0:01

President Joe Biden, maybe

0:03

you missed it. Maybe you missed it. But

0:07

there was a pro

0:09

A B O R

0:11

T rally in

0:14

Florida. And

0:20

during her, a woman's appeal

0:22

about moving the cut

0:27

off from 15 weeks to six weeks. President

0:30

Biden, who claims to be a Catholic,

0:33

who recently said Pope Francis encourages him

0:35

to receive communion every single week, makes

0:38

a blasphemous sign of the cross in the

0:40

name of the father and of the son

0:43

and of the Holy Ghost. I'm

0:45

going to show you that video here

0:47

in just a little bit. And

0:50

I'm also going to do some questions and

0:53

answers today. So

0:56

this really brings us back

0:58

into the debate over

1:01

what does it mean to be a Catholic? What

1:04

does it mean to be a human? And

1:06

can you be fundamentally

1:09

opposed to

1:12

the teachings of the Catholic church

1:17

and still receive

1:20

communion publicly

1:22

in scandal?

1:26

And then this raises the other question of, we

1:28

got Bergoglio and

1:32

he's saying it's all good. All

1:35

right. So we got problems

1:38

in America. We got problems in Rome. And

1:40

that's what today is

1:44

the discussion. So here is the video. I'm going

1:46

to run it for you. And

1:51

here we go. And then we

1:53

come back here to state of Florida where

1:56

Ron DeSantis felt like he needed to run for president.

1:58

And so 15 weeks was. That's not good enough.

2:01

We had to go to six weeks. Okay. So,

2:06

you know, we're on to Santa's 15 weeks. We're

2:08

getting back up to six weeks. So

2:12

we're saving human

2:14

life. We are making a

2:17

pro life gain

2:20

politically in Florida and

2:24

president Joe Biden, who is in favor

2:27

of the a word in

2:30

all trimesters in all weeks. It's

2:32

making this on the cross. Now, maybe this

2:34

is a big maybe maybe Biden

2:37

in that moment had a change of heart. And

2:41

now he's like, thanks be to God for

2:43

Ron DeSantis changing this. This is just

2:45

great. But

2:47

that's not the case because he's actually

2:49

at a rally promoting

2:53

the culture of death. He's

2:55

actually spending his time as the

2:57

president of the United States, promoting

3:00

the culture of death. And

3:04

he is anointing

3:07

falsely. He is

3:09

anointing falsely the

3:12

pro death culture, the

3:14

pro death agenda. And

3:16

he has the

3:19

approbation. He

3:22

has the encouragement from Pope Francis to

3:24

continue to receive communion. I covered this.

3:26

I did a whole show on it

3:29

when it happened. I'm going to read it to you again.

3:33

This goes back to 2021

3:35

in October 2021. This

3:43

is an article reporting on it. I didn't use

3:45

a Catholic source. I wanted to use a secular

3:47

source. There's tons of them, by

3:49

the way. The secular press was so excited

3:51

about this story that Biden

3:53

went to Rome and

3:56

got this approval from Pope Francis. Here's what

3:58

it says. from

4:00

PBS. Biden takes

4:02

pride in his Catholic faith, using

4:04

it as a moral guidepost to shape

4:06

many of his social and economic policies.

4:10

Biden wears a rosary and attends Mass

4:12

Weekly, yet his support for

4:14

abortion rights and same-sex marriage has

4:16

put him at odds with many United

4:18

States bishops, some of whom

4:21

have suggested that he should be denied

4:23

communion. Joe

4:25

Biden said he and Francis did

4:27

not discuss abortion but offered that

4:30

the Pope said he was happy I am

4:32

a good Catholic and I should keep receiving

4:35

communion." And then

4:38

I think it was the next day or the day after

4:41

that Biden did receive communion in

4:43

Rome under the Pope's

4:45

approval, they're just

4:47

verifying and validating what

4:50

Biden said. And again Biden says,

4:53

Francis says, he was happy I'm

4:55

a good Catholic and I

4:57

should keep receiving communion. So

5:00

this is the question really, what

5:03

is communion? Aren't

5:07

we all sinners? No

5:09

one's worthy to receive communion, I'm not worthy

5:12

to receive communion. So if nobody's worthy then

5:14

it doesn't really matter, right? Well

5:17

in Catholicism we have distinctions,

5:22

we have original sin which is being

5:24

born outside the Garden of Eden, it's

5:26

being born without righteousness, without sanctifying grace.

5:30

And then there's what's called actual

5:32

sins and actual sins are

5:34

divided into venial sins and mortal sins

5:36

and this comes from the first epistle

5:38

of St. John in the New Testament.

5:40

You also find it in the

5:43

Epistles of St. Paul, if you see my book, The

5:46

Catholic Perspective on Paul, I show

5:49

that there's places in Paul's

5:51

epistles where he lists out mortal sins.

5:54

Right now if you're a Protestant non-Catholic

5:56

watching this, you're like well what's the

5:58

distinction, aren't all sin? equal to God? No.

6:02

Jesus says to Pontius Pilate that

6:05

he who betrayed

6:07

him committed

6:11

the greater sin. There

6:15

are greater and lesser sins. John

6:20

in 1st John says that there are

6:22

sins unto death, sins leading to death,

6:24

and there are sins not leading to

6:26

death. This is where we

6:28

get the distinction between mortal sins and venial

6:31

sins. And in the Old Testament there were

6:33

certain sins that were so grievous that

6:35

you received the death penalty. There were

6:37

other sins that were so grievous that

6:39

you had to bring livestock animals, animal

6:41

sacrifice at the temple. You'd put

6:43

your hands on the head of the animal and

6:46

confess your sins in the presence of

6:48

a priest. Sound familiar? And

6:50

that animal would die as a

6:52

propitiatory sacrifice for your mortal sin.

6:55

Other sins were venial. You

6:58

know, you stubbed your toe and you said, oh damn it,

7:01

that's not good. That's not

7:03

pleasing to God. It's using your mouth in a

7:05

bad way. But it's not a mortal sin, right?

7:11

As a raping a person,

7:14

murdering a person, stealing

7:19

a widow's home and throwing her on

7:21

the street. Mortal sin. That's

7:25

the distinction. And

7:28

in the Catholic Church we

7:31

are taught through Jesus Christ

7:33

and the 12 apostles that if

7:36

we are in a state of mortal sin,

7:39

alright, so if I murder someone, I'm

7:43

not in a state of grace. I'm in a

7:45

state of mortal sin. Now if

7:48

I'm in a state of mortal sin, I will go to hell. If

7:50

I die in a state of mortal sin, I will go straight

7:52

to hell. There's no appeal. There's

7:54

no purgatory for that. Mortal

7:57

sin, you only go to purgatory if you die in

7:59

a state of of grace. If

8:02

you die in a state of mortal sin, not

8:05

in a state of grace, you go to hell. If

8:08

you're in a state of mortal sin, you

8:10

cannot receive communion because

8:12

you're on your way to hell. Even

8:14

if you're baptized, even if you say, I believe

8:16

in Jesus, he's great. I

8:19

love him. He's awesome. But you're in a state of

8:21

mortal sin. You're on

8:23

your way to hell and

8:27

you can't receive communion. The

8:29

remedy for mortal sin is

8:32

another sacrament. It's the sacrament of

8:34

penance. I know

8:36

nowadays everybody calls it the sacrament of

8:38

reconciliation. It's

8:41

true. It's a little soft.

8:45

The council of Trent and tradition is called

8:47

the sacrament of penance. What is penance? Penance

8:50

is repentance, metanoia,

8:52

changing of your mind, changing of

8:54

your heart, a radical change away

8:58

from sin and towards God. We

9:03

go to the sacrament of penance and

9:05

this was established by Jesus Christ on the

9:07

day of his resurrection, three days after he

9:10

was crucified and died on the cross. He

9:13

appears to the 12 apostles in John

9:15

chapter 20 on the

9:18

evening of his resurrection. So

9:20

he hasn't even been resurrected a full 24

9:22

hours yet. And he breathes

9:25

on the apostles in John chapter 20.

9:31

Peace be unto you as

9:34

the father sent me. So I send

9:36

you who's

9:38

a, whose sins you

9:41

forgive. They are forgiven. Who

9:43

sends you retain. They are retained. That

9:47

is what Jesus Christ, our Lord and

9:49

savior, all glory be to him. Wanted

9:51

to say, as soon as he rose

9:53

from the dead to the apostles, he

9:56

gave them a power. He

9:59

gave them an authority. authority. And

10:01

what is that authority? It is

10:03

the authority to forgive sins

10:07

in the name of Jesus.

10:10

St. Peter can't say, I absolve you of your

10:13

sins in the name of Peter. No. In

10:16

the Catholic Church, in

10:18

the Eastern Orthodox Church, where

10:20

there's valid sacraments as well, they

10:23

say, I absolve

10:25

you of your sins. I forgive you of your sins

10:27

in the name of the Father and of the Son

10:30

and of the Holy Ghost. That

10:34

sacrament is only for baptized people. You have

10:36

to be baptized to receive penance. And

10:40

it has to be done in the presence of

10:43

a validly ordained presbyter

10:46

or bishop.

10:49

Deacons can't do it. A

10:52

monk who's not a priest can't do it. A

10:55

nun can't do it. A layman can't do it.

10:57

It has to be a presbyter, a priest, or

10:59

a bishop because

11:01

they have that authority, that

11:04

sacramental power through another sacrament

11:06

called Holy Orders in

11:09

order to declare, ratify,

11:11

and affect the forgiveness

11:13

of mortal sins. Venial

11:21

sins, if

11:23

I say, man,

11:26

that guy's a real jackass, you

11:30

know, and I may be downplaying a little bit, but

11:32

I don't like to write him that ruin his name,

11:34

right? I'll say I do it

11:36

in front of my kids. That's bad. That's not good. That's

11:39

not the Catholic way. That's not how

11:41

Christians talk. But

11:43

it's not a mortal sin. All

11:45

right. It doesn't remove me from my

11:48

bond of charity and love union with

11:51

Jesus Christ. By

11:53

the way, for it to be a mortal sin has to be

11:55

gravely evil. You have to know

11:57

it's gravely evil, and you have to consent and

11:59

will to to do it.

12:02

So killing a man is gravely

12:04

evil. I know killing a

12:06

man is gravely evil, but if I'm out

12:08

hunting and I pull the trigger on what

12:10

I think is a deer and I walk

12:12

up and it was a man wearing antlers,

12:15

I go, I just killed a man. It's

12:18

not a mortal sin, right?

12:20

Because I did not consent in will

12:23

to murder a man. It was a mistake.

12:26

It was evil, it was bad. Guy

12:29

died. I know killing people

12:31

is bad, but in that case, I did

12:33

not will. So it's not a mortal sin.

12:37

Venial sins are

12:39

in Latin venial, like they can,

12:41

they're easily forgiven. So

12:44

San Agustin says, you know, if you pray

12:46

be our father, forgive us our trespasses as

12:48

we forgive those who trespass against us, your

12:50

venial sins gone. If

12:53

you go to mass, your

12:56

venial sins are gone. You receive communion, your

12:58

venial sin. If you're in a state of

13:00

grace, your venial sins are gone. You use

13:02

holy water to valley, your venial sins are

13:04

gone. You say an act of contrition. I'm

13:07

sorry, Jesus for sinning. I'm sorry. I said

13:09

that. I shouldn't have said that. I'm sorry.

13:11

I used that language. I'm

13:14

sorry. I laughed at that inappropriate thing. That

13:20

right there gone. No problem. Back

13:25

to Joe Biden. We're in

13:27

a situation where you have one of the

13:29

most powerful men on earth who says he's

13:31

a Catholic, Joe Biden. And

13:34

it's not just that he says, you know, I just

13:37

think women should have a choice. That's up

13:39

to them. Right. It's not just like a

13:42

thought that he has in his head.

13:45

He is actively day

13:48

by day for

13:51

many decades as

13:54

a Senator, as a vice

13:56

president and as a president. Using

14:00

money votes

14:02

political power to

14:04

year by year extend the culture

14:06

of death As

14:10

a Catholic, he knows the Catholic Church is

14:12

against it You can't at this at

14:15

this late of the game say why I

14:17

never heard that Catholics were pro life. Are

14:19

you kidding me? All

14:22

these years I've been a senator and a vice

14:24

president and a president and going

14:26

to church. I had no idea You

14:32

It's gravely evil He

14:35

knows what the church teaches and he does

14:38

it any way This

14:41

is gravely wicked. It is

14:43

a scandal to the faithful and When

14:47

you have public notorious

14:49

sin Says

14:51

Thomas Aquinas and other church

14:53

fathers It is

14:56

permissible for the clergy to

14:59

gently pastorally in

15:01

a sensitive way Speak

15:03

to him about getting his life right

15:05

and not letting him have communion if

15:07

he's in a public notorious sin Now

15:11

let's talk about Judas Iscariot Judas

15:13

Iscariot received communion at the Last

15:15

Supper Did Jesus

15:17

Christ all knowing second person the Trinity?

15:19

Did He

15:22

know that Judas was in mortal sin that

15:24

Satan had entered Judas that Judas was about

15:27

to betray him that Judas was in mortal

15:29

sin. Yes, Jesus knew that and Yet

15:33

he gave him communion anyway Doesn't that

15:35

prove that we should be giving communion

15:37

to everyone in mortal sin because Jesus

15:39

gave communion in Jesus is

15:41

my knowing that Judas was in mortal

15:43

sin doesn't that prove that we should

15:45

give communion to Joe Biden Thomas

15:48

Aquinas says no Because

15:50

there's another important distinction You

15:55

can only not

15:57

give communion refrain from giving communion to

15:59

a Center if

16:01

it is a notorious public

16:04

sin. In

16:08

that case, he is

16:10

obliged, the priest or the bishop

16:12

is obliged not to give communion

16:14

to the notorious public center. Let

16:17

me give a couple examples of

16:19

what would and would not qualify according to

16:21

St. Thomas Aquinas in the Summa

16:23

Theologie. And by the way, if you want to

16:25

take online courses with me on St. Thomas Aquinas

16:27

and these topics, sign up at New

16:30

St. Thomas Institute. We call it nsti.com.

16:32

There are 10 courses. I'm your

16:34

professor, you can earn your certificate

16:37

in Thomistic Studies in Thomas Aquinas

16:39

and Catholic Philosophy. We have a

16:41

whole curriculum, we have courses, it's

16:44

fun, it's interesting, and it'll take your

16:46

faith to the next level. So today,

16:48

join nsti.com. I'll be your professor. I'll

16:50

walk you through Thomas Aquinas. In fact,

16:52

we have a whole video on

16:55

the topic that I'm discussing today, which is,

17:00

can a notorious sinner receive

17:02

communion? So you're getting a little

17:05

preview, getting little tidbits,

17:07

some appetizers today for

17:09

nsti.com. Here's

17:13

some examples. Okay, let's

17:15

say the priest, we're going

17:17

to call him Father McGillica. He

17:20

knows all the people in this, he's in a small

17:22

town. He knows all his parishioners pretty well, knows him

17:24

by name. He's been there for 10 years. One

17:28

night, he's got a

17:30

flat tire and

17:33

he kind of pulls up on the side of

17:35

the road next to a bar,

17:39

kind of a sleazy bar. You know, he

17:41

wouldn't normally go to that. It's not a pub, you

17:43

know, it's kind of a not so good

17:45

place. As he's changing his tire,

17:48

he sees Bill from his parish. Bill

17:51

is an upstanding man

17:53

in the community. He's married, he has

17:55

six kids, he donates a

17:57

lot of money. He's a good Catholic, right? And

18:00

Bill stumbles out of this sort of

18:02

sleazy bar with a

18:04

young woman on his arm.

18:07

And they start making out and he

18:09

touches her inappropriately. And then

18:11

Father McGillica, he kind of hides himself

18:13

and changes tire and he leaves. And

18:16

that evening he's thinking, man, Bill and

18:18

my parish is a real son of

18:20

a gun. He's married,

18:22

he's got five kids, he's

18:24

active in the church, but,

18:27

you know, he's out at night with

18:30

this young woman and he's being inappropriate with her

18:32

and who knows what's going on there. You

18:35

know, this is not good. And then the

18:38

next morning it's mass and he sees Bill

18:40

come forward to receive communion. Thomas

18:43

Aquinas would say that Father

18:46

McGillica, he must

18:48

give communion to Bill. Why?

18:52

Because his grave sin is

18:54

not notorious in public. Only

18:58

Father knows about it. Just

19:02

like with Judas, only Jesus

19:04

knew that Judas was going to betray him.

19:06

Even the other apostles were like, oh, he's going to

19:08

go do something important, you know, bye Judas. Sorry,

19:11

you have to leave early, you know, and Jesus

19:13

wasn't like, he's betraying me. You

19:15

know, it was all kept discreet. So

19:19

Thomas Aquinas says in that case, Father

19:21

McGillica, he cannot receive, cannot refrain from

19:24

giving communion to Bill because the sin

19:26

is private. Now

19:29

let's change the scenario. Let's

19:33

say that a year

19:35

later, Bill

19:38

gets arrested for drunk

19:40

driving and

19:42

that leads to an investigation and

19:45

Bill admits,

19:50

yeah, not only am I drunk driving, but I

19:52

was drunk driving to my mission mistress's house. Oh

19:55

my goodness sakes, right? And

19:58

then everyone finds out and there's an investigation.

20:00

investigation the he in the mist he's

20:02

been the mistress has been helping him

20:04

in bezel money and Steel

20:07

from people in the community. So he's

20:09

got adultery. He's got embezzlement

20:13

He's drunk driving. I mean

20:15

bill golly Come

20:18

on bill, but instead of

20:20

bill saying I'm so sorry I'm

20:23

so sorry I've taken the

20:25

wrong way. I need to get back to Jesus. I

20:27

need to repent. I'm gonna go to confession on it

20:30

Bill says, you know what? Screw all you people

20:33

I'm gonna do things my way. I don't want you

20:35

to you can't judge me And

20:39

He comes to mass the next day

20:41

defiantly to make a point and to

20:43

receive communion Thomas Aquinas

20:45

says that in this scenario The

20:49

priest the pastor should refrain

20:51

from giving communion to bill

20:53

why what changed? notorious

20:57

public sin scandal

21:03

Right Or if a

21:05

man were to come to mass and say

21:07

these are my two wives And

21:10

I'm here to receive communion It's a

21:12

public thing that a man is married to two women

21:15

and he's flaunting it and coming to the

21:17

communion rail That's a public because marriage is

21:19

a public thing. That's a public scandal public

21:21

sin This

21:24

is the teaching of the Catholic Church Traditionally,

21:26

it's not the teaching of Francis Progolia,

21:28

but it's the tradition traditional teaching of

21:31

the Catholic Church and Thomas Aquinas Does

21:35

that make sense So

21:38

with the public notorious scandalous

21:40

sin the priest refuses The

21:43

communiqué if it's private the

21:45

priest gives communion in the case of Joe Biden. I'm

21:48

gonna ask all y'all right now we got live Live

21:52

chat going we got 2,000 people. I'm gonna ask y'all

21:56

Is the sin of Joe Biden? grave?

22:02

Is it public? Is it

22:04

notorious? Is it manifest? And

22:07

if it is, shouldn't he be

22:10

refused communion according to the criteria

22:12

that we just went through in

22:14

Catholic moral theology? While I wait

22:16

for you all to answer that in the life chat, I'm gonna

22:18

ask you to like the video, share the

22:20

video. This is an important topic. We're

22:23

getting into some real theology.

22:25

People need to understand these

22:27

distinctions because the Catholic Church

22:29

has been thinking and pondering

22:31

on these questions for

22:36

two millennia, 20 centuries.

22:40

And if you're new, please subscribe. My name is Dr. Taylor

22:42

Marshall. I make videos, podcasts

22:44

about philosophy, theology,

22:47

church history, current

22:49

events, news, etc.

22:52

Okay, so I'm going to jump in here to the... Everyone's

22:55

saying yes, yes, yes, yes, yes. I'm

22:57

looking for a no. Anyone disagree with

23:00

me? Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes.

23:03

Okay, everyone is in agreement because

23:06

I have a really good

23:08

audience. Yeah, everyone's in agreement. So

23:14

if that is the teaching of the

23:16

Catholic Church, why is it that Pope

23:19

Francis Progolio is

23:21

telling him, you're a good Catholic, Joe

23:24

Biden, Joey Joe,

23:27

Joey Biden. You're a

23:30

good Irish Catholic. You

23:32

keep receiving that communion. You're

23:35

a good Catholic. How is that the case? I

23:41

mean, Adolf Hitler was

23:44

baptized Catholic and he received Catholic

23:46

confirmation. So the sacramental

23:48

preparation for Adolf Hitler was Roman

23:50

Catholic. I don't know if y'all

23:52

knew that. Adolf

23:56

Hitler killed a lot of people. All

23:58

right. I don't know. of y'all knew

24:00

that big scandal. I

24:03

would call that a public and nus and

24:06

notorious scandal. Now,

24:08

obviously Adolf Hitler did not profess to be

24:11

a Catholic. He did not attend mass kind

24:13

of became an occultist later in

24:15

his life. He committed

24:17

suicide. So he did not

24:19

persevere in being a Catholic, but

24:22

he was sacramentally a Catholic, baptized

24:24

and confirmed. What

24:27

if Adolf Hitler came to Rome to

24:30

Pope Francis Bergoglio and

24:32

said, Hey, I'm here to receive communion. I

24:34

want to receive communion every Sunday. I'm here. I want

24:37

to receive communion. I want to receive communion from you,

24:39

Pope, Holy Father. Oh, I'm

24:41

Catholic. I want to receive communion. Should

24:44

and would the Pope

24:47

give communion to

24:49

the sacramentally Catholic Adolf Hitler

24:53

just because he's baptized Catholic, or

24:58

is there a public scandal? Is

25:00

there a grave situation that would

25:02

cause a priest, Bishop,

25:05

Archbishop Cardinal, and or Pope to

25:07

say, you know what, you

25:10

are in a scandalous

25:12

situation, Adolf, and

25:14

until we can remedy that and

25:17

see some public penance for some

25:19

public sins, you don't receive the

25:21

body and blood of Jesus Christ.

25:25

Adolf, would you like to go to confession and

25:28

confess your multitude of sins? And

25:31

if he says no, then he doesn't get

25:34

communion. And what we have right now is

25:36

a situation where

25:39

you have a leader of

25:41

a nation who

25:45

is promoting a

25:47

culture of death. Unrepentant.

25:54

No sign of stopping. In fact, pushing

25:56

it. I mean, he is at. Here

26:00

he is. And

26:02

then we come back here to I

26:06

mean, he is at a rally promoting the edges of this

26:11

issue in De Lincoln. He

26:15

is the Matter of � colourful, invisible

26:17

ic his

26:29

so makin the sign of the

26:31

not only is there a public notorious scandal

26:33

or makin the sign of the cross while

26:36

we discuss that Joe Biden and

26:40

yet Pope Francis

26:42

is saying, give

26:44

them communion. Keep going on the communion.

26:50

Let's get your thoughts on that. What

26:53

is the bigger scandal here? I

26:55

want to get your thoughts on that. Is

26:57

the bigger scandal here, Biden making the sign of

26:59

the cross at a rally, let's

27:02

suppose the Catholic teaching or is the bigger

27:04

scandal here? A

27:06

Pope telling Joe

27:08

Biden, you're a good Catholic. Keep

27:11

receiving communion. Good,

27:13

good little boy. All

27:19

right. Looking at your Renee

27:23

X, pre Vatican II, Pope's ex

27:25

communicated unrepentant Catholics who scandalized the

27:27

faith 100% they did Renee. See

27:31

Renee has read Catholic church

27:34

history and

27:37

it's not just Pope's. Bishops did the same.

27:39

St. Ambrose of Milan. He was the

27:41

Bishop of Milan. He baptized

27:43

San Augustine. He was one

27:46

of the greatest theologians who ever lived.

27:49

He's one of the Western

27:52

fathers of the church. There

27:54

was an Emperor, Theodosius

28:00

I think it was Thessalonica. He had a

28:02

bunch of people killed in thousands. There was

28:04

a political revolt. So

28:08

all these people got killed by the order

28:10

of Theodosius. The

28:12

next Sunday, doo-doo-doo, Theodosius is coming to

28:14

church, walking over to the cathedral as

28:16

probably his retinue. He's

28:19

gonna come to Mass. And

28:23

Bishop Ambrose sees this and he goes to the door of the

28:25

church and he says, no! Emperor

28:29

Theodosius, Emperor of Rome,

28:33

you have blood on your hands.

28:36

You can't even come into the

28:38

church. You cannot pass this door

28:40

into the cathedral, Emperor, because you

28:42

have blood on your hands. What

28:45

was the response of Theodosius? Only

28:50

God can judge me. No, Theodosius

28:52

was cut to heart. He

28:54

realized Ambrose was right and

28:56

Theodosius did penance and

28:59

was absolved to the sacrament of penance

29:01

and was reconciled to Holy Mother Church

29:04

and then he went back to Mass

29:07

and received communion. That's

29:11

how you do it. That's Catholic.

29:13

That's Catholicism. That's a church father.

29:15

That's a saint. That's a doctor.

29:20

St. Ambrose. He

29:22

didn't say, I'm

29:24

just gonna respect your conscience on that one,

29:26

Emperor. Yeah,

29:29

I'm just gonna like accompany your conscience

29:32

and just assume that because

29:34

you're the Roman Emperor, you

29:36

formed your conscience before you killed those people and

29:38

you did it in a good

29:41

conscience. So you can receive

29:43

the Eucharist today. That's

29:45

the modern Jesuit approach.

29:49

It's lame. It's offensive. All

29:53

right. Gregory

30:02

Cox says, now

30:04

we can see how the Antichrist

30:06

uses weak leaders to wreak habit

30:08

in the world. Yes, but

30:11

it's not just leaders in

30:14

America or in Europe. It's

30:16

leaders in the

30:18

church. Talk

30:21

about infiltration. It's

30:24

leaders in the church. Infiltrating

30:30

their way in and giving the

30:32

green light to this

30:34

sacrilege, to this blasphemy.

30:37

If you agree, please

30:39

like the video. You

30:41

agree with what I just said, like the

30:43

video. Which

30:47

is a bigger problem? The

30:49

fact that Francis is saying, you're a good

30:51

boy Joe Biden, keep receiving communion. Or

30:54

the fact that Joe Biden is going to these rallies and

30:56

making the sign of the cross. Which is worse or are

30:58

they the same? American

31:03

Toughtop says, 50% of Catholics are registered Democrats in

31:06

the same amounts of abortion. I

31:08

think it's actually higher than that. But yeah, you're right.

31:10

And I wonder why that is. Oh,

31:12

I know it's because our bishops are

31:14

weak sauce. Affeminate.

31:17

Right? They see

31:20

themselves as CEOs. They

31:23

wear their black business suit and they have

31:25

their cross here. They

31:27

strut around and have a little entourage. And

31:31

if you want to talk to your bishop, you can't talk to

31:33

him. Right? There's all

31:35

these people that are a buffer at the dialysis

31:37

and office around the bishop. And

31:40

you have to talk to those people. Right?

31:45

You see a lay person. Oh. So

31:50

they're CEOs. And

31:53

unfortunately, in the United States of America and

31:55

in Germany, they get so much money from

31:57

the government through grants. And

32:01

germinates through taxation. You

32:03

know, they really at this point in America don't care

32:06

about the money that's in the pews. Like when you

32:08

put your money, yeah, they want the diocesan appeal. Yeah,

32:11

they want the catherádicum. That's

32:13

the tithe that they take from all the parishes. Yeah, they

32:15

want all that. But I mean, they get money from other

32:17

places. And

32:21

they don't want the Democratic

32:24

Party to get mad at them. So

32:27

they have their little black business suit on. Oh,

32:31

no, like Mugatu, you

32:33

know, in

32:35

Zoolander. I have

32:38

the entourage, little guy with a little dog. Bishop

32:45

Mugatu. That's a real right there,

32:47

Dan. Bishop Mugatu. Somebody

32:50

spilled a latte on him. He's

32:53

like, ahh. There

33:00

are good bishops out there. But

33:02

I'm just saying, our experience as

33:04

lay people in the United States of America

33:06

is the bishop is

33:09

not a father, not a priest, not

33:12

an overseer, not a shepherd. The

33:14

bishop is a CEO who

33:17

is currently closing down churches,

33:19

merging churches, and dealing with

33:22

lawsuits because of sexual molestation.

33:25

And they're just, their mind is

33:27

in lawyers. And

33:33

what we want as Catholics is we

33:35

want shepherds. We

33:37

want shepherds. Someone

33:42

says, Bishop Strickland, he's good. Yeah, but he got

33:45

removed. Jeffrey

33:48

says, they are both equally serious

33:50

problems. The president is not being

33:52

counseled to take the actions that

33:54

will save his soul. Exactly.

33:59

And that's on who? That's on Francis. And

34:02

then people say, well, gee, too, or why do

34:04

you always hate Francis? You're always hating on Francis.

34:06

Like I'm loving Francis here. This

34:09

is the truth. You

34:11

know, I'm not gonna sit here on a

34:14

webcam, dad on a webcam and say, yeah, you know,

34:18

what we need to do is just everyone who's

34:20

a public, everyone is a center, we'll just pat

34:22

them on the head and be like, keep receiving

34:24

communion. It'll all work out in

34:26

the end somehow. What? Like

34:29

how disingenuous would I be if I said

34:31

that? And

34:34

when I say, I think it's

34:36

completely disingenuous and hypocritical for

34:39

a man who says, I am Pope Francis to

34:41

do that, am

34:44

I wrong? Am I wrong? No,

34:47

I'm not wrong. I

34:49

am standing with the tradition of the church. I

34:52

am repeating to you exactly what Saint

34:54

Thomas Aquinas says, which is the man

34:57

should be refused Holy Communion, not given

34:59

Holy Communion. Does

35:03

anyone disagree with me? Does

35:06

anyone disagree with me? I'd love to hear someone

35:08

say, man, you are a real peace,

35:11

Marshall. Solitary.

35:15

Dr. Marshall, have you approached the

35:17

AI priest on the best pastoral

35:19

approach? Man, the AI priest that

35:21

Catholic Anters put out this past

35:23

week is such an embarrassment. It

35:25

is so lame and

35:28

they've walked it back, but Catholic

35:30

Anters has fallen so far.

35:35

15, 20 years ago, they were on

35:37

the forefront. They were

35:39

on radio, they were in places and

35:41

they were doing catechesis and helping people

35:43

understand Catholicism. Catholic Anters

35:46

has very much become Francis Anters. How

35:48

do we defend everything that Francis

35:50

says? And Dr. K

35:52

exposed that with the AI bot priest.

35:56

And it was just, the AI bot

35:58

priest had weird things about absolution. And

36:00

I mean, I haven't sorted the whole thing out, but it

36:04

was a horrible idea to

36:06

create an AI priest that

36:09

people were going to, I mean, who made

36:12

this decision? That

36:15

person should be fired. That person

36:17

should be terminated. Yes, let's do

36:19

an AI bot. Not an

36:21

AI bot apologist, like

36:24

some avatar of Jimmy Aiken. That'd

36:27

be funny. It'd be interesting. But no,

36:29

we're going to make a priest, an AI

36:31

priest, who's going to talk to

36:33

people and give pastoral sacramental. I

36:35

mean, this was such a bad idea. Whoever

36:38

thought of it should be fired. It's

36:42

bad. I mean, this is

36:44

how people's souls are led

36:46

astray. You're putting the pastoral,

36:50

spiritual father role of

36:52

people using AI chat

36:54

bot over people. Very

36:57

bad. Very bad. I

37:00

hope they learned their lesson on this at

37:03

Catholic Answers. John

37:06

Wick. I always love to see John

37:08

Wick. John Wick, how you doing? John

37:12

Wick, is Biden's subject automatic excommunication

37:15

as abortion accomplice? He aids

37:17

people obtain, he

37:20

aids people obtaining abortion by

37:22

actively supporting public funding. Yes,

37:24

John Wick. This is what

37:26

Cardinal Burke

37:29

said. Cardinal Burke

37:31

said that there

37:33

is a Lates Intensiae automatic

37:35

excommunication placed on politicians who

37:38

are funding and voting for

37:40

policies that lead to the

37:43

termination of life. I

37:47

mean, go back to the Adolf example.

37:50

As far as I know, I don't think Adolf

37:52

ever stood on a firing squad

37:54

or at a camp. Right?

37:59

I mean, he may not even fired a bullet at

38:01

anyone, but he was writing the orders, right?

38:06

He was sending the decrees, making

38:09

the decisions. Stalin may not

38:11

have actively killed someone directly,

38:16

but he was making the decrees for them

38:18

to be killed, making the orders.

38:21

So you can't say, well, politicians

38:24

in the Senate, in the House,

38:29

in the Supreme Court, in

38:32

the Oval Office, you

38:34

signed that into law. You

38:37

provide funding, taxpayer money to

38:39

accomplish it. You

38:42

are an accomplice. You

38:46

are in it. You did it. So

38:48

yes, anyone who is in a comp... Like

38:51

if, for example, if your

38:53

neighbor says, hey, I need you to drive me somewhere,

38:55

okay, I'll drive you somewhere, where are we going? Planned

38:57

Parenthood. Why are we going to Planned Parenthood? I'm going

39:00

to get an A, B-O-R-T. If you

39:02

drive that person knowing that there, you

39:05

are automatically excommunicated from the church.

39:08

Did you know that? Because you're an accomplice. So

39:12

that's a good point, John Wick. Does

39:25

the excommunication matter if the Pope and the

39:27

bishops give him communion, though? Well, the excommunication

39:29

does matter, and that means every time he

39:31

receives communion, he's damning himself deeper and deeper

39:34

into hell. And

39:36

the fact that a Pope and bishops would

39:38

be accomplices in a man, sinking

39:41

further and further into the mire

39:43

of perdition is just another judgment

39:45

on them. It's

39:48

disgusting. And they're

39:50

going to come out, by the way, they're going

39:52

to say, keep receiving communion, keep receiving communion, and

39:54

then they're going to put out a document called

39:56

infinite dignity. Take a

39:58

hike. You're going

40:00

to put out a document, infinite dignity, and

40:04

yet you're going to allow someone like

40:07

Joe Biden to continue to receive communion.

40:12

What he does. Funding

40:15

and loss. All

40:24

right. Like the video, everybody. Let's say, I think we

40:26

should say a prayer for Joe Biden. Let's

40:29

say a prayer together. We're going to say a Hail Mary. The

40:31

mother of life, the mother of the

40:34

Messiah, the mother of Jesus Christ. Hooray,

40:36

Musa. Nomeni Patris et Firi et

40:38

Spiritus Sancti, Amen. Ave Maria,

40:40

gracia, plena, domino, stecum. Benedicta

40:43

II and Moliaribus et Benedictus

40:45

Fructus Ventris, Tui, Jesus. Sancta

40:48

Maria, Mater Dei, Oropronovius,

40:51

Pecatoribus. Nunket ettorum

40:53

mortis nostre, Amen. Nomeni

40:55

Patris et Firi et Spiritus Sancti,

40:58

Amen. All

41:00

right, now it was a prayer for Joe Biden.

41:03

St. Joseph, pray for Joe Biden.

41:07

God wills for no one to go to hell. God

41:10

wills the condemnation of no one, but

41:12

he gives us a free will. And if you choose

41:14

to reject him, his love, his mercy, not

41:17

to have hope and faith in his

41:19

son, Jesus Christ, who bled out

41:21

for all of our sins, if you choose

41:23

to reject that, if you choose

41:25

to persevere in wickedness and evil, it

41:28

says in John's Gospel, John chapter three, you

41:31

are already judged. You

41:34

are all ready judged.

41:37

And the judgment of God is

41:39

just against sin. The

41:41

only refuge is in Jesus Christ, our

41:43

Lord and Savior, the son

41:46

of God, the son of man. So

41:48

turn to Jesus Christ. If you're not a

41:50

Catholic and you're watching this, you need to

41:52

become a Catholic. Wait, there's so many

41:54

scandals in the Catholic Church. Yes, there

41:57

are so many scandals in ancient Israel and yet ancient.

42:00

Israel was the one true people

42:02

of God. There

42:05

is only one true church. Jesus

42:07

Christ has one bride, the church.

42:09

Not many brides, he's not a

42:11

Muslim, he's not a

42:13

polygamist, he didn't have two brides, he didn't have the

42:15

Catholic bride and the Protestant bride or the

42:17

East North of Knox bride. He

42:20

has one bride, one church. Join

42:23

the one true church. How do you join the one true

42:25

church? Holy baptism. Unless

42:29

you were born of water in the Holy

42:31

Spirit, you cannot enter the kingdom of heaven.

42:35

Number two, receive the sacrament of confirmation,

42:37

that's the gift, the

42:39

outpouring of the Holy Spirit, third

42:41

person. If

42:44

you're already a Christian,

42:46

but you're in a heretical assembly,

42:50

you need to join the church through a profession

42:52

of faith, believing everything the church says, and then

42:54

you need to go to confession. We

42:57

talked about that earlier. Confess all

42:59

of your mortal sins that you've ever committed

43:01

since baptism. You'll receive absolution, you'll

43:03

be admitted into the church. Then

43:06

you can begin to receive confirmation and

43:09

the Holy Eucharist. This is

43:11

the way, this is the way forward. And

43:14

we need all Christians on earth, all of

43:16

us need to come together into one true

43:18

church in submission to

43:20

Rome, in submission to the Holy

43:22

Pontiff, the Vicar of Christ, believing

43:25

everything Jesus taught and everything the apostles

43:28

taught. If you agree with that, go

43:30

ahead and do a thumbs up. Read

43:34

your Bible every day, go to

43:37

Mass every single Sunday, and Holy Day of Obligation.

43:39

Go to confession every two to four weeks if

43:41

you can. Find a

43:43

traditional Latin Mass if you can. Pray

43:45

the rosary every single day, five

43:47

decades minimum every day. Pray the

43:50

rosary every day or you're not

43:52

on the team. The

43:54

rosary is the weapon. This is how we fight the

43:56

culture war. If you're not praying the rosary every day,

44:00

really with us. You're not holding the

44:02

weapon. You're

44:04

not doing the spiritual battle that needs to be

44:06

done. I didn't make that up. The

44:08

Blessed Virgin Mary said it at Fatima. Popes

44:11

have said it. Padre P has said it.

44:13

Saints, mystics, this

44:15

is the way forward. So pray the rosary every

44:18

single day. Make sure you have subscribed to

44:20

the Dr. Taylor Marshall

44:22

podcast. Thank you everyone for

44:24

watching. And if you'd

44:26

like to support my work and

44:29

support my podcast, you can go

44:31

to patreon.com/Dr. Taylor Marshall. I'll send

44:33

you signed books, rosary, there's different

44:35

levels of support and giving

44:37

at Patreon. So if you go

44:39

to patreon.com/Dr. Taylor Marshall, you

44:41

can support the work that I'm doing,

44:44

this message, this education

44:48

that we're trying to accomplish in a

44:50

world that's confused inside

44:52

and outside the church. Also,

44:54

if you want to move and go to a different part of the

44:56

country, I encourage you to contact

44:58

realestateforlife.org. Real Estate for Life are the

45:00

people I trust. They have real estate

45:02

agents all over the world, especially in the United States of America.

45:04

So if you're like, you know what, I don't want to live

45:06

in California anymore. I don't want to live in New York. I

45:08

want to move to Texas. I want to move to Florida. I

45:11

want to move to Tennessee, Idaho.

45:14

These are the people who will

45:16

help you. So contact realestateforlife.org. Visit

45:18

their website, realestateforlife.org. And then

45:20

tell them you heard about it at the

45:23

Dr. Taylor Marshall show and they can

45:25

help you. All

45:27

right. If you want to learn how we got into this

45:29

big problem, check out my book,

45:32

Infiltration. You can get the audible. You can read the

45:34

book. It's a 200 year history on

45:37

how there was an infiltration of

45:40

bad people into the seminaries, into the

45:42

convents, into the monasteries who have sought

45:44

for the last 50 to

45:46

60 years to corrupt and

45:49

infiltrate the one true

45:51

Catholic church. I explain

45:53

how it happened, what's going on, who the

45:55

key players are. And then at the last

45:57

two chapters of the book, I give

45:59

a game plan. plan on how we can kick

46:01

these infiltrators out and reclaim the one true

46:04

church for our Lord Jesus Christ. He still

46:06

has it, by the way. He's not lost,

46:09

right? There's just some bad players inside.

46:11

We can get them out. That's

46:13

what an infiltration is. Thank

46:16

you for watching. May

46:19

God bless you. I'm very excited. Tomorrow I'm going to go

46:21

get my honeybees. Got honeybees

46:23

arriving. Two nukes. So

46:26

I got my bee suit,

46:28

my smokers, and I'm ready to go.

46:30

So I'll report back on how the bees went. Maybe I'll

46:32

make a little video of the

46:34

new honeybees. So I'm excited about that. And

46:38

remember that God has a plan for

46:40

you. You are special. He wants you

46:42

in heaven. He wants to make you into a

46:44

great saint. Do not be discouraged.

46:46

Do not give up. And

46:49

he says, you are the light of the

46:51

world and the salt of the earth. So

46:53

go out there and be salty. God

46:55

bless and Godspeed.