Podchaser Logo
Home
Is there still momentum for Scottish independence?

Is there still momentum for Scottish independence?

Released Wednesday, 19th June 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Is there still momentum for Scottish independence?

Is there still momentum for Scottish independence?

Is there still momentum for Scottish independence?

Is there still momentum for Scottish independence?

Wednesday, 19th June 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

2:01

Ben, not great for the

2:03

Tories, obviously it's one person, but he's

2:05

a big name and has deep pockets.

2:08

Yes, he is big. The number of people who tend to go

2:11

from giving money to the Conservatives to giving

2:13

money to Labour is pretty common. So to

2:15

be honest with you, it's not hard to

2:17

find a number of people with very deep

2:19

pockets saying very loudly, I've

2:21

given money to all sorts. I've given money

2:23

to the Conservatives and Labour and Leave and

2:25

Remain and UKIP and so on and so

2:27

forth. This is just another

2:30

such instance. You know, though, the

2:32

number of defectors among voters

2:34

is not, it doesn't appear quite as

2:36

great as among the super rich, I

2:38

suppose. So you know, when you think about

2:41

the polls moving, the polls changing, votes changing

2:43

hands, so to speak. Really,

2:46

you know, what changes elections is

2:48

people being brought out to vote,

2:51

not necessarily people changing sides. So, you

2:53

know, you look at the Tory base

2:55

now, all of those 2019 Boris Johnson

2:57

backing Conservatives, only about one in 10

2:59

of them are going Labour. And that's

3:02

pretty something. That's what is that? That's

3:05

like a million, a million or two,

3:07

a million or two Tory voters going Labour,

3:09

which in the grand scheme of things isn't a

3:11

lot. What is primarily driving,

3:13

you know, big changes in party

3:15

support is a lot of the

3:17

Tory base staying at home and a

3:20

lot of new people coming back out to bat

3:22

for Labour or, you know, as part of their

3:24

first time vote, coming out to bat for them

3:26

as well. So defectors amongst voters,

3:28

Tory to Labour, Labour to Tory,

3:31

isn't that great? But amongst donors,

3:33

oh, it's endemic, isn't it? It

3:36

could be, but I mean, he's for

3:38

someone who's never voted Labour to be

3:41

a hugely successful businessman and Labour are

3:43

trying to win over voters on the

3:45

economy, traditionally not a strong point for

3:47

Labour. It's a big boost for them

3:50

regardless of, you know, the optics

3:53

look good, don't they? It's a sign

3:55

of the times really. And that time,

3:57

those times, I think were kind of

28:00

I think it's probably going to work. And

28:02

yeah, as Chris was saying, the polls do

28:04

point to the S&P losing a

28:06

lot of seats. The Britain Perdix forecast has,

28:08

I think, Labour on around about 24 seats,

28:10

the S&P on 22. And

28:12

a lot of these races, by the

28:14

way, are coming right down to the

28:16

wire. That tactical voting I talked about,

28:18

that pro-union, that pro-independence tactical voting is

28:20

going to be absolutely key on

28:23

the 4th of July. On

28:25

the more overall polling, we talked about

28:27

reform and how that's holding up. And

28:30

or increasing. Do we

28:32

see generally across both

28:34

the main parties, I mean, the

28:36

Lib Dem's still doing very well. I

28:39

mean, talk about a democratic

28:41

deficit potentially happening come July the

28:43

5th, where you have an enormous

28:46

Labour Party in terms of parliamentary

28:48

majority, but actually not on a

28:50

huge vote share. Are we

28:53

seeing a fall in support for Labour

28:55

as well, but it matters less because

28:57

the Conservatives aren't doing well? We're

29:00

seeing a slight drift. So, reminder of the polls, Labour

29:02

was on 41, 42, 43%. And

29:07

they rose, they started to rise a little bit to

29:09

43% by the end of May. They drifted

29:11

back down to 41, 40, and

29:14

you're seeing some polls again. It's within

29:16

the margin of error. It's noise. Let's

29:19

not get too obsessed with those, having

29:21

them on 30-something, okay? And yes, but

29:23

nevertheless, Britain Elect poll tracker measures all

29:26

the polls is finding a slight drift.

29:29

Two things of this, primarily it is

29:31

because more people are coming on the

29:33

pitch of electors. So here's the football

29:35

analogy that I am completely under qualified

29:37

to talk about. Okay, imagine you've got

29:39

100 people on a pitch and

29:42

Labour's got about 50 of them. That was the polls

29:44

in May. Now there's 120 people on the pitch

29:47

and Labour's still got about 50 of them, okay?

29:50

And you see what I mean there.

29:52

So Labour isn't necessarily shedding any new

29:54

support or any support whatsoever. They

29:57

may actually slightly a little bit, so it might be

29:59

done. to 49, 48. But

30:02

overwhelmingly what is happening is those

30:04

undecided voters, those who came out

30:06

for the Conservatives in 2019, who

30:08

were undecided throughout from the Liz

30:10

Trusbender, from during the Rishi Sunak

30:12

years, years, we're already talking about

30:14

it as if it's past tense

30:16

now, who were undecided then, they

30:18

are now saying, I am going

30:20

to vote, I am going to

30:23

re-engage with the democratic civic process,

30:25

but I'm not going to return to the

30:28

Conservatives as I normally would as

30:30

a supporter of an incumbent party in nine times out

30:32

of ten elections. So they're just returning to the pitch

30:35

of engaged politics and they're coming for

30:37

other parties in some parts of rural

30:40

England, especially in Suffolk, keep an eye

30:42

on Wavenley Valley, that does mean some

30:44

Tories go into the Greens, it definitely

30:47

means going to reform, the wild polls

30:50

for reform, it really is something. You have

30:52

Ugov finding almost three in ten to four

30:54

in ten 2019 Tory voters

30:56

going reform and that compares to about

30:59

one in ten, about a few months ago. If

31:01

that crossover happens, i.e.

31:03

if more Conservative voters think the best party

31:06

of the right, the best party that reflects

31:08

me is reform, not the Conservatives, we could

31:10

see a crossover, a dramatic change

31:12

and to reiterate, Canada 1993 would be the

31:16

closest comparison. Do I think it's likely? No. Do I

31:18

think it's probable? No, I just think it's possible and

31:20

we've got to prepare for it. Canada

31:23

1993, our takeaway for today, thank you

31:25

so much Ben and to those who

31:28

were listening yesterday, news

31:30

in today that sadly Boris Johnson will

31:32

not be returning from holiday to join

31:34

the campaign trail that has been confirmed.

31:36

Thank you so much for listening. If

31:38

you'd like to submit a question for

31:41

us about the election to answer in

31:43

a future podcast, you can do so

31:45

at newstatesman.com/you ask

31:47

us. If you're listening

31:49

on Spotify, just scroll

31:52

down on the episode

31:54

page or if you're watching

31:56

on YouTube, you can leave a question in

31:58

the comments. You've been listening

32:01

to the New Statesman podcast with

32:03

me, Hannah Boulds, and my colleagues,

32:05

Chris Dearing and Ben Walker. We'll

32:08

be back tomorrow. This episode was

32:10

produced by Catherine Hughes. The

32:12

video editor is Rob LeMare. Find

32:24

your perfect fit with a custom suit

32:26

from Indochino. From timeless classics to bold

32:28

statements, you can express your style exactly

32:30

how you want. Get 10% off

32:32

any purchase of $3.99

32:34

or more at indochino.com

32:36

with code PODCAST. This is

32:38

a story about a fugitive who's been on

32:40

the run for more than 30 years. A

32:44

good American is a dead

32:46

American. And the special agent who's

32:48

spent decades trying to bring him to

32:50

justice. If he had hung himself, I wouldn't have

32:52

lost no wink of sleep. It's about

32:55

a man whose crimes appear to

32:57

have simply drifted away. Or

33:00

have they? I'm Chloe Hajimathayu.

33:03

From Tortoise, this is The Gas

33:05

Man. Listen wherever you get your

33:07

podcasts.

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features