This week Morgan covers the gruesome tale of a romantic fantasy between an adult and child goes over the deep-end when a young girl is convinced that killing her whole family is in order for a toxic, manipulative love to exist. How does one con

Jeffrey Lundgren and The Kirtland Cult

Jul 17th, 2022 28m 26s

This week Amanda covers another local Ohio story. Following Jeffrey Lundgren, a self-proclaimed prophet that unfortunately leads misguided members to murder a compliant and devoted family of five. --- Support this podcast: https://podcaster

Cold Mysterious Car Fire Case

Jul 10th, 2022 23m 33s

This week, Morgan covers the unsolved case of Leslie Barker, a school teacher. Found inside her car that was ignited with a mysterious substance; go over some ideas and theories this week with us and special guest, Jeremiah, an intern from Kent

The Hello Kitty Murder

Jul 3rd, 2022 27m 37s

Thanks for joining back after last time! Today Amanda covers the gruesome torture Fan Man-yee endured after her kidnapping for an entire month before her horrible demise. Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter for updates on when new epi

Christine and Lea Papin

Apr 3rd, 2022 14m 47s

For our season finale, Morgan wraps us up with a short and (maybe?) sweet episode covering the Papin sisters. Were these sisters justified in their murders? Or is it just a little too weird for that?--- Support this podcast: https://podcast

The Murder of Cassie Jo Stoddart

Mar 27th, 2022 19m 38s

This Sunday, Morgan covers a nightmare that no teenage girl should ever have to experience. Cassie Jo Stoddart's killers made it a goal to make their evening exactly as if it were out of a horror movie. Join us this week at 1pm on most major pl

Freddie and Truus Oversteegen

Mar 6th, 2022 13m 59s

Morgan and Amanda cover an unlike any other sisterly bond this week in a short light-hearted episode, accopanied by a few glasses of wine. Join us this Sunday at 1p (est)!--- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/cri

William Bonin, Part 2

Feb 27th, 2022 30m 46s

This week, Morgan covers the second part of her horrific story: William Bonin, a.k.a. The Free Way Killer... Not to mention his accomplices. Their means of torture and murder are covered in this second part episode of Morgans previous podcast e

Rodney Alcala, The Dating Game Killer

Feb 20th, 2022 25m 50s

This week join Amanda and Morgan, as they cover their accidental duplicate story; The Dating Game Killer. Active between the years of 1968 and 1979, Rodney Alcala's death toll reached unknown numbers. Morgan and Amanda can agree that this fiend

William Bonin, The Freeway Killer

Feb 13th, 2022 32m 25s

This Sunday another new episode of Crime in the Coconut will flow into your head holes...preferably your ears. Morgan covers William Bonin (a.k.a. The Freeway Killer). A gruesome tale of the child torture/murdering type. We hope you can joi

Lavinia and John Fisher

Feb 6th, 2022 22m 55s

This week Morgan and I cover Lavinia and John Fisher, having rumored to be one of America's earliest serial killers taking place in the 1800's. Join us on a trip back in time to learn of how things worked back then and how people have always be

Aileen Wuornos

Apr 3rd, 2021 29m 12s

Ashley and Amanda cover the youth and troubles of Aileen Wuornos and the crimes committed by her and her girlfriend over the course of a year. Topics get heavy and they discuss their own troubles, to hear more join our Patreon as bloopers and e

The Moors, Scotland Murders

Mar 21st, 2021 25m 40s

This week Ashley covers the gruesome murders committed by Ian Bradley and Myra Hinkley against unsuspecting children. These unforgivable crimes took place in the 60's in Manchester, Scotland in a desolate waste known as The Moors.This episode

Dorothea Grey - Fan Submission

Mar 14th, 2021 24m 10s

Our first fan submission episode from Glen Allen, Virginia! Read by Amanda; Morgan covers the awful childhood leading up to a seemingly sweet old woman's murderous money scheme--- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/sh

Ed Gein

Mar 2nd, 2021 25m 42s

Leatherface, Buffalo Bill, American Psycho..if this story sounds familiar to you it's because Ed Gene inspired some of the most iconic horror stories of all time. But in our opinion, his true story is the scariest of them all.--- Support th

Emmitt Till

Feb 21st, 2021 35m 37s

In honor of Black History Month, this story covers the horrendous murder of Emmitt Till. Just a heads up, it's infuriating.--- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/crime-in-the-coconut/support

John and Susan Hamilton

Feb 14th, 2021 20m 24s

This week, Ashley tells us the story of Dr. John Hamilton, a man who many say loved and was deeply devoted to his angelic wife, a man who found that wife, in a pool of her own blood on Valentine's day in 2001. Hold your Valentine close while yo

The Chicago Tylenol Murders

Feb 8th, 2021 32m 59s

WE'RE BACK BABY. Did you miss us? We sure missed you. After a much needed hiatus Ashley and Amanda are back for season two of Crime In The Coconut. First up to bat is Amanda, and she covers the Chicago Tylenol Murders. There have been many copy

The Exorcism of Anna Michel

Oct 25th, 2020 31m 22s

This week, Amanda covers the classic case of Anna "Anneliese" Michel. One of the most infamous cases of exorcism in history. Do you think a demon had hold of her, or do you think her epilepsy and religious guilt caused irreversible mental traum

The Dybbuk Box

Oct 21st, 2020 43m 1s

What a turbulent week it's been..but here it is, the third Scary Sundays episode! This week, Ashley makes Amanda cry and then promptly gives her the willies as she tells the story of the Dybbuk Box. Who else is ready to hear about the other 9 b

Scary Sundays - Terrifying Audio

Oct 13th, 2020 47m 21s

Sorry for the late upload..but here is Scary Sunday episode two! This week, Amanda brings us some truly terrifying audios and makes Ashley cry. Which one did you find most unsettling? Make sure to follow us on social media (@crimeinthecoconut o

Scary Sundays - The Amityville Horror

Oct 5th, 2020 46m 47s

Welcome to Scary Sundays! This week kicks off the month of October's episodes and as promised, this first one is sure to scare. Listen to Ashley cover the gruesome Defeo Family murders as well as the infamous haunting of the Lutz family that fo

Katherine Knight

Sep 28th, 2020 45m 10s

This week is special for many reasons! This week, Amanda covers the story of Katherine Knight, the first woman to receive a life sentence without parole in Australia. She had a prized set of butcher knives and a few screws loose..Make sure to

Bonus

Scary Sundays Trailer

Sep 28th, 2020 2m 14s

Welcome to a whole month of nothing but scares..Make sure you follow us on Instagram (@crimeinthecoconut), Twitter (@CITCPodcasts), and email us your MERCH ORDERS at [email protected]!!--- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.

Mary Vincent

Sep 21st, 2020 27m 14s

This week's episode is near and dear to Ashley's heart, and is one of the most important stories we've told so far. Listen and be awestruck by the powerful story of Mary Vincent, who at only 15 years old became the literal definition of "Not to