Episode Transcript
Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.
Use Ctrl + F to search
0:00
So I don't know if you realize
0:02
this, Hermes is reporting earnings in like
0:04
two days. Yes. And at first I was like, we
0:07
should probably not do this episode because their
0:09
annual report comes out in two days. What
0:11
if we're not current? And then I realized
0:13
this is Hermes. The short term is of
0:15
no consequence. Yeah. Also
0:18
the Hermes annual reports are
0:21
the most beautiful annual reports
0:23
ever created in the history of the
0:25
financialization of mankind. You might think you
0:27
can't do all of your charts in
0:30
orange. You need different colors, but you
0:32
would be wrong. The
0:34
illustrations, the themes, you
0:36
can tell they care. You can tell. All
0:39
right, let's do it. Let's do it. Who
0:41
got the truth? Is
0:44
it you? Is it you? Is it
0:46
you? Who got the truth now? Is
0:49
it you? Is it you?
0:51
Is it you? Sit it down,
0:53
say it straight. Another story on
0:55
the way. Who got the truth? Welcome
0:58
to season 14, episode two of
1:00
Acquired, the podcast about great companies
1:02
and the stories and playbooks behind
1:04
them. I'm Ben Gilbert. I'm David
1:06
Resenthal. And we are your hosts. Today,
1:09
we tell the story of a handbag
1:11
company that won't sell you a handbag.
1:13
A traditional saddle maker that makes very
1:16
little of their revenue from saddles. A
1:18
company that somehow has grown to be worth
1:20
over $200 billion, despite
1:23
rejecting manufacturing efficiencies and
1:25
economies of scale. A
1:28
company so obsessed with craft and
1:30
a reputation for quality that they
1:32
have stayed independent while every other
1:35
luxury brand has merged into conglomerates.
1:37
That's right, listeners, today. We
1:40
tell the oldest story we have ever told
1:42
here on Acquired, older than Standard Oil or
1:44
the New York Times. This company dates
1:46
back to 1837 in Paris, France. The
1:51
crown jewel of the luxury industry,
1:53
Hermes. Ben, do you
1:55
know what company was also
1:58
founded in 1837? that
2:00
we have discussed quite a bit on
2:02
acquired. Hmm. No, I
2:04
do not, David. That would
2:06
be the other iconic color
2:08
luxury company, Tiffany. Oh,
2:11
really? Also founded in 1837. Chuck
2:14
T. Well, this episode,
2:16
listeners, has been probably just under
2:18
12 months in the making. LVMH
2:20
was just after one year ago.
2:23
And it was in that episode that I feel
2:25
like I got a real penchant for everything that
2:27
Hermes stood for. After 187 years,
2:30
still under family control. They're on
2:32
their sixth generation of family leadership
2:34
at the helm. David,
2:36
everything Hermes does is just so
2:39
focused and intentional and pure,
2:43
as much as they get lumped together
2:45
with brands owned by LVMH. They are,
2:47
in many ways, the anti-LVMH. Oh,
2:50
we've got a great discussion of that later in the
2:52
episode. I used to think that, and I no longer
2:54
think that. But after our
2:56
LVMH episode, you were so inspired by learning
2:58
about Hermes, you went out and you bought your
3:01
first luxury object. It was not an
3:03
LVMH brand. Yes, that is true. My
3:05
wife and I were on our honeymoon,
3:07
listeners, after LVMH the last summer. And
3:10
we were in Aix-en-Provence. And we walked by an
3:12
Hermes store. And I thought, would this be a
3:14
great time to go in and get each other
3:16
something as a honeymoon gift? My
3:18
wife got a little twilly scarf. I got
3:21
an Hermes belt. And it's
3:23
the only luxury item I own
3:25
of any luxury brand, traditional luxury
3:27
brand. As foreshadowed on
3:29
our holiday special episode a couple of months ago.
3:32
Well, listeners, if you want to know every time
3:35
an episode drops, you can sign up at
3:37
acquired.fm slash email. You'll get hints at what
3:39
the next episode will be, and follow up
3:41
facts from previous episodes when we learn new
3:43
information. Come discuss this episode
3:45
with us at acquired.fm slash Slack. Come
3:47
check out our second show, ACQ2, where
3:51
we interview founders, investors, and experts, often
3:53
as follow ups to these episodes. And
3:56
before we dive in, we want to briefly
3:58
share that our presenting sponsor this season. is
4:00
JP Morgan, specifically their incredible payments business.
4:02
Yeah, we really uncovered the breadth of
4:04
JP Morgan payments as we went deep
4:06
into industry research for our visa episode
4:08
last year. And just like how we
4:10
say every company has a story, every
4:12
company's story is powered by payments. And
4:14
JP Morgan payments turns out to be
4:16
a part of so many of our
4:18
acquired companies' journeys. So with
4:20
that, the show is not investment advice. David
4:23
and I may have investments in the companies
4:25
we discuss, and this show is for informational
4:27
and entertainment purposes only. David, I
4:29
feel like we're starting before 1837. Yes,
4:32
but not too much before 1837. All
4:34
right, we're not going to like the sort
4:37
of Egyptian invention of the handbag or anything
4:40
like that. Boy, let me tell you, I was tempted.
4:44
Well, if you read the luxury strategy, which
4:46
is great book that we've referenced many times
4:48
on acquired, they start back 50,000 years ago,
4:51
we start in 1801, not
4:54
in Paris, not even in France. You know,
4:57
as we've been talking about the land of
4:59
beauty, luxury, enlightenment,
5:01
where Hermes, of course, was founded
5:03
and is still based today. And
5:06
uniquely, Hermes still does 85%
5:09
of their production by hand by Master Crafts
5:11
people in France, as we will talk a
5:13
lot about. But instead,
5:15
we start in the land of
5:18
hardness and precision, of
5:20
engineering of exactitude, the
5:23
future land of the Porsches of the
5:25
world that is right, Germany.
5:27
A century before the Porsches and
5:29
Volkswagens of the world. Yes.
5:32
Where Thierry Hermes was born in the
5:35
town of Crefield, which is just outside
5:37
of Dusseldorf, where he's
5:39
the sixth child of a family
5:41
of innkeepers. So Hermes, is
5:44
that a German name, a French name?
5:46
Hermes is obviously not a German name.
5:48
I mean, even I know that. Thierry's
5:52
father was French and
5:54
his mother was German. And
5:57
shortly after Thierry is born, he was born in 1801.
6:00
something pretty major
6:02
happens in France and then
6:04
throughout continental Europe that will become very
6:06
very important to our story here and
6:09
that is that Napoleon comes to
6:11
power in France. I mean
6:13
this is the era we're talking about
6:15
here like Napoleon. We finally did it
6:17
here on Acquired. Your AP European history
6:19
class has now merged with business history
6:22
or cover in Napoleon. He is critical
6:24
to what is about to happen here.
6:26
So in the aftermath of the French Revolution
6:29
Napoleon essentially stages a coup, declares
6:31
himself Emperor, first of France, and
6:33
then he basically begins conquering
6:36
all of continental Europe including
6:38
Germany. Now this
6:40
Napoleonic conquest was at
6:43
the same time both the very best
6:45
thing that could happen to young Thierry.
6:47
I mean it leads directly to Hermes
6:50
but also the very worst
6:52
and truly worst is all
6:54
this conquering this glory of France that we're going
6:57
to talk about becomes important to Hermes. That's
6:59
the result of war. So Thierry's
7:01
entire family, his parents, his mom,
7:03
his dad, all five of his
7:05
siblings, they are all killed either
7:08
directly in the Napoleonic wars or by disease
7:10
and famine as a result of this. I
7:12
mean absolutely terrible and
7:15
the result is that Thierry by the
7:17
time he's 20 years old he's an
7:19
orphan. He is the last Hermes left.
7:21
So David 1821, you know
7:23
pretty rough time out the world. Do you
7:26
know who was born in this year 1821 and was also
7:28
an orphan? Oh we have talked about
7:33
them unacquired. Obviously not
7:35
Rockefeller which is where my mind first went because
7:37
we talk a lot about his dad. Yep Louis
7:41
Vuitton himself. Ah ha
7:43
ha he will also come up here in
7:45
a minute. 20 years younger than Thierry Hermes
7:48
but also an orphan. Wow I didn't know
7:50
he was also an orphan. Yep. Wow
7:52
it's just crazy. Two orphans,
7:54
one of whom was German, go
7:57
on to found the two most important most
8:00
French, most luxurious brands
8:03
and really communicators of status in
8:05
the modern world. That's wild. Yeah,
8:08
especially crazy considering they both came
8:10
from nothing. These people who would
8:12
create the monikers of the elite,
8:15
of what would go on to
8:17
be the symbols of wealth and
8:19
nobility, came from nothing
8:21
and were orphans and at
8:23
their greatest aspirations were craftspeople
8:25
for the elite, their own
8:27
servants. Yes. So
8:30
in 1821, Thierry leaves
8:33
Cranfield, leaves Germany. He
8:35
abandons his original kind of destiny as
8:37
an innkeeper and he moves to France,
8:40
not to Paris, but to Normandy
8:42
in the north. And there, he
8:46
becomes an apprentice under
8:48
a master craftsman learning
8:50
the art of écupage
8:52
craftsmanship. Now, écupage is
8:54
the business of outfitting
8:56
horse-drawn carriages. And
8:59
who were the customers of horse-drawn
9:01
carriages, Ben, like you're talking about?
9:03
The nobility. The nobility. Horses
9:06
were extremely important to the world back
9:08
then. The horse was the car. It
9:11
was the Ford F-150. It was the
9:13
Toyota Camry. It was also
9:15
the Rolls-Royce that drew the carriage.
9:18
And only the Rolls-Royces were the
9:20
carriages. So when Thierry
9:22
moves to Normandy and takes up his
9:24
apprentice, he apprentices
9:27
for 16 years. Wow.
9:30
And it's not until 1837 that he finally moves to Paris
9:34
as now a master
9:36
craftsman and opens up
9:38
his own shop in Paris on the
9:40
Rue Bass du Rompart in
9:42
the 9th arrondissement, which that
9:44
whole street today no longer exists.
9:47
And there, he establishes himself
9:49
as really quite
9:51
an exceptional harness maker for
9:54
horse-drawn carriages. Now, it's
9:56
kind of unclear to me at this point if
9:58
he's using the famous... Saddle stitch,
10:01
which becomes so important to
10:03
Hermes. And the reason it's unclear to me is
10:05
because he's not making saddles. Saddles
10:07
are what other people are making. It's
10:10
not that the nobility don't ride
10:12
horses. They do. But
10:14
they ride horses like the elite
10:16
today drive a Ferrari. It's
10:18
not something they do every day. Right.
10:20
Their daily driver is a Bentley because someone
10:23
else is driving them and they have a
10:25
Ferrari for when they occasionally want to drive
10:27
a Ferrari. They'll climb in a saddle occasionally,
10:29
but mostly they're in the carriage. Yeah. So
10:31
when Thierry arrives in Paris in 1837, he
10:34
pretty quickly starts becoming known as
10:37
really the best harness
10:39
maker and carriage outfitter in
10:42
Paris serving the nobility, which
10:44
is pretty impressive. I mean, here he's this
10:46
immigrant from Germany, apprenticed in Normandy. He shows
10:48
up in Paris and all of
10:50
a sudden he's making the best stuff out there.
10:53
Turns out he was just really good at the
10:55
craft. And he
10:57
had exceptionally good timing. We
11:00
spoke about Napoleon a little bit earlier.
11:03
When Thierry finally comes
11:05
to Paris, at this point, Napoleon I
11:07
has been defeated. The Battle of Waterloo.
11:09
That was 1815. France
11:12
has now seesawed through like a
11:14
whole bunch of different republics and the monarchy
11:17
comes back and, you know, it's crazy French
11:19
history stuff. But shortly
11:22
after Thierry returns, Napoleon's
11:25
nephew, Napoleon III,
11:27
stages another coup and
11:30
re-establishes the empire in France. And
11:32
this is super important, Ben, to what
11:34
you were talking about earlier about, hey, this
11:36
guy's an orphan. Louis Vuitton was an orphan.
11:38
How did they become so important? When
11:41
Napoleon III comes to power in France,
11:43
he does two things. One,
11:45
he completely modernizes
11:48
the city. So if
11:50
people have heard of the Baron Osman
11:52
who kind of rebuilt Paris, that happens
11:54
at this time under Napoleon III. They
11:57
transform Paris from a city. medieval city
11:59
with super tight streets. Like if you
12:01
go up to Montmartre, those streets around
12:04
there, that is old Paris. But what
12:06
do you think of the Eiffel Tower,
12:09
the museums, the Grand Boulevard,
12:11
the Champs-Élysées, that's happening right
12:14
at this time. And
12:17
the Baron Osman, he's
12:19
kind of like Robert Moses was in New York
12:21
in the mid 20th century, remaking New York. He
12:24
is given full latitude and
12:27
direction by Napoleon III to
12:30
burn Paris to the ground and
12:32
remake this city as a modern
12:34
city. Fascinating. And
12:36
this is super important for Thierry and
12:38
Hermes for two reasons. One, in the
12:41
old medieval streets in Paris, not
12:43
that many people were going up and
12:46
down them, not that many people were
12:48
gonna see the nobility in their carriages
12:50
in all their finery. Now you've
12:52
got the Champs-Élysées, the Grand Boulevard,
12:54
everything about the sort of gallantry
12:56
of Paris that we know today.
13:00
And it's all on display now. So this
13:02
becomes really important for showing off, for
13:04
signifying your wealth, your status. The
13:07
other kind of related thing here that
13:09
happens with Napoleon and Napoleon III is
13:12
that status is no
13:14
longer just about what you were
13:16
born into. In the
13:18
old system, the nobility, the royalty, it was
13:20
like, look, you're born noble or you're not.
13:22
And it's kind of independent of how much
13:24
money you have or what you do or
13:27
what influence you have. And
13:29
then under Napoleon, he brought in this
13:32
modern idea that you could shift your
13:34
class. I mean, he was essentially a
13:36
nobody and he became the emperor of
13:38
Europe. That'll completely upset the mindset of
13:40
people. Yeah, so all this
13:42
is happening. This is the best
13:44
thing that could ever happen to Thierry. He's
13:47
the best artisan,
13:49
most exclusive crafter of
13:53
carriagewear, of a cepage. The
13:55
city is being transformed so that this
13:58
can all be displayed prominently. socially
14:01
stratifications are becoming more blurry.
14:03
People can spend money for
14:05
the first time to buy
14:07
status. Great for business. These
14:10
are like the disruption waves that
14:12
enabled him to create a business.
14:15
Yes, before all this, before this
14:17
era, there's no way that this evolves
14:19
into Hermes or honestly that Louis Vuitton and
14:21
what he's doing with luggage and with trunks.
14:24
There's no way that that evolves into Louis
14:26
Vuitton. So speaking of, both
14:29
Hermes and Vuitton have
14:33
one really important client,
14:36
a key influencer, so to speak, that
14:38
they both land at this time. I
14:41
remember Louis Vuitton's key client was
14:43
the Empress Eugenie. Is Hermes the
14:45
same client? Yes, the
14:47
same client. So Napoleon III's
14:50
wife, the Empress Eugenie, becomes
14:53
a client of
14:55
both of these men. For her
14:57
carriages, in the case of Hermes, and
14:59
for her luggage and for her trunks, and
15:01
actually I think also for her packing.
15:03
I think Louis Vuitton was the royal laitier,
15:06
I believe, and he packed the trunks. He
15:08
was the luggage guy, Hermes was the carriage guy.
15:11
Which is so funny because that is still in
15:14
some ways both of their legacy today. Yes,
15:17
absolutely. Eugenie and everything going on
15:19
at this time makes
15:21
Louis Vuitton and makes Thierry
15:24
Hermes. But it's
15:26
interesting, right? Vuitton and
15:29
luggage, that is inherently
15:31
of the world that's coming, the modern
15:33
world. The train, that exists at
15:35
this point in time, steam engines are a
15:37
thing, and then the car is about to
15:39
come. And Louis Vuitton and
15:41
trunks and luggage, it all translates directly. Right,
15:43
it's sort of built for the upcoming world.
15:46
Yes. Not the case
15:48
with Hermes. And actually
15:50
today, I think this is one of
15:53
the biggest strengths of
15:55
Hermes, and they still, you know, the
15:57
Equestrian theme, the horse, is
15:59
so much. of their brand, they talk about it
16:01
so much of their products, the saddle stitching, it's
16:04
calling back to that
16:07
other era, like that pre-modern
16:09
era where the horse was primary.
16:12
Right. Hermes is deeply rooted in
16:14
French history and Parisian history and
16:17
really a key part of how
16:20
France as a nation has
16:22
the identity that it has today. But
16:26
it would all be irrelevant if
16:28
the brand didn't translate out of the horse
16:30
era and into the car. Which
16:33
was not Thierry Hermes is doing, nor
16:36
was it his son's doing. So Thierry
16:38
dies in 1878 and
16:41
his son Charles Émile takes
16:43
over. Now he
16:46
apprenticed coming up in the shop
16:49
in exactly the same way that
16:51
Thierry apprenticed. He just apprenticed for
16:53
his dad. So by the time
16:55
he takes over, he's been working in the shop
16:57
as a craftsman for 20
17:00
years. And by
17:02
the way, this sort of family
17:04
tradition and way of business
17:07
continues to this day. So
17:09
Axel Dumas and Pierre-Alexi Dumas, who
17:11
are the two descendants of Hermes,
17:14
the sixth generation that are running
17:16
the company today, Axel is the
17:18
CEO and Pierre-Alexi is the artistic
17:20
director. They apprenticed in
17:22
the business. When they were teenagers
17:24
for five years after school, they
17:27
went to the atelier, they learned the
17:29
saddle stitch, they made bags, they made
17:31
items with their hands. Now
17:34
obviously they also sort of learned the business
17:36
from their parents, but they're not
17:38
learning the business the way that there are
17:40
no children are learning the business at LVMH
17:42
as executives. They're learning with their
17:45
hands as craftspeople how to make this
17:47
stuff, which is wild. Axel is the
17:49
CEO of a $200 billion plus
17:51
company. It's crazy. And to bring it back
17:53
to the late 1800s, I think the
17:55
point you're making here is when
17:58
Charles Emile was apprenticing, There
18:00
was no other example of what
18:03
this company could become. So he thought,
18:05
why don't I carry it on in
18:07
exactly the same manner, Thierry, that you
18:09
did? And so there's not this grand
18:12
ambition to innovate and change with the
18:14
times. It's, well, how do I learn
18:16
exactly your craft, exactly the way you
18:18
do it, and then continue that? Right.
18:21
The business and the craft are intimately
18:24
intertwined. They cannot be separated. And
18:26
this is a playbook theme I want to pull all
18:28
the way forward. But it's so critical to
18:31
understand about Hermes and what really,
18:33
in my mind, differentiates it
18:35
from LVMH. LVMH,
18:37
as we talked about on that episode,
18:40
has world-class, best-in-the-world
18:42
business executives who
18:45
partner with world-class, best-in-the-world
18:47
creatives. At
18:49
Hermes, these are not different
18:52
people. Now, obviously, there is a
18:54
different CEO and artistic director that are both
18:56
members of the same family and who are
18:58
cousins. But in spirit,
19:00
they're cut from the same cloth and
19:02
they apprentice as
19:04
creative craftspeople, and
19:07
they collectively and the family is
19:09
in charge as much of the creative side
19:11
of the house as they are of the
19:13
business side. Yeah, makes sense. So
19:16
back to Charles O'Mearle and the second generation.
19:18
He finally adds saddlery to the
19:21
business. That's his big expansion. He
19:23
adds saddles. Ba-da-na! Ba-da-na!
19:25
Which, again, like as Paris is modernizing,
19:27
as you can now buy
19:30
your way into status, for
19:32
the first time in Paris, you can
19:34
be seen riding in addition
19:36
to carriages. And the
19:38
ideal of what it is to be a
19:41
noble person or a noble person of status
19:43
has changed. It's no longer just,
19:46
oh, I'm a leisurely courtier. It's
19:48
like, no, I'm Baron Osman. I
19:51
am doing things for the
19:53
state, for the country I'm doing big things. It's kind of
19:55
like American in its way in
19:57
the Rockefellers. Right. You're not just famous.
20:00
for being famous. You are famous because you've achieved
20:02
something or you're in the act of achieving something
20:04
or you hold a high office in which you
20:06
were elected or appointed to get a specific goal
20:08
done. You're on the move. You got stuff to
20:10
do and you know, you got to get there.
20:12
Exactly. And you need a saddle for that. So, Charles
20:15
Emile, he adds saddles. And in 1880,
20:18
he moves the workshop in the store
20:20
to Venkat, Rue du
20:23
Fauxberg-Sainte-Honoré. 24, Rue
20:25
du Fauxberg-Sainte-Honoré in the 8th
20:27
Aérendissement of Paris. The
20:29
famous address. The building that is
20:31
today known as Le Fauxberg by
20:34
everybody in the Hermes universe. This
20:37
street and this location is one of the most
20:39
iconic streets in the world, buildings
20:41
in the world, headquarters in the world.
20:43
It was stunning to walk it last
20:45
summer when I was there. You can
20:48
feel the presence of Hermes
20:50
and all the other brands that are
20:52
there. Yeah, the Rue du Fauxberg-Sainte-Honoré is
20:54
where the French presidential residence
20:56
is. It's where the British
20:58
embassy is. It's where French Vogue is today,
21:01
probably because Hermes is there and because
21:03
all of the other luxury flagships are
21:05
there. So, Charles Emile runs
21:07
the business for 25 years. He
21:09
adds saddles. He moves the
21:11
company to the Fauxberg. And
21:14
then in 1902, he
21:16
retires. And his two
21:18
sons, Adolph and Emile,
21:21
who have apprenticed in the business just like
21:23
him, just like every generation will do for
21:25
many generations to come. They
21:27
take over and they change the name of
21:30
the company to Hermes Frere. Hermes
21:32
Brothers, because the two brothers are
21:34
now running the company. And they're going to do this
21:36
forever together. And they're going to be thick as thieves.
21:39
And they are of one mind on how this
21:41
company should go. They've been apprenticed together. They're going
21:44
to be like, Accel and Pierre Alexei today. Well,
21:47
of the two brothers, I think it is fair
21:50
to say that Emile, who I believe is
21:52
the younger brother, is the sort
21:54
of much more ambitious and much more
21:56
adventurous one. There's this great
21:58
story that in the late... 1890s,
22:01
so before his father Charles Emile retires,
22:03
the young Emile sets off to
22:06
conquer Russia for Hermes. He literally
22:08
like gets on a train with
22:10
a notebook and a suitcase filled
22:12
with miniature versions of the saddles
22:14
and the harnesses that Hermes makes,
22:17
and he just finds his way into the
22:19
Czar of Russia's court and
22:21
lands him as a customer. That
22:24
is wild. Unreal. They have to staff
22:26
up a whole new atelier with like
22:28
80 craftspeople to fulfill all the orders
22:30
for the Czar in Russia. Whoa. Yeah.
22:33
So this is Emile. He's going places.
22:36
And right as he and Adolf are taking
22:38
over, kind of at the end of Charles
22:40
Emile's tenure, they decide to introduce
22:42
a new product. Now, they're not thinking that this
22:44
is going to be a big thing at the
22:46
time, but some of their
22:49
customers, again, now that they've added
22:51
saddles, once they get off
22:53
the horse, they want something to carry
22:55
the saddle and maybe they're riding boots
22:57
with them while the horse is in
22:59
the stables at wherever they're going. So
23:01
they say, great, we can help you with this. And
23:04
they introduce the haute aqua bag,
23:07
which translates as the high belted
23:09
bag to carry saddles
23:12
and boots for their clients.
23:14
Now, like I'm saying here, this was
23:17
intended to be an accessory to the
23:19
main business of incubage and
23:21
saddles, the equestrian business. It's
23:24
not really practical for anything else. I don't know
23:26
why anybody else would want a big tote bag
23:28
that could carry your boots. What's this
23:30
bag look like? Well, this bag looks
23:32
exactly like the Birkins and the Kelly's today, except a
23:34
lot bigger. Interesting.
23:36
Because you're putting a whole saddle
23:38
in it, like you're de-saddling your horse, and
23:41
then you're putting that in this bag. Yeah,
23:43
but it has the same trapezoid
23:45
shape. It has the crossover
23:47
belt, the haute aqua. It means the high
23:50
belted bag. It has the belt. It
23:52
has the turnstile lock closure for
23:54
the belt at the top of
23:56
the bag. Fascinating. So this accessory
23:58
that we're going to add
24:00
to the business. This becomes the
24:02
spiritual heritage to the business
24:05
today. That's crazy. It's like
24:07
if Apple eventually transitioned to being not
24:10
the Vision Pro company, but the Vision
24:12
Pro carrying case company. Yes. Yes. Yes.
24:15
Oh, did you get the carry case, by the way? No, I'm
24:17
not going to spend another $200 on that. That
24:20
thing looks like a balloon. It's enormous.
24:22
Yes. And it takes up your whole
24:24
backpack. This bag,
24:26
this accessory that would become
24:28
the Kelly and then the Birkin, they
24:31
introduced it just at
24:33
the right time. It's 1902, kind
24:36
of as Charles O'Neill is
24:38
retiring. And this idea of
24:40
this bag that you would put stuff in, because
24:42
you wouldn't bring a bag on a train. If
24:44
you're of this class, you need a trunk, a
24:47
flat pack trunk that Louis Vuitton is going to
24:49
make for you. And none
24:51
of these three men could have
24:54
seen it at the time, but this
24:56
accessory to the real business
24:58
of saddles and horses and harnesses was
25:01
going to become the perfect transition
25:03
to move Hermes into the age
25:05
of the automobile. But before
25:07
we tell that story. Yes. We
25:09
mentioned Hermes founded in 1837 is the
25:11
oldest company we've covered on Acquired, but
25:14
we might have to caveat that. Yes.
25:16
Our presenting partner this season is JP Morgan
25:19
payments and JP Morgan Chase traces its heritage
25:21
back to 1799. Over 200 years. Incredible. You
25:23
only survive as long as Hermes or JP
25:29
Morgan with a relentless focus on the
25:31
long term and exceptionally high
25:33
quality bar and counterintuitively when talking
25:35
about handbags and banks, technical innovation,
25:38
which is exactly the JP Morgan
25:40
payments story. Yeah. Their current
25:42
payments business was officially forged a few
25:44
years ago, but many of the
25:46
capabilities and products came from different parts of
25:49
the firm, which were already powering the whole
25:51
payments industry. You can trace their
25:53
merchant acquiring to the nineties, their treasury
25:55
products to well before then, and even
25:57
their blockchain work started earlier than most.
26:00
in the mid 2010s. When they
26:02
combined all that together under one
26:04
group, it really became a one
26:06
of a kind end of one
26:08
business, a portfolio of treasury, online
26:10
commerce, point of sale, global trade,
26:12
card, cash management, fraud prevention, analytics,
26:14
and more. A one
26:16
stop payment shop for businesses of all sizes.
26:18
Yep. And when you move $10 trillion a
26:20
day in 160 countries and
26:24
120 currencies, these learnings really compound.
26:26
And that is exactly the story
26:28
of their new offering embedded banking.
26:30
This actually reminds me a bit
26:32
of our episode on Amazon and
26:34
AWS on how companies can take
26:36
internal capabilities and scale them externally
26:38
as brand new products. In this
26:40
case, JP Morgan said, Hey, we
26:42
already facilitate credit card acceptance. We
26:44
manage KYC and anti money laundering.
26:46
We pool money and split across virtual
26:48
ledgers here. We disperse funds. Oh, wow.
26:50
We can embed all of these into
26:53
our customers marketplace businesses to power their
26:55
end to end payments for buyers and
26:57
sellers and lower risk across the whole
26:59
ecosystem. So while Hermes explicitly
27:01
avoids e commerce for their most coveted products,
27:03
as we will talk about later, for
27:06
the other 99% of you out
27:08
there, that's probably not your strategy. You
27:11
want to do more business online. Large
27:13
retailers are increasingly adopting a digital marketplace
27:15
strategy to connect buyers and sellers directly.
27:17
But for the underlying platform, whether that's
27:19
B2C or B2B, there's a lot of
27:22
complexities that come with having a friction
27:24
less payments experience, you have to create
27:26
and manage the seller bank accounts, money
27:28
movement, and most importantly, who's going to
27:30
take on the compliance and risk of
27:32
holding and dispersing the funds, the third
27:34
party seller or the platform? Yep.
27:37
Macy's is a great example. They wanted
27:39
to offer more selection to customers and
27:41
support diverse owned small businesses at the
27:43
same time. But Macy's needed a solution
27:45
to onboard sellers seamlessly and manage the
27:48
state by state complexity of the payouts.
27:50
So they turned to JP Morgan payments
27:52
and their embedded banking solutions, which
27:54
enables a large number of suppliers
27:56
and their bank account details on
27:58
a single platform supported by tokenization
28:00
and utilizing a single API integration. This
28:03
frictionless and secure payment solution worked to
28:05
say the least. Macy's nearly doubled its
28:07
marketplace sellers in the first quarter of
28:09
2023 and increased revenue by 50%. So
28:14
whether you're in retail, luxury, or
28:16
really any industry, there's a clear
28:18
growth opportunity from having an end-to-end
28:20
payment solution. Head on over to
28:22
jpmorgan.com/acquired to discover more payment solutions
28:25
driving growth for businesses, whether that's
28:27
Fortune 500, startups, or
28:29
any stage in between. And also,
28:31
if you're heading to the retail conference Shop
28:33
Talk in Las Vegas in March, be sure
28:35
to stop by the J.P. Morgan Payments booth
28:37
where you can learn more directly from their
28:39
team of experts. Yep. Thank
28:41
you, J.P. Morgan. Now, David,
28:44
how was Hermes perfectly positioned for
28:46
the age of the automobile with
28:48
this new accessory? So
28:50
this is wild. I suspect
28:52
you probably also found this in research, but
28:56
when I did, my mind melted.
28:59
So during World War I in 1916, Emil
29:03
becomes a officer in the French
29:05
military, and the military sends
29:07
him to the United States to learn about
29:09
kind of U.S. industrial and military production. You
29:12
know, he's sort of a leading
29:14
industrialist in France at this time, shall
29:16
we say? And one
29:19
of the people that he gets sent to meet with
29:21
is, do you
29:23
know about this, Ben? No, I have no idea. I can't
29:25
believe you didn't find this. No. He meets
29:28
with Henry Ford. No!
29:31
He goes to Detroit. He sees the
29:33
assembly lines. He sees the
29:35
car. He sees the future. He
29:37
sees the assembly lines, and then he like had blinders
29:39
on. He's like, oh, pay no attention to the manufacturing
29:42
efficiencies they've got going on over there. Ha
29:44
ha ha! This is what's so funny.
29:46
No, he's like, this is unbelievable. And
29:49
to the, you know, manufacturing efficiencies point,
29:51
he actually does take some elements of
29:53
the assembly lines and brings
29:56
them back to Hermes. It's not like
29:58
they're anti-efficiency. They're pro-efficiency. efficiency,
30:01
but in the context of being
30:03
a craft, you know, non-mechanized human
30:06
master craftsman built object. So
30:08
he actually does take some of the production
30:11
ideas from Henry Ford, but
30:13
more importantly, he's
30:15
looking at this place and he's like, my God,
30:18
there is a Model T rolling off
30:21
the assembly line every three minutes.
30:24
Ford at this point is producing
30:26
half a million cars per year.
30:29
Everybody knew about the automobile, but this is
30:31
a different era. This is kind of the
30:33
same time as when we talked about our
30:35
Novo Nordisk episode about the start of that
30:37
company where like news didn't
30:40
reach Europe. This wasn't a
30:42
global world. And so Emil
30:45
getting this window, like literally seeing
30:47
the assembly lines in Detroit, he's
30:49
like, whoa, once
30:51
this war is over, the world is
30:53
going to change forever. Okay.
30:56
So Emil both figures out how to open
30:58
business in Russia and goes to America, meets
31:00
with Henry Ford, understands the automobile is going
31:02
to change the world. Yeah. He's quite the
31:04
character of this guy. The other
31:06
thing he finds in America is, I know
31:08
you know this one. Yeah. The zipper. Yes.
31:12
Or as it was originally called, the
31:14
clothes all. Yes. Which really does not have the
31:16
same ring to it. I'm glad we changed the zipper.
31:19
I couldn't believe this. The zipper
31:21
was a late 1800s, early 1900s
31:23
invention in America. And it was
31:26
primarily used for industrial use cases.
31:28
In this case, it was zipper
31:30
enclosed, the hood of a car. I
31:33
think like a military car. Yeah. Where Emil first
31:35
sees it. It's not at the Ford factory. I
31:37
think it actually might've been in Canada on the
31:39
later leg of his journey where he sees it
31:41
on the car. It was also
31:43
used for opening and closing boots. And
31:46
that is how the name zipper
31:48
came to be. I think it was the
31:50
BF Goodrich company. Really? Yeah. I believe they
31:52
made a brand of boot with this clothes
31:55
all function and they called it the zipper.
31:57
And that's where the zipper came from. Regardless.
32:00
And needless, enterprising young Emil, he tracks
32:02
down the inventor of the zipper, like
32:04
the holder of the patent in America.
32:07
He obtains an exclusive license for two
32:09
years in France. This literally is like
32:11
the Novo Nordisk episode. Totally. Brings
32:13
it back to France and makes the
32:16
first zippered products. He makes
32:18
the first zippered jacket ever
32:20
created anywhere in the world.
32:22
It is a leather golf jacket for the
32:24
British Duke of Windsor, the heir to the
32:26
throne. Just amazing. In
32:29
France, the zipper would be called the
32:31
Hermes Fastener in France. Yes,
32:34
that's right. Just a while. I
32:37
think they made the right decision
32:39
not to make zippers the business
32:41
and instead to stay focused on
32:43
leather kids. It does show their
32:45
penchant for innovation. The idea
32:47
that we can push the envelope forward
32:49
in functionality and what people would be
32:51
willing to wear. I mean, this guy's
32:53
a Duke and he's wearing a zippered
32:55
jacket. I'd imagine that drew some
32:57
eyes at first. Yeah, and a golf jacket
32:59
literally for use while playing golf, while playing
33:02
sport. What more modern activity to
33:04
happen here? Yep. Regardless
33:06
though, the big thing for Hermes that he brings
33:08
back is, oh my God, the car is
33:10
coming. Okay, so we're still
33:13
in the third generation of the
33:15
Hermes family. Two brothers are
33:17
running it. What's next? When
33:19
Emil comes back and he's
33:21
running around making zippered jackets,
33:23
he's collaborating with car companies,
33:27
leads to a rift between the two brothers.
33:29
Adolph, the older brother, he's much
33:32
more conservative. He wants
33:34
to remain in the horse market.
33:37
He's kind of depressed about the car coming. He's
33:39
like, hey, I just
33:41
want to remain a niche leather worker and
33:43
I'm not really cool with everything you're doing
33:45
here. This is literally like he wants faster
33:47
horses of the analogy of like, if you
33:49
would ask people what they want, they'd say
33:51
a faster horse. He's stuck in horse land.
33:53
Right. I don't know if it was
33:56
that he had his head in the sand or more just like
33:58
he didn't want to go build a big company. which
34:00
I could understand. Totally, I could totally understand
34:02
that. Either way, in 1919,
34:05
Camille buys him out and says,
34:07
I believe in my
34:10
ability to lead this company making this transition
34:12
into the automobile era. And legend
34:14
has it that he goes
34:16
to the craftsman in the
34:18
atelier above the shop in the faux
34:20
board and says, okay,
34:24
what are we gonna do? What
34:26
can we make with our hands
34:28
here in this atelier that will
34:30
interest our clients today? And I think
34:32
this is still kind of legend around our meds
34:35
of like, what can we make
34:37
with our hands that will interest
34:40
our clients today? And the
34:42
obvious answer at the time is a version
34:45
of the Hauta Courois bag. You know,
34:47
it's bags for these cars. And
34:49
if you want the most exquisite
34:52
bags, the most exquisite things to
34:54
show in your automobiles that you're
34:56
buying, who better
34:58
than Hermes? And
35:01
finely handcrafted leather bags
35:03
and accessories that you
35:05
can outfit your car in the same way you could outfit your
35:07
horse. So the business is now
35:09
a meals and the business is now handbags. And
35:12
once again, to timing and
35:15
insight here, kind of like Thierry in the
35:17
original case, what the
35:19
automobile does, and it's not just
35:21
automobiles, it's also improvements to trains
35:24
and improvements to ships. The
35:26
global rich, the
35:28
global elite, they start traveling
35:30
a lot more. You know, we're now
35:33
in the 1920s, the roaring 20s. This is what
35:35
F Scott Fitzgerald is writing about. The
35:38
visible symbols of wealth. It's
35:40
when you're home, it's in your car and the
35:42
bags and the accessories you're using with your car.
35:45
But you're also out traveling a lot
35:47
more. You're rubbing shoulders with elite all
35:50
around the world. The American elite
35:52
are going to France, they're going to Europe,
35:54
vice versa. People are starting to travel around
35:57
the world. People are traveling to Asia. People
35:59
are traveling. traveling to the Middle East,
36:01
people are traveling to South America, Emile's
36:03
going right along with all these people,
36:06
and your luggage, your bags, that's
36:08
what you bring with you. That's what you show. Yeah.
36:11
And importantly, it's not just that you're
36:13
trying to show a label,
36:16
which is a little bit different than the modern
36:18
version of luxury. It's that you're trying to have
36:20
something really nicely crafted. When you show up somewhere,
36:22
someone should just look at your luggage and go,
36:25
wow, that is beautiful. Hermes
36:28
is not yet a
36:30
recognized brand. So merely slapping
36:32
Hermes on it won't do
36:34
the trick. The way to wow the people
36:36
that you want to wow is through
36:38
the raw craftsmanship. The product
36:40
itself, yes. Yep. So
36:44
in 1922, Emile's
36:46
wife famously complains that the
36:48
large bag they've been making,
36:50
the La Tocorua, the saddlebag,
36:53
it's too large to fit through car doors.
36:55
So she asks for a smaller version. And
36:58
this launches the handbag business
37:02
in 1925. And by
37:04
the way, by this point, they've put the
37:06
zipper on a handbag. Yes, exactly. And speaking
37:08
of the zipper, in 1925, they had ready
37:10
to wear clothes, like the legacy of the
37:12
golf jacket here. The legend has
37:14
it that they added clothes because a long time
37:16
client came in and said, I am fed up
37:18
with seeing my horse better dressed than me. Who
37:23
knows if that's true, but it's a
37:25
nice story. But they really go into
37:27
this. In this modern world where the
37:29
global wealthy, the global elite are traveling,
37:32
they're seeing each other. What outward signifiers
37:34
can they supply them? Clothes,
37:36
1927, they had jewelry, 1928,
37:39
they had watches. And
37:42
something interesting that is different than the Hermes
37:44
you know today, the way
37:47
that they're adding all of these things,
37:49
they're finding crafts people who are experts
37:51
at particular crafts. Exactly what you're talking
37:53
about, David, a watchmaker. They're finding a
37:55
watchmaker and they're saying, can we work
37:58
with you on designing something new? uniquely
38:00
Hermes, but you're the craftsperson. We're
38:02
not trying to build this competency in-house. Right.
38:05
It's not right to say that they're
38:07
licensing products. You know, it is a
38:09
collaboration, but they are selling
38:13
products in their stores that
38:15
are not made end-to-end
38:17
by Hermes employed craftsmen.
38:20
Right. And it's interesting,
38:22
because they're sort of towing this line
38:24
between first and foremost
38:26
being a craftsman themselves, and being a
38:28
manufacturer and being a designer, but also
38:31
kind of being a retailer, where they're
38:33
just bringing in other branded goods and
38:35
selling it in their shop. Yes.
38:38
And I think all this is being figured
38:41
out real time. These ideas
38:43
of retailers versus
38:46
brands, it
38:48
was a much fuzzier line then than it
38:50
was today. So what does
38:52
Hermes do? What does Emil do? They
38:55
start opening up stores outside of Paris,
38:58
and where are they gonna go? They're gonna
39:00
go to the travel destinations where their clients are going.
39:02
So the first store is in the Côte des Eures
39:05
in the south of France, and then
39:07
they start opening up more stores around
39:09
the world. You know, again, not
39:11
necessarily in like the London's or the
39:13
Rome's or the New York's of the
39:15
world. They're opening them up in the
39:18
travel destinations. Their mindset around
39:20
additional stores at this point is, it's
39:22
for the same clientele in all the
39:24
places that they travel. Yes.
39:27
And the clientele was primarily French at this
39:29
point in time. Yeah. Or
39:31
if not exclusively. Other than the Czar and
39:34
yeah. I suspect though that it was strategic
39:36
of like, our French clients are
39:38
gonna go to these places. They're gonna rub
39:40
shoulders with the Americans, with the British, and
39:43
then we're gonna have a store there so
39:45
that those Americans, those British elite,
39:47
they can go purchase our
39:49
products there too. Right. This
39:52
by the way is a different retail strategy
39:54
than what they have today. Today, management sort
39:56
of insists that the idea is that each
39:59
store is for the same. the local clientele.
40:01
And we will only expand into an
40:03
area if we feel that we can
40:05
serve the local clientele that lives there
40:08
well. And that's sort of a
40:10
recognition of the maturation of their business. The rich
40:12
people are going to go find an Hermes store
40:14
somewhere. It's easy for them to travel somewhere, buy
40:16
it on vacation. But if we're going to open
40:18
new stores, we should open it in
40:21
places where there is a thriving
40:23
new upper class who can buy the
40:26
goods locally there in their city. Yes.
40:29
Now, I think some
40:31
element of this certainly still exists. You had
40:33
a nice time going into the Hermes store
40:36
in X, right? Yes, for sure. But
40:38
it plays well for me as someone
40:40
who is on vacation and shopping to
40:43
believe that I'm shopping in a store that
40:45
is for the locals. It's less fun to
40:48
be shopping somewhere that is very clearly created
40:50
for you as a tourist. Yeah, I think
40:52
they very brilliantly walk this
40:54
line. And the products that the shops carry
40:56
are very different. And we'll get into that
40:59
later in the episode too. But
41:01
back to this era. So I
41:03
think we've laid the groundwork of a
41:06
few critical components of Hermes so
41:08
far. First and most
41:10
importantly, the craftsmanship. These things are
41:12
handmade by artisans with their hands
41:14
and the family and the people
41:17
who own the company are the
41:19
chief artisans. That goes all the
41:21
way back to Thierry. We've
41:23
talked about the connection to the
41:26
legacy of French nobility, but not really French
41:28
nobility. It's sort of like status, but accessible
41:31
status for the first time in the world
41:33
and the modernization of the world. We've
41:35
talked now here about the true modernization
41:38
of the company and the transition to
41:40
the automobile era. What
41:42
we haven't talked about yet and what Hermes at
41:44
this point certainly is not is
41:48
this element of whimsy
41:50
and art that is
41:52
really, really critical, I think, to
41:54
the company. Plus, if
41:57
you've ever been in an Hermes store.
42:00
you can feel a warmth that
42:02
doesn't exist in other luxury stores.
42:06
If you're in a destination with a lot
42:08
of luxury shops, you'll walk
42:10
past a lot of bright lights and
42:12
mirrors and punch you in the face
42:14
reds and black
42:16
and white and you just feel like there's
42:19
a lot going on. And then you arrive
42:21
at Hermes and it feels
42:23
warm and it feels soft and it
42:25
feels welcoming and it feels
42:28
whimsical. And there's this almost dream-like
42:31
color palette that they use starting
42:33
with a base of orange and
42:35
having this explosive rainbow of fun
42:37
but in some ways it all
42:39
feels natural and from the earth
42:42
and just whimsy. I think that you
42:44
nailed it David whimsical. And this
42:46
I think is really a very different
42:49
thread than the original
42:51
kind of leather craftsmanship and
42:53
it is a critical one in the
42:56
kind of weaving of the Hermes business.
42:59
And this thread comes from the next
43:01
generation of the family, specifically
43:04
Robert Dumas. So a
43:06
meal had four children but
43:09
they were all daughters and tragically
43:11
one died young but the other
43:13
three grew up and they
43:15
got married and back in this day
43:18
women weren't going to take over the
43:20
business unfortunately. Right same story as the New York
43:23
Times. There was a whole generation of daughters. Well none
43:25
of the ox daughters get the business
43:28
and so it goes over to the
43:30
son-in-law of the Solesberger and now it's
43:32
the Solesberger ox family that owns the
43:34
business in the same way that Hermes
43:37
is the Hermes Dumas family. The son-in-law
43:39
tends to do well in this early
43:41
20th century period of passing it down
43:43
from unfortunately father not the daughter but
43:46
father to son-in-law. And in
43:48
this case when you read about the Hermes
43:50
family fortune today it's the Dumas family that
43:52
are obviously the CEO and the artistic director
43:55
that you hear about visibly but
43:57
really I think all the sons-in-laws and
44:00
all of their descendants become active in the
44:02
business. So there's Robert Dumas, there's
44:04
Jean René Guerin, and there's
44:06
Francis Pouche. And these are all son-in-laws. And
44:08
these are all son-in-laws. And those are the
44:10
three family names that you still hear about
44:13
to this day of the Hermes family. But
44:15
back to Robert Dumas and the fourth generation,
44:18
he brings this whimsy and real art
44:20
into the business. And the
44:22
way Hermes describes it today when you read
44:24
their annual report is they talk about their
44:27
trademark humor and imaginative flair. And despite the
44:29
fact that they really are tied to this
44:31
old French elite, they
44:33
really don't take themselves too seriously in
44:35
all their products, especially the entry-level ones.
44:38
I mean, the Birkin is the Birkin.
44:40
Yeah, they'll do some special editions here
44:42
and there, but there's a weight to
44:44
that product line. But there's an
44:46
overall playfulness that's exuded from the brand
44:49
that comes from this era of leadership.
44:51
Totally. And this comes from Robert. So
44:54
one of the first things he does when
44:56
he joins the business is he redesigns the
44:58
kind of smaller Ota Corwa bag, the
45:00
handbag line, into what
45:03
he calls the Sac de Peix in 1935.
45:06
Really great name. It's got a ring to it. I feel
45:09
like that's going to go be a viral hit and appear
45:11
on Sex and the City. Beautiful,
45:14
beautiful, elegant bag. So
45:16
Sac de Peix, hold on to that
45:18
one, listeners. Yep. A little later in
45:21
the 1930s, he introduces the
45:23
Chandonque bracelet, which is another
45:26
iconic Hermes item in there. Great,
45:29
David. I can't let you get away
45:31
with that. Métiers, please enlighten listeners. I
45:34
know Hermes sprinkles around French words in
45:36
all their literature, and it just expects
45:38
Americans to deal with it. If it's
45:40
italicized, it's French, and you can
45:42
go look up what it means yourself. Here on
45:44
Acquired, David, tell us about a métiers. A
45:47
métiers is like someone's
45:49
work, but in the craftsman sense.
45:51
A métiers is like a trade.
45:53
It's like a craft profession. And
45:56
this is what Hermes calls their
45:58
divisions. I feel gross. even just
46:00
saying the word divisions. There are
46:02
16 of them today, and jewelry,
46:05
of course, is one of the métiers.
46:07
Oh, I feel so much better saying métiers. I bet,
46:09
yeah. There's a levity here in the room now. So
46:12
chandanca in French means chain of anchors,
46:14
you know, anchor chain. And these are
46:16
anchors like boat anchors. And
46:19
the way that this bracelet comes
46:21
about is Robert is walking along
46:23
the beach in Normandy one day, and
46:26
he's just inspired by the scene of these
46:28
boat anchors on this foggy beach. And so
46:30
he makes a little little sketch in his
46:32
notebook, and then he plays with it. And
46:35
then he decides he's going to turn this
46:37
into a bracelet. Love it. And
46:39
so an important thing to know here
46:41
is when you're buying Hermes
46:43
products, they're really not
46:45
pushing the brand. There
46:48
is not an iconic
46:50
recognizable Hermes H, or
46:53
horse and carriage logo or bright
46:56
color that you're supposed to identify.
46:58
This is really the origin of
47:00
quiet luxury, where Hermes is handcrafting
47:03
the highest quality product they can make.
47:06
A single artisan is
47:08
the person making the good. And, you
47:10
know, when you receive it, you really
47:12
are just aware that it's the highest
47:14
quality thing made by a single person
47:16
with their blood, sweat, tears, love, a
47:19
piece of them left inside. And
47:22
it's super different than luxury
47:24
today because it is just
47:26
not branded. And Hermes hadn't
47:28
even really developed the iconography
47:31
yet that would become Hermes's
47:33
version of, you know, slightly louder luxury. Over
47:35
the years, if you sort of look at
47:38
products now, the belts have an H, you
47:40
know, they incorporate horse motifs into designs on
47:42
their ready to wear clothing, but that really
47:44
wasn't a thing yet in this era. Hermes
47:47
is on the lighter side of branding
47:49
their goods today, but it's still... Well,
47:51
they have to adapt to the market.
47:53
The customers want some way to let
47:55
people know that they're wearing an Hermes
47:58
item, even if it's lower key. than
48:00
other luxury brands. So Hermes builds that
48:02
for them. The family talks about
48:04
this a lot. The words
48:06
they use is, this is not a museum. There
48:09
is this artistic element to what we do, but
48:12
we are not a museum. We are a
48:14
business and we have clients and we are
48:16
here to serve our clients. There
48:18
is this push-pull here. Yes.
48:21
Okay, so what year are we that the bracelet
48:23
is entering the market? That was in the mid-30s.
48:26
Then in 1937, Robert introduces the other key pillar
48:28
of Hermes' product
48:34
that is less talked about today
48:36
relative to the bags and the leather goods,
48:38
but for many, many decades was the bigger
48:41
business. Oh, yes, I
48:43
have numbers on this. So silk
48:46
scarves, the Hermes
48:48
classic silk scarves.
48:50
This is the embodiment of this art and whimsy
48:52
that we're talking about. The silks
48:54
that they use are the finest silks in
48:56
the world. It takes 300
48:59
silk moth cocoons per scarf, as
49:01
they will readily tell you to
49:03
produce these things. But
49:05
the designs on them, the
49:07
artwork on them, are whimsical.
49:09
Like we said, so the first design, the
49:12
Jeux des omnibus et dans blanche, where these
49:14
sort of white ladies at play, I guess
49:16
you could translate that, is based
49:18
on a wood block engraving that
49:21
Robert does. I mean, this is like what an
49:23
artist this guy is. He's about to become CEO
49:26
of Hermes, but he's
49:28
making wood block engravings, and then making silk
49:30
scarves out of them. That's the
49:32
first design that they put out there, and quickly they
49:34
become a huge, huge
49:37
phenomenon with Hermes' clients. Yeah,
49:40
and so fast forward all the way to 1988, when
49:44
Excel Dumas has his very first internship
49:46
with the company. This
49:48
is crazy. Silk was
49:50
55% of
49:53
the company's sales. Leather was only 9%.
49:56
You compare that to today, it is
49:58
a completely different story. Leather
50:01
is 43% and
50:03
silk and textiles is 7%. So
50:05
there was a run, I mean this was introduced when David? The
50:07
30s? 1937. So 1937 through probably the 1990s where the silk scarves
50:16
were the Hermes franchise. And
50:18
the reason this sort of took
50:20
off is it almost became part
50:23
of the French woman's uniform to
50:25
have an Hermes scarf as a
50:27
part of your outfit. Well,
50:29
it's funny you say the French woman's
50:31
uniform. Yes, that is entirely true. But
50:34
the woman who really popularizes
50:36
them around the globe is
50:38
a British woman, specifically Queen
50:40
Elizabeth. Oh, I didn't realize that
50:43
really. Yeah, this is so iconic
50:45
Queen Elizabeth. She starts wearing
50:47
them as head scarves in the 1940s.
50:50
And I mean Queen Elizabeth, she's Queen of England for
50:52
what, like 60, 70 years.
50:54
Yeah. And she's wearing these scarves,
50:56
these whimsical playful scarves on her
50:59
head as the Queen of England.
51:02
Fascinating. So this is a
51:04
good time to talk about how these silk
51:06
scarves are made. And I was going to
51:08
do this later when we talk about their
51:10
modern day production process. But it
51:12
turns out that their modern day production process is
51:15
not that different than it used to
51:17
be. So here's how Hermes scarves are
51:19
made today. They are first
51:22
sourcing the finest silk that they
51:24
can find, which is now from
51:26
their own owned farms
51:29
in Brazil. So that's where the silk comes
51:31
from. Only 20 new
51:34
designs are created every year and they
51:36
retire old designs. There's sort of a
51:38
Disney vault aspect to this. They'll bring
51:40
them out of the vault. Yeah. The
51:43
pipeline to get a new design into
51:45
the customer's hands is two
51:47
years. Now you might be
51:49
asking yourself like, come on, why is
51:51
this taking two years? This is a ridiculous thing.
51:54
Here is the process. They
51:56
screen print every single scarf
51:59
by hand. There's no digital process
52:01
here. It's not like you're going to
52:03
custom-make.com and ordering up some Hermes Scarf.
52:05
Right. Some of the design does
52:07
seem like it involves computers now. If you watch
52:09
documentaries about the craftsmen at Hermes, which there's a
52:12
couple of good ones we'll link to in the
52:14
show notes, if you want to just sort of
52:16
watch Hermes craft people at work, they
52:19
do seem to be translating designs off
52:21
of a computer. But it's not like
52:23
they're hitting Command P. That's not how
52:25
this works. Every single
52:27
color of the scarf is
52:29
screen-printed using its own mask or basically
52:32
a stencil. So if your scarf has
52:34
20 colors, it has at least
52:36
20 masks that they
52:38
then squeegee the ink over, and
52:41
the precision is perfect. This
52:43
is like EUV lithography. Yes. I was
52:45
looking at my wife's sort of twilly
52:47
scarf, the little wrist or
52:49
hair tie scarf that we got at next on Provence. I
52:52
mean, I don't know how you do this
52:54
by hand. And I don't know how you do it by hand
52:56
20 times over and over and
52:58
over for every single layer. If
53:01
you've ever been to an Hermes store or you own
53:03
one of these, you just can't believe that this is
53:05
done by hand without any of the layers being out of
53:07
alignment. Because if any of them are out of alignment,
53:09
you ruin the whole thing and you have to start
53:11
over. And so if
53:13
that's not enough, the masks are
53:15
also hand-etched by a craftsperson. Their
53:18
entire job is to know how to translate
53:20
a design into all
53:22
the different color layers, which
53:24
they then hand-etched. So the
53:26
pipeline is designer, engraver,
53:29
that's an engraver of
53:31
each mask, colorist, weaver,
53:34
printer, and then someone to do the
53:36
finishing. All of which are like
53:39
extremely hard to replicate
53:41
and involve both extreme
53:43
craftsmanship and extreme taste.
53:45
The competitive barriers to the Hermes scarf,
53:48
I think they're way higher than the
53:50
bags, honestly, even though the bags are
53:52
a bigger business now. Even the skills
53:54
are completely non-transferable. This process doesn't really
53:56
exist, certainly not at scale at any
53:58
other company. I was talking
54:00
to my wife about this. She brought up
54:03
the idea that it's kind of like Disney
54:05
Imagineers, or almost like Pixar employees, where you
54:07
specialize in this one crazy little piece of
54:09
the production process that no other company has
54:11
your same production process. And the
54:13
attention to detail is so staggering
54:15
that once you enter the Hermes
54:17
universe, then you're sort of in
54:20
that universe for the rest of your career,
54:22
because that is where your trade is still
54:24
practiced. And I think also, you know, as
54:27
a client too, at least in Scarves, like
54:29
if you enter the Hermes Scarves universe, you're
54:31
not buying any other Scarves. Totally. And
54:33
you really like all the lore. Part
54:36
of what makes Hermes Hermes at this
54:38
point is their callbacks to their own
54:40
history. I mean, they have 187
54:42
years of history to call upon,
54:44
and they do so over and
54:46
over and over again, and they
54:48
remix and they name things
54:50
after stores that used to exist
54:52
at certain addresses. It's a universe.
54:54
Yeah. I mean, I remember growing up
54:56
and my mom is half British, I'm a quarter British,
54:59
and to the Queen Elizabeth thing,
55:01
Hermes Scarves, you know, my mom's Hermes
55:03
Scarves were an R among her most
55:05
treasured items. Yep. So
55:08
you'll note all of this that's
55:11
happening, Robert, the innovations, these
55:13
new products, the art, the whimsy.
55:16
He's doing all this in the 1930s.
55:18
This is the Great Depression era.
55:21
This tells you about Hermes and
55:23
Hermes clients. They are
55:26
unaffected. They
55:29
keep buying. And this carries through right to this
55:31
day. I mean, I don't know that there is
55:33
a more recession
55:35
insulated business than
55:38
Hermes. You're exactly right. 12 months
55:41
now after we did the LVMH episode,
55:43
we're finally on the tail end of
55:45
the sort of pandemic bubble of luxury.
55:47
And we're seeing a lot of these
55:50
brands take a hit. Hermes is the
55:52
most insulated of all the luxury brands,
55:54
where they have these sort of least
55:56
cost sensitive clients. So after this, there's
55:58
World War Two. And famously,
56:01
before the war, Hermes products
56:03
came in cream colored boxes.
56:06
Robert was very meticulous about
56:08
the packaging that his crafted
56:10
items and his art would
56:12
come in. And it was
56:14
cream. It had to be cream. During
56:16
the war, there's a shortage
56:19
of packaging materials. They can't get cream.
56:21
The only color that is available to them
56:23
in the quantities that they need is
56:26
orange. That was designed for patisseries,
56:28
for bakeries. Oh, is that what the orange
56:30
ones were used for? That's why there was
56:32
an excess of it, because they were used
56:34
for bakeries, and bakeries weren't baking as many
56:36
croissants and penne au chocolat during the war,
56:38
etc. There's all this
56:41
orange packing material. Robert
56:43
embraces it. And Hermes' orange
56:46
box is born. And this is
56:48
crazy. I didn't know this whole research. Hermes
56:51
owns this color. You cannot
56:53
get Hermes orange anywhere else. Pantone
56:55
does not list it in their
56:58
colors. It's interesting you say
57:00
Hermes owns this color. So you
57:02
are correct that Hermes has selected
57:04
a non-pantone color. But
57:07
what Hermes tries to do is say, well,
57:09
we own orange. We can't
57:11
be nailed down by
57:13
a Pantone-specific code. We
57:16
own orange more broadly. And they've actually
57:18
gone head-to-head with the EU. And this
57:20
has gone to court, where it's been
57:22
determined that, no, you can't own orange.
57:24
You can't just own all the oranges.
57:27
Amazing. And so what they've done is
57:29
they've actually leaned into this, where there
57:32
is a classic Hermes orange,
57:34
but it presents differently on
57:37
each of the leathers. They have
57:39
10 different leathers or something like
57:41
that that they work with. When they dye those
57:43
leathers, it presents a little bit differently. And so
57:45
they sort of have this, sure,
57:48
there's a digital, perfect representation
57:50
of the color of classic
57:52
orange. But there's this whole
57:54
spectrum of the way that it shows up
57:56
on leather. And they've sort of even further
57:59
kind of winked at all of
58:01
us by creating five or six other
58:03
oranges. They have Hermes Fue,
58:05
which is sort of the fire. They
58:08
have Hermes Sanguine, which is sort of
58:10
this red, hot orange, like lava. Or
58:13
they have the Hermes Moutard, which is sort
58:15
of their mustard. And each of these is
58:17
a little bit of, I think
58:19
it's to continue to assert that we
58:21
own the whole spectrum of oranges, but
58:24
it's definitely to be able to stay
58:26
current, stay present, encapsulate the theme of
58:28
a season, because every year they sort
58:30
of pick a theme. And so they play with
58:32
their oranges a little bit to evoke the whimsy
58:34
that they want from this year's theme. Yeah, there's
58:37
this sort of like, you know,
58:39
meta level or like corporate level playfulness to
58:41
this too of, we own all the oranges.
58:43
Totally. The Hermes oranges are almost like,
58:45
to continue the Disney analogy, it's almost like the people that
58:47
go to the park and look for the hidden mickeys. It's
58:50
a way to even more deeply participate in
58:52
the Hermes universe. So a
58:55
few other things that Robert adds over
58:57
the years, he adds the men's silks
58:59
matie, aka ties.
59:02
The legend behind that one is pretty great. Supposedly
59:05
in Cannes, a number of
59:07
gentlemen were refused entry to the
59:09
casino and thus went to
59:11
the neighboring Hermes shop, you know, next
59:13
door and said, can you take
59:15
some of your beautiful silk scarves and cut
59:18
and tailor them into ties for us so that we can
59:20
enter the casino? I'm
59:22
sure that's apocryphal, but adds to the legend
59:24
here. And they are these patterns, you know,
59:26
they're just as intricate as the scarves. There's
59:28
less storytelling that happens in the tie. The
59:30
scarves tend to be something you could frame
59:33
and put on the wall and look at
59:35
in 16 different ways and the
59:37
story behind it. But it's still, I
59:40
mean, when you look at it, you kind of can't
59:42
believe that it was hand screen printed. Totally.
59:45
After World War II, Robert decides
59:48
that Hermes needs a logo. So
59:50
taking inspiration from the 19th century
59:53
painting, Le Duc atlais groom all'attente,
59:55
which means hitched carriage waiting groom,
59:58
the famous Hermes logo. is
1:00:01
born, the logo is the callback
1:00:03
to the carriage. It's the
1:00:05
nobility. I find it really interesting, especially
1:00:07
at that point in time that
1:00:10
Robert decided, you could imagine
1:00:12
a galloping horse or something like that
1:00:14
would be the appropriate logo. No, it's
1:00:17
so genius. No, it's the carriage. Yes,
1:00:19
it's to intentionally ground
1:00:21
the brand in history, in something
1:00:23
that they were a part of
1:00:25
that is only theirs
1:00:27
because nobody else starting today is gonna
1:00:29
have that as a part of their
1:00:31
history. They're leaning into the thing that
1:00:33
makes them unique, special, the almost like
1:00:35
defensible, durable asset that they have is
1:00:37
that they participated in that era that
1:00:39
has a nostalgia about it. And no
1:00:42
longer exists. Yes. Horses
1:00:44
in the Achestrion world still exists. It's obviously
1:00:46
not what it once was, but it
1:00:49
still exists. The carriage world
1:00:51
is gone. It's just a
1:00:54
dream these days. And that's what Robert is
1:00:56
so good at, this dream. The
1:00:58
other thing we have to talk about are
1:01:00
the window displays. You referenced this a little
1:01:02
bit earlier. So he hires
1:01:04
first Annie Bomel, and then she's
1:01:06
soon joined by the legendary Leila
1:01:09
Manchari. Specifically these two
1:01:11
women, they come from theater set design.
1:01:14
Just to design the window
1:01:16
displays at the foreboard, at
1:01:19
the flagship store on the Rufo Borg Saint-Honoré.
1:01:22
I mean, there are a whole
1:01:24
museum exhibits just dedicated to these
1:01:26
window displays. And it's not like,
1:01:29
again, you walk by XYZ other
1:01:33
store, even the most prestigious brands, and
1:01:35
it's like the products are there. Here's
1:01:37
the products, here's the brand you're buying,
1:01:39
here's the LV, et cetera. These
1:01:42
displays, it's a dream. There
1:01:44
are probably some Hermes products in there,
1:01:47
but it's like a museum exhibit. It's
1:01:49
artwork. Yes, and art
1:01:51
is exactly the right way to put
1:01:53
it. There is no utility to these
1:01:55
displays. Much like any
1:01:58
advertising that you see of Hermes. today.
1:02:00
It's not about the product, it's
1:02:02
about how you feel.
1:02:05
So I think this is an interesting
1:02:07
place to revisit this idea
1:02:09
that we talked about on the
1:02:11
LVMH episode of luxury versus premium,
1:02:14
where premium means you pay more and you
1:02:16
get more utility out of a given product.
1:02:19
I pay for a bigger storage space on
1:02:21
my iPhone and I get, you
1:02:23
know, more utility out of that. I can store
1:02:26
more photos. Luxury means you pay more literally because
1:02:28
it doesn't create more utility.
1:02:30
It is either more pleasing to you
1:02:32
intrinsically for the feeling or it's an
1:02:35
extrinsic signal where you are signaling to
1:02:37
others that you have the
1:02:39
means to spend on this item even
1:02:41
though it doesn't provide
1:02:43
more utility. It's a sort of
1:02:46
despite rather than a because. But
1:02:48
art, it does fall on this spectrum.
1:02:51
Art is like luxury taken to
1:02:53
its logical extreme. It
1:02:55
has actually zero utility. A
1:02:58
Birken bag is a piece of art,
1:03:00
but at least it also carries your
1:03:02
stuff around. Luxury products are this interesting
1:03:04
midpoint between extreme functionality, but
1:03:06
also artwork. And so when you buy
1:03:08
an Hermes product, you aren't just buying
1:03:10
the product, you're buying a piece of
1:03:12
art, a piece of their heritage, a
1:03:15
feeling that connects you to the maker and
1:03:17
the place it was created. You're trying to
1:03:19
buy a piece of Hermes's heritage and reputation
1:03:22
and hoping to adopt it as a part of
1:03:24
you, as a part of your identity. And
1:03:26
you are seeking, whether it's conscious or not,
1:03:29
to let other people know about
1:03:31
this too. And you're not necessarily trying to signal
1:03:33
it to everyone, but you do want to signal
1:03:35
it to the right people who would appreciate it.
1:03:38
There's this genius aspect too to what Hermes is
1:03:40
doing and what Robert's doing with
1:03:42
the arts like these window displays. The
1:03:44
luxury strategy book talks a lot about
1:03:47
this. When you're
1:03:49
selling luxury items, they
1:03:52
can't just be art. They need to have some
1:03:54
utility to them. You will
1:03:56
never see any of these brands, Hermes
1:03:58
included, become art galleries. They're not
1:04:00
selling paintings, but it's
1:04:03
critical for luxury brands to have a
1:04:05
connection to the arts. I
1:04:07
think he realized this before anybody of
1:04:09
like the windows in our stores are
1:04:12
these portals into this world of
1:04:15
dream and art. And you'll come in and you'll
1:04:17
buy a scarf that you'll wear, you'll
1:04:19
buy a bag that you'll use, maybe you'll
1:04:21
buy a tie, maybe you'll buy a wallet
1:04:24
or homewares or furniture or any of the
1:04:26
other things over time that they sell. And
1:04:29
that will have utility, but it's
1:04:31
connected to this dream. Yes, you're taking
1:04:33
a piece of that dream with you.
1:04:35
And it's almost a daily reminder of
1:04:37
the dream that you're now participating in. The
1:04:40
key insight is that by
1:04:43
adopting art as a
1:04:45
critical piece of the
1:04:48
bundle that is your product, it
1:04:51
enables you as the seller to
1:04:54
completely switch tracks
1:04:56
to disconnect from any
1:04:59
evaluation of value or
1:05:01
features. Exactly. You're out of
1:05:03
the feeds and speeds world. You are
1:05:05
not being comped against, well, this other
1:05:08
purse is much cheaper and serves the
1:05:10
same function. Now we have
1:05:12
bundled in the function
1:05:14
of the object and an
1:05:18
unevaluatable, priceless feeling, a
1:05:20
priceless feeling. And so
1:05:23
now we can sell the
1:05:25
goods for whatever we want, because it's
1:05:27
impossible to know the value of that
1:05:29
second component that we've bundled in. Yeah,
1:05:31
totally. So speaking of
1:05:33
dreams, we're now in the 1950s, in
1:05:36
the post-World War II era, the
1:05:38
most amazing,
1:05:42
unbelievable, fantastical
1:05:44
dream of
1:05:46
the 1950s happens
1:05:49
to Hermes in real life. And
1:05:52
that dream is Princess
1:05:54
Grace Kelly. So
1:05:56
I sort of mentioned a little while back that one
1:05:59
of the first things, that Robert did
1:06:01
when he came into the business was redesign
1:06:03
the handbag and christen
1:06:05
it the Sac de Pache. Well,
1:06:08
it becomes popular but like we're talking
1:06:11
about leather goods, handbags, you know, important
1:06:14
but that kind of was the previous generation of
1:06:16
the business. Now under Robert it's the
1:06:18
scarves, it's the dream, it's all this stuff and leather's
1:06:20
part of it but a smaller part. Well
1:06:22
in 1956
1:06:25
Princess Grace Kelly of Monaco, this
1:06:29
is a girl from Philadelphia, an
1:06:31
American girl who
1:06:34
goes on to become a movie star, who
1:06:37
then goes on to become Princess
1:06:39
Grace of Monaco. I
1:06:41
can't imagine a bigger dream
1:06:43
for any woman or any person in the
1:06:46
1950s. She
1:06:48
is photographed using the Sac
1:06:51
de Pache in Life
1:06:53
magazine. On the cover of Life magazine.
1:06:56
So the legend is that it was on the
1:06:58
cover of Life magazine but I googled a lot
1:07:00
of 1956 covers of
1:07:03
Life magazine and I didn't
1:07:05
find it on the cover. Oh interesting. So maybe
1:07:07
that's been sort of played up over time. This
1:07:09
might have become part of the lore. Regardless, big
1:07:12
picture in Life magazine, she
1:07:14
is clutching her beloved Sac
1:07:17
de Pache to her
1:07:19
midsection. And it's almost like as she's exiting
1:07:21
a building and it's it almost seems like
1:07:23
it's like a paparazzi type photo. It is,
1:07:25
it's a paparazzi photo and her husband Prince
1:07:27
Renier of Monaco is holding the door behind
1:07:29
her. It's like the most dreamlike
1:07:31
thing you could imagine and
1:07:34
it's in black and white and the
1:07:36
reason that she is clutching this fairly
1:07:38
large bag, unbeknownst to the world at
1:07:40
the time, is she's trying to hide
1:07:42
her pregnancy from the paparazzi.
1:07:44
She's pregnant with her first daughter
1:07:47
and this photo just becomes iconic.
1:07:51
Everybody wants to be
1:07:53
Grace Kelly. Everybody wants
1:07:56
to have this bag. And one
1:07:58
of the last things that Robert does
1:08:00
right before he retires in 1977 is
1:08:03
he officially changes
1:08:06
the product name of the second to pitch to
1:08:08
the Kelly bag. And this is
1:08:10
the birth of, I don't even
1:08:13
know what to call it, the Kelly and the Birkin
1:08:15
are ends of ones, but these leather good products that
1:08:18
transcend everything that
1:08:21
are like so truly end
1:08:23
of one, there's no other way to describe them. And
1:08:26
there is so much to say about
1:08:28
these bags and how they're crafted and
1:08:30
the lore around them and the
1:08:33
supply and demand and Econ
1:08:35
101. But before we
1:08:37
get to that, this is the
1:08:40
perfect time for another story about
1:08:42
ServiceNow. ServiceNow is one
1:08:44
of our big partners here on season 14
1:08:46
and is really an incredible company. Yep.
1:08:49
ServiceNow digitally transforms your enterprise,
1:08:51
helping you automate processes, improve
1:08:54
service delivery and increase overall
1:08:56
operational efficiency all in one
1:08:58
platform. Over 85% of the Fortune 500 runs
1:09:00
on them. And
1:09:03
today they are the 76th largest company
1:09:05
in the world by market cap.
1:09:07
That's wild. They're coming up on Hermes here.
1:09:09
Yeah. And that story is
1:09:12
really the story of their CEO, Bill
1:09:14
McDermott. When he took over in
1:09:16
2019, the idea that this just 15
1:09:18
year old company would be bigger
1:09:21
than Nike or Pfizer soon was
1:09:23
insane. ServiceNow was the leader
1:09:25
in enterprise IT automation. But what Bill has
1:09:27
done since, like we talk about all the
1:09:29
time on the show, is evolve that product
1:09:32
into a true solution for the entire enterprise.
1:09:35
Yep. It's just like our Nvidia series. Moving
1:09:37
from product to solution makes you an
1:09:39
essential partner for your customers, which lets
1:09:41
you build real enterprise value. And Bill
1:09:43
is the best in the world at this. Bill's
1:09:46
story is great. He started his career at
1:09:48
age 17 in a very different business.
1:09:50
He bought his local corner deli in
1:09:53
working class Long Island. As a high schooler,
1:09:55
this is amazing. He buys the deli for
1:09:57
$7,000 in seller. financing
1:10:00
from the owner who is retiring. And Bill
1:10:02
realized that the kids like him who hung
1:10:04
out at the store, they
1:10:06
weren't coming there for the product. Sure,
1:10:09
they wanted food, but it wasn't about the sandwiches.
1:10:11
It was about hanging out with your friends. That
1:10:13
was the solution. Now, this was the 1970s. Bill
1:10:17
starts installing arcade cabinets, Pac-Man, space
1:10:19
invaders, everything we talked about on
1:10:21
our Atari and Nintendo episodes. And
1:10:23
guess what? Kids spend way more
1:10:25
time there and Bill makes way more
1:10:28
profits than just selling sandwiches. He literally
1:10:30
made life-changing money from this deli. He
1:10:32
buys his parents a beathouse. So
1:10:35
after college, Bill joins the tech world
1:10:37
in sales, rises through the ranks at
1:10:39
Xerox, and eventually becomes CEO of SAP.
1:10:42
But he's always bringing that mindset. Why
1:10:45
are my customers really here? So
1:10:48
when he joins ServiceNow in 2019, he
1:10:50
takes them from, oh, you can make
1:10:52
my IT function better to, you can
1:10:55
digitally transform my entire company. And
1:10:58
the company's performance since then has been incredible.
1:11:00
I mean, honestly, it's like Hermes over the
1:11:02
past couple of years. Revenue
1:11:04
has doubled. Earnings have nearly 10xed
1:11:06
since 2019. And
1:11:08
Bill and ServiceNow have entered the
1:11:10
conversation with the NVIDIAs, the Microsofts,
1:11:12
as the most important technology partners
1:11:14
for enterprises around the globe. So
1:11:17
if you want to learn more about the
1:11:19
ServiceNow platform and see how it can transform
1:11:21
your business, go over to servicenow.com/acquired or click
1:11:23
the link in the show notes. Now when
1:11:25
you get in touch, just tell them Ben
1:11:27
and David sent you. Okay,
1:11:30
David, so Life magazine,
1:11:33
the Kelly bag, it's out. So
1:11:36
this thing must sell like hotcakes, right? Well,
1:11:39
yes and no. Certainly
1:11:42
this plays right into this whole
1:11:44
dream thing that we've been talking
1:11:46
about. And Burnish's,
1:11:49
Hermes is already incredible brand
1:11:51
and image. I mean, my
1:11:54
God, Princess Grace Kelly of Monaco
1:11:57
Is carrying this bag? not just carrying this bag,
1:11:59
but it's Her.. Favorite bag The closest
1:12:01
thing to her body. But.
1:12:04
We're. Still in the fifties here. So
1:12:06
weak. Yes, it becomes incredibly popular. Yes,
1:12:09
I'm pretty sure becomes their messes biggest
1:12:11
selling bag. But. The
1:12:13
market isn't quite there yet in the way
1:12:15
that it is today with the burton said
1:12:18
the Kelly's. Sig Global.
1:12:20
Ritz. Isn't. That
1:12:22
big of a population. And. Luggage. I'm
1:12:24
sure they're all buying Kelly's. But. Robert
1:12:27
probably knows all these clients personally. Had
1:12:29
this point, we're not anywhere near the
1:12:31
scale that we're talking about to this
1:12:33
and here point I keep saying it's
1:12:35
launched. It's not really launch, they just
1:12:38
rebrand to the Kelly Bag. But when
1:12:40
the Kelly Bag is formally launched, It's
1:12:43
really expensive. It's a nine
1:12:45
hundred dollar handbag in the
1:12:47
system, which today is ten
1:12:49
to twelve thousand dollars, approximately
1:12:51
the price of a Kelly
1:12:53
bag today. So. It comes
1:12:55
out. As. This thing that
1:12:57
is completely ridiculous and inaccessible price wise.
1:12:59
So the people who are buying it
1:13:01
or the Grace Kelly's of the World
1:13:03
and there's not really this. Stratified.
1:13:07
Class below that that's got this
1:13:09
huge amount of purchasing power. Rests
1:13:11
The. Number of people who could
1:13:14
spend the equivalent of twelve thousand dollars
1:13:16
on a bag back then was just
1:13:18
much much much smaller than it is
1:13:20
today. Yeah, exactly. So.
1:13:22
No, handbags do not immediately become a
1:13:24
huge part of the business. where I
1:13:26
should say it's the dominant whatever it
1:13:28
is today, six or seven times larger
1:13:30
than silk part of the business right
1:13:32
away. And in fact, Actually,
1:13:35
sadly, kind of quite the opposite happened.
1:13:37
so as we head to the sixties
1:13:39
and into the Nineteen seventies and the
1:13:42
end of Roberts tenure in his generation.
1:13:44
As. The head of him as. The
1:13:47
company's highness starts to fall on hard times,
1:13:49
which is crazy to say right? I
1:13:51
remember this moment in the Porsche episode. You're
1:13:53
like, know, come on, Porsche skinny down
1:13:55
the entire lineup to only making the Nine
1:13:58
Eleven because they couldn't justify any. Other
1:14:00
products in the whole company was a frickin' mess. Air.
1:14:02
Masses not quite in those dire straits,
1:14:05
but. I mean, they have
1:14:07
the ingredients of errors that we know.
1:14:09
Today they've got the Kelly bag, They've
1:14:11
got the orange box, they've adopted the
1:14:13
logo of got the scarves. They've got
1:14:15
the scarves. They have these small workshops
1:14:18
where they make everything but it's not
1:14:20
working yet. And. It's particularly
1:14:22
now working because. Like
1:14:24
we just talked about. That. Market.
1:14:27
Was. Not that big. Yeah, And
1:14:30
as we entered the Nineteen seventies. Something.
1:14:32
Really funny happens. The
1:14:35
next generation. Rejects
1:14:37
that dream, This. Is
1:14:39
the don't you and me?
1:14:42
Our parents generation? The Hippies?
1:14:44
The Nineteen seventies? This is
1:14:46
democratization. Little girls don't wanna
1:14:48
be Grace Kelly anymore. They
1:14:51
wanna be like Stevie Nicks
1:14:53
Her as you, something like
1:14:55
that and the dream of
1:14:57
a mess that was once
1:15:00
so elegant and so desired
1:15:02
by so many people but
1:15:04
inaccessible. Is kind of now like.
1:15:08
You know, it's certainly still got it's audience. By.
1:15:10
It's not as universal. This.
1:15:13
Is when so many the other but we
1:15:15
now think of is luxury brands really
1:15:17
start to come up and we talked about
1:15:19
this on the Lvmh episode. but they're connected
1:15:21
to Fasten. First your
1:15:24
and eighty Sandler and he notices
1:15:26
the Mondrian dress from Eve Sandler
1:15:28
at this is pseudo the Revolution.
1:15:30
Which. Guzzi. It's scenario in the
1:15:32
eighties when Karl Lagerfeld takes
1:15:35
over and what they're selling
1:15:37
is very very very different
1:15:39
than what a mess is
1:15:41
selling. This is an important
1:15:43
distinction between air masses and
1:15:45
all the brands you just
1:15:47
named. They come from the
1:15:49
world of could to or
1:15:51
an assassin an does cutting
1:15:53
edge in your face risky
1:15:55
arts. And air
1:15:58
masses comes from my me. And
1:16:00
you by this point they're already a hundred and
1:16:02
twenty years old. Hundred and thirty years old. The
1:16:04
come from the world of leather. And. Horses.
1:16:07
And durable goods that stand the
1:16:09
test of time. And frankly, Styles.
1:16:13
That stand the test of time.
1:16:15
It's not to how creative and
1:16:17
crazy can we be, it's they
1:16:19
talk about, it is responsible gross.
1:16:21
What's the smallest amount that we
1:16:23
can move from our current compass
1:16:25
in order to do what our
1:16:27
clientele one small staying true to
1:16:29
our roots. It's a rejection of
1:16:31
risk and know must embrace of
1:16:33
history. So super different than most
1:16:35
other luxury brands which as you
1:16:37
point out come from fashion right?
1:16:39
And those brands are getting born
1:16:41
or reborn right? There in the nineteen
1:16:43
seventies. Yes, And David
1:16:45
this is probably a good time to share
1:16:47
of who we chatted with in preparation from
1:16:49
this episode and his observation about Air Mess
1:16:51
Yes this was super cool and in a
1:16:53
one of the things that for me and
1:16:55
for both as as can a blizzard mind
1:16:57
as acquired. Gross. We.
1:17:00
Got to talk with Dominica
1:17:02
to solo who was see
1:17:04
of beauty during the fight
1:17:06
with Bernard Arnault that we
1:17:08
chronicled. The. Really, I think that
1:17:10
was the best part of our Lvmh
1:17:12
episode. Absolutely, when not Dominica this away
1:17:14
and Tom Ford and that team at
1:17:16
rejected Bernard's take over and managed to
1:17:18
not become a part of Lvmh and
1:17:21
obviously then Dominica and Tom Ford last
1:17:23
to start Tom Ford after that. But
1:17:25
it was super cool. We talked to
1:17:27
Dominik Go. He comes from that world
1:17:29
even you know with the heritage of gets you. He.
1:17:32
And tom it was fashion first
1:17:34
in. In. His perspective In any
1:17:36
the perspective of many folks that are
1:17:38
coming out of this seventies, eighties era
1:17:41
of luxury. That's. What's
1:17:43
interesting? That's what's for us. Risk on
1:17:45
baby, Risk on. yeah. let's figure out
1:17:47
how it breaks and glass in what
1:17:50
we're doing. Grace. kelly is
1:17:52
not breaking any glass right that
1:17:54
does dominica helped us understand about
1:17:56
air med as may have been
1:17:58
so protective of their and
1:18:00
this unbelievable steward, they're so careful
1:18:02
at how they've chosen to deploy
1:18:05
the brand. They make
1:18:07
sure that the mystique is always
1:18:09
there, they don't violate the promise,
1:18:11
they never cut corners. They have
1:18:13
been above board in their brand
1:18:15
promise and keeping that promise with customers
1:18:17
for over 100 years. And
1:18:20
that is a strength and a weakness. It's
1:18:22
a strength as long as you learn how
1:18:25
to employ it as a strength. In the
1:18:27
world of fashion, it's butting heads. Yeah,
1:18:29
it's antithetical to fashion.
1:18:31
Yes, exactly. So all this
1:18:33
culminates towards the end of the 1970s as
1:18:36
Robert is nearing the end of his tenure at Hermes in
1:18:38
the end of his life. Sadly,
1:18:40
there's a moment, this
1:18:42
is like probably 1977 or so, where
1:18:46
they bring in consultants and the consultants
1:18:48
recommend like, hey, you guys should probably
1:18:51
do what Gucci is doing.
1:18:54
And you should probably close the atelier above
1:18:56
the shop at the Pho Borg and you
1:18:58
should probably outsource production and you should probably
1:19:00
increase your number of products and your SKUs
1:19:02
and have lower prices and have them be
1:19:05
more accessible. Unbelievable. That was the
1:19:07
accepted wisdom at the time. I don't
1:19:09
know if it was McKinsey or who
1:19:11
was saying that. Well, today I will
1:19:13
tell you that Hermes has a corporate
1:19:15
policy of no consultants. And now I
1:19:17
know where that came from. I
1:19:19
mean, this is enshrined in the
1:19:22
luxury strategy as anti-law of marketing
1:19:24
number 19. Do
1:19:26
not hire consultants. Wow.
1:19:29
So the recommendation was to come in and destroy
1:19:31
everything that makes you special and follow the playbook
1:19:33
that everyone else is running. Yeah. I
1:19:36
mean, it's working for them and it's not working for Hermes. It's
1:19:38
crazy. And this is
1:19:41
when the next generation transition
1:19:43
happens to Robert's son
1:19:46
Jean-Louis Dumas. I
1:19:48
kind of can't believe it with this family. Every
1:19:50
time they come in at a
1:19:53
generational transfer and the
1:19:55
company and the brand is under existential threat even
1:19:57
though we think of Hermes, the most honest. a
1:20:00
saleable thing in the world right now, but
1:20:02
finds itself at a moment where it can
1:20:04
be assailed, there's a generational
1:20:06
transfer happening, you would think this is
1:20:08
like the downward spiral, this is the
1:20:10
dropping of the baton, and
1:20:13
the next generation always rallies. And isn't
1:20:15
it amazing? You would think the
1:20:18
best person out there to brilliantly
1:20:20
come up with both the business
1:20:23
strategy and the creative element is
1:20:25
probably not your direct descendant.
1:20:28
Right, probably not your nepotistic family
1:20:30
member. That's not the best search
1:20:33
process to run, and yet it
1:20:35
works. There's something about the,
1:20:38
I don't think it's like this magical
1:20:40
bloodline, I think it is a deep
1:20:42
understanding of the tradition of the business,
1:20:45
of exactly what type of sort
1:20:47
of chutzpah the team has to rally
1:20:49
and take on, having the political clout
1:20:51
to find the right people and empower
1:20:54
them to make the change, to
1:20:56
have a sixth sense for where you
1:20:58
sit in the marketplace versus competitors and
1:21:00
what people may want out of your
1:21:02
brand next. It's all the
1:21:05
intangibles that come from growing up in
1:21:07
the business make you
1:21:09
able to be the right person to
1:21:11
transform it. I really do think that
1:21:13
there is an element too of
1:21:16
the successive generations, they apprentice in
1:21:18
the Atelier, it's like with their
1:21:21
hands. I think there is an
1:21:23
element of that. And they
1:21:25
also apprentice, especially these days on the
1:21:27
business side too. Axel talks
1:21:29
all the time about dinner table conversations
1:21:32
between his uncle, Jean-Louis, who we're about
1:21:34
to talk about now, who was the
1:21:36
fifth generation CEO of Hermes and
1:21:39
his mother who was head of production at
1:21:41
the dinner table growing up. You
1:21:43
can't not absorb that. I
1:21:45
think that's the flip side of nepotism, right? Which makes
1:21:47
it such a challenging topic. On
1:21:50
the one hand, obviously limiting the
1:21:52
universe of talent. On
1:21:54
the other hand, how do you replicate those dinner
1:21:56
table conversations? You know, it's funny, I called it
1:21:58
a sixth sense. I think. the right way
1:22:01
to describe it is actually a jinnessiqwa about
1:22:03
what you sort of absorbed from those. Totally.
1:22:07
Okay, Jean-Louis, the fifth
1:22:09
generation. The
1:22:11
brand, you know, the consultants are saying,
1:22:13
hey, go be like Gucci. Shut down
1:22:15
your shop where they still today make
1:22:17
Birkin and Kelly bags by hand one
1:22:20
artisan at a time in
1:22:22
the most famous address in all of
1:22:24
luxury and fashion, Nutso. Well, I do
1:22:26
have to correct you there. That is
1:22:28
not specifically true. It's certainly spiritually true.
1:22:30
I believe now the only products that
1:22:32
are made in the Pho Borg are
1:22:35
saddles. Oh, really? I think everything else
1:22:37
is made in Pentant, which is a 20
1:22:40
minute drive away. It's not like
1:22:42
the outsourced production. Anyway, we'll get
1:22:44
to that. Great. Okay. Jean-Louis
1:22:47
comes in. What year is this? Great.
1:22:51
He, like all the generations before and after him, he's
1:22:53
come up, he's apprenticed in the business. He knows how
1:22:55
to do the saddle stitch. It's in
1:22:57
his hands. It's in his soul. We've talked
1:22:59
too many times without actually talking about the saddle
1:23:01
stitch. It's time to actually talk about saddle stitching.
1:23:03
So listeners, you might be wondering, why do they
1:23:05
keep saying this? What does it mean? Saddle
1:23:08
stitching is an amazing technique
1:23:10
that Hermes uses for every
1:23:12
single bag that they make.
1:23:15
It can either, I can't
1:23:17
tell if this is true or not, it
1:23:19
can either only be done by hand or
1:23:21
until recently only be done by hand, but
1:23:25
it is a far more effective, high
1:23:27
quality, and durable form of stitching relative
1:23:29
to the typical machine sewn stitching that
1:23:32
you're thinking about right now, where the
1:23:34
same thread goes through one needle and
1:23:36
it goes up, down, up, down, up,
1:23:39
down, up, down. It's also
1:23:41
incredibly beautiful. It's got a slight di-ank-and-all
1:23:43
valence to it as opposed to
1:23:46
the normal straight line stitching. Yes.
1:23:49
So how does it work? So there's something
1:23:51
called a horse that goes between your legs
1:23:54
and the horse holds two pieces
1:23:56
of leather together, the whole point
1:23:58
of the saddle stitch. is to
1:24:00
sew two pieces of leather together. So
1:24:03
you first punch
1:24:05
little holes in the leather using
1:24:07
likely a pricking iron as your
1:24:09
method of doing this. And
1:24:12
if you're good, you don't prick all the
1:24:14
way through, you just poke a little hole
1:24:16
with your pricking iron or all partway through.
1:24:19
So that way you don't poke too big
1:24:21
of a hole, you only end up pushing
1:24:23
exactly a hole the size of your needle
1:24:25
and thread through. And you can always tell
1:24:28
if you're looking at something and it's stitched
1:24:30
and there's these big freaking holes and then
1:24:32
there's this thin thread that's moving through and
1:24:34
there's space between the thread and the leather.
1:24:37
You know what kind of craftsmanship went into that.
1:24:40
If it almost looks like the stitch vanishes
1:24:42
into the leather and you're like, is there
1:24:44
even a hole there? It's hard to even
1:24:46
see how this was done. That
1:24:48
is a saddle stitch. So you take your
1:24:50
pricking iron or your all you poke the
1:24:53
hole or the partial hole. So
1:24:55
there's a lot of muscle memory involved in this. You
1:24:58
then pass one needle
1:25:00
through going, call it from the right
1:25:02
to the left side. And
1:25:04
then you have a second needle on
1:25:06
the other end of the thread. So
1:25:08
one thread, two needles. Yes. That you pass
1:25:11
through the other direction. And so
1:25:13
what you've done as you pull both
1:25:15
of them through is created
1:25:18
this incredibly strong sort
1:25:20
of interlocking mechanism. There's
1:25:22
tensile force going in both directions.
1:25:24
Yes. If it gets ripped,
1:25:27
you're not at risk of the whole thing
1:25:30
pulling out and your saddle or your bag
1:25:32
falling apart. You just
1:25:34
lose that one stitch and that one
1:25:36
stitch can be repaired. And
1:25:38
so the only way for you to unravel
1:25:41
something that is saddle stitched together is to
1:25:43
individually go through and cut Every
1:25:45
single stitch. Compare that to most
1:25:47
products that you own. Yes. This
1:25:49
literally provides high utility if you're
1:25:51
in an A Kestrian jumping competition
1:25:53
or if your bag needs to
1:25:55
hold something that really needs a
1:25:57
lot of protection and can't fall
1:25:59
apart. Real. It's almost like it
1:26:01
started with real necessary utility because
1:26:04
something life threatening could happen. Now
1:26:06
it's just massively overkill for everything
1:26:08
that saddle stitch, But you appreciate
1:26:10
the craft behind and there are
1:26:12
very few people who are in
1:26:14
a life or death circumstance that
1:26:16
are dependent on their spirits holding
1:26:18
true from the channel. My inner
1:26:20
pure Alexi sure the current artistic
1:26:23
director of of him as. I.
1:26:25
Think it still has
1:26:27
relevance if you. Want
1:26:30
your object to be permanent. If
1:26:32
you want an object that you own,
1:26:35
To. Represent something wholly
1:26:38
different and antithetical to let's call
1:26:40
it the Amazon effect too soon
1:26:42
or the Walmart affect a certain
1:26:44
of rhythms. These. Days. You
1:26:47
want it to be made like this? Yup,
1:26:50
And something that made this really
1:26:52
special for. Hundreds of years
1:26:54
If not still is that it had
1:26:56
to be done by hand. Said he
1:26:58
wants something of this quality. Discuss this
1:27:00
Interesting had yes he is handmade stuff
1:27:02
better. Well. Not necessarily, and Xl
1:27:05
even says this in an interview. He
1:27:07
says in twenty nineteen today hand stitching is the
1:27:09
highest quality so machines are a non negotiable. When
1:27:12
the quality of a machine stitching gets better than
1:27:14
hand stitching, we will do it. We are not
1:27:16
a museum and David, this is where you're getting
1:27:18
your we are not a Museum quote from. But.
1:27:21
It really gets to this element of. Why?
1:27:23
Are handcrafted good, desirable? well, in
1:27:25
this case is literally creed something
1:27:27
higher quality, more durable, certainly more
1:27:29
aesthetically pleasing, since when done well
1:27:32
in, you can't see that whole
1:27:34
and between the bread and the
1:27:36
leather. It's a pretty special process.
1:27:38
And. For everyone who sort of wondering.
1:27:40
Okay, but what is the rest of creating
1:27:42
one of these bags look like. Start
1:27:45
to finish. A tele bag, And
1:27:48
will talk about Brooklinen. A little bit
1:27:50
of a similar story is made by
1:27:52
one craftsman. So. One craftsmen
1:27:54
starts with. Thirty.
1:27:56
Six unique pieces of high
1:27:58
quality leather as much as
1:28:00
possible from the same animal
1:28:02
and match exactly. Yes, exactly.
1:28:05
And. So it's not source from all
1:28:07
these different places all over the world.
1:28:09
And one persons responsible for the bottoms
1:28:11
and someone else is responsible for the
1:28:13
straps is one craftsman that takes these
1:28:16
thirty six cuts in, stitches it together.
1:28:18
it takes twenty hours. He and his
1:28:20
is over the course of a few
1:28:22
weeks to create the so. The. One
1:28:24
person assembling at all and putting
1:28:27
the fasteners on it's stitching it.
1:28:29
This. Takes two years to learn how
1:28:31
to do before you are allowed to
1:28:34
create one for the first time. Or
1:28:36
I think it's even more than that.
1:28:38
It's two years of training to become
1:28:40
i am as artisan period. I.
1:28:43
Don't think you're allowed to touch the
1:28:45
Burke and the Kelly's Who. And you
1:28:47
start day one on the job. I
1:28:49
believe you need at least another three
1:28:51
years, if not more before you're allowed
1:28:53
to touch the Perkins and the Kelly's
1:28:55
Fascinating. So. This knowledge is
1:28:57
passed from generation to generation and
1:28:59
Air Med refers to this as
1:29:01
the Savoir Faire or the know
1:29:03
how are the expertise about the
1:29:06
materials and the exceptional technique that's
1:29:08
transmitted from one crafts person to
1:29:10
another who hang on to have
1:29:12
a lot more to say when
1:29:14
we get to the current generation
1:29:16
about this. Do. You know, David and
1:29:18
I'll stop after this. but I thought this is pretty
1:29:20
funny. Have you read the annual Report
1:29:22
Third six hundred page document that they were
1:29:24
once a year. I have to been I
1:29:27
have not read it. Cover to cover, you
1:29:29
did more the history and I did for
1:29:31
this but I've read large sections of it.
1:29:34
I was reading. I found myself
1:29:36
laughing at how often Savoir Faire
1:29:38
was used in the pros. Every
1:29:40
other paragraph they the Disorder throw
1:29:42
in a Savoir Faire one hundred
1:29:44
and thirty three times. Savoir Faire
1:29:46
is referenced in the Air Masses
1:29:48
registration documents, Partially in their defense,
1:29:51
Savoir Faire literally translates as know
1:29:53
how It's kind of like a
1:29:55
proper term in. France. Yeah.
1:29:58
Fair. but i think the take away his real that
1:30:00
this knowledge is transmitted from one generation to
1:30:02
the other in the very same way that
1:30:04
it was from father to son all the
1:30:06
way back at the founding of the company.
1:30:09
And that is how they scale production. And
1:30:12
we'll put a pin in that and come back to
1:30:14
it later. Yeah, that's the
1:30:16
true genius of the current generation is they
1:30:18
have scaled that to 7,000 people.
1:30:21
It's unbelievable. Unbelievable. I
1:30:23
was going to talk about this towards the end of the Jean-Louis era, but
1:30:25
I want to say it now because I think it's perfect. I
1:30:28
got to talk to a woman named
1:30:30
Beatrice Amblaard, who lives here in San
1:30:32
Francisco. This is amazing. She
1:30:35
was an artisan at Hermes
1:30:37
in Paris. She
1:30:39
was hired right at the start
1:30:41
of Jean-Louis' tenure. She
1:30:43
worked in the atelier at the foreboard
1:30:46
when Jean-Louis' son Pierre, a Lexi Curran
1:30:48
artistic director, came to train after school
1:30:50
as a teenager. He sat
1:30:52
next to Beatrice. And I got
1:30:54
to chat with her about this. She runs April in
1:30:56
Paris in San Francisco. She moved to San
1:30:58
Francisco when Hermes opened the San Francisco store here. I asked
1:31:00
her, I was like, oh, you transitioned to the front of
1:31:02
the house. And she was like, no, no, no. I
1:31:05
was the person for the West
1:31:07
Coast who repaired everything
1:31:09
for North American West Coast clients. There
1:31:11
was one person in New York and
1:31:13
I was in San Francisco and we
1:31:16
came from the foreboard. A few
1:31:18
of these people go around the world. And one of
1:31:20
the things about Hermes, and actually Jean-Louis, who
1:31:22
would say this, the true essence of luxury and
1:31:24
the true essence of Hermes is everything they make
1:31:26
can be repaired. And so if you
1:31:29
buy an item from Hermes, no matter
1:31:31
what it is, they will repair it. Yeah, I
1:31:33
think that's true. Even if it's 100 years old,
1:31:35
you bring it in, they will repair it. Yeah,
1:31:37
that's true. They have 15, this is flashing forward
1:31:39
today, 15 dedicated repair shops worldwide
1:31:41
and they mend 120,000 pieces a year. Wow.
1:31:47
Amazing. Yeah. So I
1:31:49
asked Beatrice when I was talking to her, what
1:31:51
was this like? What was it special? She said, look,
1:31:54
you have to understand, When I
1:31:57
was training as a young person and decided I
1:31:59
wanted to go in. it is field. Or
1:32:01
Mans was absolutely the greatest
1:32:04
company that anyone. Could.
1:32:06
Hope to work for were wasn't even
1:32:08
close. There was no comparison to what
1:32:10
years this was in the late eighties
1:32:12
early nineties. She said look I
1:32:15
decided that either I was going to get a
1:32:17
job at him as or I was gonna leave
1:32:19
this industry and go do something else. it isn't
1:32:21
that high of esteem and I said or while
1:32:23
wise and he said lit. By. The time
1:32:25
we're at this era. Nobody
1:32:27
else was last. Justice rates everything
1:32:29
we talked about in the nineteen
1:32:32
seventies. all these other brands that
1:32:34
he all wedding this complete other
1:32:36
direction. The consultants were telling your
1:32:38
meds to go in that direction
1:32:40
to, but it'll last one standing.
1:32:42
That did all of this by
1:32:44
hand in the tradition handed down
1:32:47
through hundreds of years if that's
1:32:49
important to you. There's. No
1:32:51
place else you can apply your trade doing
1:32:53
that anywhere else. I asked her. Then I
1:32:55
was like okay, well. As for
1:32:57
the products and today clients to
1:32:59
the customer is. Why
1:33:02
does that make a difference? And.
1:33:04
What he said is what you'll hear the family talk about
1:33:06
all the time. She. Said like it's
1:33:08
about so. This. Product has
1:33:11
a soul. Somebody made that sing
1:33:13
with their bare hands. That means
1:33:15
something. And there's nobody
1:33:17
else certainly at are massive
1:33:20
scale. That. Does that you see
1:33:22
Ended up leaving him as and starting
1:33:24
her own particular in San Francisco, april
1:33:26
in Paris and she actually also runs
1:33:28
around. Whether school here in San Francisco
1:33:30
to to train artist you can get
1:33:32
custom stuff. small boutique staff. Beatrice as
1:33:34
a. Worldwide. Masters you
1:33:36
can get that from her. But
1:33:38
the idea that at two hundred
1:33:40
billion dollar company at scale would
1:33:42
be doing best like there's nobody
1:33:45
else. Gets. Nuts. It's completely
1:33:47
insane. And the people who don't
1:33:49
work for M as. Your options are
1:33:51
in the dozens. if you
1:33:54
go as a customer and
1:33:56
you want something like a
1:33:58
saddle stitched fag or wallet
1:34:00
or something like Hermes would make
1:34:02
in that traditional sort of pre-war
1:34:05
early 20th century fashion. There
1:34:08
aren't that many other artisans out there. Hermes
1:34:10
employs 7,000 of them. I
1:34:13
don't know how many other ones there are. 1,000,
1:34:15
2,000? And it's not like Hermes has cornered the
1:34:17
market. They're hiring more people and training them as
1:34:19
fast as they can. They're trying
1:34:21
to preserve this market that otherwise would
1:34:24
have entirely been zero. It's
1:34:26
a pretty crazy thing that they've managed to
1:34:28
scale, even to the scale that they're at.
1:34:31
The other thing Beatrice said to bring it
1:34:33
back to Jean-Louis, he is
1:34:35
a legend. He
1:34:37
really cared. The idea
1:34:40
that he would follow the consultants, like
1:34:42
it was just so completely anathema to
1:34:45
him. He's the artistic director and CEO of the
1:34:47
company. She ran into him in the
1:34:49
elevator in the faux board right after she started. He
1:34:51
looks there and said, you're Beatrice M.
1:34:53
Blard. Welcome to Hermes. She
1:34:56
knew everybody by name. And
1:34:58
then when she ended up leaving in 1997 to
1:35:00
open her own store, he called her. He
1:35:05
was genuinely shocked.
1:35:08
Nobody ever leaves. What are you going to do? And
1:35:11
she explained that, well, she wanted to
1:35:13
be entrepreneurial, start her own thing. And
1:35:16
then shortly after the San Francisco Chronicle
1:35:18
did an article about her, he found
1:35:20
the article, read it in France, cut it
1:35:22
out, mailed it to her with a
1:35:24
note of congratulations handwritten. And
1:35:26
it doesn't cost him anything to do that because, I
1:35:28
mean, on the one hand, you just say they're being
1:35:31
a kind person and gave so much to
1:35:33
your house for so long. On the other hand, this is
1:35:35
the CEO of Hermes. Right. And
1:35:38
I think it's important to realize these
1:35:40
individual craftsmen are entirely
1:35:42
non-competitive with Hermes. It's
1:35:45
a completely different value proposition to the
1:35:47
customer. When you're buying
1:35:49
Hermes today, you don't start from a
1:35:52
place of, you know, I think I
1:35:54
want some of the very
1:35:56
best sewn leather
1:35:59
goods I can find. And let me evaluate
1:36:01
the whole landscape of people who could
1:36:03
deliver that for me, and then I'll decide
1:36:05
which maker to go with. Either
1:36:08
A, you're doing that and you are
1:36:10
a person who knows about a bunch
1:36:12
of individual leather craftsmen, which
1:36:15
is rare, or B, you
1:36:17
actually just want to buy something from
1:36:19
Hermes, and there's not any evaluation going
1:36:21
on. And maybe there is between big
1:36:23
luxury brands, but probably not. The
1:36:26
value proposition is not you have a
1:36:28
need for a leather good and you can bake
1:36:30
off all the competitors. You either
1:36:32
want something from Hermes or you're a different type
1:36:34
of customer. Yeah. Okay.
1:36:37
So Jean-Louis' story, how did he
1:36:39
turn this thing around and save
1:36:42
Hermes from the consultants? Well,
1:36:45
like we said, he'd apprentice just like every
1:36:47
other generation. But
1:36:49
unlike any other generation, or I guess maybe sort of
1:36:51
like Emile back in the day going and meeting Henry
1:36:53
Ford, he comes to America. And
1:36:57
specifically he came to America to follow his
1:36:59
wife, Renna, who became a
1:37:01
world famous architect. Renna
1:37:03
was interning with IM Pei in
1:37:06
New York. Really? And Renna
1:37:08
Dumas would go on to design
1:37:10
all the stores that they offered
1:37:12
to fall around and design to
1:37:15
Atelier and Pantan when they expand
1:37:17
production. IM Pei, famous
1:37:19
from a number of things, including
1:37:21
previous acquired episode with Michael Ovets,
1:37:23
designed the CAA building in
1:37:26
Los Angeles, designed the Louvre pyramid.
1:37:28
I was going to say, think
1:37:30
about the connection here at France
1:37:32
and Paris. Yeah. Which by
1:37:34
the way, everyone in Paris thought the pyramid
1:37:36
was hideously ugly when it first, relative
1:37:39
to this 1700s building around it. And
1:37:42
over time now it's become this iconic
1:37:44
triangle pyramid, beautiful signature of the city.
1:37:47
Jean-Louis, when he's in America,
1:37:50
he works for Bloomingdale's. Bloomingdale's!
1:37:53
My God, of all places. Well, there was
1:37:55
a heyday of department stores. In fact, if
1:37:57
you go way back, do you...
1:38:00
know how Hermes entered the United
1:38:02
States in partnership with Neiman Marcus?
1:38:04
Yes, 1930s. Good.
1:38:07
Wow. He did find that. It's
1:38:09
hard to stop me. Yeah. But you do
1:38:11
it sometimes. Okay, so Bloomingdale's.
1:38:14
So from that experience, being in
1:38:16
America, being in this
1:38:18
much more mainstream audience,
1:38:22
he comes to
1:38:24
understand what these
1:38:27
other brands are doing, what the consultants
1:38:29
are suggesting. But
1:38:31
he takes that back. And what
1:38:34
he says, like, look, the way forward is we're
1:38:36
going to figure out how to make Hermes relevant.
1:38:39
We're not going to throw away everything we've done.
1:38:41
We're going to keep our tradition. We're going to
1:38:43
keep our craftsmanship. We're going to keep our market
1:38:45
position. But our
1:38:47
clients want to be like these
1:38:49
young people, particularly these young
1:38:51
women, you know, the moms don't want to be
1:38:54
like their moms, they want to be like their
1:38:56
daughters. And it's a tall order to figure out
1:38:58
how to revitalize, rejuvenate, make
1:39:00
Hermes relevant for this new era
1:39:02
with this new audience with the
1:39:05
same products. This is key, right?
1:39:07
Keeping the same products and
1:39:10
not violating everything that Hermes
1:39:12
currently stands for. We
1:39:14
talked about this on LVMH, the Not
1:39:16
Your Mother's Tiffany campaign. It's almost like,
1:39:18
how do you not insult your current
1:39:21
customer base by adapting for the next
1:39:23
one? This is such a tight
1:39:25
needle to thread to use a pun here.
1:39:27
They need to run the Not Your
1:39:30
Mother's Tiffany campaign without actually running the
1:39:32
Not Your Mother's Tiffany campaign. Right. So,
1:39:35
well, the first thing in 1979, the first year he takes
1:39:38
over, he launches a new ad campaign
1:39:41
in Paris with
1:39:43
young Parisian women
1:39:46
wearing the iconic Hermes scarves,
1:39:49
which remember, like that's the main part of the business
1:39:51
at this point in time. But
1:39:53
it's, you know, all these old people who want to be like
1:39:55
Queen Elizabeth wearing the scarves. Young
1:39:57
women wearing the scarves. Not
1:40:00
how you would typically wear a scarf. Different
1:40:03
parts all over their body. It's
1:40:05
the Hermes version of not your
1:40:07
mother's Tiffany. And most importantly, they're
1:40:09
wearing these scarves with
1:40:11
jeans. Grace Kelly would
1:40:14
never wear jeans. I don't know if she ever did
1:40:16
wear jeans, but she sure as hell wouldn't be photographed
1:40:18
wearing jeans. Fascinating. These ads
1:40:22
are the scarves that Queen Elizabeth
1:40:24
is wearing with jeans. And
1:40:27
in fun, interesting ways, playful
1:40:30
ways to wear the scarves.
1:40:32
But they're still the same scarves. Fascinating.
1:40:35
And this is like a revolution. I mean, the
1:40:37
rest of the family is really upset about it.
1:40:40
But he pushes it through. And
1:40:42
you can still see echoes of this
1:40:44
to this day, like a big part
1:40:46
of Hermes fashion and probably the biggest
1:40:48
part of, I think, the scarf fashion
1:40:50
these days is tying the scarves on
1:40:52
your bags, on
1:40:54
your accessories, on various parts of your body, not
1:40:57
wearing them like your mother wore
1:41:00
them. And this is how they've adapted for
1:41:02
the digital era too. They've come out with
1:41:04
like five or six different apps to try to
1:41:06
figure out how do we engage people in the
1:41:09
mobile era. And one of the ideas that
1:41:11
they had was this app that basically gives
1:41:13
you suggestions and all the different ways you
1:41:15
could tie a scarf. That's
1:41:18
super cool. Yeah. But I think this
1:41:20
is brilliant because this is
1:41:23
allowing Hermes to exist and
1:41:28
be relevant alongside fashion
1:41:31
without actually getting into fashion
1:41:33
themselves. The scarves
1:41:35
and then ultimately the bags can
1:41:38
be the accessories to your
1:41:41
jeans, to your fashion, to your, you
1:41:43
know, we're past the era of bell
1:41:45
bottoms, but like the spiritual equivalent of
1:41:47
bell bottoms here. And they can
1:41:49
say something about you, but they're still the same products
1:41:51
that they always were. And it's
1:41:53
pretty interesting if you can figure
1:41:56
out how to coexist alongside cool,
1:41:58
fashionable, new cutting edge things. Then
1:42:01
you sort of deserve
1:42:03
a place in someone's lineup
1:42:05
where they say, well, I
1:42:07
both am embracing a current trend,
1:42:10
but I'm also respectful of the
1:42:12
past. I also found my own
1:42:14
way to weave this high class,
1:42:16
high status thing into the rest
1:42:18
of my image. And
1:42:21
I think that especially at their price points, they're
1:42:24
serving someone who wants to raise one hand and
1:42:26
say, I look cool and
1:42:28
raise the other hand and say, I'm classic.
1:42:30
Well, I'm classic and I have the money
1:42:32
to spend on things that are very price
1:42:35
anchored. Everyone knows what
1:42:37
a Kelly bag costs and like it's
1:42:39
gone up a little bit, but Hermes
1:42:41
has very high price point products that
1:42:43
stay approximately that price forever. Yeah.
1:42:46
So Jean-Louis has a quote about this,
1:42:49
which is very French. He says, the
1:42:51
young customers came to us more than we went
1:42:53
to them. People saw again,
1:42:55
but with a new eye, the
1:42:57
beauty of materials worked by fine
1:42:59
hands. They came, we
1:43:02
followed. That's the best French way of ever saying
1:43:04
this, but like this is what we're talking about. He
1:43:06
got their client base
1:43:09
and often the young people's parents who wanted to
1:43:11
be more like the young people here to
1:43:14
see with new eyes the
1:43:16
same things. Yep. Total genius. Yep,
1:43:19
for sure. Okay. So that's brilliant. So
1:43:22
that's on the product side and kind of doing
1:43:25
this jiu-jitsu to reposition the product
1:43:27
center. The other thing
1:43:29
that he did, which was
1:43:31
huge, was he had the very same
1:43:34
realization that Henri Rachamier had at Louis
1:43:36
Vuitton. And we foreshadowed this earlier. What
1:43:39
Rachamier figured out at Louis
1:43:41
Vuitton in the 1970s was the
1:43:44
market now, the global
1:43:47
wealthy, the global elite, the global
1:43:50
rich is so much
1:43:52
bigger now than it was in the
1:43:54
1950s. The number
1:43:56
of people with wealth on
1:43:58
the order of Grace Kelly has been a
1:44:00
huge number. and Prince Rainier of Monaco, or
1:44:02
even a few rungs below them. But the
1:44:04
number of people who can be in our
1:44:06
client base around the world is
1:44:09
just so, so, so much larger than it used
1:44:11
to be. And it's happening in this country by
1:44:13
country way, which is perfect for a brand like
1:44:15
this. Like they can go to America and then
1:44:17
they will observe the rise of Japan and then
1:44:19
they'll go to Japan in the 90s and 2000s.
1:44:22
Then they'll observe the rising upper middle class of
1:44:24
China. So they'll go there in present day. They
1:44:27
can really position themselves as sort of
1:44:29
the second mover, where they can sort
1:44:32
of watch, see when this
1:44:34
wealth class exists somewhere, and then
1:44:37
set up shop and say, hey, France's
1:44:39
whole heritage is now available to you
1:44:41
to adopt as part of your persona.
1:44:44
Yeah, and this is super key. And
1:44:46
I think to this day
1:44:48
is a huge part of the defensibility
1:44:50
of Hermes and Louis Vuitton too. No
1:44:53
matter where you live in the world and
1:44:55
no matter what your cultural background is, when
1:44:57
you attain this status, there's
1:44:59
still something about this connection to
1:45:02
French and European nobility that
1:45:05
you cannot buy from a brand
1:45:07
from any other country. It's
1:45:09
super fascinating that French
1:45:12
nobility, fashion and
1:45:14
heritage is universally revered everywhere.
1:45:16
And Italian is too, like
1:45:18
I would say European generally,
1:45:20
but French specifically has
1:45:23
an ability to do this in any
1:45:26
geography as it develops. Yep.
1:45:29
So all of
1:45:31
this stew comes together in 1984
1:45:35
with Jean-Louis's greatest achievement.
1:45:38
And unlike the Kelly bag, which, you know, again was an
1:45:40
accident, like, yes, it was his
1:45:43
father, Robert, and incredible genius, and then
1:45:45
repositioning and renaming the bag, the Kelly
1:45:47
bag. Jean-Louis, this
1:45:49
is literally whole cloth conceived of
1:45:52
by him. On a
1:45:54
flight from Paris to London in
1:45:56
the early 1980s, where he's seated
1:45:58
next to the French and... British actress, Jane
1:46:02
Birkin. The It Girl of the
1:46:04
time. Now here's what's really interesting.
1:46:07
I bet 95 plus
1:46:10
percent of people listening to this right now
1:46:12
have no idea who Jane Birkin was. Which
1:46:14
is so funny because in interviews with her,
1:46:17
as the Birkin bag was blowing up, or
1:46:19
at least getting a lot of attention, an interviewer
1:46:22
joked that she was gonna be
1:46:24
more famous for the bag than for her
1:46:26
acting career and her modeling and all that.
1:46:28
And she sort of laughed and said, wouldn't
1:46:30
that be something? Yeah, right. But
1:46:32
totally 95%, if not more of the
1:46:34
listeners to this podcast will have no
1:46:36
idea who Jane Birkin is before this
1:46:38
episode. But you definitely know the Birkin bag.
1:46:41
Yep. Or at least you know of the
1:46:43
Birkin bag. I bet seven out of
1:46:45
10, maybe eight out of 10 people listening to
1:46:47
this couldn't spot it. But if you say a
1:46:49
Birkin bag, you sort of know that it's like
1:46:52
a unattainably
1:46:54
expensive, high status, hard to get handbag.
1:46:57
Well, certainly if you follow the Hermes stock, you
1:46:59
know what a Birkin bag is, even if you
1:47:01
probably couldn't pick it out of a crowd. Yes.
1:47:04
But anyway, this is the culmination of
1:47:07
everything we've been talking about. Who is Jane
1:47:09
Birkin? She was British, she
1:47:11
was born in England, but she moved to
1:47:13
France and became a French citizen. And she
1:47:16
became like a French cultural icon. I mean,
1:47:18
again, the tide of France is so important
1:47:20
here too. We didn't talk about this with
1:47:22
Grace Kelly either. Grace Kelly was an American
1:47:24
from Philadelphia, but she became the
1:47:26
princess of Monaco. These two
1:47:28
women, these two personas that are
1:47:31
embodied in Hermes, like Hermes doesn't
1:47:33
do celebrity advertising. I think
1:47:35
it's so important that even though neither
1:47:38
of them were French, they
1:47:40
became so deeply European in what
1:47:42
they represented. Yeah, that's a great
1:47:44
way to put it. And for
1:47:46
Jane Birkin, she
1:47:48
was this next generation. She was an actress
1:47:50
both in film and theater. She
1:47:53
was a singer. She was
1:47:55
incredibly beautiful. She
1:47:57
was the hit girl, but in a very, very different way.
1:48:00
Grace Kelly, she wore jeans.
1:48:03
And in particular, she had
1:48:05
a trademark accessory fitting
1:48:07
with the 1970s. Oh,
1:48:10
the basket? Yep. Counterculture,
1:48:12
back to the land type
1:48:14
ethos. She carried a
1:48:16
wicker basket with her everywhere that
1:48:18
she went. Which has an
1:48:20
ethos to it, but doesn't lend itself well
1:48:22
to overhead bins. No, it does not. So
1:48:25
as the two of them, Jean-Louis, CEO
1:48:27
and Artistic Director of Hermes,
1:48:29
and Jane Birkin, French cultural
1:48:31
icon, are boarding this flight
1:48:34
to London. They're seated next to
1:48:36
each other and Jane is struggling to get
1:48:38
her fixed handle wicker
1:48:40
basket up into the overhead
1:48:42
compartment. And at this point, Jane
1:48:45
had become a mother and had kids.
1:48:48
And she had, you know, kid stuff
1:48:50
in her basket. She had baby bottles that were
1:48:52
like spilling out. Totally. I mean, I carry a
1:48:54
lot of kid stuff these days. Like you need
1:48:56
a lot of stuff with the kids. By
1:48:59
the way, how crazy is it that the Kelly
1:49:01
bag was to hide a pregnancy and the Birkin
1:49:03
bag was designed to carry baby bottles and... Baby
1:49:06
forward. Yes. And again,
1:49:08
on the one hand, this is sort
1:49:10
of esoteric Birkin lore. On the other
1:49:12
hand, I think this is super important
1:49:14
to Jean-Louis. Like imagine the older generation
1:49:16
Hermes embracing this. You know, we should
1:49:18
do, we should come out with a $15,000 diaper bag. Right.
1:49:22
Right, right. So
1:49:25
they sit down, they start talking on the
1:49:27
flight and Jean-Louis introduces himself and is like,
1:49:29
I notice you're struggling with your wicker basket
1:49:31
there, Miss Birkin. And she doesn't know
1:49:33
who he is at first. It's the funniest thing. Right, right, right. And
1:49:36
she says something like, well, yeah, wouldn't that
1:49:38
be great if there was a bigger bag
1:49:40
that actually closed and, you know, but Hermes
1:49:42
doesn't make that. Or she made some comment.
1:49:44
And he goes, I am Hermes. Yeah, the
1:49:46
legend now, who knows if this is true, is
1:49:49
that she said, well, when Hermes makes a diaper
1:49:51
bag, you know, I'll use that one. And
1:49:53
specifically for her, she sort of fancies herself someone
1:49:56
that has a lot of stuff and wants to
1:49:58
bring all my stuff with me. So I just...
1:50:00
need a big bag and it needs to close
1:50:02
easily. Fashion be damned, I
1:50:04
just need a huge freaking tote." Yeah.
1:50:07
And as they get to talking, they're
1:50:09
talking about the Kelly and she's like,
1:50:11
look, Kelly's the Kelly, right? But
1:50:13
I can't wear it over my shoulder. So
1:50:16
Jean-Louis starts sketching out designs on
1:50:18
the plane and voila, the
1:50:20
Birkin is born. Larger than the Kelly,
1:50:23
but smaller than the old original
1:50:25
Hermes bag. It's a tote
1:50:27
bag and it has two handles, unlike the Kelly, which has
1:50:29
one handle. And so with two handles, you can put
1:50:31
it over your shoulder. It's this sort
1:50:33
of, it feels weird to say
1:50:35
more casual version of the Kelly, given that
1:50:37
it's the Birkin bag, but
1:50:40
it is, it's the more casual modern
1:50:42
version of the Kelly. And the Kelly
1:50:44
has cleaner lines and this sort of
1:50:46
beautiful almost mid-century trapezoidal shape, whereas the
1:50:48
Birkin, everything about it kind of screams
1:50:51
function. So here's what's interesting. They
1:50:54
release the product in 1984 and it is
1:50:56
not an immediate success.
1:51:01
I think part of this is that
1:51:03
the Hermes kind of
1:51:05
brand transformation modernization was probably
1:51:07
still underway. When you watch
1:51:10
interviews with particular Pierre Alexi, he'll
1:51:12
talk about this. He's like, any other company would have given
1:51:14
up on this product. But it takes
1:51:17
about five years before the Birkin bag
1:51:19
becomes the Birkin bag. And
1:51:21
like the time is right. We're in
1:51:23
the 1980s, the go-go years. This is
1:51:25
the years that are shaping Bernard Arnaud
1:51:27
here. There's tons of American wealth being
1:51:29
created. People are looking to be a
1:51:32
little bit flashier. Now granted Hermes is
1:51:34
the least flashy of
1:51:36
the luxury labels you could adopt, but people
1:51:39
know the brand. Yeah. I mean,
1:51:41
it takes five years for it to become
1:51:43
any modicum of success for Hermes. And
1:51:45
then like a lot of
1:51:47
these things, this just kind
1:51:49
of slow burn starts that grows
1:51:51
and grows and grows and grows.
1:51:54
And there's a real lore around it that
1:51:56
it's hard to get. And It's
1:51:59
just like. Where a kid If you tell
1:52:01
him they can't have something they wanted a lot
1:52:03
more. And if you tell your
1:52:06
very Cnc clientele that you would love
1:52:08
to be able to get something for
1:52:10
them, but there's just not enough. And.
1:52:13
We don't have it today, but gosh,
1:52:16
If you are a great customer of ours
1:52:18
and we maintain a relationship with you, let
1:52:20
me write down your number. I feel like
1:52:22
we may just have something for you soon
1:52:24
to be a few years but I'll reach
1:52:26
out as soon as we have something. You're
1:52:28
an important customers and if you want to
1:52:30
show us your it even more important customer
1:52:32
please do by all means and I'll see
1:52:35
what I cannot pass bed. You would make
1:52:37
a great erm as as and I don't
1:52:39
think so. I actually had a wonderful M
1:52:41
as associate that I worked with. In
1:52:43
the Exxon Provence store and it
1:52:45
was crazy. I mean we bought.
1:52:48
Basically. The most entry level m as
1:52:50
products that you can buy in one of
1:52:52
their stores. I think perfumes are sold and.
1:52:55
Department stores and make up their some more
1:52:57
accessible things. but in terms of those durable
1:53:00
goods. Started. At the bottom
1:53:02
you know. Had a delightful time and
1:53:04
decided to buy something and. I.
1:53:06
Think we spent an hour and a
1:53:08
half and I had the most wonderful
1:53:11
service and built a almost friendship with
1:53:13
the associate who helped us to the
1:53:15
whole process spending as much time with
1:53:17
me. As. They spent with someone coming
1:53:19
into pick up the work and back. It was
1:53:21
a crazy. Probably. The best
1:53:23
customer service I've ever received in any
1:53:25
retail establishment anywhere. So. No,
1:53:28
I don't think I would be a good
1:53:30
as an asset sales associate relative to Wow
1:53:32
where the bar has been set. It's
1:53:35
funny. you know my experience was different. Of
1:53:37
course I had to go do some research
1:53:39
for this episode. You. Drove down to the
1:53:41
Peloton store, right? Guess I went to the power officer
1:53:43
had to be down there any way for some meetings.
1:53:45
And. The. Sales
1:53:48
associate who ultimately help me
1:53:50
is equally wonderful. Woman:
1:53:52
Had a great experience. Name is Susan! I'm
1:53:55
going back to see her tomorrow. As Valentine's
1:53:57
Day and Downs birthday coming up. But.
1:54:00
I walked in the store with the intention of buying
1:54:02
what I ultimately did by. Weight. Is people
1:54:04
watch Me and I thought that's what that
1:54:06
was An apple watch band? Yup. And
1:54:09
will will get to be Apple partnership and
1:54:11
a little bit but. I was passed
1:54:14
around between a few different people in the
1:54:16
store until. Ultimately season help me
1:54:18
out and she was great and I think see
1:54:20
actually might be a. Higher level
1:54:22
as a but. When. I express
1:54:24
that I was there to buyer
1:54:26
and Apple watch their oh interesting
1:54:28
yeah. I. Don't know if that was
1:54:31
just the day in the store. As part
1:54:33
of the policy, I have to imagine solvent
1:54:35
different experience in the French countryside as compared
1:54:37
to a secret shopping center. Yeah, I can
1:54:39
see that. Back to
1:54:41
the Birkin bag by two thousand and one. It
1:54:44
becomes so widely known that there's
1:54:46
a waiting list. A sort of
1:54:49
almost secrets shrouded in mystery waiting
1:54:51
list. To get one of these
1:54:53
things that it is. the. Main.
1:54:56
Story line of a Sex in the City
1:54:58
episode. And. Samantha figures
1:55:00
out that there's a way to jump
1:55:03
the i think they use the number
1:55:05
five five year wait list will. The
1:55:07
scene where See walks into Try and
1:55:09
Buy It is just iconic where the
1:55:11
sales associate the pseudo responding to realize
1:55:13
it's twelve thousand dollars or whatever. Like
1:55:16
off I know there's a waiting list
1:55:18
of course and See name drops one
1:55:20
of her clients, her celebrity clients. In.
1:55:23
Order to say it's actually for them to try
1:55:25
to move up the wait list to get a
1:55:27
calamity ensues. They actually figure out that it's for
1:55:29
her, not the client. I. Actually, don't
1:55:31
watch the episode, but this is
1:55:33
a cultural touchstone for the Birkin
1:55:36
going from something that is sort
1:55:38
of saw. whispered. About and
1:55:40
Handbags circles and well known by the
1:55:42
wealthy elite to something that is now
1:55:44
a very well known phenomenon which is.
1:55:47
Good. Luck ever getting a Birkin bag
1:55:49
And you know that Crazy stories about
1:55:52
the most expensive one ever selling for
1:55:54
five hundred thousand dollars on the secondary
1:55:56
market and Victoria Beckham having a collection
1:55:59
of over one hundred, Then it's crazy.
1:56:01
You. Know it has become the
1:56:04
pretext to nautilus us handbags and
1:56:06
people look at it almost as
1:56:08
an investment. A way of summing
1:56:10
up what you're saying is the hard thing
1:56:12
about buying a burden is not coming up
1:56:14
with the money and which is crazy riot
1:56:17
act starting at twelve thousand dollar handbags. And
1:56:19
what you're saying is that's actually not
1:56:21
the constraints but also what you're talking
1:56:23
about. You. Do with echoes of our
1:56:25
Nike episode here. The minute that
1:56:28
you are in possession of a break and bag,
1:56:30
you could immediately sell it for a lot more
1:56:32
than what you paid for it. And.
1:56:34
Your errors essay will not be very happy
1:56:36
that you did that because the point of
1:56:38
buying one is to own one and use
1:56:41
one and appreciates the craft and the work
1:56:43
and the beauty that went into this product
1:56:45
and airmen as is not trying to sell
1:56:48
it to people that are going to flip
1:56:50
it, they're trying to sell it to valued
1:56:52
customers who will be. People. Who
1:56:54
appreciate the erm as dream for the rest
1:56:56
of their life? Yeah. That would be
1:56:58
the last Birkin bag that you ever buy. Every
1:57:01
bag I think maybe even every item
1:57:03
yes that erm as makes has what
1:57:06
I'm as cause a blind stamp on
1:57:08
it and this is a series of
1:57:10
symbols and numbers. There's one on my
1:57:12
belt right now the up this summer
1:57:15
my watch band right now. That.
1:57:17
Are stamped into the weather
1:57:19
that uniquely identify for that.
1:57:22
Item. The year it was made and
1:57:24
the crafts person who made it. And.
1:57:26
There are some very cool stories
1:57:28
of people who are transitioning from
1:57:30
across person who makes goods to
1:57:32
repairs them later in their careers
1:57:34
and who receives an item back
1:57:36
for a pair were they were
1:57:38
the original creator of that handbags
1:57:40
and that is the coolest, craziest
1:57:42
full circle air med moment for
1:57:44
any am. As crass person to
1:57:46
see this thing that I made
1:57:48
that I really wanted to be
1:57:50
durable and stand up in the
1:57:52
world hundred and actually perform and
1:57:54
to get it back ten. Twenty years
1:57:56
later and see, it has gotta be crazy cool. guess
1:58:00
So today everything we're talking about
1:58:02
here the Birken bag the Kelly
1:58:04
bag these ten to hundred thousand
1:58:07
dollar retail handbags. Depending on
1:58:09
the type of exotic leather and everything and
1:58:11
the scarcity are referred to as
1:58:13
a category of the blend
1:58:16
good and so this
1:58:18
is essentially the opposite of everything you
1:58:20
learned in econ one on one. I
1:58:23
have these everything about this company yes
1:58:25
so normally price is where supply meets
1:58:28
demand. So as the price of a
1:58:30
good increases demand for it would go
1:58:32
down a veblin good is the opposite.
1:58:36
As price increases people actually want
1:58:38
it more so price ends
1:58:40
up being a signal that the
1:58:43
item is desirable and thus it
1:58:45
stimulates demand now interestingly David this
1:58:47
is exactly what you were talking about before. Birken
1:58:50
bags sell below the market
1:58:52
clearing price yes that
1:58:54
is another defiance of micro
1:58:56
economics normally things should. The
1:58:59
price exactly the intersection of supply
1:59:01
meeting demand. I was just
1:59:03
laughing as you're talking about helping get there and I
1:59:05
whipped out my copy of the luxury strategy and
1:59:08
flip to anti love marketing number
1:59:10
thirteen raise your prices as
1:59:13
time goes on in order to
1:59:15
increase demand. So interesting
1:59:18
but one way to look
1:59:20
at this is always lost revenue their prices aren't
1:59:22
high enough because they can only make so
1:59:24
many of them. Hand they're selling
1:59:26
them below the price people are willing to pay
1:59:29
so there's money left on the table. What
1:59:32
another way to look at it is that it's
1:59:34
an investment in the brand so there's a very
1:59:36
good sub stack writer three ten value that will
1:59:38
link to in the show notes who observed. The
1:59:41
supply demand mismatch creates scarcity in
1:59:43
these two bags and that scarcity
1:59:45
likely creates more demand for the
1:59:47
bags elevates the overall status of
1:59:50
her mess and creates demand for
1:59:52
her mother's other products. As customers
1:59:54
by her messes other goods to
1:59:56
build a relationship with the company
1:59:58
in hopes of. being allocated a
2:00:00
bag at the below market retail
2:00:03
price? Yes, this
2:00:05
is the same dynamic with
2:00:08
I think a very different set of motivations
2:00:10
as we talked about on the Nike episode.
2:00:13
I very firmly believe that
2:00:16
Nike could sell many
2:00:18
of their shoes for two,
2:00:20
three, four, or five times the price that
2:00:22
they do. And they'll
2:00:24
show up on Goate or StockX all
2:00:27
the time regularly at higher prices
2:00:29
than Nike releases them for. I
2:00:32
believe that the reason that they do
2:00:34
this is to maintain goodwill
2:00:36
with their customer base and
2:00:40
maintain Nike's image as a
2:00:42
brand that is accessible to
2:00:44
everyone. Hermes
2:00:46
is doing the opposite. They
2:00:50
want this to happen in
2:00:52
order to maintain the image of
2:00:55
Hermes and specifically the Perkins and the Kelly's
2:00:58
as a brand and a product
2:01:00
that is not accessible to everyone.
2:01:02
Yes. And it's
2:01:05
not as simple as, well, they just keep
2:01:07
raising the prices to make people
2:01:09
keep wanting them more. You
2:01:11
read that in the luxury strategy and many
2:01:13
luxury brands do that. In fact, Chanel has
2:01:16
done it in record amounts the last couple
2:01:18
of years with the, I think
2:01:20
it's called the Chanel Classic Flap Medium or something
2:01:22
like that. But that's had this crazy appreciation over
2:01:24
the last few years where Chanel is just raising
2:01:26
the price. Hermes doesn't
2:01:28
do that. We'll talk about this more later in
2:01:31
the episode, but by my
2:01:33
very back of the envelope calculations, they
2:01:35
are raising their prices
2:01:37
on average across
2:01:39
the entire line 7% per year for the last
2:01:42
10 years. So
2:01:44
it's like 5% above, 4 or 5% above inflation. Yeah.
2:01:48
Which is more, but not an egregious amount. Right. There
2:01:51
was a study that found that the Birkin 30, which
2:01:53
is one of the sizes in Togo leather,
2:01:55
didn't even equal the rate of inflation in
2:01:57
the US. I'm trying to figure out what the... motivation
2:02:00
here is because it's a tremendous
2:02:02
restraint. There's
2:02:05
no cash grab happening. And
2:02:07
maybe it's because what
2:02:10
bad things would happen to Hermes
2:02:12
if they decided, you know
2:02:14
what, Birkins are 20 now, not 12. Right.
2:02:17
They're already viewed as the
2:02:19
most expensive handbags in the world. So
2:02:23
what harm done to go from 12 to 20? Right.
2:02:27
And they sell a lot of them. So that
2:02:29
actually would be a lot of profit dollars. Right.
2:02:33
And for somebody who's going to spend $12,000 on a
2:02:35
handbag, are that many more of those people
2:02:38
going to be price sensitive at
2:02:40
that swing from 12 to 20? Probably
2:02:43
not. Right. The
2:02:46
Wall Street Journal estimated in 2020 that there's
2:02:48
about 120,000 of the combined Birkin
2:02:52
and Kelly created each year. So
2:02:55
120,000 bags a year. I
2:02:57
mean, if you decide that you want to make another 8,000 of
2:03:00
pure profit on each bag, that
2:03:02
is tempting. And I think it actually says
2:03:04
a lot about Hermes's obsession
2:03:07
with conservatism, that they don't
2:03:09
meaningfully increase the price. Like
2:03:11
the Kelly is not far
2:03:13
above its original 1950s
2:03:16
price inflation adjusted. I think the
2:03:18
Birkin bag, the retail price was around $2,000 when
2:03:20
it launched in 1984. So
2:03:23
call it maybe $6,000 inflation adjusted.
2:03:27
So you're looking at maybe
2:03:29
twice the price that it launched out
2:03:31
on an inflation adjusted basis. So
2:03:34
I guess the point I'm making here is I think we
2:03:36
should keep in the back of our
2:03:38
mind the rest of the episode this
2:03:40
question of why doesn't Hermes raise the
2:03:42
prices? They're already getting the benefit either
2:03:44
way of the trickle down of people
2:03:46
participating in the Hermes ecosystem to hopefully
2:03:49
get the call one day. So
2:03:51
why not make it even more expensive when you
2:03:53
do get the call? Interesting. All right, let's
2:03:56
come back to that later in the episode. Yeah. Okay,
2:03:58
so 1984. release doesn't sell
2:04:00
well for the first five years, then it becomes
2:04:02
this cultural touchstone and gains steam every year after
2:04:05
that. And I was just thinking about that as
2:04:07
we were chatting here. This makes
2:04:09
sense to me that it wouldn't be a hit right away,
2:04:12
because it takes time to
2:04:14
build the lore and aura
2:04:17
around this bag. You can't just drop
2:04:19
a new product and have it become
2:04:21
like this immediately in
2:04:24
this category. Correct. You're
2:04:26
never going to have like an iPhone of
2:04:28
luxury handbags. Correct. It has to
2:04:30
be like a Taylor
2:04:33
Swift concert in order
2:04:35
to instantly... I actually
2:04:37
think it's a reasonable comp
2:04:39
though. Like her concert was
2:04:41
a extremely scarce brand
2:04:43
new product priced at an extreme
2:04:46
premium that did sell right
2:04:48
away because the product had so much of the
2:04:50
brand in it. Like you knew exactly what you
2:04:53
were going to get from going to the Taylor
2:04:55
concert because you were extremely familiar with the brand.
2:04:57
But it's not necessarily well
2:04:59
understood that the Birkin equals Hermes in
2:05:01
the way that the Aeros tour equals
2:05:03
Taylor Swift. Totally. It's also
2:05:05
that the product was the Aeros tour.
2:05:07
The product was not midnight. If
2:05:10
it were like, oh, I'm going to go to
2:05:12
Taylor's concert and listen to her play all the
2:05:14
songs on the new album, of course a lot
2:05:16
of people would still go. But it
2:05:18
was like, no, I'm going to go to
2:05:20
Taylor's concert and hear all
2:05:23
of Taylor. All the amazing Hermes scarves
2:05:25
from over the years released out of
2:05:27
the vault. Yes.
2:05:30
The Disney plus of Taylor Swift.
2:05:32
All right. A different episode here.
2:05:34
Okay. Back to
2:05:37
Jean-Louis. So this is
2:05:39
how he does it. He does two
2:05:41
incredible things to save the company. One,
2:05:45
he repositions the brand. I mean, this is
2:05:47
just like, I can't believe he pulled this
2:05:49
off. He pulls off Not Your Mother's Tiffany
2:05:51
without saying Not Your Mother's Tiffany. And
2:05:54
the culmination of that is the Birkin bag and
2:05:56
everything that that represents. And then
2:05:59
two, the internationalization. and discovering
2:06:01
and running the same playbook that Rakhamiye
2:06:03
ran at Louis Vuitton. By
2:06:05
the end of Jean-Louis' tenure in 2006, so
2:06:07
a couple years after
2:06:10
the famous Sex and the City
2:06:12
episode, Hermes has gone from well
2:06:15
less than $100 million when he took
2:06:17
over. The consultants were saying, you know,
2:06:19
outsource, shut it down essentially. By
2:06:22
the end of the decade of the 80s,
2:06:24
he was just under half a billion dollars
2:06:26
in revenue. And then in
2:06:28
2006, he's taken it to
2:06:30
$2 billion in annual
2:06:32
revenue from, you
2:06:34
know, nice family business to like, this
2:06:37
is a real, real thing. So one
2:06:39
more time on those numbers. So
2:06:41
I don't know the exact revenue figure when he
2:06:43
took over, but let's call it $50 million in
2:06:45
annual revenue. We know it was well less than
2:06:48
$100 to $2 billion when he
2:06:50
retires in 2006. So
2:06:54
40x in 30 years? Yeah,
2:06:56
40x in under 30 years. Wow.
2:06:59
Pretty good. Pretty transformative for the family
2:07:01
business. Well,
2:07:05
along the way, as the company
2:07:09
clearly becomes more and more valuable,
2:07:11
you know, remember he is
2:07:13
the family member who's running it, but
2:07:16
we're now on the fifth generation of the family.
2:07:18
We're starting to bleed into the sixth generation of
2:07:20
the family. We're now over 80 family
2:07:24
members out there, eight zero, many
2:07:26
of whom are involved in the business, but many
2:07:28
of whom aren't. And
2:07:31
now this business that they all own
2:07:33
is doing $2 billion a year in
2:07:35
revenue at very, very
2:07:37
high margins. There
2:07:39
starts to be some demand for
2:07:42
liquidity here. Right. Every single
2:07:44
one of those family members, most
2:07:47
valuable asset in their entire net
2:07:49
worth is their privately held Hermes
2:07:51
stock that nobody can really
2:07:53
put a price tag on. But
2:07:56
it's just sort of sitting there in everyone's mind
2:07:58
of like, I'm sure it would be easier
2:08:00
to live my life if I knew that this
2:08:03
90% of my net worth actually worth
2:08:05
something that I could access. And
2:08:07
an even split, that's $25 million a person. I'm
2:08:10
pretty sure it's the most valuable thing that any of them
2:08:12
owns. Right. So
2:08:15
in 1993, Jean-Louis lists
2:08:17
Hermes on the Paris
2:08:19
Stock Exchange. Collectively when
2:08:22
the dust settles, the family has sold 19%
2:08:24
of Hermes to the public. They
2:08:27
still own 81%. Now
2:08:30
the public float grows a
2:08:32
little bit over the years as more
2:08:34
family members sell, more generational transfer happens.
2:08:37
But more or less still,
2:08:39
70% plus family owned and
2:08:42
controlled. It would really take
2:08:44
some sort of absolute financial
2:08:46
genius to come in and even consider,
2:08:49
we own over 70% of this business.
2:08:52
We're unassailable. Who on earth could
2:08:55
possibly make a run at our
2:08:58
company? We would take a real wolf, I'll tell you. Which
2:09:04
brings us to, this has been so fun. I've had
2:09:06
so much fun with this episode, all
2:09:08
of this history. I just revel in the French connection
2:09:10
and everything. This is Hermes's finest
2:09:12
moment that we're about to talk about here, through
2:09:15
it all. And it's interesting, it's not their product.
2:09:17
No, it has nothing to do with the product. Yes.
2:09:21
The fight with Bernard Arnaud.
2:09:24
Yes. But before that,
2:09:26
now is a great time to
2:09:28
share some new news about our
2:09:30
longtime friend of the show, Vanta,
2:09:33
the leading trust management platform. Vanta,
2:09:35
of course, automates your security reviews
2:09:37
and compliance efforts. So frameworks like
2:09:39
SOC 2, ISO 27001, GDPR,
2:09:42
and HIPAA compliance and monitoring. Vanta
2:09:45
takes these otherwise time consuming and
2:09:47
incredibly resource draining efforts for your
2:09:49
organization, makes them fast and simple.
2:09:51
Yes. The big news that they
2:09:53
announced last week is they now have over 7,000 customers just
2:09:57
five years after launch. is
2:10:00
the perfect example of a quote we talk
2:10:02
about all the time here on Acquired. Jeff
2:10:04
Bezos has idea that a company should only
2:10:06
focus on what makes your beer actually taste
2:10:09
better, i.e. spend your time
2:10:11
and resources only on what's actually gonna move
2:10:13
the needle for your product and customers and
2:10:15
outsource everything else that doesn't. Every
2:10:18
company needs compliance and trust with their
2:10:20
vendors and customers. It plays a major
2:10:22
role in enabling your revenue because customers
2:10:24
and partners demand it. But yet,
2:10:27
it adds zero flavor to your actual
2:10:29
beer or your product. Yes, Vanta takes
2:10:31
care of all of that for you.
2:10:33
No more spreadsheets, fragmented tools, manual reviews
2:10:35
to cobble together your security and compliance
2:10:38
requirements. It is a one
2:10:40
single software pane of glass that connects
2:10:42
you to all of your services via
2:10:44
APIs and eliminates countless hours of work
2:10:46
for your organization. They even launched a
2:10:48
bunch of AI capabilities in the last
2:10:50
year to make this even simpler and
2:10:52
more powerful than before. They now integrate
2:10:54
over 300 external tools and even
2:10:57
enable customers to build private integrations
2:11:00
with their internal systems. And
2:11:02
critically, your security reviews are now
2:11:04
real time instead of static, which
2:11:06
you can monitor and share with
2:11:08
your customers and partners. Vanta's platform
2:11:10
helps you continuously monitor compliance alongside
2:11:12
reporting and tracking risk. Plus, you
2:11:14
can save countless hours by completing
2:11:16
security questionnaires with Vanta AI. Yep,
2:11:19
Vanta scales all the way from seed stage
2:11:21
startups to large enterprises. So if your company
2:11:23
is ready to automate and streamline security reviews
2:11:25
like 7,000 other customers, go
2:11:27
back to making your beer taste
2:11:29
better and head to vanta.com/acquired and
2:11:32
just tell them that Ben and David sent
2:11:34
you. And thanks to our friend Christina Vanta,
2:11:36
the CEO, all acquired listeners get $1,000
2:11:39
of free credit at
2:11:42
vanta.com/acquired. David Rosenthal,
2:11:45
let us return to Bernard
2:11:47
Arnaud. It's been 12 months. It's been too
2:11:49
long. I've been wanting to hear the other
2:11:51
side of the story. I know, I know.
2:11:54
Okay, so for anybody who's listened
2:11:56
to our LVMH episode, as
2:11:58
we talked about earlier, The climax
2:12:00
of the story is Bernard's fight
2:12:02
with Gucci in that episode. And
2:12:06
Gucci is the one that gets away. Bernard
2:12:08
isn't able to buy it. Right
2:12:10
after the Gucci fight ends in
2:12:12
the early 2000s, the
2:12:14
same story plays out with Hermes,
2:12:17
I think really in an even
2:12:19
more dramatic fashion. So
2:12:22
in 2001, right after he lost
2:12:24
Gucci, Bernard quietly
2:12:26
buys an initial stake in Hermes,
2:12:29
a I
2:12:31
believe that was just under the threshold
2:12:33
that they would have to disclose it
2:12:35
under French securities regulations. And
2:12:37
then here's what they do that
2:12:40
the Hermes families couldn't see coming that only
2:12:42
Bernard could engineer. He
2:12:44
continues buying for the next
2:12:46
10 years using
2:12:49
equity swap derivatives. So
2:12:52
it looks like other entities are buying these
2:12:54
shares on the open market, but
2:12:57
LVMH have the rights to
2:12:59
exercise options to go actually take those shares.
2:13:03
Now, this is really hard
2:13:05
to remember. I had to triple check these
2:13:07
numbers. At this point in
2:13:09
time, Hermes's market cap is below
2:13:11
20 billion. That's
2:13:13
like eight, 9% of what it is today. And
2:13:15
when Bernard first starts buying in the early 2000s,
2:13:18
it's below 10 billion. Whoa.
2:13:22
But you could say lots of things about Bernard and
2:13:24
genius should be top of your list. But
2:13:28
he is one of the best investors of all time. I
2:13:30
mean, to identify Hermes at this point
2:13:32
in time, and as we will see,
2:13:34
he makes a incredible amount of money
2:13:36
on these trades. You know, today
2:13:38
Hermes is a $230 billion market cap
2:13:40
company and he starts buying at below
2:13:44
Which is interesting. You say he's spotted Hermes. It
2:13:46
wasn't hard to spot. The interesting thing is not
2:13:48
that he realized it was the crown jewel of
2:13:50
luxury. It was that he realized that the crown
2:13:52
jewel of luxury could be worth 20 to 30
2:13:54
times as much as it
2:13:56
was already worth. So he
2:13:58
starts buying Hermes shares. And Accel, I
2:14:00
think, jokes about this in an interview. He's
2:14:03
like, look, Bernard isn't buying your
2:14:05
shares just because he wants to make an
2:14:07
investment or he wants to have some fun.
2:14:09
Like, obviously, he wants to own Hermes.
2:14:12
And by the way, when David and I
2:14:14
are referencing these Accel interviews, it's one interview.
2:14:17
He's made a random appearance here
2:14:19
and there, but he has done
2:14:21
one long-form, onstage interview, and it
2:14:23
is fantastic. Yes. That's great. We'll
2:14:26
link to it in the sources. You should go watch it. So
2:14:28
why is Bernard doing this? Obviously,
2:14:30
on the one hand, he sees the value
2:14:32
here. I mean, for God's sake, because the
2:14:34
Sex and the City episode was just dedicated
2:14:36
to the Birkin. There's a lot
2:14:39
of value to be unlocked here, shall we
2:14:42
say, in owning Hermes. But
2:14:44
it's not just that. I hope
2:14:46
on our LVMH episode, this is some of
2:14:49
the nuance that we painted about Bernard. He's
2:14:52
not just a corporate raider. He
2:14:55
actually is an operator,
2:14:58
and he is one of, if not
2:15:01
the best, luxury operator out there. So
2:15:04
he sees two things in
2:15:06
Hermes that maybe aren't as
2:15:08
obvious to the rest of the world and that he thinks
2:15:10
actually are going to create an opportunity for him. One,
2:15:13
generational transfer is about to happen.
2:15:16
Jean-Louis can't live forever, and
2:15:19
it's not immediately clear who the
2:15:21
next successor is going to be.
2:15:24
Jean-Louis's son, Pierre Alexi,
2:15:26
takes over as artistic director. Pierre
2:15:29
Alexi went to America for college.
2:15:31
He went to Brown University. Interesting,
2:15:33
in an interview I found this,
2:15:35
he initially wanted to study computer
2:15:38
science at Brown, but he switched
2:15:40
to art history. Very fitting.
2:15:43
And he comes in and he joins Hermes right after
2:15:45
graduation in 1992. So
2:15:47
he's being groomed. Jean-Louis
2:15:49
wants to separate out the artistic
2:15:51
director role and the CEO role.
2:15:54
Oh, they had been coupled before? Well,
2:15:56
yeah, he held both. So Robert held
2:15:58
both. was both.
2:16:00
Pierre, you was certainly both. Right. So that
2:16:02
really illustrates the point you were making earlier,
2:16:04
that the creative and the business sides of
2:16:07
the house are one side of the house.
2:16:09
Yes. Until this generation, it was one person.
2:16:11
There was no separation at all. So
2:16:14
Pierre Alexei is clearly the
2:16:16
artistic heir. There's
2:16:19
not a clear CEO
2:16:21
heir. And in
2:16:23
fact, Jean-Louis's choice, Xcel, who
2:16:26
ultimately does become CEO, he's
2:16:29
not in the business yet. Right.
2:16:31
He did that internship, his sort of
2:16:33
five-year apprenticeship, but then he left, right?
2:16:36
Yes. So the story is that Xcel
2:16:38
really wanted to go work in China.
2:16:41
And so he goes into investment banking after
2:16:44
undergrad. He goes to Sciences Po. Now,
2:16:47
and remember, Jean-Louis was his uncle, but
2:16:49
his mother, who actually was not a
2:16:51
family member, was the managing director for
2:16:53
production, or
2:16:56
Hermes. Xcel has this sort
2:16:58
of dinner table trading in addition to
2:17:00
the apprenticeship craftsman trading. But he goes
2:17:02
off into the investment banking world. He
2:17:05
works first in China and then in
2:17:07
New York for Banh Pei
2:17:09
Paribas. Wow. So he
2:17:11
is an expert in
2:17:13
corporate structure. Yep. And he's
2:17:16
an expert on this pretty interesting luxury market
2:17:18
in the next 20 years, China. Yep.
2:17:21
And America too. But
2:17:25
he doesn't join the business until 2003 when... Jean-Louis
2:17:28
taps him. And again, on
2:17:31
the one hand, as we've talked about, this is a nepotistic
2:17:33
business. On the other hand, they're not going to just give
2:17:35
him the CEO title right away. He
2:17:37
needs to come pay his dues. He
2:17:40
starts in the finance department in 2003. And then in 2006,
2:17:45
when Jean-Louis retires, Xcel takes
2:17:47
over running the jewelry, Métiers, as
2:17:49
CEO of Jewelry. Which listeners
2:17:51
you should know, jewelry is not an important
2:17:53
part of the Hermes business. It's one of
2:17:55
the 16 Métiers. They don't even
2:17:57
break it out in earnings. It probably rolls
2:18:00
up under other Hermes
2:18:02
sectors because I don't think it's under
2:18:04
watches and I don't think it's under
2:18:06
ready-to-wear accessories. All of other is 12%
2:18:08
so I'm gonna guess
2:18:10
this thing is like 1 to 3%. So
2:18:13
he does that for two years and then in 2008 he
2:18:17
goes and takes over the leather goods and
2:18:19
salary business. So the big one. Which that's
2:18:21
43% of the business and I think at
2:18:23
the time it was closer to 50%. Yes.
2:18:26
So Bernard sees, okay,
2:18:29
got a generational transfer opening here
2:18:32
and in fact when Jean-Louis retires
2:18:34
in 2006 he promotes his sort
2:18:36
of COO right-hand
2:18:40
person Patrick Thomas to
2:18:42
be the first non-family member CEO
2:18:44
running the business side of the
2:18:46
house alongside Pierre Alexei on the
2:18:48
artistic side. And at least in
2:18:50
retrospect they try to make this seem like
2:18:52
not a big deal that a non-family member
2:18:55
took over as CEO. They sort of bill
2:18:57
it as, well, they
2:18:59
needed someone to look after the business in the interim
2:19:01
period before the family was sort of ready to have
2:19:03
the next heir. I think there's
2:19:06
as much chances not that that was right
2:19:08
but at a minimum I
2:19:10
think this shows the sort
2:19:13
of ignorance. You know I don't want to
2:19:15
say lackadaisicalness of the family
2:19:17
here because it's certainly not that
2:19:19
but maybe sort of ignorance
2:19:21
or naivety that, hey, you're now a public
2:19:23
company and there are people
2:19:26
like Bernard Arnault out there. You
2:19:28
can't just be like, oh
2:19:30
yeah, we're gonna do public company CEO
2:19:32
transition in this way and take our
2:19:35
time. You can but
2:19:37
you're opening the door for... Right, you're vulnerable.
2:19:39
The Arnault's of the world. So
2:19:41
that's one thing that Bernard sees. The other,
2:19:44
and I really think this is a
2:19:46
testament to his vision, despite
2:19:48
all of the strength within Hermes
2:19:50
and everything that Jean-Louis did, they
2:19:54
actually are showing some cracks.
2:19:57
And this we had to kind of piece together a
2:19:59
little bit. And talking to folks in the industry helped
2:20:01
us out here. But look,
2:20:03
there's no questioning Hermes's financial results
2:20:06
and sort of on the surface brand
2:20:09
value at this point in time in
2:20:11
the 2000s, early 2010s. But
2:20:15
there are a few things that are just kind of
2:20:17
starting to slip as they scale. And
2:20:19
I think actually the best story
2:20:21
that illustrates this is
2:20:24
one that the family members themselves do
2:20:26
not tell, but that you'll hear out
2:20:28
there in the lore about Hermes, which
2:20:30
is that in, I believe it was
2:20:32
in Japan, they had a product,
2:20:35
a bag. Oh yeah, this is
2:20:37
so interesting listeners. If you listen to other coverage
2:20:39
of Hermes, you will hear this story. And
2:20:42
you never hear it from the perspective that we're about to tell
2:20:44
it. Okay, so here's how the story goes. It's
2:20:47
called the late 2000s, early 2010s. And
2:20:51
Hermes is selling a canvas
2:20:53
beach bag in Japan, and
2:20:55
it is flying off the shelf selling
2:20:58
like hotcakes. It's like equivalent of call
2:21:00
it $150 canvas tote bag beach bag. And
2:21:06
this obviously gets the attention of management
2:21:08
and the company that this is happening.
2:21:12
And they decide that they are going to in
2:21:14
true Hermes fashion because they're selling so well, they
2:21:16
are going to not only stop selling
2:21:18
the product, they're going to take all their supply
2:21:20
of it and destroy it. And
2:21:23
they come into a board meeting with
2:21:25
all the family members and management,
2:21:27
they sort of announced this and it is
2:21:29
met with a standing ovation from the family.
2:21:32
This is upholding what Hermes is,
2:21:34
which is we don't sell beach bags.
2:21:36
The family and the board is so
2:21:38
aligned that no one even asked a
2:21:40
question about this. They just stood and
2:21:42
gave applause. And here's
2:21:44
how this went on a
2:21:46
meta level listeners. I heard
2:21:48
this story, David heard this story, and
2:21:51
David texted me at one point was like, isn't
2:21:53
this an odd story? And I was
2:21:55
like, what do you mean? And we sort of
2:21:57
realized, oh, this is not ever
2:21:59
told. by any of the family members or company
2:22:02
executives anywhere. It's just sort of out there. And
2:22:04
the company is not secretive. They love
2:22:06
telling these legendary or mezz stories. Yeah.
2:22:08
And they've got a 600 page
2:22:11
document they release once every year that
2:22:13
clearly lays out their entire strategy. They
2:22:16
produce documentaries, interviewing their artisans,
2:22:18
showing videos of their factories.
2:22:21
So it rings a little bit odd. It's like, okay,
2:22:24
why are they not telling this story,
2:22:26
given how often it's bantied about? So
2:22:28
then you think about it a little bit and you're like, wait
2:22:31
a minute. Why the F did
2:22:35
this happen in the first place? Exactly.
2:22:38
A canvas beach bag in Japan for $150.
2:22:40
And they're making enough of it that it's
2:22:46
flying off the shelves? What company
2:22:48
is this? How on
2:22:50
earth did this happen?
2:22:53
The story here is not a heroic one
2:22:55
of we destroyed the supply. This is a
2:22:57
tragic one. It's almost like when
2:22:59
I was sitting there watching Wonder Woman 84 and
2:23:01
I was just so appalled
2:23:04
at what I was watching that on this meta
2:23:06
level, it occurred to me like the
2:23:09
story here isn't the plot of this movie.
2:23:11
The story here is how do you have
2:23:13
such a process failure
2:23:15
at Warner Brothers where this thing was let
2:23:17
out the door? That is a failure of
2:23:19
creative leadership and that is what you have
2:23:22
going on with a $150 canvas tote bag
2:23:24
after 175 years of
2:23:29
successful Hermes brand stewardship. And
2:23:33
building up the Birkin, the Kelly, I mean, for
2:23:35
God's sakes, the scarves sell for like $500. So,
2:23:37
okay, that
2:23:40
I think is the most visceral illustration
2:23:42
of this. Two other things
2:23:44
that I saw in the research and I
2:23:46
think Bernard probably saw here too. Towards
2:23:49
the end of Jean-Louis tenure,
2:23:52
he and Hermes started buying and
2:23:55
investing in other companies. But
2:23:57
why is Hermes doing this? This
2:24:00
is like the weird stuff going on at Nike when they
2:24:02
were buying, you know, Converse was the
2:24:04
good example, but starter and it
2:24:06
was almost like they didn't realize, oh, we
2:24:08
should be concentrating our firepower behind our one
2:24:10
hero brand. They were trying to create the
2:24:12
constellation of weak brands. The best
2:24:15
Hermes could ever hope for by doing this
2:24:17
is they're going to be a subscale,
2:24:19
like they're not even going to be Reismont or
2:24:21
Kering. Now one argument, you know,
2:24:23
bootmaker John Lobb and all these other companies that
2:24:25
they either bought in whole or in part, it
2:24:28
became important for them to own
2:24:31
their key supplier relationships. Yes.
2:24:33
Those I think were probably strategic acquisitions.
2:24:36
Yeah, especially in watches where they actually
2:24:38
fairly recently took a 25% position in
2:24:40
the company
2:24:42
that makes the movements to make sure that they
2:24:44
have enough supply coming to them. But that
2:24:47
wasn't all of what they were
2:24:49
doing. They were also buying other brands. Yeah. Did
2:24:51
you find the biggest disaster? This is kind of in your
2:24:54
wheelhouse. Ooh, I don't know. I was wondering if I could
2:24:56
stump you with this. They bought,
2:24:58
I believe, a 30, 35% stake. They
2:25:02
were the largest shareholder in a
2:25:04
German company that makes what
2:25:07
is really a piece of technology, an
2:25:09
old piece of technology, not
2:25:12
something that should be a luxury brand. This
2:25:14
is very much in the performance end of
2:25:16
the spectrum. They became the largest
2:25:18
shareholders in Leica, the camera company. Really?
2:25:22
Yeah. The
2:25:24
motivation is like, oh, they're beautiful and they're
2:25:26
like luxurious cameras and they have leather on
2:25:28
them and we can put Hermes leather on
2:25:30
the Leica cameras. Yeah. If
2:25:33
they made a Hermes edition Leica
2:25:35
camera with a... They did? I
2:25:38
should probably look into that. But okay,
2:25:40
you're talking about a very
2:25:43
narrow target market here and
2:25:45
it's just a technology product. We'll
2:25:47
get into this with Apple in a minute, but it
2:25:49
didn't go well. Let's put it that way. They ended up
2:25:51
divesting the stake. It reminds me of when the New York
2:25:53
Times did all of this with all the TV stations in
2:25:55
the 90s too. It's almost
2:25:58
like every company that ever thinks it's a good... idea
2:26:00
to start buying up other brands is
2:26:02
wrong. Yeah. Unless that
2:26:04
is the core strategy of what you are doing,
2:26:06
like LVMH. Yes. Yeah.
2:26:10
The third thing that they do, they
2:26:12
incubate and create a
2:26:14
new luxury brand and
2:26:16
company in China called
2:26:19
Shangxia. I believe I'm pronouncing that
2:26:21
right. In 2009 is
2:26:23
when they launch it. It literally means
2:26:25
up, down, or past,
2:26:27
present. And the idea is that
2:26:29
the Chinese market is so big and so important
2:26:31
to Hermes. They're going to
2:26:33
lend the Hermes brand to this
2:26:36
new brand that is going to
2:26:38
have Hermes principles but take traditional
2:26:40
Chinese craftsmanship, of which there's a
2:26:43
long, multi-thousand-year history. Yep.
2:26:45
I actually like the strategy. Well, yeah,
2:26:48
I mean, it sounds good on paper, right? But
2:26:51
here's the problem, like we were talking about earlier. Nothing
2:26:54
compares to French culture as an export
2:26:57
and when you're buying luxury. And
2:27:00
this is a great experiment to run, sure. But
2:27:03
the reality is that for probably
2:27:05
most countries in the world, when
2:27:08
you're talking about spending $20,000 on
2:27:10
a piece of leather, you
2:27:13
want that to be from Hermes and you want
2:27:15
that to be from France. Right. And I think
2:27:18
this is especially true in China. Yeah,
2:27:20
that's such a good point. That's funny. I
2:27:22
have a playbook theme called selling a sense of place
2:27:24
to those outside it. The numbers behind this are crazy.
2:27:27
Today, 76% of their production is
2:27:30
in France and 85% is sold outside of France. Yeah.
2:27:34
First of all, 76% of production in France is kind
2:27:36
of incredible, the fact that they do this with all
2:27:38
these different workshops that are sort of scattered around the
2:27:40
country. But yeah, the
2:27:42
incredible French history that is
2:27:45
encapsulated by the brand and the French
2:27:47
nobility and the French sense of place,
2:27:50
it really is just an intangible
2:27:53
connection to the culture that
2:27:55
is lusted after everywhere in the world. Why
2:27:58
on earth would you throw that away? when that really
2:28:00
is the essence of your core asset.
2:28:04
Now, easy for us to armchair quarterback
2:28:06
here, like obviously it didn't work. They end up
2:28:08
selling it off actually pretty recently to
2:28:10
the Aniele family from Italy, which
2:28:13
is the family behind Fiat. Now
2:28:15
look, certainly that one, the Leica
2:28:18
thing, it's the combination of
2:28:20
all these and the beach bag
2:28:22
incident, Bernard sees all this. Here's
2:28:25
what he says in the press at the time. I
2:28:28
would never diminish the quality of Hermes.
2:28:31
Hermes can be an even rarer and
2:28:33
greater quality business if they ever wanted
2:28:35
to work with us. And I think
2:28:38
he's genuine about that. The
2:28:40
family obviously circles the wagons
2:28:42
and mounts the rebel alliance
2:28:44
here, mounting
2:28:46
their defense against the empire. Which I think
2:28:48
is quite impressive, absolutely. The fact that they
2:28:51
were able to link arms like this and
2:28:53
say in the face of
2:28:55
someone trying to make
2:28:57
you and all your relatives collectively
2:29:00
a multi-billionaire in
2:29:02
liquid cash, it's kind of incredible to
2:29:04
link arms and manage to rebuff it.
2:29:06
Totally, we'll tell the story here and
2:29:08
it's amazing. But I think this is
2:29:10
like a really important point that I want
2:29:12
to land is I don't think Arnaud
2:29:15
was wrong. I think he had a point
2:29:17
and I think the company at the time didn't get it. They
2:29:20
certainly do now. So, okay,
2:29:22
what's the story? What happens? Finally,
2:29:26
in October of 2010, Arnaud is patient. He
2:29:29
spent nine years? Nine plus
2:29:31
years, yeah. That he's just
2:29:33
building this stake, being patient. In
2:29:36
October 2010, LVMH exercises
2:29:38
its options on the equity swaps
2:29:40
that it owns and announces that
2:29:43
it now controls 14.2% of Hermes
2:29:45
shares. And
2:29:48
Bernard at the time he says, I had
2:29:51
to do it because other luxury
2:29:54
groups were also talking
2:29:56
about making a run at Hermes. And
2:29:58
I didn't want this crown. of France
2:30:00
to be owned, heaven forbid, maybe by
2:30:02
a non-French, you know, organization, quote
2:30:05
here, I could not sit by
2:30:07
and allow a competitor or another investor to
2:30:09
take a snake in Hermes. Oh,
2:30:12
he's good. He's so good. I love it. In
2:30:14
response to this is the
2:30:16
famous or infamous, if you will, quote
2:30:18
from Patrick Thomas, the then CEO of
2:30:20
Hermes, which we're not going to say
2:30:22
the full thing here on air. You
2:30:24
can go Google it. But the
2:30:27
response and this is an official press
2:30:29
conference, you know, with investor relations people.
2:30:32
He says if you want to seduce a
2:30:34
beautiful woman, obviously Hermes being the beautiful woman
2:30:36
here, you don't start in the
2:30:39
fashion that Bernard is and he doesn't
2:30:41
use those words. This is hilarious. This
2:30:43
is amazing. That makes, of
2:30:45
course, a huge splash in the
2:30:47
French and international press. The
2:30:49
drama here is delicious. Carl
2:30:52
Lagerfeld has asked his thoughts
2:30:54
on what's going on here at Lagerfeld. Of course,
2:30:56
he's a legend. He's the
2:30:58
longtime creative director of Chanel. He
2:31:00
comments publicly, well, if you
2:31:02
don't want to be taken over, don't put
2:31:04
your business on the public market. Which hey,
2:31:06
game recognize game. That's a great point. He's
2:31:09
got a point. If you want liquidity, I
2:31:11
mean, this is the trade off you make. Now,
2:31:14
of course, Lagerfeld, yes, famously
2:31:16
is the creative director of
2:31:18
Chanel, but he wasn't exclusively the creative
2:31:20
director of Chanel. Who is he also
2:31:22
working for at this point in time.
2:31:25
He is also, I believe the menswear
2:31:27
creative director for Fendi, which is owned
2:31:29
by, by LVMH. LVMH. He's
2:31:31
on payroll. He's on payroll. This
2:31:34
continues on for months in the public markets
2:31:36
and in the press. By December
2:31:38
of 2011, the LVMH stake has grown to 22.6%.
2:31:41
Now, the family owns 73% of the company
2:31:50
at this point. So Bernard
2:31:52
now owns almost the
2:31:55
entire public float of Hermes. There's what,
2:31:57
like three and a half percent of
2:31:59
it. Hermes that's publicly floated, he doesn't
2:32:01
own. Yeah, Hermes is like in danger
2:32:04
of being delisted from the stock exchange.
2:32:06
Crazy. Now, this is what's so
2:32:08
brilliant. You might ask, why does
2:32:10
this matter? The family owns 73%, Bernard can't
2:32:12
do anything. Price is a
2:32:14
function of supply and demand. So
2:32:16
as Bernard is shrinking the float
2:32:19
of this company, the shares that
2:32:21
are available for trade on
2:32:24
the public markets, well, what happens
2:32:26
to the stock price? Skyrocket. It goes
2:32:28
through the roof. So
2:32:30
now you've got 80 family members and
2:32:33
they already thought they were really wealthy and
2:32:36
they already wanted liquidity. And
2:32:39
now Bernard's coming to them and this
2:32:41
is the strategy. They just go pick off individual family
2:32:43
members one by one, keep increasing
2:32:45
his stake and saying like, yeah, I'll pay you
2:32:47
the market price, which is
2:32:49
now incredibly inflated for this company.
2:32:51
Great. Happy to pay you
2:32:54
many hundreds of millions of dollars. Crazy.
2:32:57
So what happens? This
2:33:00
is why I think this really was the family
2:33:03
and the company's finest moment. That
2:33:06
temptation must have
2:33:08
been extreme. And that's just
2:33:11
the externally identifiable motivations. I'm
2:33:14
sure Bernard and other people
2:33:16
at LVMH and everybody else in the
2:33:18
industry is doing everything they can to
2:33:20
convince family members to sell. Right, and all
2:33:22
it takes is one week link or
2:33:25
probably a few week links because the ownership
2:33:28
is so divided into the tiny chunks by
2:33:30
this point, six generations in, it's pretty peanut
2:33:32
butter to round. But still. I
2:33:34
think also just from a psychological perspective, a
2:33:36
couple of dominoes fall here. And
2:33:39
then as a family member, you start looking around and being
2:33:41
like, do I wanna be the last one? It's
2:33:43
kind of like a crowded theater, running for
2:33:46
the exits. Right. At
2:33:48
the time, you're thinking about like, holy crap. This
2:33:50
is the best it's ever gonna get. I
2:33:53
may never see another opportunity to get
2:33:55
liquid at this price ever. And the
2:33:57
minute that other family members start selling.
2:34:00
It goes down. Supply and demand, the price goes
2:34:02
down. Right. I cannot be the last
2:34:04
and it would kind of suck to be the second or the
2:34:06
third. Right.
2:34:08
So in 2011, the family comes
2:34:10
together and over
2:34:12
50 of the 80
2:34:15
family members collectively contribute
2:34:17
50.2% of the equity
2:34:19
in the company into a new cooperative
2:34:22
vehicle that's called H51, as
2:34:24
in 51% of Hermes. Whereas
2:34:29
in this vehicle, we'll have majority
2:34:32
control of the company when
2:34:35
they contribute their equity into this vehicle. They
2:34:37
contractually agree that that
2:34:40
equity will be locked up and cannot
2:34:42
be sold for at least
2:34:44
20 years. So
2:34:46
they're basically saying to Bernard, no matter what
2:34:48
you do, you could pick off anybody else
2:34:51
after this for a
2:34:53
minimum of 20 years with
2:34:55
potential to extend beyond that. You will
2:34:57
never, never, never. You or anybody else
2:35:00
have control of Hermes. So
2:35:02
badass. Dude, you and I should contribute.
2:35:04
We should make an A51, even though
2:35:06
it's completely unnecessary. It just
2:35:08
feels right for acquired. I think you and
2:35:11
I can each maintain 24.5% stakes, but A51 really should. I
2:35:17
love it. I love it. Well,
2:35:19
hey, we haven't floated our business on the
2:35:21
public markets yet, so we're taking Karl Lagerfeld's
2:35:24
advice. We don't need to incur the legal
2:35:26
fees around doing this. That
2:35:29
vehicle was and is still headed
2:35:31
by one of the family members,
2:35:33
Julie Garron, who was an
2:35:36
investment banker at Rothschild. So she
2:35:38
leaves and full time becomes
2:35:41
head of the defense, I assume, alongside XL,
2:35:43
who obviously comes from the banking
2:35:45
world too. It's so interesting. I wonder if you
2:35:47
actually can structure articles
2:35:49
of incorporation to say under
2:35:52
no circumstances can this entity
2:35:55
sell what it owns. Because
2:35:58
normally what you would do is say it requires is
2:36:00
a vote of unanimous from the board
2:36:02
of directors, blah, blah, blah. But
2:36:05
that leaves you vulnerable to the board of
2:36:07
directors getting lobbied and convinced. And so I
2:36:09
wonder exactly, I mean, this is not a
2:36:11
public document, so we can't really know, but
2:36:13
I wonder how airtight can you
2:36:15
really make something and how irreversible.
2:36:18
I don't believe these documents are public.
2:36:21
But my understanding from comments that family
2:36:23
members in Excel make about them, and
2:36:26
spoiler alert, recently they've renewed the term
2:36:28
of this for another 10 years. So
2:36:31
it's into the mid 2040s. They're
2:36:34
like, Bernard, you will be dead when this
2:36:36
expires. That's exactly what that is. But
2:36:38
I believe it's pretty ironclad that these shares cannot
2:36:40
be sold. Wow. So
2:36:44
in addition to that, two
2:36:46
of the Pouette brothers, Bertrand and Nicholas,
2:36:48
Nicholas is the one that there's the
2:36:50
gardener drama about right now. Which we
2:36:52
should say, listeners, in case you don't
2:36:55
know, there's a lot of stories floating
2:36:57
around in the press right now that
2:36:59
Nicholas Pouette is going to give half
2:37:01
of his stake in
2:37:04
Hermes, which represents something like a little under
2:37:06
3% to his gardener or like his
2:37:09
ex gardener who's now like 51, nobody
2:37:12
knows his name. Nicholas
2:37:14
does not have children or heirs or other
2:37:17
heirs. Right. So
2:37:19
there's a press story right now that just shy of 3% of
2:37:21
Hermes could be given to the family owner. Anyway,
2:37:25
the two Pouette brothers, they do
2:37:27
not contribute their shares to H51, but they give
2:37:32
H51 right a first refusal
2:37:34
on their shares. So they
2:37:36
could sell their shares, but at whatever price they
2:37:39
agree to, the rest of the family has a
2:37:41
row for on purchasing them. Oh, interesting. So that's
2:37:43
another probably 10 to 15% of Hermes
2:37:45
right there. Whoa.
2:37:49
Okay, that's significant. I wonder how this gardener thing
2:37:51
is going to play out. Yeah, right. And
2:37:54
those shares would be, I believe, subject to that
2:37:56
row for assuming that that has stayed
2:37:58
in place. Anyway, this
2:38:01
is really just an incredible coordination.
2:38:03
Yes, it's a family, they're all family,
2:38:05
but there's 80 people here. The fact
2:38:07
that they actually rebuffed this offer and
2:38:10
that Bernard sold down his stake is
2:38:12
crazy. Well, let's get into what happens
2:38:14
with Bernard's stake. Because famously,
2:38:17
as Domenico Di Sole said
2:38:19
in the press at the end of the Gucci
2:38:21
affair, even when he loses,
2:38:23
he still wins. And
2:38:25
Bernard still wins here. So this
2:38:27
effectively ends the takeover bid when H-51
2:38:29
is put in place. But
2:38:32
meanwhile, there are all sorts of lawsuits going on,
2:38:35
particularly around how LVMH amass
2:38:38
this stake in secret with
2:38:41
the equity swaps. He was basically illegal,
2:38:43
right? Well, in 2014, the
2:38:45
French court rules that this was illegal.
2:38:48
LVMH has to pay a fine, I believe like a
2:38:50
10, 15 million dollar fine
2:38:52
for having done this. Pennies. Yeah,
2:38:54
right. As we'll see, it's
2:38:57
truly pennies. And they also mandate
2:38:59
that LVMH needs to distribute out
2:39:01
that Hermes stake to its own
2:39:03
shareholders. LVMH can no longer hold
2:39:06
the stake. Well, who's
2:39:08
the largest shareholder in LVMH? It's
2:39:10
Group R-No, which is Bernard Arnaud's
2:39:13
family office. So they get 8% of Hermes
2:39:16
personally into
2:39:19
his family office entity. Which,
2:39:23
this is the brilliance of Bernard. They
2:39:25
take that value,
2:39:27
which is, call it on the order of
2:39:29
$5 billion. And
2:39:32
remember, when they started buying, the
2:39:34
whole company was trading at a market cap
2:39:37
below $10 billion. So
2:39:39
massively appreciated stock. They basically created value out
2:39:41
of nowhere here. This billions of dollars landing
2:39:43
in Bernard's personal bank account, he
2:39:46
has created that money out of
2:39:48
nowhere. He has unlocked shareholder value
2:39:50
for sure. Even in
2:39:52
the absence of a change of control transaction.
2:39:55
So back when Bernard
2:39:57
was engineering his takeover of LVMH.
2:40:00
One of the financial instruments that
2:40:03
he used to do it was
2:40:05
he IPO-ed a 25% stake in
2:40:07
Dior. He
2:40:10
already owned Dior that he had gotten
2:40:13
out of bankruptcy from Bussek. That's
2:40:15
right. He had this Russian doll
2:40:17
structure where he owned a slim
2:40:20
majority of an entity that owned a slim
2:40:22
majority of an entity that owned a slim
2:40:25
majority. And so he was able to generate
2:40:27
a bunch of liquid cash from
2:40:29
all the minority shares that he
2:40:31
sold off, but he still got
2:40:34
to control Dior, LVMH, Group RNO,
2:40:36
because he was technically the majority owner
2:40:38
of each of them. Yes. But
2:40:41
he and LVMH didn't own this 25% minority
2:40:43
stake in Dior. He
2:40:47
takes the Hermes shares and
2:40:49
does a share swap.
2:40:52
So swaps that value
2:40:54
directly with the 25% of
2:40:57
Dior that he doesn't own to bring
2:40:59
that first into Group RNO, his family
2:41:02
office, and then he trades that into
2:41:05
LVMH. So LVMH now finally,
2:41:07
as a result of this, is able to take 100% control
2:41:09
of Dior. In
2:41:14
exchange for Group RNO
2:41:16
trading this asset into Dior,
2:41:19
Bernard's ownership of LVMH goes from 36% up
2:41:21
to 46%. So
2:41:25
he gets an extra 10% of LVMH. And
2:41:27
here's the most incredible aspect of this.
2:41:30
Not a single dollar in tax is paid on
2:41:33
all of this because it's all share swaps. Basically
2:41:36
Bernard just gets 10% more of
2:41:38
his own company as a result of this. Which
2:41:41
would then go on to appreciate. Call it 400-500% over the next
2:41:43
five, six years. Five-ext
2:41:47
since 2017? Yeah. Wow.
2:41:51
Even when he loses, he wins. Unbelievable.
2:41:55
Now, this is a situation where
2:41:58
everybody wins. I don't think there are any. losers
2:42:00
here. And Hermes families
2:42:03
absolutely are not losers. And you could even say
2:42:05
they sort of have the last
2:42:07
laugh here. Because yes, Bernard
2:42:10
gets to benefit from an extra
2:42:13
4-5x appreciation in LVMH's
2:42:16
market cap here from
2:42:19
what's called the real beginning
2:42:21
of when LVMH publicly announces
2:42:24
their stake in Hermes. So
2:42:26
2010, Hermes's market cap is up 16x. It's
2:42:30
crazy. And the reason why no
2:42:33
one's a loser here and everyone's
2:42:35
a winner is because Hermes truly
2:42:37
is the crown jewel. It is
2:42:39
such an unassailable, exceptional
2:42:41
business. The last 12 months, it
2:42:44
did $14 billion in revenue, $5.7 billion
2:42:48
in operating income. They have a 71% gross margin
2:42:51
and a 44% operating margin. It's
2:42:54
a software business that doesn't need any R&D. Tech
2:42:57
companies go like, I don't know what
2:42:59
Hermes color to call it, but some
2:43:01
color with envy over this. But there
2:43:04
is one more chapter of the story that
2:43:06
we have to tell because that wouldn't have
2:43:08
just happened. It wasn't just the Bernard affair
2:43:10
in and of itself that led to this
2:43:13
16x market cap increase. He was right. Like
2:43:15
I was saying earlier, there were I think
2:43:17
some real problems in the business. And
2:43:20
that is the story
2:43:23
of the sixth generation of PRLXE
2:43:25
and XL, who I think
2:43:27
have certainly fixed those
2:43:29
problems, but have really led Hermes,
2:43:32
the business and the company into
2:43:34
a whole new era. Yes, that
2:43:36
is absolutely right. There is a quote
2:43:39
that I want to start with for
2:43:41
the XL Dumas era, which
2:43:43
is possibly the best articulation that I've ever
2:43:45
heard of business strategy anywhere. And he did
2:43:47
it in the interview that we were talking
2:43:50
about. So he says, every decision that we
2:43:52
make has got some reverse effect, which I
2:43:54
think is like a French translation for trade
2:43:56
off. So every decision we make has got some reverse effect.
2:43:58
So every decision we make has got some trade-off. There's
2:44:00
something I really like about strategy and
2:44:03
Michael Porter. Strategy is accepting that you
2:44:05
are doing something better than the other
2:44:07
and the other is doing something better
2:44:09
than you. You have to pick your
2:44:11
fight. I'm always a little bit disappointed
2:44:13
when I see someone on my team say that
2:44:15
we do everything at the same time. Great. That
2:44:18
doesn't happen in real life. You have to pick
2:44:20
your fight. And Hermes picks their
2:44:22
fights better than anyone. And
2:44:25
what they've done over
2:44:28
the last 10 years since
2:44:30
the Bernard fight is
2:44:33
that they have figured
2:44:35
out how to
2:44:37
scale hand-crafted
2:44:40
artisanal production. Yes.
2:44:43
On the surface, those are
2:44:45
completely oxymoronic terms. Those are
2:44:47
completely diametrically opposed. This is
2:44:49
a dead art in the
2:44:51
world. And Hermes manages to crank
2:44:54
out hundreds of thousands of products
2:44:56
that otherwise would only be created
2:44:58
by individual makers with no infrastructure and no
2:45:01
brand. And it'd be really hard to discover
2:45:03
them. And frankly, they would all just go
2:45:05
out of business. Most of them go out
2:45:07
of business anyway. Totally. What was the stat
2:45:09
that you said a little while
2:45:12
ago that there are 120,000 Birkins and Kelly's produced every
2:45:14
year? Yep, if
2:45:19
they were still making these things on
2:45:21
the third floor at the fo' board, no way.
2:45:23
And this was
2:45:26
kind of the problem and what the consultants were saying at
2:45:28
the start of Jean-Louis' tenure of like, hey,
2:45:30
you need to outsource production. You need to
2:45:32
scale production. You need to make this more
2:45:34
accessible. You have a global brand now. You
2:45:36
need to figure out how to serve the
2:45:38
demand for your brand. So
2:45:41
the Patrick Thomas quote that I want to start with
2:45:44
is so great. The
2:45:46
luxury industry is built on a
2:45:48
paradox. The more desirable a brand
2:45:51
becomes, the more it sells. But
2:45:53
the more it sells, the less desirable it
2:45:55
becomes. We've been talking about this whole episode,
2:45:57
but then it continues. I believe.
2:46:00
Hermes's vision provides a solution
2:46:02
to this dilemma. And
2:46:05
this is what the current generation has found,
2:46:07
the solution. So today,
2:46:10
I think we referenced this earlier
2:46:12
in the episode, Hermes employs
2:46:14
7,000 master crafts people, artisans.
2:46:20
Most of the story that we've been telling
2:46:22
thus far, until
2:46:24
1992, all of the
2:46:27
crafts people in the company, more
2:46:29
or less, were working in the
2:46:31
FauxBourg, in this one relatively
2:46:33
small building on the Rue FauxBourg
2:46:35
du Saint-Honoré in Paris. In
2:46:37
1992, they moved production to
2:46:39
Pantan, in the suburbs of Paris. That
2:46:43
building is amazing, but only houses about
2:46:45
250, 300 crafts people. And
2:46:48
actually, still to this day, Axel talks about this
2:46:50
a lot. Any one of their production sites does
2:46:53
not have more than 250 to 300 crafts people. Yes,
2:46:56
they believe that every single person should know
2:46:58
each other by name. And they think that
2:47:00
250 to 300 is the natural limit on
2:47:02
that. And Axel
2:47:04
even says, if you have more than 300, it is
2:47:07
not a workshop, it's a factory. Yeah, and
2:47:09
they are not in the business of factories.
2:47:12
At the same time, he and
2:47:15
the company have stated
2:47:17
as an explicit goal, that
2:47:19
they will ramp up production capacity by
2:47:21
7% every year. Well,
2:47:24
as the company gets larger and larger, today
2:47:26
that means adding 500 artisans every year. Crazy,
2:47:30
and when Axel started at the company all the way back
2:47:32
in the 80s, there were 250 craftsmen, period. And
2:47:36
they hired two craftsmen per year in the
2:47:38
late 80s. Right,
2:47:41
now here's the issue though, how on earth
2:47:43
are you gonna do this? Like you're saying,
2:47:45
this is a dead art. Nobody else does this.
2:47:48
Little maker with a workshop in San
2:47:50
Francisco or a workshop in Paris. But
2:47:52
like how are you even gonna find
2:47:54
them? Right, and those people, the
2:47:56
Beatrice's here in San Francisco, they're entrepreneurs, they're
2:47:58
not gonna go back. to joining Hermes, because
2:48:01
they all came from Hermes in the first place. How
2:48:03
are you going to hire 500 a year? It's
2:48:05
not like they can go hire from their
2:48:07
competitors. They're not doing this. Right. Their competitors
2:48:09
have all outsourced production and embraced assembly lines.
2:48:12
So they do the only thing that you
2:48:14
can do. They build a pipeline
2:48:18
of training, mastercraft
2:48:20
people and artisans entirely
2:48:23
themselves. They build schools.
2:48:25
They build training centers. They go
2:48:27
to parts of France that are
2:48:29
in rural areas that have high
2:48:31
unemployment. They go to those areas
2:48:34
and they open trade schools and they say, we're going
2:48:37
to train you. They have a hundred
2:48:39
percent graduation rates. They're like, we're not going to give up
2:48:41
on you. We're going to make sure you
2:48:44
learn this trade that you graduate. You may not
2:48:46
come work for Hermes when you graduate, but we're
2:48:48
going to give you this skill. And
2:48:50
then we're going to offer you a job as
2:48:53
a master craftsman. It's crazy. It's
2:48:55
unbelievable. So back in the,
2:48:58
you know, even through the
2:49:00
Jean-Louis era, the fifth generation,
2:49:03
Beatrice was the anomaly as a woman. These
2:49:05
were all like old men that were doing
2:49:07
this stuff. Today, the
2:49:10
average age of the Hermes artisan workforce
2:49:12
is 30 years old and
2:49:15
80% are women. It's wild.
2:49:17
It's a wholesale transformation and
2:49:20
they are training them.
2:49:22
They actually just opened in 2021
2:49:26
their first official French
2:49:28
governmentally sanctioned degree granting
2:49:31
program, the Ecole Hermes des
2:49:33
Savoires Faire. This is the Savoires Faire that
2:49:35
pops up in the annual report, you know,
2:49:37
a hundred whatever times. Let's name a
2:49:39
school after it too. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. They're
2:49:41
like getting into like government policy here.
2:49:44
They are preserving and growing
2:49:46
this art form in France.
2:49:49
Yeah. They're not France's largest export because they
2:49:51
have a very constrained way that they can
2:49:53
create the products, but they may be France's
2:49:55
finest export. So it behooves the French government
2:49:57
to try to figure out how to do
2:49:59
that. figure out how to make this last another
2:50:01
100 years. Yeah, so today
2:50:04
there are 31 Hermes Ateliers, art
2:50:09
is in manufacturing facilities all
2:50:11
throughout the country, each with no more
2:50:13
than 250, 300 people in it. Right,
2:50:16
it's the cloud competing idea of scaling
2:50:18
horizontally. Totally, this is AWS. This is
2:50:21
the point I'm getting to. Right, they're
2:50:23
building data centers. They were Amazon and
2:50:25
they added AWS. And they are
2:50:27
adding two to four of those
2:50:29
every year. So funny, you had that
2:50:32
thought too. Totally. And it's all people.
2:50:34
I mean, it's all sticking to the
2:50:36
thing that got them here, which is
2:50:39
every product, or at least every leather
2:50:41
goods product, every handbag made
2:50:43
end to end by one artisan. Yep. Trained
2:50:46
in the traditional early 20th century
2:50:48
way. Well, speaking of
2:50:50
cloud computing, we wanna share a fun
2:50:52
thing that our friends at Nvidia have
2:50:54
given us. For anyone considering attending GTC
2:50:56
this year, acquired listeners get a 20%
2:50:58
discount. This is
2:51:00
their big annual conference that Ben and I
2:51:02
have watched over a dozen keynotes from to
2:51:04
prep for our Nvidia series. Yep,
2:51:07
it'll be March 18th to 21st, 2024 at
2:51:10
the San Jose Convention Center. And it is
2:51:12
the first time back in person in five
2:51:14
years, which is crazy. It's the most important
2:51:16
AI conference in the world. And Jensen will
2:51:19
be speaking to 10,000 people live in person.
2:51:22
Wow. There are also
2:51:24
researchers speaking from OpenAI, Meta,
2:51:26
Google, DeepMind, Microsoft, Forge, Nentech,
2:51:29
Disney, National Labs, and more.
2:51:31
It's crazy. They will have
2:51:33
a whole bunch of futuristic
2:51:35
vehicles, robots on display. Yep.
2:51:38
If you wanna check it out, click the link in the show notes
2:51:40
and enter the code acquired at checkout, A-C-Q-I-R-E-D to give you 20% off
2:51:42
your ticket. And
2:51:45
thanks to our friends at Nvidia. Now
2:51:47
back to Hermes. So this
2:51:49
is an insane idea that leather goods,
2:51:51
which is 43% of the business. Hermes
2:51:54
did what 11.6 billion euros in revenue. Last
2:51:59
year. year they're on track to
2:52:02
probably do call it 14
2:52:04
billion in euros. Yep, last
2:52:06
12 months is 14 billion. Yeah,
2:52:08
that 6 billion of that is
2:52:11
going to be handcrafted items where
2:52:13
one artisan makes one item at
2:52:16
a time and they're sold around the
2:52:18
world like 6 billion euros worth of
2:52:20
that every year growing
2:52:22
at 15-20% a year.
2:52:24
Yeah, wild. This
2:52:26
is a really important thing to understand the company. They
2:52:29
firmly believe that only 250-300 craftsmen can work
2:52:31
in a building. So that's one. Two, it
2:52:36
takes two plus years for someone
2:52:38
to learn the craft and
2:52:40
apprentice. And three, that
2:52:42
every one of these things must be
2:52:45
created by one individual by hand. And
2:52:47
if you believe all those three things
2:52:49
for sure, then it forces a very
2:52:51
specific constraint on your business and you
2:52:53
must work backward from that. You can
2:52:55
only train so fast, you can only
2:52:57
produce so fast, which then
2:52:59
of course means that it affects your
2:53:01
products and it affects the availability and
2:53:03
it affects the price, which of course
2:53:05
means that it affects the customer set. So
2:53:07
there's a way to view Hermes, which is
2:53:10
they want the very highest end customer with
2:53:12
zero price sensitivity and they do whatever they
2:53:14
need to serve that master. But I think
2:53:16
there's another very real way to look at
2:53:18
it, which is how the company describes themselves
2:53:21
that starts with the constraints of the craft.
2:53:23
And when you hold true to that ethos
2:53:25
at its most extreme, you end up
2:53:27
with the company's brand and posture that you
2:53:30
have today as the only logical endpoint. They
2:53:32
can only hire three, four, or 500 craftsmen
2:53:34
a year. They can only do this other
2:53:36
stuff. Good luck getting a Birkenbag.
2:53:38
I mean, it's just one of these things
2:53:40
where you can say they're artificially constraining supply
2:53:42
all you want. As long as they do
2:53:44
things this way, this is the max throughput.
2:53:46
And so they would have to change something.
2:53:49
They would have to say, hey, there's
2:53:51
some new fancy saddle stitching machine that it
2:53:53
turns out makes us just as high a
2:53:55
quality product and every craftsman gets twice as
2:53:57
effective or something like that. until
2:54:00
they fold on one of
2:54:02
these constraints that they've decided are stakes in
2:54:05
the ground, the result is
2:54:07
the scarcity. That's not the goal.
2:54:09
That's the result. The
2:54:11
Amazon comparison is so apt here.
2:54:14
Hermes has this
2:54:16
incredible, unassailable flywheel, but
2:54:19
it operates in the exact opposite way
2:54:21
of an Amazon flywheel. It's not about
2:54:24
maximizing the cycles. It's slowing. It's minimizing.
2:54:26
It's an intentionally rate-limited flywheel, and it
2:54:28
all works together. At the end of
2:54:31
the day, it is probably true that
2:54:33
neither one is the starting place, and neither one is
2:54:36
the ending place. The two things that
2:54:38
I'm referring to here are the method
2:54:40
of craftsmanship and the price and
2:54:42
scarcity. They just work harmoniously
2:54:44
together. One is not driving the
2:54:46
other. It is that they both
2:54:49
want the brand posture that they
2:54:51
have, and they want the constraints
2:54:53
that they have, and so it works together
2:54:55
perfectly. But a cynical person
2:54:57
could be like, well, yeah, all
2:55:00
that handcrafted mumbo-jumbo only exists because
2:55:02
that's how you justify the brand
2:55:04
pricing and availability that they've put in place. But
2:55:06
I think it all works in concert. Totally. I
2:55:08
mean, we've told that whole episode, and I'm thinking
2:55:11
back to what Beatrice told me when I asked
2:55:13
her, why? If
2:55:15
a master craftsperson made this thing by
2:55:17
hand, it has a soul. And
2:55:20
if a machine made it in an assembly
2:55:22
line, it does not. Right.
2:55:24
Maybe. But sure, in
2:55:26
an assembly line with crappy ingredients, blah,
2:55:29
blah, blah, sure. But can craftsmen use
2:55:31
better tools? Yes. And
2:55:33
will Hermes continue to embrace tools
2:55:36
that make craftsmen more efficient? At
2:55:39
some point, did they use sharper knives than were previously
2:55:41
available in the past? They totally did. And
2:55:43
so will they use things that make the
2:55:45
needle go a little faster? Maybe. Totally.
2:55:49
Let's take a step back here. We got
2:55:51
to consider the exact opposite case
2:55:53
study of this, which is 100% happening, to
2:55:56
great success, which in a lot of ways is the
2:55:58
same thing that the consultants told you. Louis back
2:56:00
in the day, look at the rest of the industry.
2:56:03
Louis Vuitton, which as we talked about,
2:56:05
has the same caliber of heritage and
2:56:07
history as Hermes. Yes. It
2:56:09
could have Hermes's gravity if it
2:56:11
wanted to, but instead you
2:56:13
can buy a checkerboard cotton sweatshirt with 120
2:56:16
LVs on it. Right. They are
2:56:19
having the same level of success, the
2:56:22
same margins, it's working like its
2:56:24
arm. But it's less durable. Well,
2:56:27
I think that's sort of the question. Is
2:56:30
it less durable? Or is
2:56:32
it just these are different markets
2:56:34
or different strategies? Now here's the crux of it
2:56:36
that we've also been teasing on the episode that
2:56:38
I think now's the time to come back to.
2:56:41
This thing that I'm wearing on my wrist. The
2:56:44
Apple Watch partnership. Out of
2:56:46
left field, very surprising, very odd
2:56:48
for the brand to do this. I have a
2:56:51
lot of complicated feelings about the thing on my wrist, including
2:56:53
primarily that I love it. Okay,
2:56:58
here's the story. 2015 Apple launches the Apple
2:57:00
Watch. Supposedly
2:57:02
the story goes that Johnny
2:57:04
Ive and the watch I think
2:57:06
was really Johnny's kind of like pet project
2:57:08
as his last hurrah before leaving Apple. He
2:57:10
had all these quotes at the time of
2:57:12
the Swiss watch industry, better watch out, we're
2:57:14
coming for the video, et cetera, et cetera.
2:57:16
Which was true. I mean,
2:57:18
different market, but it's by far the best
2:57:21
selling watch in the world. Yes, but it's
2:57:23
far from been the death knell of the
2:57:25
Swiss watch industry. Right. Yeah. The Swiss watch
2:57:27
industry has done just fine since the Apple
2:57:29
watch came out on the high
2:57:31
end. Yes. Mark Newsen was consulting for
2:57:33
Apple specifically on the watch and Johnny
2:57:36
asked Mark to introduce him to Pierre
2:57:39
Alexia and XL and to Hermes.
2:57:43
Apple was looking for
2:57:45
a luxury fashion brand.
2:57:47
Remember there is the Apple watch edition in
2:57:50
the beginning that was like the gold Apple
2:57:52
watch and all that. Oh man, $10,000 for
2:57:55
something that was going to be obsolete in
2:57:57
the year. It's crazy. Yeah. That clearly didn't
2:57:59
work. But it's. beautiful. Yeah, totally beautiful.
2:58:01
But they needed a luxury brand. They
2:58:03
needed a brand that was
2:58:05
not deeply in bed with the
2:58:08
traditional Swiss watch industry, which
2:58:10
some of these luxury groups are. How
2:58:12
it's funny, I hadn't actually made that
2:58:14
connection that that's why it's Hermes and
2:58:16
not. Well, I think there's two reasons.
2:58:18
That's one reason. The other reason is
2:58:20
they needed a brand that was going
2:58:22
to appeal to pretty much everybody. Yeah.
2:58:24
For everything we've talked about
2:58:26
with Louis Vuitton and how successful that's
2:58:29
been, it's polarizing. Totally.
2:58:31
And Apple also needed to go to the
2:58:33
very top of whatever they were going to
2:58:36
grab. Like that's the thing about Hermes is
2:58:38
whatever they make. Nobody is ever going to
2:58:40
say that Hermes makes crap. Right. They make
2:58:42
the most fully realized
2:58:44
version of whatever they're making.
2:58:47
If they have an idea, they want
2:58:49
to release the best possible, most extreme,
2:58:51
exquisite version of that thing. And that's
2:58:54
very Apple. I mean, Apple has to
2:58:56
make compromises for the scale that they're
2:58:58
at. But if Apple
2:59:00
had partnered with someone that
2:59:02
was more opinionated, let's say they were better
2:59:04
in some ways, but worse than others, it
2:59:07
kind of doesn't play for Apple's brand. They
2:59:10
need to partner with someone unassailable. Accel
2:59:13
and Piaorelaxi talk about this all the time
2:59:15
when they're asked about, oh, XYZ
2:59:17
flashing celebrity is carrying a Birkenberg, blah,
2:59:19
blah, blah. They say, look, we don't
2:59:21
judge. We never judge, here at Hermes.
2:59:24
Our clients are our clients, whether it's
2:59:26
Grace Kelly or Kim Kardashian. Yeah. And
2:59:29
that's what Apple needed. So Accel is
2:59:31
a great quote on this. He
2:59:33
says, we had an incredible talk with Jonathan
2:59:35
Ive, and there was a lot of mutual
2:59:37
admiration and common values. From that,
2:59:40
we said, wouldn't it be nice
2:59:42
to have something combining our craftsmanship
2:59:44
or vision? It was about trying
2:59:46
to make a contemporary elegant object.
2:59:48
It was not a master plan
2:59:50
of global domination. Okay, this thing
2:59:52
on my wrist is exactly what Accel is saying
2:59:54
there. It is a
2:59:57
contemporary elegant object That
2:59:59
is...
Podchaser is the ultimate destination for podcast data, search, and discovery. Learn More