New York City! The big apple, the city that never sleeps, call it what you will - people are definitely getting murdered there. And we've got two wildly different stories based in the city we're calling home right now.

Brandon is taking us back in time so be prepared to picture his story in black and white. He's telling us the story of 'Cigar Girl' Mary Cecilia Rogers. Poor Mary was the hottest lady in town, people literally came from far and wide just to...stare at her? Kevin can relate.

No one knows for sure what happened on the night of Mary Cecilia Rogers murder. So get ready for some juicy speculation of this strangulation!

Then Kevin takes us to a totally different scene. Remember club kids? If you don't...how old are you/how straight are you?

This is the story of Michael Alig, a prominent club promoter notorious for peeing on unsuspecting party goers, and Robert D. "Freeze" Riggs brutally killing Andre "Angel" Melendez.

Unlike the Cigar Girl, we know exactly what happened to Angel. And every last detail will make you gag. Don't say I didn't warn you! But what else can you really ask for on Halloween?

Just remember, murder is NOT funny. But we are! So sit back, relax? And enjoy the show.

And if you're thankful to finally have a gay perspective on true crime, don't forget to rate and review the show. And don't commit a hate crime by saying something mean. Also, share it with your friends because otherwise, you are a loser!