Podchaser Logo
Home
The City Bank Axe Murders – Part One

The City Bank Axe Murders – Part One

Released Wednesday, 24th January 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
The City Bank Axe Murders – Part One

The City Bank Axe Murders – Part One

The City Bank Axe Murders – Part One

The City Bank Axe Murders – Part One

Wednesday, 24th January 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

Tired. Of ads barging into your favorite

0:02

news broadcasts. Good. News ad

0:04

free listening on Amazon. Music is

0:06

included with your prime membership. Just.

0:09

Had the amazon.com/ad Free news podcast

0:11

to catch up on the latest

0:13

episodes. Without. The ads. And.

0:15

Without into a guy shows every suffers some shows me how that.

0:20

This podcast is proudly sponsored by

0:22

ancestry.com Toda You! from birth, death

0:24

and marriage indexes to military records,

0:26

passenger list and Police gazette. ancestry.com

0:29

Dot A You helps may find

0:31

a lot of the personal details

0:33

that bring to life the people

0:35

you hear about in each episode

0:37

of Forgotten Australia. And by joining

0:39

these genealogical dots you could bring

0:41

your family history alive to. For

0:43

more information go to Ancestry Dot

0:46

Com Dot A You because they

0:48

could be more to your story.

0:51

Forgotten. Australia is written and produced by

0:53

me Michael Adams in the Blue Mountains of

0:56

New South Wales on land traditionally on by

0:58

the dog and gun and got People. I.

1:00

Pay my respects to aboriginal elders

1:03

past and present. This.

1:05

Podcast episode contains descriptions of

1:07

murder and violence. Mister Discretion

1:10

is advised. It

1:15

Saturday the third of December, eighteen,

1:17

Ninety Two and at the Exhibition

1:19

Building in Prince Alford Park in

1:21

Sydney, a doc prediction of death

1:23

and disaster is about to be

1:25

made. Not.

1:27

That you'd project such a prediction at

1:29

this time and place. That's.

1:32

Because it to sunny seen of fun and

1:34

color. This. Is the opening

1:36

day of the German Fair which

1:38

celebrates the Teutonic people and culture.

1:41

The. Gathered crowds a Loving the

1:43

Brass bands, The Merry Go Round,

1:46

The Punch and Judy Pantomime, The

1:48

Shooting Gallery, and others Sideshow entertainment's.

1:51

But the most striking attractions are

1:53

the fourteen stores inside the exhibition

1:56

building. Each. Of these bears

1:58

the name of a German city. Dealing

2:00

with it's heraldry of might, eagle

2:03

and ferocious black bear impresses upon

2:05

everyone's the power and glory as

2:07

a unified German reich. With.

2:10

Christmas just a few weeks away.

2:12

Frankfurt offers a grand display of

2:14

German gingerbread in the shape of

2:16

St. Nicholas. Dresden.

2:18

Off as a splendid array of

2:20

dolls, Baden showcases charming traditional toys

2:22

and say go as clem around

2:24

Cologne to try their luck on

2:27

the spinning prize. We'll. Each

2:30

of these doors attended by local

2:32

women dressed in colorful peasant costumes.

2:35

Among them is a tall, slender

2:37

and raven haired beauty in her

2:39

mid twenties. Well known

2:41

in Sydney society, she has great

2:43

talent as a pianist and as

2:46

a musical composer. Goodness.

2:48

Even her name brings to mind

2:50

grace, beauty and harmony. May

2:53

some a bell. And

2:55

today on this bill of a summer's

2:57

day miss any May Somerville to give

3:00

her full name and title is hard

3:02

to miss. Just. As you will

3:04

be over the next few days of the fair.

3:07

That's because my isn't wearing

3:09

traditional German garb. Instead, she's

3:11

presenting herself as a Romani

3:14

soothsayer. Turbans, silver trinkets,

3:16

crystal ball, that sort of thing.

3:18

Crossover palm with a penny and

3:21

may will read your palm. divine.

3:23

The lines forecast your fortunes. It's

3:25

all a bit of fun and

3:27

to raise funds for German charities.

3:31

But. During the fare. As the

3:33

story will soon appear in the newspapers, My.

3:35

Summer Bills prognostications take a

3:38

decidedly seems to turn. This.

3:42

Happens when she has a customer

3:44

named the T Shirt Francis Cavanaugh.

3:47

Funny. As she's known is also

3:49

in her mid twenties and she lives

3:51

locally and sorry hills. When.

3:53

May takes Fannies hand may

3:55

tell so that she sees

3:58

sudden and early days. Funny

4:02

is absolutely and

4:04

understandably horrified. Realizing

4:08

what she's done made a

4:10

soothsayer tries to suits fanny

4:12

look she says holding out

4:14

her own hand my palms

4:16

lines i just like yours.

4:19

The. Lines also off us. Disastrous

4:21

indications for me. This

4:23

strange intense encounter does have

4:25

a witness to be described

4:28

in the newspapers as a

4:30

well known lady journalist. This

4:32

respected right a child's both

4:34

funny and my for indulging

4:37

in such fortunetelling foolishness. Seeing

4:40

funny is still ruffled. The woman

4:42

journalist reassures who this way. If

4:45

any, hand lines are like maze,

4:48

Stingy has absolutely nothing to worry

4:50

about. That's because my

4:52

summer both leaves a charmed life.

4:55

The lady journalists is my is so

4:57

lucky she draw a squatter out of

5:00

the lottery. What? She means bodies

5:02

is that nice? A sort of girl

5:04

who could fluke the ultimate prize for

5:06

a woman of her class and her

5:09

time that is a rich young husband.

5:11

It's true, Made. Does leave

5:14

a fortunate laws. A student of

5:16

the renowned musical teacher Madame Telamon,

5:18

my has already published a hit

5:21

song. And as things will

5:23

turn out, within a few months, she

5:25

will be engaged to the son of

5:27

a wealthy pastoralist. Beautiful.

5:29

Talented lucky in love My some

5:32

A Bill has it all. Maybe

5:35

even a touch of the second

5:37

size. That's. Because with

5:40

a made in Salinas or

5:42

in seriousness maze palmistry prediction

5:44

is right. Dead.

5:46

right? Sudden

5:49

and early days. Does loon

5:51

says any? Kevin are. Yet

5:53

that very same sudden the and

5:55

early days is also to shut

5:57

us may some of those seemingly.

6:00

The Live. While.

6:02

These strangers now united only

6:04

by the strange incidents at

6:06

the Germans they enlist. In

6:09

a year these sites will

6:11

be again intertwined. Intertwined,

6:13

In a bloody catastrophes and acted with

6:16

a swinging acts in a dark and

6:18

branch of the City Bank of Sydney.

6:22

Or Michael Adams and this is

6:24

part one of the Forgotten Stride

6:26

episodes The City Bank Acts Murders.

6:29

Part. To will be released soon but

6:31

you can hear the story turns out

6:33

right now if you are Patriot on

6:35

or Apple supporter. Being. Supported

6:38

cost as little as a cup of coffee

6:40

a month. And it gives you

6:42

early ad free access to all episodes

6:44

and you'll also get a show shout

6:46

outs and bonus episodes. So.

6:49

A big thank you to Timothy

6:51

Thornton and Bill Saunders has recently

6:53

become patriot supporters. Remember.

6:56

If you've become an Apple, support us

6:58

and you'd like a shoutout. Drop me

7:00

a line at Forgotten Australia Podcast at

7:02

G mile.com. You. Can also use

7:04

that email address to send me a

7:07

question for the upcoming David Hunt Book

7:09

Club episode. So. If you'd

7:11

like to know something about David

7:13

Hands research and writing process or

7:15

his good trilogy, send a Christian

7:18

to that email address or record

7:20

your question as a voice message

7:22

via Speak pot.com Forward/forgotten Australia. Apple.

7:25

Patriot and Speak Pot links are

7:27

also in you show. Notes: Although

7:32

it happened nearly a century ago

7:34

before most people now living were

7:36

born, we nevertheless have a strong

7:38

cultural memory of the Great Depression

7:40

of the Nineteen thirties. Our

7:43

parents, grandparents, or great grandparents

7:45

might have even told us

7:47

about their experiences. at

7:49

the very least it's a world

7:51

with familiar with from novels like

7:53

kati tenants the battle is from

7:56

haunting photographs and newsreel footage and

7:58

from subsequent movies and television show

8:00

that depicted the hardships. But

8:03

an earlier disaster in Australian

8:05

and global economic history is

8:07

barely known. This is the

8:09

depression of the early 1890s. In

8:13

the preceding decade, Australia had

8:15

experienced a massive property boom

8:17

and this had been fueled

8:19

by wild speculation. In

8:22

this period, banks handed out loans

8:24

left, right and center. When

8:26

the property market tanked, there was no

8:28

backup and there were no bailouts. Bankruptcies

8:31

and business failures followed.

8:34

As the economy went into

8:36

freefall, banks closed their doors

8:38

across the colonies and people

8:40

were thrown into poverty and

8:42

into desperation. This was the

8:44

decade before Federation, so

8:46

there was no central government and

8:48

no coordinated economic policy or relief

8:50

measures. How bad was

8:53

it? My friend Dr.

8:55

Peter Dokkity, who was taught economics at

8:57

the University of Technology in Sydney for

8:59

more than 20 years, assures me that

9:01

the depression of the 1890s

9:04

was actually far worse than the Great

9:06

Depression of 40 years later. It's

9:09

mostly forgotten now because of how long ago

9:11

it took place. Everyone who

9:13

experienced it has long since died.

9:15

Also, the depression of

9:17

the early 1890s wrought

9:19

its destruction before there was a

9:21

popular culture to enshrine it in

9:24

moving pictures, recorded stories and songs

9:26

and locally published popular novels. Despite

9:29

its obscurity for us, its effects

9:31

were very real for many Australians,

9:34

including those we're going to hear about

9:36

in this episode. In

9:40

1893, John Phillips, known as

9:42

Jack, was a valued veteran

9:44

officer of the Citibank of

9:46

Sydney. He was 33

9:48

years old and he'd worked for this

9:50

institution for half of his life. The

9:53

Citibank of Sydney had been founded in 1863 and it had

9:56

gone from strength to strength. When

10:00

economic storm of the Eighty Ninety

10:02

smashed many of it's competitors, Citibank

10:05

was sound and sturdy enough to

10:07

keep it's branches opens and it's

10:09

workforce employed. Jack. Phillips

10:11

had a job when many men did not.

10:14

But what seemed like good fortune

10:16

was anything but. According

10:21

to records it ancestry.com.a youth. Jack

10:23

Phillips was born in July eighteen,

10:26

sixteen km Us on the New

10:28

South Wales South Coast. He

10:30

was the first child born to Thomas

10:32

and Christina Philips. Despite. Being

10:34

an ordinary Irish immigrant farmer who

10:37

lived in a quiet part of

10:39

the country, Thomas Phillips was destined

10:41

to feature twice in Colonial newspapers.

10:43

The. First time, as in January eighteen, sixty

10:46

one when he son Jack was just

10:48

six months old. Thomas.

10:50

Was cold to sit on the jury at

10:52

the inquest into the murder of a ten

10:54

week old baby. This tiny

10:56

victim had been shot to pieces with a

10:58

reaping hook by her deranged on he. The

11:02

grisly remains were on display during

11:04

the inquest at a local hotel

11:06

as the grieving mother testified about

11:08

how his sister had slaughtered the

11:11

charge and declared. I'm the

11:13

butcher. It was

11:15

the stuff of nightmares, and it had

11:17

to be incredibly disturbing for all the

11:19

jurors. But especially so Sir Thomas Phillips

11:22

as a new father. We.

11:24

Don't know if he later told his

11:27

son Jack about his experiences on that

11:29

jury. Perhaps Thomas kept it

11:31

from him to spare the boys feelings?

11:34

But the next time Thomas Phillips name

11:36

was in the newspapers, Jax would know

11:38

all about it because he'd also been

11:40

central to the tragic event in question.

11:44

On. The first Monday of January Eighteen

11:46

seventy five. Thomas in Jack went

11:48

fishing. By. The in jack

11:50

was fourteen. he'd grown

11:52

into a fine young lad known for

11:55

his good conduct modest character and his

11:57

attention to his school and domestic duties

12:01

Around 10 in the morning, Thomas and

12:03

Jack were at Bombo Point, a mile

12:05

and a half north of Cuyama. Here,

12:08

farmland ended in bluffs above the

12:10

dark sea. Father

12:12

and son settled on a spot that wasn't

12:14

too high up, just four or five feet

12:17

above the waves. They were

12:19

swinging their lead-weighted lines around their heads

12:21

to send their baited hooks far out

12:23

from shore. Jack would

12:25

say he believed that as his dad

12:28

was doing this, he'd miscalculated and smack,

12:30

his heavy sinker had struck him hard

12:32

in the skull. The

12:35

impact was enough that Thomas overbalanced and

12:37

fell from the little cliff. Jack

12:40

grabbed for his dad, but his fingers

12:42

closed only around his father's hat. Thomas

12:45

Phillips plunged into the dark waters below, and

12:48

he didn't resurface. Young

12:50

Jack was frantic, but he didn't jump in.

12:53

Instead, he ran and he raised the

12:55

alarm. The district's police,

12:58

sailors and local farmers all sprang

13:00

into action. But despite

13:02

their best efforts, which included dragging

13:04

the waters, no trace of Thomas

13:07

was ever found. An

13:09

Associated Press reporter helpfully explained,

13:12

quote, the place abounds

13:14

with sharks. This

13:16

tragedy made news all across the

13:18

colonies. Young

13:21

Jack was haunted by his father's death,

13:23

and no doubt he replayed those

13:26

terrible moments over and over. If

13:29

he'd acted a split second sooner, could he have

13:31

gotten a hold of his father and saved him?

13:34

If he'd been bolder, could he have dived

13:36

into the water and rescued his dad? Of

13:39

course, weighing against these what-ifs

13:41

were sombre realities. It's

13:44

likely Thomas had been stunned or knocked

13:46

out by the self-inflicted blow. He

13:48

may have hit his head on a rock when he hit the

13:50

water. So Jack's dad may

13:52

have been unconscious or even dead when

13:54

he disappeared beneath the waves. It'd

13:57

certainly explain why he didn't resurface

14:00

try to save himself. If

14:02

Jack had been able to get into the water, his

14:05

father may have already been dead. At

14:07

the very least he would have been dead weight. If

14:10

Jack had been able to grab him, there was

14:13

no way back up the bluff and the waves

14:15

were treacherous. So, had Jack

14:17

dived in, he likely would have been

14:19

dashed against the rocks and also ended

14:21

up as shark food. Survivors

14:24

guilt was to be expected, but

14:26

Jack might have been suffering more than that.

14:29

Months later, a man who'd known him at

14:31

this time would tell a story to the

14:33

barrier miner at Broken Hill. And

14:35

what he said was reported this way, quote,

14:38

It was believed that the lad, in twirling

14:41

a line around his head, preparatory to casting

14:43

it into the sea, struck his father on

14:45

the skull with the lead and sinker. He

14:47

made a grab at his father as the

14:50

latter was falling and caught his hat. The

14:53

fatality had a great effect on the lad. Had

14:56

Jack accidentally killed his own father.

14:59

Whatever had happened at Bombo Point, Jack had

15:01

to live with it. But

15:04

it would seem he never fully got over

15:06

the tragedy. Jack would

15:08

be described as having grown into a timid

15:10

man who had a bad case of the

15:12

nerves. So what would

15:14

he do if he ever faced another

15:16

split second life or death moment? Especially

15:19

one that involved himself and the protection of

15:22

a family member. Sadly, in

15:24

this case, time was to tell.

15:28

But before it did, Bombo Point,

15:31

site of the tragedy, would transform

15:33

the fortunes and landscapes of both

15:35

Caima and Sydney. Bombo

15:38

Point was soon quarried for its basalt

15:40

and blue metal. These

15:42

materials shipped to Sydney and used

15:44

respectively in the construction of the

15:46

city's steam tramways and its roadways.

15:50

As a result, Caima's economy

15:52

boomed. In those good

15:54

times, people needed banks they could trust.

15:57

And banks needed trustworthy young men. Jack

16:00

Phillips. Jack

16:03

started working at the Citibank of Sydney's Cuyama

16:05

branch in June of 1877. He

16:09

was then a month shy of his 17th

16:11

birthday. Jack lived a

16:13

quiet life as a civic-minded teetotaler.

16:17

After nearly five years at the

16:19

Cuyama branch, Jack's qualities and talents

16:21

saw him promoted to the Citibank's

16:23

headquarters in Sydney. In

16:26

January 1882, Jack was farewelled at

16:28

a Cuyama dinner attended by three

16:30

dozen friends and colleagues. There

16:33

were plenty of speeches and toasts that

16:35

praised the young man's personal and professional

16:37

qualities. The manager of

16:39

the Citibank's Cuyama branch said that

16:41

he'd never worked with a fellow officer

16:44

of such an amiable and agreeable disposition

16:46

as Jack Phillips. Reading

16:49

between the lines of that speech, which

16:51

was reported in detail in the local

16:53

newspapers, was to get the impression that

16:55

Jack was a chap who'd go along

16:57

to get along. This

16:59

idea was reinforced when Justice of the

17:02

Peace, Mr James Collie, got up to

17:04

speak. Telling the gathering

17:06

that he'd known Jack since he was a boy, Mr

17:09

Collie said he'd like to offer the lad

17:11

just one word of advice. And

17:13

that word was no. Jack,

17:16

Mr Collie said, had to learn how

17:18

to say no. He

17:21

had to know when to say no

17:23

emphatically and learning to do so required

17:26

courage and manliness. Mr

17:28

Collie seemed to recognise that this

17:30

young man, for all of his

17:32

great qualities, lacked the ability to

17:34

stand up for himself. At

17:37

the Sydney head office, Jack Phillips

17:39

got more responsibility. He

17:41

worked as an assistant to the Citibank's secretary

17:44

and for a time he had charge of

17:46

the shareholders list. Jack

17:48

was then transferred to the Oxford Street

17:50

branch in Paddington, where he worked as

17:52

an accountant. During the

17:55

mid to late 1880s, Jack was

17:57

briefly posted out to the country

17:59

to car-call. 150

18:01

miles west of Sydney past Bathurst.

18:04

Sheltered in a valley beside the

18:07

Birbling Bella Bueller River, Karkor had

18:09

first been colonised by white people

18:11

in 1821 and the

18:13

town had briefly boomed during the Gold Rush of the

18:16

1850s. Since then

18:18

Karkor had settled into a placid place

18:20

that was as pretty as a picture.

18:24

Around this time the Sydney Mail would

18:26

describe it this way, quote, Karkor

18:29

is a pleasant little town lying at

18:31

the foot of the hills in the

18:33

Western District and has ever been regarded

18:35

as one of the most comfortable settlements

18:38

in a particularly fortunate district. There is

18:40

a great abundance of cultivation and there

18:42

are several well-to-do pastoralists in the vicinity

18:44

of the town which has always enjoyed

18:46

the reputation as being one of the

18:49

quietest and most law-abiding in the colony.

18:52

While it was quiet and peaceful Karkor

18:54

did have at least one lawless claim

18:57

to fame. This event

18:59

which had involved brave bank employees

19:01

had made Australian criminal history. In

19:03

1863 bold Bush Ranger

19:07

Ben Hall and his gang had been operating

19:09

in the area. In

19:11

July of that year two of

19:13

these outlaws John Gilbert and John

19:15

O'Meally stuck up the Karkor branch

19:17

of the commercial bank. This

19:19

was the first attempt at a daylight

19:21

bank robbery in the Australian colonies but

19:23

it didn't go well for the bad

19:25

guys. The bank's plucky

19:27

manager and a brave teller refused

19:30

to play along and thwarted the

19:32

gun-toting robbers who were forced to

19:34

beat a hasty empty-handed retreat. Jack

19:38

Phillips's temporary Karkor posting was

19:40

far less exciting. He

19:43

was there as an accountant. The

19:45

days of the Bush Rangers were long

19:47

gone. Karkor had earned its placid reputation

19:49

and Jack took a shine to the

19:52

little town. Yet his

19:54

Citibank superiors soon shuffled him

19:56

back to Sydney. It

19:58

was there in August 18. The Ninety Seven

20:01

that Jack married twenty three year

20:03

old any stoddart. Any

20:05

had older siblings, but she was

20:07

closest to her younger sister, Susan,

20:09

and about seventeen. Any

20:12

and Susan were also very close

20:14

to signing Cavanaugh then around eighteen.

20:17

Thirties mother had been childhood friends with

20:19

their mother says goes had all grown

20:22

up together. Jack.

20:24

In any. had their first child

20:27

in May I say ninety one,

20:29

a baby daughter they named Gladys.

20:31

Around this time, Jack was posted

20:33

to curb ah ago so the young

20:36

family packed up for that south coast

20:38

town. After sitting there

20:40

for about a year, Jack was nixed

20:42

given a choice of positions. The.

20:45

And any in the baby's could return

20:47

to Sydney with to take up a

20:49

role as the caso y straight branch.

20:51

Or. He could go back to

20:53

car. Cool way he'd take over as

20:55

branch manager. Jeff. Chose to

20:58

go to car pool. Is

21:00

or perhaps to be a big feast in a

21:02

small pond? Managerial. Experience even

21:04

if it was in a backwater like

21:06

car. Cool was an important run on

21:08

the career ladder. But. Other

21:11

sectors would have played into his decision. He

21:14

knew cock whole, He knew it was a

21:16

nice little place and he liked the people.

21:18

He. Was also making his decision in

21:21

I say Ninety Two when the

21:23

banking crisis and economic collapse was

21:25

causing a lot of misery. Particularly

21:28

in the cities around the colonies.

21:31

So. Why not write out the

21:33

tough times in a pretty little village

21:35

when nothing much happened? And.

21:37

As a bonus, the car cool

21:39

posting included use of the fine

21:41

managerial residents that was attached to

21:44

the City Bank building Their. John.

21:47

And any move to the town around

21:49

September. Eighteen Ninety Two. she

21:51

soon so pregnant again and this second

21:53

child daughter dorothy would be born in

21:56

the middle of the next year Tired

22:02

of ads barging into your favorite news

22:04

podcasts? Good news. Ad-free

22:07

listening on Amazon Music is included with

22:09

your Prime membership. Just head

22:11

to amazon.com/ad-free news podcast to catch

22:14

up on the latest episodes without

22:16

the ads. Some shows may have

22:18

ads. The

22:23

Citibank building was an attractive brick

22:25

edifice built into the slope on

22:27

the western side of Bella Bueller

22:30

Street, Carcours, Main Thoroughfare. The

22:32

bank's offices occupied one side of the

22:34

ground floor. The other part

22:37

was given over to the private residents. A

22:39

hallway entrance led into a dining

22:41

room and upstairs to the first

22:44

floor bedrooms. The rear

22:46

downstairs section of the building held the

22:48

kitchen and quarters for the servant girl

22:50

Agnes McVicar, who was to help Annie

22:52

with the children and the domestic chores.

22:56

Jack and Annie's closest neighbor lived next

22:58

door. This was Joseph

23:00

Derwin, the Citibank's accountant and

23:02

thus Jack's right-hand man. Behind

23:06

Jack and Annie lived Reverend Mr. Clark,

23:08

who kept his horses in a stable

23:10

adjoining their backyard. Everything

23:13

in Carcours was merely a stone's throw from

23:15

Jack and Annie's front door. A

23:18

minute up the hill and they'd be at

23:20

St Paul's Anglican Church with its tower and

23:22

steeple. A hop skip and

23:25

a jump down Bella Bueller Street and they'd

23:27

be at the Post and Telegraph Office, the

23:29

Royal Hotel or the fine terraces of the

23:31

Great Western Warehouse. On

23:34

the corner, opposite the river, where

23:36

the Main Street met Isley Street,

23:38

stood Carcours' most impressive building, the

23:40

courthouse. This Italianate

23:43

beauty, complete with clock tower, was

23:45

the work of colonial architect James

23:47

Barnett, who'd also designed many of

23:49

Sydney's most impressive buildings. Outside

23:52

the courthouse was Carcours Police Station

23:54

and its lock-up. Carcours

23:58

was a fine town and 33

24:00

year old Jack Phillips was a fine man

24:02

about town. He was important

24:05

because he handled many of the town's banking

24:07

services. People relied on him.

24:10

But Jack's job also made him the

24:12

bearer of bad news during these times

24:14

of economic trouble. He

24:16

was the man who had to chase debts and

24:18

had to foreclose on assets if they couldn't be

24:21

paid. This of course could

24:23

lead to disappointment and disgruntledment.

24:26

But Jack Phillips was just doing his job.

24:29

Most folks recognised this and he was

24:31

popular. Jack was regarded

24:33

as civic minded and as a pillar of

24:35

the community. Thus, Jack was

24:38

elected as Treasurer of the Car

24:40

Corps Hospital and as Treasurer of

24:42

the town's Agricultural, Horticultural and Pastoral

24:45

Association. But then, only

24:48

a year after that arrived and

24:50

settled in, Jack's Citibank bosses did

24:52

another management reshuffle. This

24:54

one was a bit like musical chairs. See,

24:57

the manager's job over at Bathurst

25:00

had become vacant. So it

25:02

was to be filled by the manager from

25:04

Caima. The Caima job would

25:06

then be taken by the present manager from

25:08

Young. This was where Jack

25:10

came in. He was now to go to

25:12

Young to be the manager there. It

25:15

was a bother to have to relocate yet again.

25:18

But taking the job at Young was another

25:20

step up the seniority ladder. Everything

25:23

was settled. At

25:26

this time, Jack and Annie's little daughter Gladys

25:28

was staying in Sydney with Annie's mum. During

25:31

this holiday, Gladys had spent a lot

25:33

of time with her aunt Susan and

25:35

with Susan's best friend Fanny Cavanaugh. The

25:38

little girl had become particularly close to Fanny.

25:42

Susan and Fanny had planned to bring Gladys back

25:44

to Jack and Annie at their new place in

25:46

Young. Then, a health

25:48

hiccup complicated that game of musical

25:50

chairs even more. See,

25:53

the wife of the outgoing manager at Young had

25:55

taken ill and she'd been told by her doctor

25:57

that she'd need to stay in bed for a

25:59

long time. for a month or so. So

26:02

she'd have to remain in the Citibank

26:04

residence in Young, even though her husband

26:06

was about to take up his new

26:08

position in Kaima. The

26:10

knock-on effect was that Jack would still

26:12

move to Young and take up the

26:15

manager's role, but he'd stay in a

26:17

hotel temporarily. Annie and the children would

26:19

remain in the Karkor Citibank residence until they

26:21

could join him. Incoming

26:23

Karkor branch manager, Mr Healy, would

26:26

then temporarily stay in a Karkor

26:28

hotel. It was

26:30

all a bit of a palava, but

26:33

this was how the Citibank wanted things done. Jack

26:36

was now scheduled to leave for Young on Saturday,

26:38

the 23rd of September 1893.

26:40

Annie had advised

26:43

Susan and Fanny about this change

26:45

of plans. But she, Annie,

26:48

also had an idea. Why

26:50

didn't Susan and Fanny come up to Karkor to

26:53

keep her company? They could bring

26:55

Gladys with them. Then they could all

26:57

go to Young. Susan

26:59

liked the idea. Fanny

27:01

wasn't so keen. Just

27:04

as her recent encounter with May

27:06

Somerville at the German Fair was

27:08

soon to make the newspapers, it

27:10

would also be widely reported that

27:13

Fanny Cavanaugh had had a bad

27:15

feeling, a presentiment, about going to

27:17

Karkor. Yet her father,

27:19

to whom she was exceptionally close, said

27:21

that she should go, that it

27:23

would be good for her. Fanny had

27:25

been hearing such things all of her life.

27:28

As a child, she'd been terribly sick

27:30

with rheumatic fever. Fanny

27:32

had then, and later, been sent to

27:35

the Blue Mountains to take the air

27:37

for her health. Lately,

27:39

Fanny had been unwell again, and

27:42

her doctor agreed with her father. Karkor,

27:44

at nearly two and a half thousand

27:46

feet above sea level, had good air,

27:48

and it would help her get better.

27:51

So Fanny agreed. Susan

27:54

and Fanny planned to get the train west on

27:56

the morning of Saturday 23rd September. This service would

28:00

get them to nearby Blaney around

28:02

about 7 o'clock that night. In

28:05

order to pick them up and to

28:07

see Gladys, Jack Phillips delayed his departure

28:09

for young until Monday morning. Now

28:12

everything really was settled. On

28:15

the Thursday night, the 21st of September,

28:18

Jack's farewell dinner was held at

28:20

Karkor's Victoria Hotel. 40 of the

28:23

town's most prominent citizens gathered to toast

28:25

the man they'd come to regard as

28:27

a friend. The mayor

28:29

chaired the celebration and read from

28:31

a beautifully illuminated and framed address

28:33

that was presented as a goodbye

28:35

gift to Jack. The

28:37

parchment read, quote, Dear

28:39

sir, it is with feelings of regret we

28:42

have heard that your connection with us is

28:44

to be severed by your removal to young.

28:47

Those of us who had business

28:49

transactions with you must acknowledge your

28:51

unvarying courtesy, your willingness to oblige,

28:54

yet at the same time your

28:56

anxiety to advance the interests of

28:59

the institution you represent. During

29:01

your residence here you have by

29:04

your uprightness your genial presence and

29:06

gentlemanly bearing endeared yourself to all

29:08

with whom you came in contact,

29:11

wishing you and Mrs. Phillips

29:13

long life, happiness and prosperity.

29:17

The town's men gave him another parting

29:19

gift, a silver fruit

29:21

stand, and other speakers agreed that

29:23

Karkor was indeed losing one of

29:26

its best and most conscientious citizens.

29:30

A decade earlier, at his

29:32

Kaima farewell, Jack had only been in

29:34

his early 20s and that

29:36

night he delivered what was

29:39

reported to be a halting

29:41

and awkward response. Now years

29:43

and experience had made him a little

29:46

more at ease. In

29:48

his reply Jack said that Karkor's people

29:50

had become his best friends and the

29:52

sadness he felt at leaving them was

29:54

too great to put into words. Gazing

29:57

at the framed address and at the

29:59

silver fruit stand, Jack told them

30:02

that these gifts would become heirlooms

30:04

in his family, and

30:06

that they would always bring him and

30:08

his wife Annie long and sweet remembrances

30:11

of their time in Car Corps. Two

30:15

days later, Saturday, the 23rd of

30:17

September, after weeks of cold and

30:19

wet weather, spring had finally sprung

30:22

and it was beautiful and warm.

30:25

Jack had by then done the handover to

30:27

incoming manager Mr Healy and this included giving

30:29

him the keys to the bank and to

30:32

its safe. But there

30:34

were still things for Jack to finish up that day. This

30:37

included finalising the sale of a

30:39

Car Corps butcher shops assets. It

30:42

was an unpleasant task that had

30:44

been made necessary by the financial

30:46

recklessness of the business's young owner.

30:50

This chap, Bertie Glaussen, was the

30:52

son of a wealthy local family.

30:55

Yet he'd made a mess of his own affairs.

30:58

Jack had tried to get Bertie to pay his debts.

31:01

It had been to no avail. Bertie

31:04

hadn't taken responsibility. In

31:06

fact, he wasn't even around Car Corps

31:08

for the final act of his failure.

31:11

He was instead holed up in Sydney

31:13

at the Hotel Metropole with the young

31:16

woman he'd only recently married, Mae

31:18

Sommerbell, well known for

31:20

her beauty and for her musical talents.

31:24

What no one knew, not even

31:26

Mae, was that Bertie was that

31:28

day headed back to Car Corps.

31:31

He'd gotten the train that morning

31:33

from Redfern Station and was seated

31:35

in the same carriage as Susan

31:38

Stodart, Fanny Cavanaugh and little Gladys

31:40

Phillips. Just

31:43

after 7 o'clock that night the steam

31:45

locomotive chugged into Blaney Station, which was

31:47

10 miles or so north-east of Car

31:49

Corps. Jack had

31:51

come with the Reverend Mr Clark in the

31:54

Preacher's two horse carriage to pick up Susan,

31:56

Fanny and Gladys. They were

31:58

back at the Citibank residence in Car Corps. by

32:00

around 10 that night. The

32:02

Reverend said his goodnight and went back to

32:05

his place to stable his horses. Jack,

32:08

Annie, Susan Fanny and next-door

32:10

neighbor accountant Joseph Durwin enjoyed

32:12

a late supper. It was

32:15

a happy affair and even little

32:17

Gladys was allowed to stay up

32:19

past her usual bedtime. It had

32:21

been a long day for everyone. At

32:24

11.30 Fanny said goodnight. She

32:27

retired to the upstairs children's bedroom

32:29

taking Gladys with her. Mr.

32:32

Durwin said his goodbyes next. John,

32:35

Annie and Susan all went upstairs around quarter

32:37

to 12. Husband

32:40

and wife went to their bedroom with

32:42

baby Dorothy. Susan went

32:44

to join Fanny and Gladys.

32:46

Baby Dorothy was restless and this

32:48

kept John and Annie awake for a

32:51

while. Finally the little

32:53

one settled. The Citibank

32:55

building was quiet and dark.

33:00

Outside the moon was nearly

33:02

full and shining bright directly

33:04

overhead. At

33:10

around 2 in the morning Annie Phillips woke

33:13

up. She could hear sounds,

33:16

noises in the house, like

33:18

someone climbing the stairs from the basement to

33:20

the ground floor. Through

33:22

the open bedroom door she could see candle

33:24

glow. Someone was moving around

33:27

below in the dining room. Jack

33:29

she said, wake up. He

33:32

did. Jack heard and

33:34

saw what Annie did. He

33:36

grabbed the revolver that the bank had issued

33:38

to him. While it had

33:41

been 30 years since Ben Hall

33:43

had roamed these parts, Jack's Citibank

33:45

bosses still wanted their car core

33:47

manager to be able to protect

33:49

himself, his family and their cash.

33:52

The revolver was loaded. Five

33:55

bullets in five chambers. Jack

33:57

and Annie got out of bed. Husband

34:00

and wife went down the stairs together. He

34:03

with the revolver extended, she

34:05

gripping his arm. They

34:07

went into the dining room, where a candle

34:09

was burning. Annie picked it

34:12

up. That's when she saw the man,

34:14

standing behind one of the dining room doors,

34:17

his face covered with a black mask.

34:20

He was holding an axe. Annie

34:22

Billie had time to register the menace before

34:24

the masked man blurred into motion. She

34:27

knocked the candle from her hand and as

34:29

it sputtered against the floor, he swung the

34:31

axe, the blade hitting Jack. Jack

34:33

went down, dragging Annie to the floor

34:35

with him. She scrambled away.

34:38

Jack and the burglar fought in the shadows. Annie

34:41

screamed at her husband, why don't you

34:44

use the revolver? Give me the pistol.

34:46

If you can't shoot him, I will. Annie

34:49

attacked the man. He threw her off, but

34:51

not before she pulled off his mask. Annie

34:54

staggered away into the hall and screamed up

34:56

the stairs to Susan and Fanny. My

34:59

baby, she said. Murder. Someone's

35:01

killing Jack. Help. Behind

35:03

Annie, she heard a terrible thud thud

35:06

thud. Annie's mind was on

35:08

her children. She had to save them. She

35:10

stumbled up the stairs, in the dark, into

35:12

her bedroom and lit a candle. Dorothy

35:15

was gone. The he, the

35:17

monster, had come in behind her. Annie

35:20

whirled as the man brought his axe down. The

35:23

blade hit her in the face, splitting

35:25

one cheek from her chin to her

35:27

ear. Cutting so deep, it

35:29

sliced her tongue in half. With

35:32

the blade embedded in her face, Annie

35:34

fought her attacker as he struggled to

35:36

prize the axe free so he could

35:38

hit her again. As

35:41

he yanked it from her face, Annie fell

35:43

back just as Susan ran into the bedroom.

35:46

She nearly fainted at the sight of her sister

35:48

and the axe-wielding fiend who was ready

35:51

to strike again. Susan

35:53

said no. Stop. Please. Don't

35:55

you have a wife and children? Spare

35:57

us. Money, the man demanded.

36:00

I must have money, I must have money."

36:04

And he managed to say that she'd do whatever

36:06

he wanted. But first she had

36:08

to know. My Jack, is

36:11

he dead? No, the ax

36:13

man said. He's just stunned.

36:15

He'll be alright. The

36:17

man demanded the keys to the bank safe. And

36:20

he told him that whatever keys Jack had were

36:23

in his trousers and they were hanging up. The

36:26

man went to the pants and helped himself to

36:28

the keys and to a small amount of cash.

36:31

He went downstairs, leaving the terrified

36:33

women. Where were the

36:35

children? When Susan

36:37

had heard the sounds of the attack

36:40

and Annie screaming, she'd grabbed baby Dorothy

36:42

and had hidden her in the other

36:44

bedroom. Fanny had snatched up

36:46

close and had run for safety. So

36:48

the little girl should be alright. Servant

36:51

girl Agnes McVicar came into the room.

36:54

She was in shock, but she was unhurt. Everyone

36:58

was alive. That was what mattered.

37:01

The attackers talked back into the bedroom. He

37:03

was furious and he swore at Annie and

37:06

Susan. These are the wrong keys, he

37:08

told them. They're no good for the safe.

37:11

Through her day's state, Annie remembered.

37:14

Jack had given the keys to the safe to his successor,

37:16

Mr Healy. She

37:18

explained this. My husband, she

37:20

said, is to leave for young on Monday morning.

37:22

You don't have the keys for the safe here.

37:25

Where is this Mr Healy? The man demanded. Staying

37:28

in one of the hotels in town, she said.

37:31

Susan chimed in saying she didn't know which

37:33

one. She'd only arrived on the train last

37:36

night. Like the car

37:38

called Bank Raid made by members of Ben

37:40

Hall's gang 30 years ago, all

37:42

of this had been for nothing. The

37:45

axe man said he was going to leave and

37:48

he was going to leave them alive, but

37:50

whether they stayed that way was their choice.

37:53

Don't scream or make any noise, he said. If

37:56

any of you do or if any of you

37:58

leave this room, I'll come back. and

38:00

I'll shoot you." Then he was

38:03

gone in the dark. The terrified

38:05

women cowered. Even

38:08

in Annie's days terrified and bloodied

38:10

state, she was dimly aware of

38:12

something that was as far beyond

38:14

her comprehension as what had just

38:16

happened. When she'd caught

38:18

off the man's mask, she'd recognized

38:20

him. She knew him. It had

38:22

been Bertie Glassen. After

38:25

a few minutes, she mustered the courage

38:27

to call into the darkness. Are

38:30

you gone? There was no

38:32

response. The maniac seemed

38:34

to have left. But

38:36

what he'd left in his wake would

38:38

shock colonial Australia from coast to coast.

38:44

I'm Michael Adams and you've been listening

38:47

to part one of the forgotten Australia

38:49

episode, the Citibank Axe Murders. The second

38:51

and final part will be on general

38:53

release pretty soon, but if you'd like

38:55

to hear it right now, you can

38:57

do so by becoming a patreon or

38:59

Apple supporter. Links are

39:01

in your show notes and you can get

39:03

a free trial which will give you access

39:06

to part two along with access to a

39:08

whole bunch of bonus episodes. If

39:11

you choose not to continue it's easy to cancel

39:13

and you won't pay a cent. As

39:15

always, thanks for listening and thanks for

39:18

supporting. Tired

39:33

of ads crashing your comedy podcast

39:35

party? Good news. Ad-free

39:37

listening on Amazon Music is included with

39:39

your Prime membership. Just head

39:42

to amazon.com/ad-free comedy to catch up

39:44

on the latest episodes without

39:46

the ads. For thousands of ACAT shows ad-free for

39:48

Prime subscribers. Some shows may have ads.

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features