14:29

a third. So

14:31

it is a lot of part is. The most. Of

14:36

the same. Code.

14:41

I. Also decide on the order of the

14:43

clips. This. Could mean personal reflection

14:45

from the end of an interview and seeking

14:47

it at the beginning to help emphasize a

14:50

certain angle. Sometimes. To

14:52

flesh out an idea. A. Group clips

14:54

on a theme from two different interviews together

14:56

and men pass it off as though was

14:58

spoken all in one go. I'm.

15:01

Not changing. crucial information.

15:03

And. Just massaging a little. Like.

15:06

I told Ernesto photographer friend.

15:09

It's easy to see how editing contains

15:11

the content and context of what

15:13

people are talking about. This.

15:15

Is part of has story is constructed.

15:18

And depending on the outlet and

15:20

imagined audience, Whether. It's News

15:23

at Five or Dateline. These. Choices.

15:25

They're gonna look different. That

15:29

even the greatest sound design and

15:31

most strategic editing don't make a

15:33

great story. We. Still need

15:35

meet. Fournier. but the grimy.

15:38

The grimy stuff. I guess what

15:41

I'm saying this was swimming in

15:43

their Bowmore. I mean I want to

15:45

hear about all that. I guess I have

15:47

some questions about sort of the challenges as

15:49

the industry. He talked about a few things

15:51

like one of them that you tosca with.

15:53

sort of. this is feeling of objectification fulfilling.

15:55

Certain people expect certain things. Me

15:57

of the home being a model.

16:00

You are not said that their disposal they

16:02

will sell you show up here tomorrow and

16:05

even if you have work you have to

16:07

show up for they will look at to

16:09

lie he doesn't want a model Finding what

16:11

haircut looks best for mean we're was in

16:14

does was style I should give off to

16:16

the world. What is really means your. The

16:18

What will sell as you. And

16:20

As and a big controversy and modeling are

16:23

many of these people are absolute is

16:25

trying to cater to an audience that they

16:27

know they can make money out of. And

16:29

grown up in the Bronx. Walking. Always

16:32

told a story a lot of gangs would

16:34

limp with a certain foot. who express we're

16:36

getting they were with. And

16:39

sometimes I will tell the designer which

16:41

was the want to see we want

16:43

to see my walkers your to see

16:45

the model walk. you look at a

16:47

lot of fashion shows, models aren't even

16:49

lotsa who the neighbor express themselves. It

16:51

feels very limiting at times when you

16:53

are self proclaimed. art is. So.

16:57

Arnold as a response you're looking

17:00

for but I kept the pretty

17:02

boy. Know it's great I

17:04

guess. That is

17:06

it. Great. On

17:11

the subway have something about assassin

17:13

angle isn't sitting right little. At

17:17

his audition, Ernesto keys all

17:19

this stuff without the seedy

17:21

underbelly of a glamorous industry.

17:23

That the things I found most interesting?

17:25

The story that began to emerge in

17:27

the four hours I spent at the

17:29

Fashion Show. For. Not so much

17:32

about Ernesto. Such a structural issue

17:34

in that diversifying fashion industry. How

17:37

Ernesto and other particularly

17:40

racialized models. Are.

17:42

Objectified: Asked to

17:44

be a canvas for someone elses

17:46

brands. Or to come on

17:48

fi their. Culture. For no

17:50

or very little money. What

17:53

I hear is a story about how

17:56

bodies like Ernesto is are being used

17:58

by the fashion industry. And

18:00

it the same time are going

18:02

unseen. I

18:07

think it's a risk territory. But.

18:10

I'm a white woman from Canada,

18:12

and there are definitely many people

18:14

who do a much better job

18:16

than me of understanding all the

18:18

nuanced racial dynamics at play in

18:20

the story. Also.

18:22

The story is much bigger than Ernesto, and

18:24

to do it well, I'd need to talk

18:26

to a lot more people. And. I

18:29

just don't have the production budget take that

18:31

on. The. Series

18:33

I sold to Radio Topeka features

18:35

personal stories, and that's partially because

18:37

stories of individuals facing struggles are

18:40

easier and faster to produce and

18:42

to deliver on. So

18:45

now I make an executive decision,

18:47

a practical and professional ones to

18:49

stick to the brief of the

18:51

project. I now already been partially

18:53

paid for. To keep the stories

18:56

contained to the personnel and work

18:58

with the resources, I do have

19:00

access to a new to ask

19:02

Ernesto if we can pivot to

19:04

his addiction. Story. Heads

19:09

up. When. Her back from the break.

19:11

Things are gonna get real with Ernesto and

19:14

there will be talk about drug use. And

19:16

self harm. I

19:26

arranged to meet Ernesto at his apartment

19:28

in the Bronx. There

19:31

are dishes stacked in the sink,

19:34

overflowing ashtrays that looks almost

19:36

like are sculptures, and piles of

19:38

leather and lace and denim. Fabric.

19:41

every word. Cameras think

19:43

it's. The centerpiece of the

19:46

room is a sewing machine and a

19:48

raft of structured. Garments. It

19:50

turns out that Ernesto the fashion designer

19:52

to. A made this would

19:55

rather for some Mansell with a

19:57

necklace class put it on. However,

20:01

for. Amazing

20:03

section strengths. Cool

20:06

though. He's a cool. Thing:

20:09

these are your style little

20:11

bit fuzzy party pooper know

20:13

a span. Of

20:17

these are really gorgeous. Have

20:20

a lot of potential I just need to increase. Was.

20:24

Mean he grabs. An armful of clothes

20:26

off the couch, dumps them on a side

20:28

table to make room for us, and then

20:30

launches. Into. His story and know

20:32

hours a drug addict before

20:34

even touched drugs. Janis Joplin,

20:36

Jimi Hendrix, All of them.

20:38

I would watch the documentaries

20:41

about them. Twenty Sevens Club

20:43

heroin addict. I

20:45

saw refuge in all the stars

20:47

and stuff. Or mom and Dad

20:49

divorce When. I came

20:51

basically my dad was and ready and has

20:53

been like an absence of my life and

20:55

is hard for kids and I have is

20:57

that when you for Hudson. You

20:59

know any means and get bullied and

21:02

called names home as well as a

21:04

failure. Couldn't. Again would have been.

21:06

Some. Was on the moon. On

21:10

So smoke weed out with people

21:12

smoking weed together, giggling and I

21:15

felt that community assault like I

21:17

belonged. For

21:20

everything else, sorta on

21:22

nice. It

21:25

only took a couple months for me to get

21:27

into purposes. Getting

21:29

high on opiates was like and

21:31

workers node last hours. And

21:35

you just feel warm, overly giving homes.

21:38

And. Soy One.

21:41

He was like the hose I never got. From

21:44

friends and my Dad and mom. And

21:48

her so drawn from the only convicted. In

21:52

own, sometimes the drugs or in in

21:54

Austin and I'll get high end and

21:56

not even feel better. I was still

21:59

feel the same. The news whom I

22:01

spoke getting on my knees and praying

22:03

willing I promise I'm a single anymore

22:05

as please Lord opening in Mclean would

22:08

over have to do please. And

22:12

a new it's and I'll isn't bad

22:14

mind drugs and I just felt hopeless.

22:16

And Roses on Fanatic for Lights and

22:18

Will. Eventually

22:26

earnest as family finds

22:28

out just how bad

22:30

things. Are. In they

22:32

said this it was gonna drive

22:35

straight to or institution where have

22:37

you can do. But

22:39

as much as he hates being

22:41

addicted, the treatments don't seem very

22:43

useful. It became like a

22:45

fun game to go into programs

22:48

and just mess around a thesis.

22:50

Corny weight by old lady psychiatrists

22:52

and. since I'm

22:55

a preacher. Came in. And

22:57

in the psych ward and he gave us

22:59

business cards. If you have room to talk

23:01

about the lord, give me a call. And

23:04

I said the card and assorted putting my

23:06

wrist. who's As And instead of painting my

23:09

hand blood and a selling your muscles or

23:11

the hands of thing with blood. Cenozoic

23:16

selling addicts to stop stop

23:18

been I like was a

23:20

problem. just be good but

23:22

why would they want a

23:24

bigger than why would they

23:26

want whatever that means good

23:28

while the they want to

23:30

be in society. Has

23:40

I'm listening. I'm getting these. Kindles,

23:44

This happens to me when

23:46

I transition from performing interest

23:48

as the interviewer, nodding eye

23:51

contact, following the scripted the

23:53

questions I prepared to getting

23:55

sucked in. Feeling. That

23:57

my interview he is saying. The.

23:59

Team. Those are. A. Tell tale sign

24:01

that the power of story is

24:04

working on me. They remind me

24:06

of my old dream to build

24:08

empathy through documentary. Is

24:10

someone's words can touch me in the moment?

24:12

display? I. Know they'll have the power

24:14

to work on my listeners to. After

24:18

a slew of different sailed programs

24:21

are nestor winds up in this

24:23

last treatment program. Or

24:25

same in it was all. Be

24:28

good orders and became my

24:30

worst enemy. And

24:32

hopes to. Not be

24:35

a victim of it anymore. And they

24:37

called it an image As an arena

24:39

so you have image negative image. He

24:41

needs a change. So.

24:44

I let go when I complied

24:46

and have found myself. It's

24:53

been four years of sobriety or

24:55

Nestor says he looks around his

24:57

apartment, at the fabric in the

24:59

close, at the sewing machine, And

25:03

will Bruin artist and tell myself that

25:05

like enough for me she was. Thinking

25:08

and seal it. Is

25:13

very scary when I get the

25:15

predecessor overwhelmed. No

25:18

no drugs to escape reality. I

25:20

on have bad have is I

25:23

don't know those escape routes sun

25:25

never thought. grown up obeying orders

25:27

for a close. this has me

25:29

like second one motions and letting

25:32

them so well. I

25:35

hope I have the opportunity to

25:37

bring this to the world and

25:39

share My story is not something

25:42

like. This vocally on

25:44

a podium. My

25:47

hopes own. All of them are

25:49

close and see some emotion as

25:51

on triumphs and some old. How's

26:02

it going? Freeze? Are you doing so as a

26:04

villain? supposed? To that. Sylvia

26:07

haven't I feel like gun or nord

26:09

to save some within. You

26:12

know I'm used to tell my story to addicts

26:14

and Room for that is What? What When a

26:16

toads of the world as oh no really know

26:19

how is a different. Animal

26:21

simulators you understand in an immunity. Easy to

26:24

tell him that it's man I really want

26:26

to use to the i don't know they'll

26:28

get it and they can give me where

26:30

is. I

26:33

know you want the engagement. the wow He

26:35

must be tough for him to still. Feel

26:38

like an added either four years apart.

26:40

while. Being. An

26:43

industry embellishing is. Important

26:45

in entertained socially oriented thousand different

26:48

ways on it's own Most engaging

26:50

intriguing funny man who brings out

26:52

the most most and new known

26:55

as or. So

26:57

I only know. What

27:00

I should sound like house Project Morpheus

27:02

has to be a little deeper in.

27:07

The first first phone the

27:09

accent only know what. What?

27:14

Do you think listener? Do

27:17

you need something different from Ernesto?

27:20

Do you need him to tell his story

27:22

in a different way? With.

27:25

A different accents. Or

27:27

more drama. Do

27:30

you have the tingles? Does

27:32

Ernesto story seal Worth your

27:34

time and attention? Or.

27:37

Does it seem? Generic.

27:41

I'm. Always wondering what you need my

27:43

listener as I wade through moments

27:45

like this: Moments. That

27:47

probably won't make the final cut. One.

27:50

Of the things I really like a

27:52

better Nest though is that he seems

27:54

to get that any story he's telling

27:56

me is going to become the product.

27:59

He's. Certainly producing himself.

28:02

In. Some ways, this makes him an

28:04

ideal partner. And my project. I

28:07

feel like something that I've been. Struggling.

28:11

With I guess as

28:13

an. Outsider, that china

28:16

of you tell you story

28:18

is like. Trying to get

28:20

beyond. The

28:23

say you know beyond us

28:25

surface level there it is

28:27

of like I had trauma.

28:31

I became a drug out here. Now I'm

28:33

clean. You know that I just. What

28:36

is the lesser you're here to teach me

28:38

or it's guide me to we can talk

28:40

Obama current struggles more I know I ramble

28:42

lot I don't want to idle for your

28:44

guiding me to it. you know because of

28:46

I just rambling ramble the would and. What

28:51

do you want the documentary to be? Like

28:53

you know, we've recorded a bunch of

28:55

hours together so far. The

28:57

like as a citizen of. What?

29:00

Should be. Trying to

29:03

think about it as internal how of

29:05

audio works and stuff. It's

29:07

been a few hours and I think we're

29:09

both running out of steam. In

29:12

I'm trying not to be whistle blower like.

29:16

And modeling industry they tried to

29:18

rape me. I guess I'll go

29:20

of police brutality me and wanted

29:22

to that possessed like selling out

29:24

and I'm not running a to

29:27

do that. Yeah with as it's

29:29

around the moon. For

29:32

both tired. And I'm kind of at

29:34

a loss of what to do next. So

29:36

I decide to wrap things up here. He.

29:43

I mean I guess that's that's part of

29:45

this. the struggle that I have because. So.

29:47

Did easy to say oh I want him

29:50

to steer the ship. Public.

29:52

Doesn't know how I met my bi

29:55

weekly editorial meeting with the Radio Topi

29:57

a team talking about what I've recorded

29:59

so. Far with Ernesto and

30:01

how I'm feeling about this

30:04

process. As a professional storyteller,

30:06

Where you're like trying to hold. Ah,

30:08

like and but the and

30:10

knowledge of. Market.

30:13

Functionality as the same time. On

30:16

some god that it feels

30:18

messy. And the Radio Topi

30:20

a team is trying to help out. I

30:22

was like who is the savvy

30:24

one here by you know, just

30:26

the professional or. Or

30:29

nest, oh, the model where

30:31

he's very comfortable with the

30:33

idea of be like God.

30:36

Like played to be molded. That's.

30:39

Managing producer Uri Lasorda and

30:41

he's the one who psych.

30:45

Traded maybe Ben and as I.

30:47

Know this is the system. And

30:50

here's Audrey again Radio Topi

30:52

as executive producer The Question

30:55

that you're sort of dancing

30:57

around his. Yes,

31:00

documentaries are supposed to be

31:02

impossible, but they are also

31:05

entertainment and like. They're

31:08

being sold, right? So that is

31:10

often how people are selling them

31:13

is as entertainment. As infotainment

31:15

or whatever you want to call

31:17

it. And so how A? How

31:19

to? How Do. You are? can

31:21

you do do both? It's a

31:24

great question. And no one on

31:26

the call seems to have an answer. The.

31:29

Zoom meeting screen is just

31:31

a grid of silent nods.

31:33

Lucy. For. Food.

31:38

Or. Everyone's

31:40

bobbing. A.

31:46

Few weeks later and I'm still puzzling over

31:49

what to do with all that tape from

31:51

Ernesto. it's clear to

31:53

me now that within the scope of

31:55

my project i plan to let ernesto

31:58

direct his own documentary about himself was

32:00

always doomed to fail because

32:02

I have a product to deliver. But

32:05

as I listen back to the tape, I

32:08

start to hear a third story angle.

32:11

It's something Ernesto didn't pitch to me

32:13

directly, but that he's been showing and

32:15

telling me. Speaking of which, I

32:17

do have Venmo. So,

32:19

so because I owe you some

32:21

money. Yeah, I can really use some money right now

32:24

too. For years

32:26

now, one of Ernesto's main

32:28

jobs has been being a model. Like

32:31

he said, it's being a

32:33

professional object. And now

32:35

that he's part of my project, he's

32:37

essentially become a professional

32:39

subject. OK, I only

32:41

have 700, when 1200. So

32:45

we spent about seven hours

32:47

together. So

32:49

seven hours is one hundred and

32:51

forty dollars. And what

32:54

Ernesto needs is five hundred dollars to

32:56

pay rent, object

32:58

or subject, the

33:00

transformative power of storytelling

33:02

or not. This

33:05

gig simply isn't paying enough to make

33:08

a difference in Ernesto's life. And

33:11

usually this sort of professional

33:13

subject opportunity doesn't

33:15

pay at all, just

33:17

like the modeling gigs. I

33:19

really appreciate if you sent me like.

33:26

And that's my pride and shyness. You know, I

33:28

don't have it in me to say I ain't

33:30

doing it for this much. Like I'll do it for

33:32

free. I'll never ask you. By

33:34

necessity, Ernesto has become an expert at

33:37

giving people what they want to see

33:39

and hear. Cash rules, everything around.

33:41

Queen gets the money. Tada, Tada,

33:44

do your own. That

33:50

pressure to tell a story that

33:52

seems exceptional and not generic, it

33:55

forces us to take real lives, to

33:58

take Ernesto's life. and

34:00

to ascribe value to how well

34:02

he can narrate his most traumatic

34:05

experiences, so that

34:07

we can experience empathy. But

34:11

empathy to what end? And

34:15

for whose benefit? Whose

34:17

bottom line? I

34:23

could tell a thousand stories about

34:25

Ernesto using all my tricks of

34:27

the trade. I

34:29

could even have him tell the rape or

34:31

the police brutality stories he offered up. But

34:34

the last thing I want to do

34:37

is turn Ernesto's pain into your pleasure.

34:40

And I'm beginning to think I've designed this

34:42

whole project around a flawed premise. How

34:46

can I make good on my commitment to

34:48

radiotopia now? And

34:51

how does it change how I need to work with my

34:53

other three subjects? I've

34:55

only just started. At

34:59

least if all else fails, we're

35:01

all getting paid. Man goes to

35:04

college and poor man goes

35:06

to work. Another

35:09

one. I love

35:11

that line. I

35:16

don't want much nothing at all,

35:18

but I will take another. I

35:28

will take another. Oh

35:33

no, no, no. I'm

35:35

not a place to be kind. And

35:38

to be a dear son, to

35:40

be free to call am I,

35:42

and be a intercede. I'm

35:45

far too always, even

35:48

if I don't do it

35:50

all the best. But

35:53

that's just How the service getting

35:55

deeper makes me heard. From

36:03

Radio Toby Presents this was

36:05

episode to of shocking heartbreaking

36:07

transform it as a series

36:10

about what happens to all

36:12

of us subjects, documentary ends

36:14

and audiences when stories about

36:16

our lives become products. I'm

36:21

just saying. I wrote and produced

36:23

this episode with help from a

36:25

bunch of people like editor is

36:28

Sarah Next, The executive producer radio

36:30

Topeka is Audrey Mart of It's

36:32

Pretty Utopias. Managing producer is your

36:34

Elazar Dell or Sound designer and

36:36

mix engineer is Michelle Maclin and

36:38

our music was composed by Allies

36:41

and the Me with additional music

36:43

by Michelle Maclin. Mona has and

36:45

provided production support and are episode

36:47

are is by Justin Broadbent. Thanks

36:49

also to. Cali Anderson's Jason Fox

36:51

T okay I, Anson Jordan Lord

36:53

Meter couple least Eleanor Mcdowell and

36:56

Pooja Random are also wanted to

36:58

shout out who does amazing book

37:00

and mediations which blew my mind

37:02

and in for much of the

37:04

thinking behind this episode and the

37:06

series as a whole audible into

37:08

the book in the show Notes:

37:11

This reporting. Was also supported by

37:14

the International Women's Media Foundations Howard

37:16

G. Baset Fund for. Women Journalists'

37:47

You to me.

Rate

Join Podchaser to...

  • Rate podcasts and episodes
  • Follow podcasts and creators
  • Create podcast and episode lists
  • & much more

Episode Tags

Do you host or manage this podcast?
Claim and edit this page to your liking.
,

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features