Podchaser Logo
Home
Show Finale- Speculations V: 100-700 CE

Show Finale- Speculations V: 100-700 CE

Released Sunday, 21st January 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Show Finale- Speculations V: 100-700 CE

Show Finale- Speculations V: 100-700 CE

Show Finale- Speculations V: 100-700 CE

Show Finale- Speculations V: 100-700 CE

Sunday, 21st January 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:06

G'day. I'm Gary

0:08

Stephens. And welcome

0:10

to the third season of the History

0:13

in the Bible podcast. In

0:16

this final season, I explore

0:18

how the Jews and the Christians

0:21

constructed new religions when they were

0:23

sent spinning into the void after

0:26

the destruction of the temple. All

0:29

of the history about all of the

0:31

books beyond the Bible. Episode

0:39

3.34 The Series

0:42

Finale – Speculations

0:44

Part 5 Welcome

0:47

to the final show in my main

0:49

narrative, The Series Finale.

0:52

There will be the occasional bonus

0:54

episodes in future, but the

0:56

chronicle I began 9 years ago in

0:59

2015 has finally reached its

1:02

natural conclusion. And

1:04

I'm old and fatigued. It

1:07

is time to pack up my bongos and

1:09

leave the stage. I

1:12

don't know about you, but I've had a

1:14

ball. I made

1:16

so many new friends. Of

1:19

course, you the listener really made the

1:21

show what it was. Thank

1:24

you to all who emailed me over

1:26

the years. I

1:28

replied to each and every person. Except

1:31

the complete nutcases of course. I

1:35

am so glad you came with me

1:37

on my journey and that I

1:39

gave you a few hours of listening pleasure.

1:42

I learned a vast amount over the years

1:45

and I hope that I have passed some

1:47

of that down to you. My

1:51

podcast was researched, produced,

1:53

written, narrated and recorded

1:55

by me, Gary Stephens. My

1:58

cat was no helper to me. I have

2:02

relied entirely on the writings of others.

2:05

Such virtues as the show has are

2:07

entirely due to them. All

2:10

its shortcomings are my own. I

2:13

can only claim two modest contributions

2:16

to Bible Studies. The

2:18

first is coining the term

2:20

Imperial Church Incorporated. I

2:23

think this introduces a worthy new

2:26

concept into Bible Studies. The

2:28

second is proposing the logistic growth

2:31

model of Christianity. I

2:34

am shocked to say that

2:36

proper mathematicians are now expanding

2:38

on my initial simplistic proposal.

2:42

Let me conclude with a potted biography.

2:45

No one has actually asked me for this but let

2:48

me indulge myself. I

2:51

began my working life as an

2:53

academic in Australian and American universities.

2:56

I gained so many degrees that I now

2:58

have 27 letters after my name. Each

3:02

and every letter has been utterly

3:05

useless. Back

3:07

in the day I wrote three books issued

3:10

by major American publishers and

3:13

translated into a few languages. One

3:16

of those books was used by other scholars

3:19

to construct an entirely new

3:21

sociological way of looking at

3:23

the profession of architecture. Now

3:26

no one thought to tell me about that development for 25

3:28

years. Entirely

3:31

unbeknownst to myself I

3:33

had become the founding figure of

3:36

a miniature, iny weeny new school

3:38

of thought. By

3:40

then I had long left academia

3:43

and joined the real world as

3:45

an IT contractor. As

3:48

I aged I had more and more

3:50

down time between contracts. IT

3:53

is an industry populated by young

3:55

people. No potential

3:57

boss in a tech industry. kindly

4:00

on a job candidate, old enough to

4:02

be their father. I

4:05

began the show as a hobby to

4:07

fill in that downtime. I

4:10

immersed myself in research for two

4:12

years before I recorded my first

4:15

show. And long ago

4:17

that was. Oh

4:20

and before I forget, as a

4:22

final flourish, I am working on an

4:24

Amazon self-published set of paperback volumes about

4:26

the show. There

4:28

will be four in the series. One

4:31

for each season and one

4:33

collection of visual resources derived from

4:36

my website. The

4:38

volume of resources will be published first.

4:41

I'll let you know when the first paperback is

4:43

available. So

4:46

with this episode I finish the

4:48

series with three more speculations. First,

4:52

what if Marcianism had become the

4:54

orthodoxy of the Imperial Church in

4:57

Corbett? Second,

4:59

could Manichaeism have swallowed up

5:01

the church? And

5:03

finally, could the church have

5:06

survived and prospered had it

5:08

not become the state religion of the Roman

5:10

Empire? Well Steve, we're

5:12

on the home stretch in

5:14

our speculations. Scenario

5:18

13. What

5:20

might have happened if the church had

5:22

gone down the Marcianite route? Or

5:25

if you can say the Marcianites would have won? Who

5:28

are the Marcianites? Fairly

5:30

early on in church history, around about the year 130 I

5:32

think, a wealthy guy called

5:35

Marcian who was the son of a bishop

5:37

in Asia Minor comes to Rome and he

5:39

basically tries to buy his way into the

5:41

church. He gives

5:43

the Roman church a massive amount of money.

5:46

I actually did some calculations and I was like enough

5:49

money to feed all the Christian

5:51

poor in Rome for about three years on

5:53

bread. But

5:55

he starts coming up with ideas which

5:57

the Roman church thinks are decidedly

6:00

off. So Marcin's

6:02

in Rome and he starts church

6:06

become incredibly dubious about. But

6:36

Marcin says, no I'm going

6:39

to ditch the entire Old Testament. Here's

6:41

my canon and he's the first person in

6:43

Christianity to explicitly create a canon. And here's

6:46

canon is for what in Getha it's a

6:48

sort of a shortened version of the book

6:50

of Luke and all the

6:52

letters of Paul that Marcin knows about. He

6:55

redacts them to to remove sort of Jewish

6:58

influences. The Roman

7:00

Jesus Club basically said, no, no, no, no, no,

7:02

no, this is all wrong. Our

7:05

roots are in Judaism. They

7:07

boot him out of the city in effect. They return

7:09

his money and I'm sure that was hard to do

7:11

because it was a lot of money. Marcin

7:14

goes back to Asia Minor and

7:16

he invented his own parallel church basically. It

7:19

was never a threat to Christianity. It

7:23

just didn't really take off. But

7:25

had Marcin succeeded in persuading the

7:28

Roman Jesus Club of teaching Judaism.

7:31

Well that entire link is cut and

7:34

Christianity then becomes its own unique

7:37

religion and I'm sure given

7:39

that all this is happening around about the year 130, by

7:41

around the year 200, Christianity

7:44

would have forgotten entirely about its

7:46

Jewish roots. Our here

7:48

happened to have been born in Judea

7:51

but it would have regarded that as important as

7:53

had he been born in Espana

7:56

or Gallia. Now

7:58

Steve, do you think that Marcinism had

8:00

a chance of becoming the Orthodoxy? I

8:03

think that's the major question. Didn't it have a chance? I

8:07

don't think it had the chance

8:09

to be the major Orthodoxy. It

8:12

just seemed that that was just a

8:15

bridge too far, because most of the

8:17

people really were Jewish or

8:19

were attracted to the religion because

8:21

of that Jewish element. And to

8:23

just completely cut that out would

8:25

be, I think that that just

8:27

would be too much. And

8:30

that I think that it would have watered

8:33

down the religion too much. It would have

8:35

really felt, I think, for most people back

8:37

then, yet he was inventing something brand new,

8:39

which they were not big fans of brand

8:41

new. Yeah, the

8:43

Romans really didn't like brand new. To

8:46

them, that was a superstition as

8:49

opposed to a religio. The

8:52

Romans loved like Egyptian religions.

8:54

Even Judaism were honored as

8:56

being ancient. But this

8:58

new stuff that you guys are thinking up. Gary

9:01

and I were talking about Dutch

9:03

influences on English. It could be

9:05

poppycock. Poppycock. Which

9:09

is interesting that it's much more

9:11

popular in Britain to say something's

9:13

poppycock, but it actually came through

9:15

the Dutch in America and

9:18

then made the leap over to British

9:20

English, which is unusual at that time.

9:23

But that's a whole different story for a different

9:26

day. Poppycock does sound

9:28

like one of those quintessential British

9:30

expressions. Poppycock, old

9:32

chap. Poppycock. Spoken

9:35

by a middle-aged retired colonel

9:39

with a big handlebar mustache and

9:42

preferably one of those pith helmets. I've

9:46

actually got a pith helmet. Oh,

9:51

maybe we'll have to have that

9:54

in the show thumbnail. You wearing

9:56

the pith helmet? With

9:59

mars. Marcionism, maybe

10:01

as an alternative to it

10:03

becoming the Orthodoxy, I wonder

10:05

if it really caught

10:08

hold in Rome, let's say. Maybe

10:12

it wasn't revolutionary. It just

10:14

slowly, over time, the

10:16

Jewishness of Christianity faded

10:19

away. And this

10:21

idea that the God, the Hebrew

10:23

God, the God of Israel was

10:25

the Demiurge and that Jesus is

10:27

the real manifestation and eons and

10:29

all that stuff, that they go

10:32

into that direction maybe over 50

10:34

years and it

10:36

causes a multipolar Christianity where

10:39

in the West, people

10:41

are more towards this non-Jewish

10:43

version and that almost maybe

10:45

becomes a rump version of

10:47

Christianity because that

10:49

could have split the Roman Empire earlier.

10:54

Or what does Constantine take up?

10:57

There could have been a much

10:59

earlier cleavage between the Latin-speaking and

11:01

the Greek-speaking parts of Christianity which

11:04

didn't really completely separate until 1100

11:06

or something in

11:08

the early... Yeah. Or

11:10

even as another alternative to

11:12

that Marcionism vibe stuck in

11:15

Rome. Even

11:17

if Rome stays nominally Orthodox,

11:19

there's always the... It's stuck

11:21

in people's craw that Rome

11:23

just isn't right heresy-wise and

11:26

the bishop of Rome doesn't

11:28

accumulate that power because people

11:30

just don't respect Rome. Oh,

11:32

Rome. There

11:35

they go again. Now

11:37

that's a possibility and you kind

11:39

of had the bishops or the

11:42

patriarchs of Alexandria and Angio becoming

11:44

the big guys until Constantine of

11:46

course built Istanbul, Constantinople. Yeah,

11:50

there's a lot of possibilities I

11:52

think with that and I think

11:54

that's another one where it's

11:56

maybe the alternative history that Marcionism

11:59

doesn't take. over in Rome.

12:02

You have to be pretty back

12:05

that much money. An amazing

12:09

act of the

12:12

fantasy views really quite

12:14

repugnant. But just for

12:16

the two of you about say Rome goes

12:18

that way, I suppose they

12:21

could have then started to regard

12:23

the Old Testament a bit like

12:25

most Christians regard the apocryphal books

12:28

today. You know,

12:30

there's first and second Maccabees and

12:32

there's Baruch. Yeah,

12:34

yes, yeah, I heard about them once. Now

12:39

the next scenario is Steve. The

12:41

Manicheans take on Christianity.

12:45

Now Steve, I'm going to rely a lot on your

12:48

insights here. What I

12:50

know is a guy called is the pronounced

12:52

Manny, Manny. Take

12:54

your choice. Manny

12:57

was active around about the year 240

13:00

in the society and Sassanid Empire.

13:04

The year 240 is if I remember correctly the

13:06

time of great political crisis in the Roman Empire,

13:08

but that's by the by. Manny

13:11

seems to have viewed himself as the

13:13

final successor in a long line of

13:15

prophets and he regarded himself as a

13:17

universal messenger designed to replace all other

13:20

religions and he

13:22

recorded his teachings in writings. The

13:24

religion he founded seems to have been a real

13:27

octopus. It just

13:30

sucked in everything that it could find.

13:33

Bits of Christianity, bits of Zoroastrianism,

13:36

bits of Gnosticism and

13:39

the Manichean Church was dedicated to

13:41

vigorous missionary activity like the Christian

13:43

Church was. Manicheism

13:45

seems to have been really quite successful

13:48

and he spread throughout all

13:50

the Aramaic speaking regions of

13:53

the Near East. So

13:55

it spreads out from the Sassanid Empire

13:58

into parts of the Roman Empire. seems

14:00

to have been very popular. And

14:03

it sort

14:35

of thing. Now firstly, do you

14:37

think it's really

14:39

a biggest threat? I

14:41

don't know if it was a threat per se.

14:45

That's really in the time in the

14:47

Roman Empire where they were going towards

14:49

making Christianity the official religion and then

14:51

by the time of Theodosius, the only

14:54

religion. I

14:56

think you could maybe make the

14:58

case that it's almost like what

15:00

do they say non-African humans have

15:02

a certain percentage in Neanderthal DNA

15:05

in them. But

15:07

I think that you could make

15:10

the case with Augustine, St. Augustine

15:12

or Augustine if you prefer having

15:14

been a Manichaean during a

15:17

really pivotal part of his

15:19

life. There's some

15:22

ideas that have snuck into

15:25

Augustine and it'll probably it

15:27

was in his religious DNA

15:30

this idea of dualism and

15:33

that snuck into his writing and you

15:35

could almost say that certain strains of

15:38

Christianity today have a

15:40

little Manichaeanism. That

15:42

might be a controversial opinion but

15:44

I'd love to

15:46

hear what people have to say about that. I think

15:49

there you could maybe make that case. You

15:52

could say that the alternative timeline actually

15:54

did happen and Christianity

15:57

absorbed elements of Manichaeanism. So

16:01

you don't think it's possible that I

16:04

am and say Constantine or whoever might

16:08

have made it the state religion instead

16:11

of Christianity. You don't think that's a goer? It

16:13

seems like the like Manichaeanism wasn't

16:16

the going concern in around the time

16:18

of Constantine. I mean I could be

16:20

wrong on that. But

16:23

so even if we put that aside, it

16:25

seemed like Manichaeanism spread differently

16:27

than Christianity as well. It

16:30

was like a wildfire and it just blasted out and

16:33

it almost seemed like it couldn't

16:35

maintain that rate of growth. So

16:39

it was a wildfire destined to die in the end.

16:42

I must admit, had I been alive say

16:44

the fourth century, I would have been very

16:47

worried about Manichaeanism because it just does seem

16:49

to have been this great intellectual. I

16:51

need a word, I'm sick of using

16:53

the word octopus, something which sucks in

16:56

everything. Black hole.

16:59

That's it. Manichaeanism

17:01

seems to have been a black hole

17:03

of a religion which just consumed everything

17:06

in its path and threatened to dominate

17:08

the religious universe. And

17:10

it had the advantage I suppose over Christianity in that

17:13

it wasn't exclusive. I mean you could be a Manichaean

17:15

and be something else. But

17:17

Manichaeanism was so flexible and all encompassing.

17:19

Being something else almost didn't matter. It

17:23

was probably already part

17:25

of Manichaeanism. Yeah and I

17:27

think that's why it's spread into India

17:29

and it's spread into China and even

17:31

beyond. And

17:34

sort of in parallel with Christianity, it

17:36

seemed to have run parallel to Christianity

17:38

and it may have really been that

17:40

when Islam came around, it cut the

17:43

middle out of it. Almost

17:46

like with Christianity in those areas

17:48

of the Middle East that Islam

17:50

went into, they just didn't have

17:52

the juice to stick around. Christianity

17:54

stuck around a little bit more

17:56

in the Persian Empire in that

17:58

time And in that. Place at the

18:01

weren't on top of that social structure.

18:03

You probably were gonna be a pretty

18:05

big trouble and near long term outlawed.

18:09

I miss you Talk to the state Religion demon. Yeah.

18:12

Exactly like if you weren't the state

18:14

religion or your days were numbered. Maybe.

18:17

Manichaean as and could have reached a

18:19

point where a couldn't be stamped out

18:21

by that islam The advent of Islam

18:23

that I think what if spell the

18:25

end of it because it really did

18:28

a cut the men allowed of heads

18:30

and that would be really hard to

18:32

overcome. Her. Other theories

18:34

that the man a key and turn

18:36

it into the Bulger me else

18:38

and some of those odd gnostic christian

18:41

sagged spend same audible Eastern Europe

18:43

European Slavic i don't have those are

18:45

owed really off of wall theories

18:47

but it kind of makes sense. Some.

18:50

As far as it's entirely possible, And

18:53

we know what happened to that. The and A Cathouse

18:55

and the Vulgar Mills in Europe. That

18:58

could be that reverse situation where

19:01

manichaean as I'm say it does

19:03

take over the empire and it

19:05

just takes at suck softball lot

19:08

of christianity and to at so

19:10

it's maybe sixty percent christian. net.

19:13

And. Has a very heavy belabor

19:15

of christianity, but it's not

19:18

the whole structure of the

19:20

Orthodox church said all the

19:22

hierarchy that comes with that

19:24

norma arguing about spine points

19:26

of theology. I

19:29

guess all these days. We.

19:32

Know that Constantine

19:34

legalized Christianity. It's

19:37

not entirely clear whether he himself was a

19:39

christian I mean cause any got baptized on

19:41

these displayed did. Me which. Seems a little

19:43

bit I'm a cop asks. About

19:46

two generations later it was went to

19:48

the state by see as doses who

19:50

basically said i can everyone's a christian

19:52

now with you like it or not.

19:56

says the state supported and

19:58

promoted the organ structure of

20:00

the church. It

20:03

gave it money, it gave it protection. Would

20:06

Christianity have succeeded, prospered and carried

20:08

on, had that not happened? That's

20:12

an interesting one because then we have

20:14

a Roman Empire that's a pluralistic society

20:16

where you can be who you want

20:18

to be and I wonder

20:21

how that would look practically

20:24

in a situation because even

20:26

during that time period between

20:28

Constantine legalizing Christianity and giving

20:31

it boosts, maybe not

20:33

the official religion but the preferred

20:35

religion to Theodosius that it becomes

20:38

the official religion, Christianity

20:40

is still the preferred religion and

20:43

then you have that oddball time period

20:45

with Julian the apostate and that doesn't

20:47

really take off. I

20:50

think Christianity would have stayed around

20:52

for sure and I think that

20:54

it probably would have been the

20:57

preferred religion because most of the

20:59

emperors were Christian and Christianity had

21:01

really sunk such deep roots especially

21:03

in the east. It

21:06

might have been a different situation in the

21:08

west though. Maybe

21:10

you do have a situation where the

21:12

people probably Sol Invictus would have risen

21:15

to the top. That's

21:17

true. And you have a situation you could

21:19

be a Sol Invictus person, you could be

21:21

a Christian and maybe they syncretize together or

21:24

maybe they have the battles between each other.

21:26

And actually just

21:28

speaking of the west, I wonder what

21:30

would have happened then with the barbarian

21:32

invasion. Now Steve,

21:35

I just know you're going

21:37

to talk about Arianism. What

21:39

exactly is Arianism? It's

21:41

funny you should ask. That's

21:46

the brand name you might

21:49

say for a position that

21:51

was called more properly. It's

21:54

called Subordinationism. It's A

21:56

Christological discussion of where

21:58

does Jesus. That said,

22:00

Air Net, The Trinity. But.

22:03

Areas would say that or

22:06

the subordination as fits that

22:08

Jesus is not God is.

22:11

Now. There's a spectrum, as Jesus

22:13

does very best human being that's

22:15

ever been. Sort of the an

22:18

archetype, all human being. a perfect

22:20

human beings. These.

22:22

Are ideas that go back all the

22:24

way to the very beginning of the

22:26

Christian Movement. Is

22:28

Jesus a perfect human being? Sort of

22:31

almost where the Jewish view you might

22:33

say. All. The weight to that

22:35

he was just a manifestation of God

22:38

the with the subordination of would say

22:40

yes Jesus was actual person who lived

22:42

in time and. He

22:45

sees something less than God

22:47

the Father. And

22:49

there's offshoots to about where the Holy

22:52

Spirit sets and their that beds. Basically

22:54

God the Father Jesus A Holy Spirit.

22:56

But they would say is that that

22:59

you can go down a real philosophical

23:01

and theological rabbit hole up how Jesus

23:03

emanates from. Matt Got a God the

23:06

Father and all that stuff. Some.

23:09

People say that for example, the

23:11

Gospel of John has area and

23:13

elements to weds or subordination as

23:15

talmud. Were. How it

23:17

gets said in an area that is

23:20

that there was a breeze. Ah of

23:22

Alexandria. His name is Harry. Yes, And.

23:25

He was sort of a spokesman

23:28

for arianism. He wrote hims that

23:30

sailors would pick up. From.

23:33

What I've read it's is that

23:35

they were almost like Rome and

23:37

sea shanties. know add sailors with

23:39

sing man. A

23:41

Interestingly enough for a lot of

23:43

vivid the Goths but Visigoths and

23:45

the ask for God's work Christian

23:47

already they were area ends before

23:50

they had conquered Rome. I thought

23:52

I did know that really? They.

23:55

Had been converted at what

23:57

they lived in north of

23:59

the Danube and again modern

24:01

day Bulgaria region and. A

24:04

lot of them had been

24:07

converted to area in christianity

24:09

through the Byzantine empire. But.

24:12

It was sort of a soft peronism you

24:14

might say. Oh, Jesus

24:16

was something more than meets you

24:18

men by less than Deborah hi

24:21

Im it says split be a

24:23

logical hair Hers even more. So.

24:26

I wonder favorite com and and

24:28

maybe had an easier time and

24:30

converting people in the west to

24:32

area in his home as opposed

24:34

to and promo or while it

24:36

when be proud orthodoxy at a

24:38

be at orthodoxy at that point.

24:42

Maybe. It would have been easier

24:44

for them to have converted where

24:46

the christians already there were and

24:48

this struggle with Saul invictus people

24:50

or whoever as but pay again

24:52

that reprise his to the top.

24:55

And. The ike's may don't

24:58

become Catholic or orthodox.

25:01

They. Become Aerion Them. Now.

25:04

The scenario you're painting. Is

25:07

basically that Roman west stays

25:09

a plurality religions, but it

25:11

it may have been converted

25:13

to christianity by the pup

25:15

areas. That. Be an

25:17

interesting thing to to see. She's.

25:20

Wouldn't be that's a weird seem to think about

25:23

that that it could have happened in reverse. That.

25:26

Uses that: Stretching that timeline out a

25:28

little bit more. I think that's true.

25:30

counterfactual historians who had been that give

25:33

us a slap on the rest on

25:35

this one. Think.

25:37

About the vandals took over North Africa

25:39

neighbor A little bit more serious about

25:42

their area in as I'm a fan

25:44

that the Visigoths who had settled in

25:46

Spain. And. That

25:48

the Visigoths when not armies

25:50

of Islam came through with

25:53

a lot of the at

25:55

Vandal aristocracy converted to Islam

25:57

at because of their version

25:59

of treaty. That he wasn't too far

26:01

or at least that's one theory net as

26:03

that they are version of in of area

26:05

in as unless it was at least compatible

26:07

with his alarm. So. Why

26:10

not join the winning team? basically?

26:13

If. You look at the way of

26:15

Islam spread in Spain, Spain or has

26:17

spawn at that time, it's still had

26:20

a lot of hold outs of area

26:22

isn't Even though the Visigoths had adopted

26:24

an orthodox Catholics christianity. But.

26:27

Then of a lot of

26:29

of with islam is they

26:31

would absorb the aristocratic class.

26:34

And then you bring the people

26:36

along. We talked about bad in

26:38

our previous speculations episodes where people

26:40

converting to their a religion off

26:42

and time wasn't a personal decision

26:44

at was effort potter from nearly

26:46

as made the decision to convert

26:48

than that the whole family and

26:50

family and that had a much

26:52

broader sense of slaves and lie

26:54

and send people out down the

26:56

line and. But. In

26:59

Egypt and then when you they.insists

27:01

started to get into Northern Spain

27:03

and then Southern France. Those.

27:05

Two places were much more tryna

27:08

terrier mix southern France, northern Spain

27:10

so that their conviction and held

27:12

them against the muslims. and if

27:15

you look that's kind of word

27:17

the spread of Islam stop. And.

27:20

Then pockets of the Middle East where

27:22

Christianity stuck around for much longer than

27:25

you think it which should ever stick

27:27

around as because they were much more

27:29

tryna terry an end their convictions didn't

27:32

allow them. To. Convert to

27:34

Islam. Is. So

27:36

with the Islam I think that that

27:38

could have been and out com at

27:41

least in the west of Christianity not

27:43

becoming the state religion. I think in

27:45

the east Christianity probably would have become

27:47

the state religion by default. Just.

27:50

Through inertia christianity I think what have

27:52

become the state religion in the eastern

27:54

part of the empire just because it

27:56

was so much more christina. I.

27:59

think in the way I think you could have really seen

28:01

a plurality of religion

28:03

and then maybe Islam taking

28:06

over a lot more of

28:08

Western Europe than it did.

28:11

True, but that is a fascinating speculation.

28:15

Okay, Steve, that wraps up our speculations.

28:19

Thanks for joining me. Oh,

28:21

thank you, Gary. It's been a blast to

28:24

talk about these things. It's rare you get

28:26

to just go off on a speculation. And

28:30

you don't need any academic credentials to do it.

28:33

No, we're all speculators. We all have

28:35

the ability and the right, dare say.

28:38

God given rights too. Speculates.

28:42

After nine years, that's the end of my show. We've

28:45

got a wrap-up party to go to. Our

28:48

Uber's arrived. Woo-hoo!

28:50

Let's party. the

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features